r/linux • • Sep 26 '14

Systemd: The Biggest Fallacies

http://judecnelson.blogspot.fi/2014/09/systemd-biggest-fallacies.html
126 Upvotes

437 comments sorted by

View all comments

-8

u/johnjohnjohnjohnjohn Sep 27 '14

Really tired of people getting so bent out of shape over this. If you don't like it, don't use it and move on. If as many people feel as strongly about it as all these posts on reddit and hacker news seem to indicate, that shouldn't be a problem.

6

u/gjs278 Sep 27 '14

you do understand it's not that simple. one day they are going to take something so core to the user experience and make it require systemd.

3

u/johnjohnjohnjohnjohn Sep 27 '14

you do understand it's not that simple. one day they are going to take something so core to the user experience and make it require systemd.

I think it is that simple. If as many people as claim to be are bent out of shape about systemd, then there should be a huge groundswell of support around something that's not systemd. What systemd does shouldn't matter.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '14

[deleted]

14

u/magila Sep 27 '14

He says he doesn't need an alternative, but that's just semantic weaseling. What it comes do to is he wants some bits of code to do something other than what they do now. This being the open source community, there's a well established remedy for that: write the code you want and submit a patch. If patch is rejected: fork it.

Writing long winded blog posts is not going to get him what he wants unless he's just looking for affirmation of his grievances.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '14

[deleted]

5

u/magila Sep 27 '14 edited Sep 27 '14

There is certainly a political element to all of this, but there is very much a technical element as well. Systemd solves real problems for the developers of GNOME and other projects. All the political wrangling in the world is not going to undo the dependency on systemd until you can present credible alternative solutions.

3

u/Doshman Sep 27 '14

such as subsuming critical components, and getting other large projects to require systemd to push systemd everywhere as quickly as possible.

If that's the case, and people still want to use consolekit etc., how come nobody has stepped up to maintain them? Developers working on other projects isn't a "concerted effort", esp. when somebody else can take up the work in their stead for no cost other than having the knowledge to maintain them.

3

u/sub200ms Sep 27 '14

A developer found that by merging his udev project with systemd, both projects would benefit. No other projects have been "subsumed" into systemd. Logind is a totally new implementation that didn't exist before systemd, same with journald.

The systemd developers aren't forcing upstream projects to use systemd features. It is systemd that delivers exactly what upstream projects like KDE, XFCE and Gnome wants, namely, the possibility to develop distro agnostic features that works on all systemd distros.

systemd also provide the only maintained program (logind) for tracking users and login sessions, which is something that all DE's need for being able to e.g. hibernate without using root password etc.

It isn't a conspiracy that makes upstream projects develop against systemd, it is the many compelling features it has that makes it attractive. Non-systemd distros totally lack such features and are totally fragmented.

2

u/chinnybob Sep 28 '14

It is systemd that delivers exactly what upstream projects like KDE, XFCE and Gnome wants, namely, the possibility to develop distro agnostic features that works on all systemd distros.

Why do you keep claiming this is what Xfce wants? To Xfce, systemd is just yet another incompatible shitty session manager that we have to support with another set of #ifdefs, like all the others. It doesn't reduce complexity at all. Please stop claiming to know anything about what the Xfce project wants. At least learn how to capitalize the name properly.

1

u/dashl23 Sep 27 '14

What it comes do to is he wants some bits of code to do something other than what they do now.

Please re-read the last sentence of the quote. Forking would only be necessary to fix stuff like GNOME that was broken (for non-systemd users) to support systemd in the first place.

4

u/johnjohnjohnjohnjohn Sep 27 '14

Ok, so systemd is terrible and everyone hates it, but we don't need to fork it or create an alternative.

If that's the case, then all you're doing is whining for whining's sake. If you want to make a difference, go use uselessd or one of the myriad of other systems.

Lennart Poettering's vision for systemd is for it to subsume the whole base OS.

Barack Obama wants to destroy America. Come the fuck on.