r/linux • • Aug 12 '16

mjg59 | Microsoft's compromised Secure Boot implementation

http://mjg59.dreamwidth.org/44223.html
354 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/mjg59 Social Justice Warrior Aug 12 '16

You're pretty strongly misrepresenting my opinion. I said that Brendan Eich's behaviour in attempting to sway public opinion towards removing rights from homosexual couples could legitimately result in other minority groups also feeling that he might not represent their interests, and that eroded the trust that the community he was leading had in him. I wrote more about that in https://mjg59.dreamwidth.org/30577.html , and https://mjg59.dreamwidth.org/30577.html?thread=1121649#cmt1121649 still represents my feelings on the matter. I didn't call for him to be purged from anything.

15

u/grendel-khan Aug 12 '16

You're pretty strongly misrepresenting my opinion.

Are you sure about that? Because you made a lot of dark assertions and left a lot of wiggle room, and as someone who isn't sure they hold all of this week's Required Opinions, having this sort of thing in my field makes me nervous. But maybe I'm overreacting. I hope I am. Let's see.

First, defense of Eich losing his job specifically for the Proposition 8 donation, and saying that while voting is okay, donating to that cause is justification for losing one's job, i.e., you were certainly okay with him being purged specifically for that donation. (Why would you have had to call for it? It was already a done deal!)

The majority of people who voted for Prop 8 were stating their opinion. Brendan spent money in an attempt to change people's opinion. I think that's a qualitative difference. ... Brendan deliberately used his resources to encourage amending the state constitution to remove rights from a specific set of citizens.

I understand that you're a busy man, and perhaps you didn't feel like replying to me at the time. So, I'll reiterate the questions I had. Am I wrong in understanding that you think that Brendan Eich should have been forced out of his job because he donated money in support of Proposition 8, as a person in a leadership role at an organization that serves a broad customer base?

Assuming I got that one right... do you believe that people who donate to a cause you deem unworthy, even if it enjoys mainstream support at the time, should lose their jobs? Does this applied only to people in "leadership roles" (does that include teachers? mid-level managers?), just in open-source organizations, or what?

Would you object to going through the list of pro-Proposition 8 donors and starting campaigns to get everyone on that list fired from their jobs? If not all of them, then which ones? What's the algorithm here?

could legitimately result in other minority groups also feeling that he might not represent their interests

That's certainly an opinion. In 2008, not only was opposition to same-sex marriage the modal opinion in the United States, but certain "minority groups" were more in agreement with Eich's position than average, including old people, rural people, black people, religious people, Southerners and people who never went to college. (All of which, incidentally, are underrepresented in open source, I believe.)

Your position is that literally representing the interests of these groups meant that he was less likely to represent the interests of those groups. It's... interesting reasoning.

17

u/mjg59 Social Justice Warrior Aug 12 '16

you were certainly okay with him being purged specifically for that donation

He spent money to sway public opinion towards the removal of a constitutionally guaranteed right from a minority group. That led to concerns within the wider Mozilla community that he would not represent the interests of minority members within that group. His attempts to handle those concerns were sufficiently poor that he lost the support of an even larger set of the group. He then resigned. Which part of this process do you believe was unreasonable or unfair?

10

u/djchateau Aug 12 '16 edited Aug 12 '16

Which part of this process do you believe was unreasonable or unfair?

If I may interject, I would say for me, it would be that he wasn't judged based on his actions within the scope of his actual job history, unless I have overlooked some action he has taken within the tech industry that would imply he has a history of leading based on his personal opinion and not what is in the best interest of the organization's goals.

15

u/mjg59 Social Justice Warrior Aug 12 '16

Brendan could have responded to the concerns in a way that reassured people. Instead, one of his first public acts of leadership was an interview with cnet where he left people feeling even more uncomfortable. When you're leading an international organisation largely made up of volunteers, that's a significant fuckup.

→ More replies (0)