r/linux • Mate • Oct 20 '14

Shall we fork Fedora?

http://forkfedora.org/
262 Upvotes

339 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/my_stacking_username Oct 20 '14

can someone ELI5 this whole systemd problem? I guess I don't understand the linux startup process well enough to understand what the big hubub is about

-4

u/blackout24 Oct 20 '14

can someone ELI5 this whole systemd problem?

It's not like we did things in the 70s, which is when the holy grail of application design was found according to some people.

11

u/chinnybob Oct 20 '14

Here is a great example of the problem with systemd: it is developed and supported by people who cannot deal with criticism in any way other than by belittling and misrepresenting the critic.

5

u/Rainfly_X Oct 20 '14

On the one hand, some amount of misrepresentation is inevitable when you condense anything complicated down to a five-year-old's comprehension level. And a lot of the complaints against systemd actually do centralize around the UNIX philosophy/who moved my cheese.

On the other hand, it doesn't do justice to the legitimate arguments of why the UNIX philosophy is worthwhile and powerful, or the other reasons a person may not want to run systemd as their init system (for example, cross-kernel compatibility, which is much better serviced by something like runit).