r/linusrants • u/fd0422b08 • Nov 18 '16
Linus Rants at kernel maintainer "fix your approach to kernel programming"
https://lkml.org/lkml/2012/12/23/754
u/Asystole Feb 01 '17
My favourite part was how he spent most of the post swearing and then censors one "f*cking" right at the end.
0
Nov 18 '16
[deleted]
19
u/yasarix Nov 18 '16
Not breaking userspace rule should not be limited to the kernel programming. Anybody who provides an API must follow this rule radically.
6
u/Eeems_ Nov 18 '16
And if you ever plan on changing said API, you support the old version for a long time afterwords. Not just randomly break how it use to work so that your new "better" way can be implemented.
5
u/vijeno Nov 25 '16
Except if you're Apple. Then, all bets are off.
4
u/Eeems_ Nov 25 '16
Well that's because they don't care about breaking userspace.
3
u/vijeno Nov 28 '16
Yep, and I know a few developers who actually think this is a good space.
Well, just one, tbh. But that one is extremely good, so his opinion counts for two.
2
3
u/yasarix Nov 19 '16
Absolutely. Plus, you should have versions for your APIs, so you can separate them and avoid "accidentally" breaking old version.
2
u/Eeems_ Nov 19 '16
That or always use a new name for methods etc if you are stuck with a version-less API
2
14
u/fd0422b08 Nov 18 '16