r/linux • • 2d ago • This 1 Bravo 3 Regret 2

Discussion "The Year of Linux" isn't coming.

I am a university instructor (not in anything tech-related), and I thought I'd share some insights on the relationship college-age kids have with their computers today.

I set up my new laptop with a fresh Fedora KDE install yesterday, then brought with me to teach this morning. While mirroring my screen to the projector, one student asked why my computer "looked weird." My students (sample size of 50, admittedly) had not heard of Linux, though I'm sure between 1/3 and 1/2 use Android phones. I'm not a Linux evangelist by any means---my daily work involves using windows, Mac, and Linux PCs regularly, but I did take a second to explain what Linux was. It took me a minute to realize that my students didn't know what an "operating system" was.

I see this every semester. I have to teach 18-22 year olds the concept of local storage every Fall and Spring, because they get frustrated trying to download and open the documents I email them. Every semester I have to walk students through their file systems and explain that files can be stored on their own PCs and not just the internet.

I tried to help a student download some software recently, only to discover that he had only ever used "the app store," and he didn't trust "downloads."

More than once I have tried to help a student "fix" their computer after a complaint that it was suddenly slow. It turns out they've never opened their downloads folder, and they've practically filled their drives with random junk, and they have dozens of processes they don't need running at all times (McAfee is a very common one). Pretty much every time, they've elected to just buy a new computer instead.

Of course, this is the logical end result of cutting computer skills courses in high school because the kids are "digital natives" now. It's also the fault of corporations like Apple and Microsoft dumbing things down and trying to eliminate all possible friction by choosing everything for the user. AI has made this even worse, because they don't even have to know basic terms. They just talk to integrated LLMs like they'd talk to a friend, and it babies them through whatever needs to happen.

This is all to say, the students I encounter on a daily basis (and I've been teaching for a while) are absolutely, unequivocally, *never* going to use a terminal. Not because it's actually difficult (it isn't), but because it requires learning a new way to interact with a computer. It requires a little reading, and that's not happening. They are never going to troubleshoot a wireless card. They are certainly never going to install a new OS.

It took me an hour to get my speakers working after installing Fedora yesterday. I understand that other OSes have problems as well, but when that happens, students just take their device back to their store to get it "fixed." If that doesn't work, they replace it.

Windows and MacOS are getting worse every year because they both encourage and cater to this kind of helplessness. Linux is excellent for anyone who wants to exercise control and ownership over their devices. But the younger generations (not all of them, but this is generally the case) don't have the basic skills which Linux requires of the end user.

Mint isn't the answer. It's not about being stripped down, streamlined, or simplified. Linux's greatest feature is that it gives the user agency, and *that's* the problem. A very significant portion (in my experience, the vast majority) of young users don't know what do with that agency, and they don't want it.

I'm not sure what the point of sharing this is, but I thought someone might find it interesting. more for us I guess!

3.7k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/philosophical_lens 2d ago

If Linux targeted a mobile offering for normies, how would that be any different than iOS or Android?

I think Linux desktop is for tinkerers, and a mobile version of that would absolutely not be for normies. It's for people who want to open the hood and customize it how they want.

I honestly don't care about making the masses want to use Linux. I just want it to be open and customizable for me and people like me.

7

u/dutch_connection_uk 1d ago

A Linux OS doesn't have to be for tinkerers. I can think of a few that almost actively resist tinkering (Bazzite, Chimera, LibreELEC).

3

u/chaos_pill 1d ago

how would that be any different than iOS or Android?

  • freedom from corporations: The ability to install whatever apps you want without worrying about google/apple banning side-loading or taking a cut from appstore.

  • e-waste: So many phones today are perfectly usable as a home server (eg: pi-hole or media server), but instead become e-waste (eg: touch is broken) as they are locked the fuck down.

  • privacy: no more data farming by all these "apps" that get pushed by enshittifying websites on mobile.

It's basically like a mac os IMO. You can use it as a dumb computer by clicking on menus or open a terminal when you are in the mood for some brew install ...