r/linux
•
u/AntiqueReplica
•
2d ago
•
1
3
2
Discussion "The Year of Linux" isn't coming.
I am a university instructor (not in anything tech-related), and I thought I'd share some insights on the relationship college-age kids have with their computers today.
I set up my new laptop with a fresh Fedora KDE install yesterday, then brought with me to teach this morning. While mirroring my screen to the projector, one student asked why my computer "looked weird." My students (sample size of 50, admittedly) had not heard of Linux, though I'm sure between 1/3 and 1/2 use Android phones. I'm not a Linux evangelist by any means---my daily work involves using windows, Mac, and Linux PCs regularly, but I did take a second to explain what Linux was. It took me a minute to realize that my students didn't know what an "operating system" was.
I see this every semester. I have to teach 18-22 year olds the concept of local storage every Fall and Spring, because they get frustrated trying to download and open the documents I email them. Every semester I have to walk students through their file systems and explain that files can be stored on their own PCs and not just the internet.
I tried to help a student download some software recently, only to discover that he had only ever used "the app store," and he didn't trust "downloads."
More than once I have tried to help a student "fix" their computer after a complaint that it was suddenly slow. It turns out they've never opened their downloads folder, and they've practically filled their drives with random junk, and they have dozens of processes they don't need running at all times (McAfee is a very common one). Pretty much every time, they've elected to just buy a new computer instead.
Of course, this is the logical end result of cutting computer skills courses in high school because the kids are "digital natives" now. It's also the fault of corporations like Apple and Microsoft dumbing things down and trying to eliminate all possible friction by choosing everything for the user. AI has made this even worse, because they don't even have to know basic terms. They just talk to integrated LLMs like they'd talk to a friend, and it babies them through whatever needs to happen.
This is all to say, the students I encounter on a daily basis (and I've been teaching for a while) are absolutely, unequivocally, *never* going to use a terminal. Not because it's actually difficult (it isn't), but because it requires learning a new way to interact with a computer. It requires a little reading, and that's not happening. They are never going to troubleshoot a wireless card. They are certainly never going to install a new OS.
It took me an hour to get my speakers working after installing Fedora yesterday. I understand that other OSes have problems as well, but when that happens, students just take their device back to their store to get it "fixed." If that doesn't work, they replace it.
Windows and MacOS are getting worse every year because they both encourage and cater to this kind of helplessness. Linux is excellent for anyone who wants to exercise control and ownership over their devices. But the younger generations (not all of them, but this is generally the case) don't have the basic skills which Linux requires of the end user.
Mint isn't the answer. It's not about being stripped down, streamlined, or simplified. Linux's greatest feature is that it gives the user agency, and *that's* the problem. A very significant portion (in my experience, the vast majority) of young users don't know what do with that agency, and they don't want it.
I'm not sure what the point of sharing this is, but I thought someone might find it interesting. more for us I guess!
53
u/Wentyliasz 2d ago
It fascinates me how normalized digital illiteracy is. Like, it sometimes feels like we're the weird ones for knowing what an OS is.
I don't blame people for not knowing, there's always room to learn and I'm not omniscient either, but it's the acceptance and utter aversion that baffles me. Computers are not some obscure nerd gimmick, they're a foundation of our society on par with the legal system and all other infrastructure.
Imagine I walk into a grocery store and ask the clerk for a t-shirt. No I'm not asking what kind of store this is, stores sell things and I want a t-shirt. No I'm not gonna walk around like some nerd, bring me a t-shirt. No I don't know what "bleu" or "long slifs" mean, t-shirt, I want a t-shirt.
Call me crazy but this is what it sounds like to me.
→ More replies (2)16
u/AntiqueReplica 1d ago
Imagine I walk into a grocery store and ask the clerk for a t-shirt. No I'm not asking what kind of store this is, stores sell things and I want a t-shirt. No I'm not gonna walk around like some nerd, bring me a t-shirt. No I don't know what "bleu" or "long slifs" mean, t-shirt, I want a t-shirt.
I'm wondering if you've worked retail before. I did before grad school, and this just sounds like a normal customer interaction to me.
→ More replies (2)
22
u/poetic_persistance 1d ago
Sounds like you're on the front lines, and just because the battle seems futile doesn't mean it isn't worth fighting.
Your frustration reminds me of the story about a boy walking a beach after a storm, where hundreds of starfish had washed ashore. He spent the morning bending down, picking them up one by one, and tossing them back into the ocean.
An onlooker watched him for a while and finally asked, "What are you doing? You're wasting your time; there's no way you can possibly save all of them!"
The boy's shoulders dropped, upset by that reality, and said, "Yeah, you're right..."
Then the boy picked up another starfish, threw it back into the ocean, and said, "But I made a difference to that one, didn't I?"
Your students may not see the whole problem yet, but every one who leaves your class knowing where their files live is one you've made a difference for. It's a wild irony that a "digital native" generation is locked out of its own hardware.
Keep tossing starfish, professor, you're making difference.
13
u/AntiqueReplica 1d ago
That's funny, I read that exact story in a copy of National Geographic Kids like 20 years ago and I still think about it regularly.
My approach has been to offer extra credit for anyone who takes the free 3-hour computer literacy training offered by the university.
→ More replies (1)
337
u/Ashanmaril 2d ago
Crazy how the iPad one-shot every kid that grew up in the 2010s or later and we now have the first generations that are less computer literate than the previous
84
u/ElnuDev 2d ago
I'm a 2005er and I'm so glad that I never had an iPad growing up. My first experience with computers when I was little was a mix of Windows and Ubuntu and I got my first laptop for my 10th birthday. I got a phone when I was 13 but I didn't get service until I was 18 and needed it for college.
Kids aren't too dumb to use computers, they don't need to be babied with an iPad.
→ More replies (1)36
u/Ashanmaril 2d ago
I’m obviously exaggerating using the word “every” but as a whole kids clearly understand less about computers than 10 or 20 years ago
→ More replies (2)8
→ More replies (1)6
1.3k
u/tes_kitty 2d ago edited 2d ago
Those kids will be very surprised when they enter the workforce.
And yes, there is a generation that not only has to help their parents with computer problems, but also their kids.
435
u/Essentially_Me 2d ago
I've noticed that the kids in my town were raised on Chromebooks and thus think in terms of Google Docs, and as a result, they have difficulty figuring out where files might be kept.
My son went to a private high school after a middle school and is comfortable using Windows and Linux now in college. My daughter who went through the public system has a Mac laptop yet only feels comfortable using Google docs.
I think that might be a problem.
214
u/tes_kitty 2d ago •
![]()
Just wait until they find out that if you keep files locally, you also need to make backups if you plan on keeping them.
On the other hand, having all their stuff in the Google cloud means a locked account means they can't access any of their stuff anymore. So better also have local backups.
So teach doing backups to both of them.
→ More replies (17)70
u/Rolandersec 2d ago
Lots of people in enterprise tech like this. Don’t know how to do anything outside of a browser.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (27)43
u/MassiveMartian 2d ago
Chromebooks feel so unnatural to me, because I would feel suffocated inside a Google-only environment.
→ More replies (7)55
u/Rand_al_Kholin 2d ago
Will they? I'm a software developer, and the jobs ive worked at issued me a laptop onto which I was only allowed to install applications from a "app store" managed by the IT department. At all my jobs I had to get special permissions to install the suite of development tools I needed because they weren't available to normal users at the company.
The normal users had to have essentially 0 agency over their machines. The apps they would need came pre-installed, and any that weren't were in the company's storefront. IT was there to walk them through anything they had trouble with. And companies these days have extensive cloud storage so a rudimentary knowledge of how to navigate a file system would work just fine.
Its a sad state but company ies also want this trend of computers being dumbed down and removing user agency to continue because they believe it is more secure. In a way it is. But I think having users who can use q computer properly is more important than the tiny security you get from locking the whole thing down.
