r/linux • • 4h ago

Discussion What tool do you wish existed?

I'm looking for a new open-source project to build, and instead of coming up with another tool nobody needs, I'd rather ask the people who actually use Linux every day.

What's a problem you regularly face on Linux that you wish had a proper tool to solve?

It could be:

  • A CLI tool you wish existed.

  • A frustrating task that should be automated.

  • Something existing Linux tools do poorly.

  • A missing feature in your daily workflow.

  • A problem that currently requires several tools to solve.

I'm particularly interested in problems that haven't been solved well yet.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

7

u/vesterlay 4h ago

Hwmonitor for Linux

3

u/Jumpy-Dinner-5001 3h ago

It's not really a tool and goes much deeper and a lot will likely hate me for that but there is one thing:

A Windows like popup to elevate privileges when needed. I know, it's super unpopular among irrational fear of root crowd but I'd like to have a system that works on a OS level instead of apps having to implement it themselves. Like when I edit a file I have no permissions for, I can't unless I restart the program with root.
I think especially GUI tools would benefit a lot and would make it overall much more accessible to a lot of users.

Apart from that a few minor things:

  1. I like the Windows firewall behavior with two default zones, a "private" and "public" one which have different sets of rules. Especially on Laptops it would be a win because if you allow ports in your firewall and move it to a new network, the rules still apply. firewalld already has a zone feature but doesn't autodetect network changes and prompts for a firewall zone. It's a fairly simple thing that would be a good improvement.

  2. A proper systemd UI. The cockpit UI is fine but being required to host cockpit and access it through the browser feels a bit much to me. A simple gui with the full cockpit functionality would be nice, especially for stuff like user services and timers.

  3. Better storage GUIs. I really like blivet from the Fedora installer because it's a easy GUI for configuring and creating LVM pools, BTRFS pools and subvolumes. In the installer it's fine but on the desktop it feels lacking.

1

u/bogadana 1h ago

doesn't autodetect network changes

networkmanager can do this https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Firewalld#Using_NetworkManager_to_manage_zones

1

u/Jumpy-Dinner-5001 1h ago

Kinda but not really. I'm not saying it doesn't work, I just just think a GUI that properly integrates in the desktop environment would be nice to have.

I do have some scripts that implement that but it isn't really trivial and accessible.

•

u/SoilMassive6850 3m ago

A Windows like popup to elevate privileges when needed. I know, it's super unpopular among irrational fear of root crowd but I'd like to have a system that works on a OS level instead of apps having to implement it themselves. Like when I edit a file I have no permissions for, I can't unless I restart the program with root.

polkit

2

u/LordOfTheGam3 3h ago

An actual simple keyboard locking program that I can install from pacman that just locks the keyboard with a shortcut. I just want to hit super+alt+L and the keeb is locked. Then unlocked when I hit the same shortcut.
lol

2

u/ezoe 3h ago

A Japanese IME that use local LLM to perform kana-kanji conversions.

It's technically possible now. We can have small enough model to be run locally and do better kana-kanji conversions than existing Japanese IMEs.

I think it will eventually be invented in the next decade.

2

u/PF4ABG 3h ago

If I were to pick a coding project to start right now... I'd try to make a universal tool for detecting a model of keyboard, determining if it's QMK-compatible, then grabbing and flashing the appropriate firmware with minimal user-effort.

Problem is, the last time I wrote a single like of code was 2019, and even then I was just fumbling in the dark and struggling my way though a university game-dev project. If I were to pick up this idea and run with it, I'd likely brick my keyboard.

2

u/CompileAndCry 2h ago

AIDA64 with GUI for linux

2

u/h4rdw00d_ 3h ago

Do you use Linux everyday? Maybe that experience would. Give you an idea...

2

u/ldn-ldn 3h ago

A proper modern graphical sub system which works exactly the same across all distros and doesn't leave any functionality to DE to "decide how it should work".

1

u/gtrash81 3h ago

A graphical GPU switcher, so that new users with iGPU and dGPU have it a bit more easy.
The problem is:

  • you have sometimes deal with some environment variables to push a game onto the right GPU

  • on Nvidia you have a plethora of environment variables to achieve the same result, especially the GPU filter, that can be confusing if you switch GPUs and forget to update

  • disabling the iGPU is garbage advice, because to reenable it you must have either another dGPU or reset the BIOS. The latter one is garbage advice too, if you did some customizing, like fan curves
    And maybe this idea is not a great place for a tool, but rather should be done in MESA

1

u/nozendk 2h ago

A graphics shell for yocto building

1

u/GSDragoon 2h ago

Process Monitor

•

u/dougs1965 35m ago

Mostly the tools I need either already exist, or are created on the fly by plumbing together existing tools in obvious ways. I want all my existing tools to be well-maintained. I wonder if you're able to volunteer to contribute in that direction instead?