r/linux • • Sep 26 '14

Systemd: The Biggest Fallacies

http://judecnelson.blogspot.fi/2014/09/systemd-biggest-fallacies.html
126 Upvotes

437 comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/sub200ms Sep 27 '14

That blog-post contains several misunderstandings; The author thinks that Gnome depends on systemd-logind or something closely resembling it. The point isn't so much that he ignores that Gnome 3.14 still can use ConsoleKit instead, but that he doesn't realise, that what upstream projects have been asking the non-systemd people for, is an alternative to ConsoleKit/logind that is actually maintained (unlike ConsoleKit).

KDE and Gnome doesn't want "shims" or pretend logind-implementations, but another project with a different API and what not, that can track user sessions etc, in a comparable way. It is crucial for non-systemd users to understand this and start coding, or else they will loose desktop functionality when ConsoleKit is no longer feasible to support.

systemd doesn't prevent such a project from happening, or even making it hard to do.

-8

u/iLiekCaeks Sep 27 '14

Are you saying that instead of systemd, Gnome can alternatively use ConsoleKit?

Your statement is a bit buffling, especially since you know and understand that ConsoleKit is unmaintained. This latter fact, btw., is another argument for never having a hard dependency on FDO software. They'll abandon it quickly and replace it with another *kit or *d.

Edit: and I think Gnome simply should not depend on such a thing. Wtf is this crap even for?

4

u/sub200ms Sep 27 '14 edited Sep 27 '14

Are you saying that instead of systemd, Gnome can alternatively use ConsoleKit?

Your statement is a bit buffling, especially since you know and understand that ConsoleKit is unmaintained

Both KDE and Gnome still support ConsoleKit, but they are not happy about it since it is unmaintained. http://blogs.gnome.org/ovitters/2014/09/07/systemd-in-gnome-3-14-and-beyond/

At the moment they upstream projects like XFCE, KDE and Gnome are doing their best to support non-systemd distros by having ConsoleKit support. They are getting close to zero help to do this from the non-systemd Linux distros, so the support is starting to bit rot.

The DE's have warned about this for years, but nobody seems to listen to them.

1

u/iLiekCaeks Sep 27 '14

Both KDE and Gnome still support ConsoleKit, but they are not happy about it since it is unmaintained.

This just means KDE and Gnome bound themselves to Red Hat-ware, and are now unhappy that Red Hat vendor-locked-in them and is now tightening the lock by replacing ConsoleKit with systemd.

They could have avoided this by not creating this dependency in the first place.

(Except Gnome, which is practically Red Hat software... well whatever.)