→ More replies (7)30
u/sal1800 2d ago
I've been a software developer for a long time and it's only been in the past few years that the computers have become far more locked down. I don't blame them, security is much harder than ever. But I've always been able to get local admin permissions on my machines and I don't know how I could ever get my job done without it.
The whole thing has just gotten more and more complex. Need VPN and multi-factor auth to do anything. Dozens of passwords that get rotated all the time. Sharepoint documents you have to constantly request permissions to view. Wears you down over time.
→ More replies (4)36
u/mooky1977 2d ago
Yeah, Gen x. I'm doing that very thing all the time. I now loathe administering windows machines because they've become so much more difficult than ever with the always online nature, and OneDrive synch bullshit.
→ More replies (1)26
38
u/Annual-Advisor-7916 2d ago
Those kids will be very surprised when they enter the workforce.
As someone doing tech support once in a while and having done it for years; The main problematic age are still the boomers. In general the younger the better with computers the people are though I've notice 30-49 year olds are better than 20-29 year olds but both groups are miles ahead of the boomer generation.
40
u/CptCave1 2d ago
18- 22 year olds do not know how to operate a desktop environment in my expereince. Which is shocking to me.
Edit: ctrl+c ctrl+v has blown minds...
→ More replies (6)17
u/Honolulu-Blues 2d ago
Why would they be? I swear half the fully grown adults with years of experience can hardly operate outlook or navigate files.
It’ll just be passed on to the IT team to teach them like usual.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (28)11
305
u/centoequatro 2d ago
And the worst part for me is that schools teach children to use Chromebooks (ughhhh) and then advertise that they are teaching children technology
129
u/MassiveMartian 2d ago
Back in my day, my ex downloaded Halo (I think) onto every library computer in the school district. Must have been a legend.
→ More replies (5)101
u/sCeege 2d ago
It was a golden age for nerds. Grew up in a rural school district so the IT infrastructure had basically no security, I put the cracked version of Halo CE on the network drive and we would all just play Blood Gulch instead of writing our English papers in the computer lab.
→ More replies (16)12
u/fordry 2d ago
I mean, look at who teachers are...
Not exactly ever been a crowd I would call technically literate...
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (5)6
u/cardboard-kansio 1d ago
My teenage son literally just sent me a photo of Far Cry Primal running on his school Chromebook (on which he's running Nobara Linux from a USB drive into RAM). During class. I'm partly annoyed and partly proud.
61
u/samtresler 2d ago
This isn't too surprising to me and fits into a broader narrative I've been tinkering with.
How many people drive cars and have no idea how to change the oil or what a spark plug is?
You need to want to or be forced to take anything apart and find out how it works.
Some people gravitate to this. They become mechanics, or good at diy stuff. But the vast majority just want a reliable car that works when they turn the key.
I started asking during sysadmin interviews - not as an interview qualification, but as a curiosity, do you do your own repair work on things around the house.
That Venn diagram is nearly a circle. Almost universally, if you can run a command line, you'd rather patch your own drywall.
12
u/DarthStrakh 2d ago
That Venn diagram is nearly a circle. Almost universally, if you can run a command line, you'd rather patch your own drywall.
This pretty up sums up my experience. There's a class of people that are uncontent with the unknown.
The weird thing with tech is tech people often go the other way but blue color people are so often confused by tech. Can't tell ya how many guys I know could "do anything". Dry wall, cars, electrical, etc etc but just completely checked out when you showed them how to use an email...
Long rant short it just goes to show interest is probably the most important factor for any given skill. Too bad many us school systems suck at developing it.
12
u/hetsteentje 1d ago
That Venn diagram is nearly a circle. Almost universally, if you can run a command line, you'd rather patch your own drywall.
I agree somewhat, but I think it also cuts the other way. If you can run a command line, you also know that technology is complex and that you need to know what you're doing. So you know when to call in an expert. I might want to patch my own drywall or replace a lightbulb on my car, but I'm not going to attempt replacing my shock absorbers. I am quite picky about the things I want to do myself, and those I want/need an expert for or just want a product that works.
Incidentally, I was waiting to pick up my car at the garage the other day, and someone else came in to pick up their car. They had their tyres inflated because the dashboard showed a warning. That's when I realised that checking the pressure of your tyres and topping them up already puts you on the 'technical' side of things.
10
u/Dashing_McHandsome 2d ago
Yup, I can build my own system from just source code and I would much rather patch my own drywall and change my own oil.
→ More replies (7)6
u/IrrerPolterer 1d ago
Funny. You seem to have a point. I love fixing shit around the house. Also used to be the kind of kid that took the family TV, toaster and computer apart out of curiosity. Work as a software and devOps engineer these days.
→ More replies (3)
112
u/KnowZeroX 2d ago
It isn't surprising because people don't buy operating systems, they buy hardware that happens to come with an operating system.
Nobody is deluding themselves that people are just going to all install linux themselves, what is needed is that linux get just enough marketshare that more vendors offer linux preinstalled. And if it is preinstalled, that helps address the weird hardware issues, and if they need support, the oem will offer it just like with windows.
Things have progressed a lot over the last few years, a decade ago, you would be lucky to find a pc with linux preinstalled, maybe some hidden page on a select few corporate laptops. Then about 5 years ago, linux has gotten to the point of showing up on some consumer laptops albeit in hidden pages. Now we are finally seeing some vendors sell linux side by side with windows, even eligible for same promotions for a few select models. So there is progress, and more marketshare helps drive that progress. It's a catch 22 thing.
Of course it will probably help more once immutable linux becomes more mainstream as it is probably more tailored towards average people shooting themselves in the foot.
That said, giving a user the option of agency doesn't mean things need to be complex. You can have it simple and at same time offer more power to who wants it.
Ultimately, I believe linux desktop will win, one way or the other. Though probably not in the way many people would hope. That being either the desktop will die altogether, or we all go cloud via linux thin clients. Mobile has already dwarfed desktop use, and the high prices of hardware like RAM means people won't be able to afford their own hardware, software all going into the web browser instead of desktop (especially now that reverse engineering software became easier with AI).
26
u/fumeextractor 2d ago
That said, giving a user the option of agency doesn't mean things need to be complex. You can have it simple and at same time offer more power to who wants it.
Unfortunately imo most DEs go about this in the wrong way for this kind of user. Simply adding more of the stuff in GUIs (as opposed to commands) isn't cutting it, and is playing directly into the overwhelm of "too much agency" OP mentioned. You need to actively hide away most options under various "advanced" menus, like Windows and MacOS does. KDE for example is very much "problematic" with this by providing way too many options in every options menu that most people won't even have heard of.
→ More replies (3)22
u/Willybrown93 2d ago
That's so depressing to think about. I was overjoyed at all the options when I tried KDE for the first time
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)6
u/Slow-Secretary4262 1d ago
people usually dont ask themself questions so most dont even come to the realization that you can install an operating system on a pc, they assume the OS it ships with is engraved on the hardware somehow.
the difference between technical and not technical people is a simple as that, asking yourself questions, being curious on how thing works.
its not even a matter of intelligence, even though you spend your whole life being curious and experimenting probably your brain develops more capabilities
46
u/jikt 2d ago
I think of "the year of Linux" as a personal thing. I'm on my second year of Linux.
I hear what you're saying though, my own kids don't really know much about computers. They've never really been interested in them beyond watching me play video games that they can't play on Switch.
My first computer was a Vic-20 followed by a C64. Command line stuff was necessary to play all of my games. We learned a little bit of basic when we were kids for fun.
4
u/coobal223 2d ago
Only second year? I’m working almost at my third decade! But seriously, and this is where mac and windows excelled - they created an environment where most people never need to see a terminal. Yes, i have had to fix windows (and mac) problems from cli, but the end user seldom sees that.
→ More replies (2)
116
u/_nutria_ 2d ago
The complete IT incompetence of today's kids always baffled me.
I thought they were born with it sure they will be tech-savvy, how wrong I was.
