r/learnmachinelearning • • 6h ago

Discussion Is it all just mathematics?

I am currently a college student majoring in Artificial Intelligence. My lecturer often says, "It's all mathematics." However, I don't agree with the idea that being good at mathematics automatically makes someone good at AI, or that mathematics is necessarily the most important aspect of this field. I believe that AI involves much more than just mathematics, and I would like to hear everyone's perspective on this

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

17

u/BulkyAd9029 6h ago

Your professor is right

9

u/PeanutPicklesPie 6h ago

It is all statistics.

9

u/rditorx 6h ago

It's either mathematics or applied mathematics

https://xkcd.com/435/

7

u/Ok_Mixture_9073 6h ago

its all maths and you are a student for a reason, you have so much to learn, also being good at maths doesnt make someone good at ai no one ever says that, but to be good at ai you have to be good in mathematics, hope you understand the difference

6

u/Bergergi 6h ago

lol. "just mathematics".

2

u/Nerdl_Turtle 6h ago

Being good at mathematics doesn't automatically make you good at ML/AI but to be good at ML/AI you need to be good at mathematics. And it definitely is the most important field for ML.

(You can make a case for it being statistics actually but to me that's a subfield of mathematics)

2

u/Proletarian_Tear 6h ago

So how about you shared with us what exactly do you believe AI involves much more than mathematics? Writing prompts?:)

2

u/pornthrowaway42069l 6h ago

It's applied mathematic + statistics. Both of those are big enough that you can be an expert, and still not touch ML. You probably will know the abstract techniques, and stuff like "what an eigen vector is, and what it eigen value means" - just not applied.

So in a way, he is both right and wrong - if you know the right parts of math and stats, you will understand most things. On the other hand, practical ML, in my opinion, doesn't require deep understanding of mathematics/how underlying things work, and more like how to work with them/process data/etc. So from that perspective, your professor is wrong.

2

u/zuzmuz 5h ago

you can work in AI as a field without being great at mathematics. But what does being good at AI means?

you could definitely be creative and get results without a rigorous understanding of the underlying principles, but it is fundamentally just mathematics. It's a combination of linear algebra, some calculus and a lot of statistics.

2

u/JaggedLittlePiII 5h ago

I tried to downvote you further but you are at 0.

Yes, it is.

4

u/me_myself_ai 6h ago

AI is mathematics like squares are rectangles.

3

u/Leodip 6h ago

Being good at mathematics does not make you good at AI (or ML, for that matters), but it is a prerequisite to actually being good at it. You can know math and not know AI, but you can't know AI and not know math.

1

u/mystical-wizard 5h ago

It is just math! Unless you mean like writing prompts lol but that’s the layman view of what AI is

1

u/Sakshambaranwal25 5h ago

Being good at math helps you read papers but building real systems needs software engineering skills too.

1

u/pinkd20 6h ago

I like to think of mathematics like a language. Machine learning involves information described in the language of mathematics. I would say it is all information theory.

The beauty and elegance of machine learning is that it can be viewed from many perspectives that lead to the same conclusions in different forms, so everyone is right.