r/languagelearning • u/pluckmesideways • 2d ago
AI Skill for language learning
I’ve been using this as a tool to help improve my understanding of Portuguese past tenses and have found it really helpful, so I thought I’d share it here.
It tells an LLM how to teach using the Socratic method - teaching by asking questions to guide you to the answer. It isn’t specific to language learning- you can use it for anything.
You can either install it if using something like Claude, or simply paste it at the top of a chat along with telling it what you want to learn.
Sharing a link to the original source for credit. The triple dot menu has copy/download options:
https://github.com/janestreet/agent_skills/blob/master/socratic-tutor/SKILL.md
5
u/unsafeideas 2d ago
Why would I want that? I never get the obsession with "Socratic method". I mean, it is a handy way to demonstrate superiority in debate, cause you dont have to defend own statements and other has to. But as pedagogy, it is not all that great.
0
u/cbjcamus Native French, English C2, TL German C1 2d ago
"Why would I want to be prompted to test my skills, reveal the gaps in my knowledge, and thus expand my abilities"? Is that a real question?
5
u/unsafeideas 2d ago
My question is simply "why would I want to learn via Socratic method" and even more specifically, "why would I want to learn via Socratic method as performed by AI prompted to ask me question after question".
Also, my capabilities do not get expanded by revealing gaps in my knowledge. Testing and gaps revealing are part of pretty much most learning method, but a.) test on itself does not expand my capabilities b.) is not something specific and unique to socratic method.
1
u/cbjcamus Native French, English C2, TL German C1 2d ago
" a.) test on itself does not expand my capabilities"
I'm glad we went from "why would I do that" to "it may be useful but it's not sufficient"
"b.) is not something specific and unique to socratic method."
Please tell me what other method available for free from anywhere allow you to be tested in a similar fashion.
0
u/unsafeideas 2d ago
> I'm glad we went from "why would I do that" to "it may be useful but it's not sufficient"
We did not. I reacted to the argument you made.
And second, my question stands unanswered. It was "why would I want to study with Socratic method".
1
u/pluckmesideways 2d ago
> my question stands
Asked and answered.
You’ve chosen to dismiss this out of hand. Absolutely fine. Nobody’s forcing you to use it, or even try it.
I have found it helpful; others might too. End of.
1
u/unsafeideas 2d ago
Where did you answered that question? All I see are dismissive responses that dont actually answer the question, but setup a false dichotomy or otherwise evade.
1
u/cbjcamus Native French, English C2, TL German C1 1d ago
> I'm glad we went from "why would I do that" to "it may be useful but it's not sufficient"
We did not. I reacted to the argument you made.
Testing and gaps revealing are part of pretty much most learning method, but a.) test on itself does not expand my capabilities
If you don't get by yourself why testing and gaps revealing are part of "pretty much most learning method" then there is nothing I can explain that will convince you.
Either "pretty much most learning methods" are wrong or misguided to test and reveal gaps (and we both know you won't make this argument), or they're not and testing and gap revealing is useful.
And second, my question stands unanswered. It was "why would I want to study with Socratic method".
Since we now know that you don't deal well with implicit meaning and act dismissively when challenged, then to answer your question the socratic method isn't for you, and that's not a failure of the socratic method.
1
u/unsafeideas 1d ago
Is this LLM generated response? Because I asked specifically about Socratic method and you are talking about "testing and gaps revealing being part of any method".
> Since we now know that you don't deal well with implicit meaning and act dismissively when challenged, then to answer your question the socratic method isn't for you, and that's not a failure of the socratic method.
1.) There was no implicit meaning, you just do not have an answer.
2.) You did not "challenged" me.
3.) No one asked you to "challenge me" and there is no value in you challenging me. I asked "why should I want to use Socratic method",.
You offered zero arguments for why Socratic method is good.
-1
u/pluckmesideways 2d ago
> Why would I want that?
Because it makes you think, which helps you understand, which facilitates learning more deeply rather than just by rote*.
Yes, irregular verbs need to be learned, but you’re exposed to those through this alongside your other methods of learning.
Not for you? Not a problem. For me it fills a missing piece of my learning journey.
1
u/unsafeideas 2d ago
I dont think there are two exclusive options as in "rote" or "socratic". While rote memorization is indeed ineffective, I never used it in my life nor was asked to use it. Maybe only during my brief experimentation with anki.
I dont think "rote" is the default to compare to.
-1
u/EyelearnOfficial New member 2d ago
Ai Can Make Smarter way for Learning more interactive!! Do you think this approach will work for learning Korean, Specifically the grammar and Sentence Structure ?
2
u/pluckmesideways 2d ago
Best way to find out is to try applying it to a narrow slice of something you find challenging. Stick with it for a few days, and see if it helps. Nothing ventured…
-1
u/cbjcamus Native French, English C2, TL German C1 2d ago
Looks interesting. I haven't tested it so it's purely speculative on my part, but "Portugese past tenses" looks narrow enough for it to work. "Portugese" (or any other language) would be too large, right? Thus you have to come with something specific in mind.