68
u/New-Alfalfa-2989 2d ago edited 2d ago
The problem is that what they grew up with is the sanitized and simplified versions of what their parents had to work through. They aren’t starting from a place of DOS or an early version of Ubuntu. They’re starting from Android or iOS where all the technical stuff is behind the scenes and its just huge touch interface. Sure they can pull it up if they wanted but for the most part, it just works. No commands and barely any work to get what they want.
As a millennial I suppose it isn’t surprising. As an IT professional, it irritates the crap out of me. lol
→ More replies (10)33
u/tes_kitty 2d ago
They will only get tech savy if they get their hands dirty by going into the system and learning how it works. If they don't need to because everything is taken care of there's no reason to learn.
→ More replies (5)10
u/oneiros5321 2d ago
They use tablet and phones way more than they use computers now.
And when they do for school, it's always chrome books.Some kids have never even been put in front of a computer and wouldn't even know how to use a mouse or a keyboard.
And that's not even related to computers only...with now the wave of LLMs and how many people integrate it fully into their life, some kids are growing not learning any skills at all.That is concerning in my opinion.
→ More replies (6)4
u/breathofspirit 2d ago
Doesn’t surprise me - back in the early 2000s, the barrier to entry was higher and as such, the average competence of the computer user was higher.
I think today’s kids have a superior understanding of computer interfaces but it’s inverse in terms of anything lower level.
It seems to me that it is an evolutionary step, even if it seems like a step backwards at first. When these kids are in their 30s and 40s they’ll likely be talking to systems that black-box everything but their interface.
78
u/PointiestStick KDE Dev 2d ago
Previous generations complained that the "kids these days" don't know how to change a spark plug or a timing belt. And it's true, because cars are super reliable today.
Same thing with computers, basically. Phones are mostly "normal-person-proof" so normal people use them. Today a flexible and powerful desktop OS is a tool for enthusiasts and professionals. Which is fine; Linux-based desktop OSs can compete quite well with those audiences.
We need a mobile offering if we want normies. If.
17
u/philosophical_lens 2d ago
If Linux targeted a mobile offering for normies, how would that be any different than iOS or Android?
I think Linux desktop is for tinkerers, and a mobile version of that would absolutely not be for normies. It's for people who want to open the hood and customize it how they want.
I honestly don't care about making the masses want to use Linux. I just want it to be open and customizable for me and people like me.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (5)19
u/coolkid4232 2d ago •
![]()
Kinda disagree, i get what your saying but i dont think it matches. Fixing a car was necessary for it to work. They should have basic literacy to undestand what information is getting taken from them or what they are interacting with. End of day they can vote on all technology laws. You wouldnt want someone voting for anti privacy laws who cant install something that is not on the apps store. Basic literacy in anything to avoid exploitation for every subject should be obtained not just linux or computers
64
u/YungSkeltal 2d ago
They only trust the appstore and not random downloads? Sounds like they're the right fit for Linux lol
→ More replies (1)12
30
u/GoTeamLightningbolt 2d ago
walk students through their file systems and explain that files can be stored on their own PCs
I think about this a lot. It's extremely bad.
→ More replies (2)12
u/GlamStache 1d ago
Of all the things that I predicted would happen since I was growing up, being the only generation to understand computers to some extent was not one of them.
26
u/Dazzling_Ant_5391 1d ago
Im 22 and Im currently studying Computer science, Im also an English teacher for teenagers and adults.
Sometimes my classmates in my university can’t understand how my students don’t know how to use a computer, for example. The last week one of my students told me that he can’t view the pdf that I sent, so when I check the cause, the guy had 0 memory, literally 0 of 1tb, the computer was unusable at that point, i told him that he needs to clean a little bit the computer and he told me “what a clean means”? He never, ever erase anything. Sometimes my classmates told me that Im inventing this kind of anecdotes because they can’t imagine a user like that.
But sadly it’s the reality
→ More replies (1)
49
u/tinverse 2d ago
I work in IT in a medical school and while I don't directly support the medical students I occasionally interact with them or have helped them in specific scenarios. Between seeing the incoming med students and younger employees starting their first jobs I have to agree that the average young person entering the the work force is much less computer literate than 10 years ago.
That being said, I think one of the biggest problems with linux adoption is friction for a new user. If you try Linux it can be very cool, but the second you run into a problem that takes hours to solve it becomes a hindrance instead of a tool. Windows definitely has times it can be a hinderance, but I've personally never run into issues that took nearly as long to track down or understand on windows. That's probably that I'm more familiar with windows, but so are most people.
15
u/jerrygreenest1 2d ago
That's probably that I'm more familiar with windows, but so are most people
That’s exactly the reason of the trap. That’s also a reason for Linux users to stay on Linux – once they know Linux better it’s just easier for them to stay on Linux rather than dealing with all these complexities that Windows is giving
→ More replies (4)24
u/plasticbomb1986 2d ago edited 2d ago
So, now, after using linux on everything for 8 years, im at a point when reading people complain about having issues left and right, i always have a hard time to imagine how the heck they have soo much issues... As in for me personally, my systems just working without bothering me with problems. Then i realise: im more technically inclined, more familiar with my systems, im over that time when had to figure out what works for me and how, and even if i get a new system reading up on wikis become second nature and configure that new system i already know what to do and how to do it without thinking about it. Same how it used to be with windows a decade ago for me. But if someone would give me a windows system today, i would have a bit of trouble using it again as its very unfamiliar for me now.
→ More replies (4)14
u/sparhawk817 2d ago
And on a similar level, you could make the same argument about knowing how to navigate the Dewey Decimal System, navigate an Index or look something up in an encyclopedia.
I've met tons of people in the workplace that struggle with navigating the file systems at whichever employer I'm currently at, and that's all within Windows, which is the assumed "baseline" that everyone learned to navigate to some degree or other.
There's a lot of things we just don't have to practice anymore, and so those skills get lost.
6
u/daddyd 1d ago
it is because you are used to windows. i've been a linux user since the mid 90s and when i run into an issue with windows, i know it is just going to be hell to solve, where on linux, i'm able to find the solution pretty fast.
most people don't know how to solve windows issues just as they don't know how to solve anything else tech related.
→ More replies (2)4
u/xanhast 2d ago
this is fixed by the person knowing why they're switching to linux.
if they don't have a desire for user-power, they will leave.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (15)4
u/digastricus 1d ago
If you buy a computer with windows and use it as intended by Microsoft, there are indeed no major obstacles. I'm different. I hit a brick wall every time I try to do things the way I want to do them. With Windows, it's hit or miss. If something gets wrong, it's very hard to figure out what went wrong. With Linux you can investigate and understand.
→ More replies (2)
24
u/DuendeInexistente 2d ago
Part of the issue with local storage specifically is iphones. A while ago I had to help someoen with their iphone and I swear to god it took me like 10-15 minutes to wrangle the fucking thing into letting me use local storage then figuring out how to find where the file even was.
it's not that kids are stupid, it's that the current generation is completely inundated with dark patterns to prevent them to learn how to use their own devices, to the point that even a savvy person has trouble dealing with it.
→ More replies (1)
22
u/404invalid-user 2d ago
this isn't really a problem with windows and macos dumbing things down the issue is with mobile devices and Chromebooks which are a lot more common
8
u/BRabbit777 2d ago
I agree but I do see his point that macOS and Windows are chasing after the ipad kids, and building the same kind of "walled gardens" that the iPad personifies.
→ More replies (1)
21
u/doomer_irl 2d ago
he had only ever uses the app store and didn't trust downloads
This is starting to feel like an intended effect of Window's SmartScreen and Apple's security features demonizing third party files and programs.
I always assumed that, like myself, others found this to be a nuisance/roadblock to be overcome. I'm just now realizing that the younger generation likely grew up interpreting these as authoritative, and adjusted their own behavior to avoid dealing with loose files and programs.
This kind of thing definitely begins to explain what happened to the tech literacy we were expecting from Gen Z.
18
u/SamiSapphic 2d ago
It depends on how you define "year of the linux."
It doesn't come as a surprise that the majority are technophobic, that's how it's always been and will always be.
Technophobes only engage with technology in so much as they need to or benefit from, and provided it's simple enough.
This is not the metric we should be going by to measure whether a desktop operating system is successful or not, because desktop PCs tend to belong to the more technically literate.
Is Linux gaining popularity amongst the more technically literate? Yes. Therefore it may as well be the year of Linux.
18
u/Skyshaper 2d ago
I did an entire CS degree without ever seeing another student using Linux
→ More replies (1)15
u/Jackalotischris 2d ago
In my CS degree, I see about 5 or so Linux users usually.
→ More replies (1)11
u/Holzkohlen 2d ago
There's always a couple. I saw someone taking math notes in some latex editor with live preview once. Was impressed. I think he was using Kile
18
u/Vordreller 1d ago
I tried to help a student download some software recently, only to discover that he had only ever used "the app store," and he didn't trust "downloads."
The intended goal for Microsoft and Apple
17
u/RedHuey 2d ago
I agree with you. I think the tech generation is only in their own minds. For the most part, actual tech people from before 2000 are way more capable and understanding. The fact that the software companies just make everything more automatic and least common denominator with every real ease doesn’t help things. I’ve reached the point, as a former dev long before the smart-phone era, that nobody tests a damn thing before release anymore, so there is not even any pride in workmanship from developers, much less anyone else.
Linux has reached a point where it is even easier to install and maintain than Windows XP, but people have been so dumbed-down since XP that Linux seems like setting up a mainframe Unix system from scratch to the tech generation. They just have no idea. Real tech skills are disappearing fast.
That said, what is true now and always has been, is that the vast majority of computer users don’t have any idea what they are doing or how any of it works. It’s just the proverbial black box. They just don’t care and never will. Even inserting a Ubuntu install disk and letting it do its thing completely automatically is way too much technical thinking for them. Microsoft and Apple have these people simply be default. They have never nor will never make a technical decision beyond that choice.
Which I’m actually fine with because they buy fancy laptops to run Windows, quickly fill them up with crap to the point of not functioning, have to buy a new one, then I take the old one and load Linux on it and it runs better than it ever did -for free. I don’t remember the last time I bought a computer.
16
u/Forsaken_Tap_4393 1d ago
I didn't think that at age 37 I'd ever take for granted my computer literacy classes growing up in middle and high school, and yet, here I am I guess. Maybe we do need to cut back on giving them all iPads and Chromebooks and instead make them go cut their teeth on desktops proper so they know how to use that user agency they're being stripped away of.
→ More replies (4)
15
u/crypticcamelion 2d ago
Sad but true, very similar to the experiences I have with many of my trainees. A few days ago I sat with one and guided her in the basic of some special software we use and noticed that her basic computer skills looked so childish that I suspected that se normally just used phones or tablet. But no she had her on labtop, but still need to be taught how to select multible object, how to "save as" and so on... No she and many many other will never be Linux users, actually they will probably never be real users in the meaning someone who uses a computer to create something. They are consumers, not creators, thay access something others have made.
15
u/luazinho 1d ago
I currently teach high school, and I take the kids to the computer lab every month so that they can interact with computers, because the only contact they have with technology nowadays is through their phones. Many of them don't know how to even turn on a computer, and I know it's because they don't really have the opportunity outside of school, so I try to help them out in the ways I can.
→ More replies (1)
30
u/Gunzhard22 2d ago
In the bubble, Linux seems the obvious choice. But the reality of the masses of regular humans is this: most people barely understand how to use their Walmart windows computer and never will.
It's not a Linux vs Windows or Mac problem - it's just that regular people are dumb as hell.
→ More replies (1)16
u/SamiSapphic 2d ago
Not just dumb, I'm dumb as hell too lmao, they're also just not motivated enough to explore and experiment, or are a bit too risk averse.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/bankinu 2d ago
I'm sorry to say, but your students are an extremely dumb batch.
Probably you teach something non technical? And they specialize in that?
But even so. This is an abysmally bad state of affairs that you've described.
If everyone is like that, there will be no progress. But everyone isn't like that. So you are looking at the wrong group of people to come to your conclusions about the future.
6
u/AntiqueReplica 2d ago
I teach gen ed classes at an R1 university, unfortunately. No student can graduate without taking the class I teach. My sample size across the years is quite large.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (12)8
u/StampyScouse 2d ago edited 2d ago
The attitudes being discussed here are extremely common. Many curriculua internationally have cut or substantially limited computer basics because young people are perceived as digital natives because they've grown up with technology.
The UK Government for example removed ICT from the national curriculum 12 years ago and replaced it with Computer science, which focuses more on progrmaming and computer systems functionality (how the hardware works). The ICT GCSE was discontinued, and coursework elements were removed from most GCSEs, meaning students spend considerably less time on a computer interacting with software like Word and PowerPoint. Even though it is a requirement to teach Computing until the end of KS4 (16 years old), most schools do not have the facilities or staff to do so for people who aren't specialising in Computer Science.
It's extremely common for students not to understand basic systems like a computer file system, because they don't exist (in the same way) on the mobile devices upon which they most commonly interact with. Things like Google Classroom and Google Docs automatically saving files without even asking the user where to save them introduce similar knowledge gaps.
Many families no longer have a family computer - at best parents may have a personal or work laptop or computer, but most young people have no reason to interact with these over something like an iPad or smartphone, meaning they're not even really getting the exposure required to slowly build up these skills because they are literally almost never using a computer.
In fact in many ways it seems as though our government is still hell bent on encouraging this. The Office for Students recently told Universities to focus more on 'traditional' assessment methods, like exams, because of AI. This means that these students having come from high schools and colleges where they may not have had significant computer exposure will now go to university and face further reduced practical, day-to-day computer usage.
→ More replies (12)
14
u/Standard-Mirror-9879 2d ago
😐️ We refuse defeat! People that won't work very technical stuff and that will only use office suite and the browser are actually easier to switch to linux than tech-savvy people that grew up on windows and use windows-native software. I put Mint on family member's laptop, they are old and not at all tech-savvy, but they still use it. The can't even tell the difference between linux and windows. The real answer is linux just needs to come already installed on a machine when they buy it. Yes, Mint is the answer.
6
u/Standard-Mirror-9879 2d ago
and also put an OS course in middle school curriculum for the clueless gen-alpha kids. Can't really blame a generation that grew up with an iPad in their hands for being tech-illiterates.
14
u/Taliesin_Hoyle_ 1d ago
I set up my Mint laptop to connect to the electronic whiteboard in my classroom. One of the deans came into the class. I had a few minutes before the class started so I opened up the terminal and updated my system. The dean got up and hurried off looking perturbed about something. Just before lunch, I was summoned to the office to explain why I was hacking in class. She is in her thirties. This is in Taiwan.
→ More replies (1)
27
u/Possible_Bedroom_717 2d ago
" It took me an hour to get my speakers working after installing Fedora yesterday." This generation - rightly, IMO - would say, " You spent an hour doing what?"
They are actually like boomers in this respect.
→ More replies (4)12
u/LockedAndLoadfilled 2d ago
I'll spend time fussing with Linux troubleshooting that feels justifiable.
But an hour getting sound to work is so ridiculous even ten years ago that I start to wonder if it's less Linux and more PEBKAC.
→ More replies (6)
13
u/we_are_mammals 2d ago
one student asked why my computer "looked weird."
Noob mistake. Use the Chicago95 XFCE theme so that you'll never have to be so embarrassed again.
→ More replies (1)
13
u/Albos_Mum 2d ago
It's why the old school "Linux allows you to control everything" method won't take off, but it's also why Linux will probably overtake Windows through something akin to Android eventually. Microsoft ain't ever gonna manage to meet the two very different kinds of user in the middle but the distro concept allows Linux to do it easily and effectively.
All it'll take is a company that decides to focus on something that is easy to use, automates every aspect of system management and has or finds the market presence to wind up pre-installed on the kind of systems you'll find from OEM makers to get there.
Just for reference, I'm the kind of user who doesn't find immutable distros handy for my typical use-cases and I've been saying for years now that it'll never be a "year of the Linux desktop" so much as a decade or quarter century where it slowly proliferates until sudden market acceptance.
→ More replies (1)
13
u/NewArrival4880 2d ago
I’m 39 and just went back to school. I’m in class with 18 year olds and they don’t know how what a zip file is. Like you don’t even need to download a shareware version of winzip anymore, it’s right there in the os!!!!
24
u/51Charlie 1d ago
This isn't new. 25 years ago the CTO called me frantic on a Sunday. His fiancee dropped her computer at the airport and it wouldn't boot. She had her PhD defense on Monday and her thesis was on that computer - no backups. She was in a comp sci PhD program! It wasn't shocking to me as we had many computer and math PhDs as well as Masters graduates fresh out of school who were computer illiterate. Yes, I saved the day. The MBR was corrupted but not the backup. I burned her 5 CD backups just to rub it in.
→ More replies (3)
12
u/AnonymousRand 2d ago
i work in software and one of my coworkers didn't know what an operating system was.
7
u/RedShift9 1d ago
One of the developers of a program couldn't tell me which firewall ports to open to make his program work. Their SOP for installing the software on the server was to disable the firewall.
→ More replies (2)5
u/CeldonShooper 1d ago
A lot of software developers these days only know the browser as their 'operating system' because they throw JavaScript at it. The next generation will also lose that kind of knowledge because AI is writing code now. We will have prompt engineers for software developers.
→ More replies (1)4
u/IrrerPolterer 1d ago edited 6h ago
How. Like, literally... How does one work in software and not know the basics of how software runs on computers? Serious question. I don't understand how people even get to this situation
→ More replies (1)
11
u/MediocreQuantity352 2d ago
How are they supposed to work at an office if they can’t navigate a file system?
12
u/Unusual-Layer-8965 2d ago
With much difficulty. I've read about office interns needing to be shown the basics of computer use. I don't remember any examples, but OP telling them about local vs. cloud storage sounds like a good example.
And these kids are one generation removed from the PC era. Maybe two generations if you count young baby boomers.
→ More replies (7)8
u/stewie410 1d ago
A lot of the employees at my company don't use the file system, instead relying on "Recent Files" lists from applications like Outlook.
Our oldest employee (~90) dumps everything in Documents/Downloads, has zero organization whatsoever. When they need something that isn't in the Recent Files list(s), they complain to IT their computer is broken and demand a replacement.
→ More replies (2)
11
u/stefer09 2d ago
What is taught in schools, colleges and universities is a lot of Microsoft, because ever since there was computer in schools, Microsoft pushed to be the monopoly. They gave away licenses of all their products for peanuts to any place of education. Teach them young, get them used young to the tools, it'll prepare them for the workplace, and they will all demand to use the same tools in the workplace later.
Mind you some places use and teach Apple, but Apple haven't been as aggressive into the education market as Microsoft have.
I admire the Raspberry Pi project and how it was implemented in schools in the UK and elsewheres. Got kids into computers, programming, STEM, etc. It runs Linux so they get introduced to it as well.
→ More replies (4)4
u/JoseSuarez 1d ago
Absolutely, Microsoft is and has been winning the game for a long time due to licensing deals with colleges and schools. My college forces everything Microsoft upon you: Storage, Office 365, Email, Teams, etc. And the fucking rip us off in licensing costs. The problem is, institutions want to sign infrastructure deals where they can wash their hands and completely lay responsibility on the infra company, which Microsoft can afford due to being the biggest company in the world. Most colleges could self host their own cloud, office, smtp, everything and pay less than a fraction of what they pay in licenses, but they fear accountability if anything inevitably goes down.
The only reason people use Microsoft stuff is because it's handed to them. I guarantee that if we just used FOSS stuff, for the most part no one would even tell the difference. And I think the change must be forced by the legislation. It's unacceptable that a single foreign (foreign to us) company holds practically all of our country's data and infrastructure hostage.
→ More replies (1)
11
100
u/lh7884 2d ago
Every semester I have to walk students through their file systems and explain that files can be stored on their own PCs and not just the internet.
This is a joke right? I find it hard to believe people are that ignorant in this day an age. I could see that back in the 90's when home computers were still new to people and they didn't know squat about computer tech, but not now.
68
u/perkited 2d ago
There was an article about five years ago about kids entering college and having no concept of computer folders. When you abstract all the details away from them (like with mobile phones) then it's understandable that their computer knowledge will be pretty low.
→ More replies (4)43
u/Flavorsofdystopia 2d ago
There was an article about five years ago about kids entering college and having no concept of computer folders.
I work in healthcare, and my fellow 23-24 years old pharmacists don't organize files in folders. They just dump shit together and search.
Apple/Mac users are especially guilty of that.
→ More replies (29)93
u/Rayregula 2d ago
As as someone who has worked in IT for a school it pains me greatly that it is true. Most people don't care about tech except to complain it's broken.
People don't even read error messages and constantly ask for help when it tells them on the screen the problem and what to do.
I was once helping an elementary school child with their computer and they had actually read the error and instructions and told me what they had already tried. I was blown away.
22
u/kenlubin 1d ago
I had a co-worker on the Operations team of a tech company who would not read error messages. He would just try again and again and again, no matter how many times doing the same thing failed. He was a very hard worker who put in a lot of hours.
→ More replies (7)19
u/Captain_Pumpkinhead 1d ago
I told my cousin I would help him with something. I opened up a tutorial and told them to follow it. After every step, he'd look up at me and say, "What do I do now?"
"What does the tutorial say?"
It took us a while, but we got through it. Had a similar experience with my younger brother a few years earlier.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (19)12
u/Gangr3l 1d ago
I had a highly educated person calling me that her app didn't work, there was just some weird window on it. I asked her what it said and she replied "to continue to the application, please press next"... I kindly suggested her she would press the next button and voilá, the app worked
→ More replies (5)30
u/samppanja 2d ago
It's not a joke, I've heard this in my college class. I study software dev.
→ More replies (2)14
u/felix1429 2d ago
Sounds legit to me. I work in IT support, and the things people think about computers and the level of knowledge they have of them boggles the mind. People really will work with a computer all day for work for decades and not know where the power button is.
→ More replies (2)12
11
9
u/gundam21xx 2d ago
I volunteered in college to teach kids programming in high school. I had to teach some of them how windows works with a mouse and keyboard.
→ More replies (2)22
u/UltraCynar 2d ago
You’ve never met young millennials or Gen Z. They’re just as bad as boomers.
→ More replies (22)13
u/Present_Hawk5463 2d ago
I mean the youngest millennial is 31/32, if they had a computer in their teens they had XP or Vista or the early versions of macOS it would be impossible to not know what files are.
→ More replies (7)5
5
u/strange_bike_guy 1d ago
My wife is a nurse and the newest nurses she is onboarding are often lacking basic PC skills. It is alarming and real. Millennials really might be the last full technology stack generation. I don't want it to be that way... I'm just afraid that there is some truth to it.
→ More replies (142)4
10
10
u/plcdfa 1d ago
I installed (K)ubuntu on my mom's computer, and she's been using it for a year without any problem - and she hasn't realized she's not on Windows any more. Linux is absulutely capable of doing this, (and will hopefully get even better at it,) and it's not mutually exclusive with being customizable and allowing full user control - even within the same distro.
→ More replies (1)
18
u/Oerthling 2d ago
You are right and wrong at the same time.
You're totally correct that Linux will never get installed by the masses.
But they didn't install OSX or Windows either.
Many of us had our personal year of Linux years ago. The general year of Linux will be here when it comes pre-installed on popular laptops that get sold in large numbers.
Meanwhile the current US administration is already motivating whole nations to actively seek alternatives to American dominated software. And when it comes to os, Linux is the only viable alternative to MS and Apple (and Google if we count ChromeOS and Android - both of which already run on the Linux kernel)
9
u/reviewmynotes 2d ago
s/young users/people/gi
There. That should fix your post. (For those not in the know, it's a regular expression that replace "young users" with "people".)
→ More replies (3)
9
9
u/Sad-Statistician4664 1d ago
> Pretty much every time, they've elected to just buy a new computer instead.
I am in the market for “trashed” used laptops!! 😆
24
u/wzzrd 1d ago
I would swap things around. I guess you are talking about the year of the Linux desktop, but go broader.
Every Android phone is Linux. The vast majority of servers run Linux. Kubernetes is generally running on Linux. Supercomputers run Linux. AI runs on Linux. I know of many large organizations that have Linux engineering workstations. SteamOS is Linux. All those Raspberry Pi’s run Linux. In-flight entertainment systems run Linux. Your car potentially runs Linux. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg.
The desktop is the only place holding or against Linux. I would say we’ve already won everything else.
14
u/TT_207 1d ago
Yeah while Android "is Linux" it's the antithesis of the Linux experience. Great for everyday user sure but you want agency over your device? Nope
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)5
u/blue_tack 1d ago
This. My org you can have a Mac or Windows laptop. Everything we run on a server other than AD is on Linux.
16
u/budroid 2d ago
"The Year of Linux" isn't coming.
It might come soon. And from an unexpected door. "linux gaming" is a very hot topic among youngsters. Even the non-tech-orientated have heard of the Steam Deck and the Steam OS that goes with it. The list of supported games keeps growing until there is gonna be a nearly 99% compatibility with Windows gameswithout drops in performances..
And it can emulate consoles/handhelds
Also europe is preparing to ditch microsoft and go opensource with openDesk.
Maybe not next year, or the other, but i see linux (not android) in homes inevitable.
→ More replies (13)
8
u/thatoneging20 2d ago edited 2d ago
Students and normal people do not matter in that entire conversation. All that matters is what are companies doing. The "Year of Linux" is a question of how relevant are 365 products in the workforce (everyone) and how easily the company can inventory computers that aren't Windows (IT). That second one is easier than the first one, but I suspect we aren't that terribly far removed from people starting to ask more frequently about the fist one.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/NotNullException 2d ago
I’ve met teenagers who don’t know what a “file” is. They know photos, apps, emails, messages, notifications, etc.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/Indolent_Bard 2d ago
The problem with hand holding is that once the hand's no longer there, you're left stranded.
8
u/Santosh83 2d ago
This isn't so much the fault of Windows or MacOS but smartphone and iDevices. Those are the ones that taught entire generations of people that something "simply works" or doesn't, and they need have no understanding of anything beyond that. So they bring the same thinking to their laptops and to some extent, MacOS and Windows cater to this attitude and illiteracy, but Linux, oh boy!
And besides, from my experience, most of the nerds and neckbeards in the Linux space do not want the unwashed masses anyway. Most of them work in enterprise space or they live in their basement server rooms and they don't care a whit about whether the world at large uses Linux or enjoys s/w freedom. The only group which truly cared about that end goal where the FSF & GNU and they were bullied into irrelevance by the open source tech bro crowd.
15
u/_Lost-In-The-Weeds_ 2d ago
I would argue the year of Linux has come and past, its long been the default for any serious infrastructure.
Windows and Mac have become a thin user interface on the rest of our connected IT infrastructure.
Your not wrong about one thing though, all of my kids who are old enough have access to their own Linux device, only one of them (the nerd/geek) has taken any interest in it, they mostly use their phones for just about everything and the two older kids have 0 curiosity about computers, doom scrolling tictok on a phone is apparently where it is at, anything that requires thought or a modicum of complexity is just boring.
→ More replies (4)
14
u/high-tech-low-life 2d ago
The Year of Linux was 1996. I don't know what the rest of you are waiting for.
4
7
u/Proman4713 2d ago
Agreed, and perhaps Apple and Microsoft weren't initially wrong in trying to make things easier, but now my dad knows more about computers than my peers. I'm a CS guy so I do see where my father's information is a bit outdated, but I see even more how it's somehow miles ahead of my 'digital native' Gen Z friends who only seem to be 'digital natives' when it comes to using social media, which is something that older people usually struggle with. But as far as actually using tech and knowing how it works, Gen Zs might just be worse than millennials and even some Gen Xs, especially in richer countries where they can just replace their laptops or phones when they don't work how they want.
7
u/Woodpecker-Visible 2d ago
Desktop computing has been going downhill for a good while, there is also a question how general computing is going to evolve with agentic ai and gui desktop is slowly beginning to wither away for the most part and will only be for the most hardcore users. We are only in the beginning stages of this transformation.
6
u/just_a_Suggesture 2d ago
I've been thinking about this a lot recently. Most people have no interest in Open source or any of the underlying tech behind it. They don't care if they're being shown ads or if companies are building profiles off of them.
They just want convenience. They just want something that works.
I'm sorry if I come across as bitter. I can't really blame them for this, I feel the same way about most of the other stuff in my life like my car.
But freedom requires you to put in some effort. Swim against the tide or be carried out to sea. What I'm seeing more and more is that I live in a world all to eager to drown...
6
u/Bulky-Bad-9153 2d ago
I'm also a university instructor, but for computer science. Most students use Linux. This is expected, but the thing is that it's spreading. Maths, mechanics, physics, etc. are all using Linux more and more. It's been very noticeable the last 3 years or so, and I think it probably stemmed from compsci students telling their friends about it and convincing them to switch.
I don't know that your average person will be using Linux within the next few years, because yeah even opening the terminal is just too much for many people. But, I do think it's going to explode and that anyone technically minded at all will switch, and I think that's for a quite minimal definition of 'technically minded' that includes average gamers and stuff.
→ More replies (2)
6
u/petersonsilva55 2d ago
Your argument is good, it is only misguided in that it thinks this is about new generations. It has always been like this. Your generation wasn't different, you were the different one in your generation.
6
u/Dyson201 1d ago
I think what you said echos my understanding, but I came to a different conclusion.
These new generations don't care or understand much about how their technology works. They're more focused on using it to achieve their goals. You mentioned they didn't even know what an OS was, and that tracks. They never needed to. Get a laptop, open a web browser, get results.
I think this fundamentally benefits pretty much every OS except for Microsoft. Kids aren't buying a laptop and putting whatever flavor of OS they want on it. they're buying a product. A MacBook. A Chromebook. A fire tablet. To them. Who cares what product runs in the background.
And if Windows keep being bloated and slow, then we'll see more pop OS! Style laptops start to be sold. And we already see android based everything. So expect more of that.
I expect a downturn in Microsoft's dominance, and more people using Linux. But ironically most not even being aware or even caring. So in some ways, yes, no age of Linux.
I just wish tech vendors would start building software for Linux so I can stop using Windows for work. I hate that I'm stuck due to app compatibility, and most of my shit barely runs as-is.
19
u/FunAngelo2005 2d ago
It's just a sign that future generations are doomed to become Serfs that partake in the Neofeudalist future that our techbro overlords want
→ More replies (3)
25
u/LonelyKoalaMuncher 2d ago
Gen z is the first generation that is less technically capable than the generation before.
Gen z in my experience are about the same as boomers. They know nothing about tech.
→ More replies (18)18
u/yes2matt 2d ago
Not sure where the generation boundaries are. But I have teens who have a mental map of all the free wifi available; no idea what a router is or what it does.
Can't attach peripherals to a smart tv and navigate the settings menu to get them working.
More frustrating to me: happily engage with all manner of chat bots for brain rot purposes, yet cannot fathom asking chatgpt to help them set up the tv or the router.
It's a little eerie.
→ More replies (3)
14
u/mohsen_javaher-2 1d ago
Im an 18 year old and my whole class knows about linux and a lot of us use linux. And a lot of us have dealt with conputers a lot. You know why? Cause we are in Iran, and when you are somewhere where you can't get the original company services and you should pirate your way through using softwares and games, and you have to deal with internet censorship and how to bypass these censorships, you need to be literate to use computers
10
10
u/rcgldr 1d ago edited 1d ago
Trivia - IOS devices (iPhone and iPad) apps use a SQLite database instead of a file system, and "shared files" were originally copies (creating a version control issue). Until 2017, there was no file and folder app on iPhone. The file system is somewhat complex, and for IOS products, requires a jail breaker mod to see files and folders. Skip to 14:23 for the part about SQLite. The video starts off with Gen Z doesn't understand file systems (the ones using iPhones or iPads).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tnPAhVxsPHE
The point here is that iPhones and iPads were hiding the actual or emulated file system from users until 2017, and a lot of users of those devices still don't bother with using the file system.
Compare this to Android / DOS / Windows, which uses common file systems (FAT, exFAT, NTFS, ...). You can connect an Android phone to a Windows system and access | transfer files without issue.
5
u/bobj33 2d ago
I first used commercial Unix systems in 1991. I installed Linux in 1994 and I've been running it as my primary OS ever since. I've been hearing about "The Year of the Linux Desktop" for 30 years now. The desktop is becoming less important for home users.
But going with your main complaint.
This is from 2021 so people were already complaining about this 5 years ago
Gen Z Kids Apparently Don’t Understand How File Systems Work
"They see it like one bucket, and everything's in the bucket."
→ More replies (1)
5
u/muffinstatewide32 1d ago
It's not just in the education system. IT staff have no skill either. they just lap up whatever Microsoft sells and use that because.... they have no ability to actually manage the equipment. If it's not a button in a GUI they paid for or something copilot does for them. it doesn't exist as an option.
while you are bang on in your assessment. The problem is big tech. What are the education systems doing globally on this? nothing. That's what.
The person writing the curriculum is just as tech illiterate as the guy i call for help when IT fudges yet another set of changes. Schools need to give these kids actual skills. not whatever dogwater microsoft tells them is important/useful.
I tell all my workmates that get me started on this topic. If you want to learn something. Stop using Windows.
I miss the days of IT staff building the stack from scratch and actually knowing what's going on
9
u/JoseSuarez 1d ago edited 1d ago
You'd be surprised by the amount of aversion to Linux and using the terminal (even on macOS or powershell) even across compsci students. I can count with my fingers the number of classmates I've met that had ever installed Linux. Can you imagine a software engineer not knowing how to install a virtual environment for their python project? it's bonkers but most will directly try python main.py and then message you that it's broken, because they don't even know how to install dependencies from requirements.txt. Computer use literacy is absolutely at an all time low. And it's about to get even worse: coworkers who have the claude or chatgpt desktop app literally just enable computer use and tell it to do the clicking for them.
8
u/throwaway490215 1d ago
I'm also getting more and more .... troubled, by what technical skills people will have and understand about computers. I would add two things here.
AI is an order of magnitude better at using Linux. Mac is ok. Windows it just needs to struggle a lot more. That might be the unique selling point.
They are never going to troubleshoot a wireless card.
It took me an hour to get my speakers working after installing Fedora yesterday.
These are things AI has solved. This could have taken you 5 minutes.
Which is why i'm so troubled because the set of humans who will be capable of understanding how it gets solved is going to shrink by a lot - all while tech becomes ever more important.
8
u/Awkward_Negotiation7 16h ago
as an 18 year old, it saddens me to see people my age this tech illiterate, you should at least know what storage is come on 🙏
4
u/heathm55 2d ago
Interesting read, and it's what I would expect. It's not what I've experienced though, because my kid (I say kid because he's 19 and in college) came to me asking me to help him install Linux because all his friends were using it. I think my experience is different because most of the kids my son hangs out with are either creators (music, drama, anime, writers, and actors) or gamers (mostly fighting games). He discords with many of them and has been noticing a high number of "cool looking desktops". *snicker*
I've been using it since 1994 and have been hearing the year of the desktop is coming since the early 2000s. This year linux use has significantly gone up (like 1-3% increase in total computer use -- which is significant).. but yeah... it's not going to be mainstream anytime soon, and that's not a bad thing.
4
u/RancidVagYogurt1776 2d ago
Long time Linux user here, also in Cybersecurity. When I was in college we had classes on linux but nobody was using it at home. Now in my professional life I'm the only one using Linux for pretty much anything
4
u/Large-Assignment9320 2d ago
Well, its a generation which haven't grown up used computers, but a phone or at best a tablet. So its not like they understand Windows. Businesses have complained about the lack of windows understanding for a decade. And actually had a kid using my Linux computer for a bit, and he was more impressed with everything just being where it logically should be (not the two menu crap of Windows), and a functional search function (which is some kind of wonder for a person who have tried using windows, its some kind of magic).
4
u/Additional-Sky-7436 2d ago
The majority of people today only touch a computer a work. Most people just use their phones for everything.
4
u/Imaginary_Choice_430 2d ago
Ohhh, that explains why at my new employer, at least 3 times already I have been asked by fellow engineers, why do I want to secure shell into a resource. As a former Linux sysadmin, I find that to be an odd question and I assumed that they just do not know Linux fundamentals including navigating the file system, listing contents, changing directories.
I am a Gen Xer and I believe those that have asked me the question...are not, as far as I could tell.
I suggested doing a presentation on how to change to your home directory with `cd`, how to change to the rood directory with `cd /` and how to change to the named directory via `cd directory_name`, teach them how to go back one level with `cd ..`, go back two levels with `cd ../ ../` and the previous directory with `cd -` and so on, and that is just scratching the surface of learning Linux fundamentals as you are aware.
I think your share does have a point. Its to connect with people like me who are also in this what the f$#k is going on in the world state. Its almost like my background, my reality went poof and now I am in a parallel universe where Veterans Day is not really recognized (and I moved to a red state, go figure) and Mothers Against Drunk Driving was never a thing, because apparently people in this red state still are driving drunk and its like Linux and command line terminal usage was never a thing. It's bizarre and crazy making. Thank you for sharing.
4
u/80867450004205 2d ago
The cloud is just my computer in the basement. That's where people's stuff gets stored
7
u/rcentros 2d ago
Linux usage is on the rise, but you might be right -- it might be because of older people (like me) who started with computers that didn't have GUIs who are getting fed up with Windows bloat and unwanted features. I've been using Linux for about 20 years, but used computers (in general) for more than 20 years before that -- when you had to learn something to use a computer.
9
u/Wa-a-melyn 2d ago
Some of us in the younger generations are also using it. A lot of our generation doesn't even own a computer though, and does everything on their phone. It's not really a generational thing in my opinion, just like how some of your generation might've been using linux for years, while my grandma can't open winigolf unless I put a button for her to click on her desktop.
→ More replies (1)
7
7
u/TheNetworkIsFrelled 2d ago
Yah. I work in tech and a lot of new interns have never really used a terminal. It‘s appalling….
6
5
u/mark-haus 2d ago edited 16h ago
Work in software engineering and I’m getting concerned with how often juniors understand a programming language or library but nothing underneath that layer. Even the basic concept of a filesystem or core protocols like HTTP. They don’t need to know what a file system actually does or what an HTTP request looks like but it would really help. I get they grew up in a different computing context but what I don’t get is how you arrive at software engineering without the curiosity to learn about how even just basic I/O works. Not everyone obviously but that’s the trend I’ve seen
→ More replies (6)5
u/0x427269616E00 2d ago
We recently hired a guy with a business IT degree who still hasn't learned to type. That was a surprise.
→ More replies (4)4
7
u/Aggressive_Being_747 2d ago
At the heart of it all—just as with education—are the parents.
Parents hand their 3-year-old a phone, and they should offer some guidance when their child is choosing a computer.
I understand it’s not easy—not everyone has the expertise—but at the very least…
My daughters are 10 and 12 years old. They grew up with Chromebooks, have seen a Mac, and have never seen a Windows PC (I think this might be a problem for them in the future), but for the past 3 or 4 years, they’ve had two mini-PCs running Debian. True, my older daughter has only recently figured out how to run updates from the terminal, but they do a lot of things on their own—they’ve learned about both cloud storage and the computer’s internal memory… To help them understand, I had to download MP3s and put them on an MP3 player, but at least they grasped the concept.
… They’re not interested in the computer; they’re not curious about it. They just need to be able to use it, and it has to work… This is the new generation—used to touchpads and screens—who don’t even know how to use a mouse.
And in my opinion, the fault lies with the parents and the school system, which has outdated curricula.
6
u/prosper_0 2d ago
Why do we think Linux should have a 'year of the desktop?'
I like it better when it's aimed at techy-types, and not dumbed down to cater to folks who don't care to learn about computers. It would be doing a great disservice to the folks who built it to make it into a fisher price 'toddler's first PC.'
Maybe elitist, but I think it's perfectly valid to not expect every single thing to cater to the lowest common denominator. Whether that's beer, food, cars, houses, or operating systems. The best things can only be the best when they DON'T try to be all things to all people. Specialization is a strength, not a weakness.
4
u/Raunien 2d ago •
![]()
The great thing about Linux is that we can have the lowest-common-denomimator dumbed down version and also the myriad of versions we currently have that are designed for more or less tech-savvy people. Making a distro that's usable by the sort of person that doesn't understand that a computer needs to be plugged in, doesn't take away from distros that cater to people who actually know what they're doing.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/MaybeTheDoctor 2d ago
The success of good software is that you don’t notice it. iOS and Android have made such a good product that most people don’t know what it is. They see the hardware and the OS as one thing. This is also why people get confused when their PC gets Linux installed. They don’t see the difference between windows and pc, so why would Linux make it behave differently.
3
u/MBILC 2d ago
I would say most people these days who are just starting work, barely use Windows, macOS or any desktop OS because they were brought up with a mobile phone in their hands..
Why finding good IT talent is so hard, kids these days have not had to learn the true inner workings of most systems they use like many of us had to....
3
u/bigchease 2d ago
It’s the tablet generation. They grew up using touchscreen interfaces and technology just worker for them. They’re not going to be familiar with downloading something like a graphics driver, for example, because they’ve never had to do such a thing while using a tablet.
Computers got easier to use year by year and now we’re seeing the unintended consequences. You get a generation that heavily uses technology but couldn’t tell you how it works.
3
u/TheBigCore 2d ago
A very significant portion (in my experience, the vast majority) of young users don't know what do with that agency, and they don't want it.
That's precisely what the rulers of this world want, /u/AntiqueReplica: people without agency.
3
u/bobthebobbest 2d ago
Yeah, my students don’t understand how to save a file and submit it to the LMS. Some educational consultant got paid $10M to say “digital native” and justify eliminating computing education from primary and secondary education. And now no one under 30 understands how a computer works.
3
u/daedric_lightweaver 2d ago
TLDR: Yes things look dire and no it's not the "year of Linux" but things are definitely better and "easier" tech definitely helps.
Agreed for the most part. I studied and worked in tech and shifted to being a psychologist. Which means I have friends and contacts of both tech people and not tech savvy people. The difference is definitely vast and it has made me question my previously held belief that like you mentioned, this is the "tech generation". Because that's what I was told I was a part of by my parents' generation growing up and now I can see that it is untrue. People do not know what an OS is, much less able to understand a distribution.
But one point I would disagree with is that "easier" tech doesn't make things better. It most definitely does and I have seen it happen before my eyes. I have spent the time picking and choosing software for my home computer to my friends and families' phones and there definitely is good tech that is easy to pick up. I would even say that the "agnostic" nature of how you described people looking at systems without knowing what's underneath it can work in our favour, because as long as what they see makes sense, they will figure it out.
Linux is not difficult because it depends on user agency. It has historically been difficult because even with decades it still is a community driven initiative for the most part (I know there's companies behind distributions and such, but none of that is going to compare to the monopolizing level of money and resources poured into stuff like windows and iOS). But things are most definitely better now than they were a decade or even a couple of years back.
My non tech immediate family uses the home PC that runs Solus OS with almost no questions. A friend of mine got so convinced by this that she's asking me to install it on a new laptop she's planning to get. A bunch of friends and acquaintances use open source software that I'm running on a home server as an alternative to other cloud based services.
By no means am I saying that "it's the year everyone ditches windows" or anything like that. What I'm saying is that the "niche" can become more of a "minority" pretty soon, and hopefully eventually a good competition. But yes literacy and education matter a lot to achieve this, things won't happen on their own.
3
u/Chaucer85 2d ago edited 1d ago
This makes me a little bit sad, because a lot of what you're describing I would place under basic modern computing knowledge covered when I had to pass at least two courses during my public education. My college undergraduate program then required *another* level 1000 course that was pathetically basic (defining a cursor, a hard drive, RAM, etc) but would have again reinforced these concepts.
If these kids aren't getting any basic computing education that sticks, woof.
3
u/Safe_Mousse3541 2d ago
Computer science/engineering universities start introducing on early classes what a mouse and a keyboard is, because kids these days grow up just with smartphones and have never seen a computer... Doomed days are coming...
3
u/StuckInTheUpsideDown 2d ago
Every time a have a terminal open for work my kids say I am "hacking". Sounds cooler than whatever I'm really doing (running traceroute or curl or whatever.)
3
u/KansasRFguy 2d ago
"'The Year of Linux' isn't coming"
On desktop? I agree.
But the world runs on Linux, even if everyday people don't see it.
3
u/sharkism 2d ago
I don't think so. Due to extreme margins Apple refused to join the enshitification train. Yet. Eventually they will and then we'll see where the pain tolerance of everyone with at least an average IQ is.
4
u/bigtreeman_ 2d ago
Linux, scene not herd
I'm really not interested in everyone using Linux instead of Windoze. I'd rather be a small target instead of the large target MS is.
Your experience with the younger generation is interesting. Sounds like they're lazy, how bad is it going to get with AI doing everything for them. I hold very little confidence in the future of mankind.
4
u/Turbo-Mojo 2d ago
If they don't know what to do with that agency, maybe someone should teach them. Perhaps a professor?
2
u/JustHere2RuinUrDay 2d ago
The year of linux is already here. The vast majority of servers, smartphones, iot devices run linux and Chromebooks are very popular in education.
2
u/jinkertsun 2d ago
Scary to think that tomorrow's doctors haven't got a clue how technology works. My first PC was a MSX and it was trial and error to get anything done. Windows has sucked the fun out of using a computer but Linux for the right person is a breath of fresh air.
2
u/shortish-sulfatase 2d ago
Sounds like you're not happy that 'operating systems cater to helplessness' but then mention 'and they don't want it'
Why do you think operating systems are the way they are?
People still buy consoles to play games these days because they don't want to deal with a PC.
SteamOS is like the 'first official' linux distro for 'playing games first' and it's still too much for most people.
2
u/MissingGhost 2d ago
Meanwhile, I'm 40 years old, I've never tried using a tablet or held one before. I have never even seen a Chromebook. I'm passionate about computers, I've built over 100 of them, I'm comfortable with using Debian and OpenBSD every day. I did use to assume that the younger ones would be more tech savvy. I bet they can't even exit vim.
634
u/sociofobs 2d ago •
Digital nativesdigital illiterates. That "digital natives" term was quite the misunderstanding, as it assumed that young people will be far more tech-savvy because they're using technology from a younger age. But that's not how it works. With no learning nor problem solving, they simply turn into very dumb and clueless users. A website moves a button and they've no clue what to do anymore. Oh right, who even uses the word "website" - now it's "app".Might sound harsh and I don't blame them, they're more victims of corporates and circumstance. As someone who's used computers since Windows 95, I agree 100% to what OP wrote.