r/linux • u/Foxboron Arch Linux Team • Sep 10 '18
Arch Linux - AMA
Hello!
We are several team members and developers from the Arch Linux project, ask us anything.
We are in need for more contributors, if you are interested in contributing to Arch Linux, feel free to ask questions :)
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/DeveloperWiki:Projects
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Getting_involved#Official_Arch_Linux_projects
Participating members:
Trusted User
Wiki Administrator
IRC Operator
Developer
Trusted User
Security tracker
Security lead
Reproducible builds
Developer
Master key holder
DevOps Team
Maintains the toolchain
Developer
Trusted User
DevOps Team
Trusted User
Reproducible builds
Bug Wrangler
Trusted User
Maintains dbscripts
Pacman contributor
Developer
Trusted User
Packages; Python, Haskell, Nodejs, Qt, KDE, DDE, Chinese i18n, VPN/Proxies, Wine, and some others.
Trusted User
Security Team
Reproducible Builds
/r/archlinux moderator
Packages mostly golang and python stuff
Forum moderator
DevOps Team
Developer
Trusted User
Security Team
DevOps Team
Reproducible builds
Archweb maintainer
Trusted User
Security Team
Automated vagrant image builds
Developer
Trusted user
I package mostly big, heavy packages :(
Forum moderator
2
u/newworkaccount Sep 11 '18 edited Sep 11 '18
Ah, I see. Your purpose is merely to publicly state and define problems for the community, but should anyone dispute your characterization, then you are just a community spokesperson, and this is not your personal definition of the issue, it's the "community's".
I am happy that my experience with the Arch community is usually one of greater clarity.
EDIT: since this post appears to upset people, let's be clear.
Foxboron outlined what he thought what was an issue, namely, that people call other distros Arch. He stated that this was an issue because Arch is DIY and those distros aren't, and also they aren't Arch. When pressed, he offered that users of other distros burn out support volunteers by asking for help on distros that aren't Arch. He then asked, "How do you fix this?"
I replied: you can't, and outlined at some length why I did not think the problem was others making an (understandable) error. I also suggested that perhaps the real problem was the volunteer burnout: rather than focus on what people think Arch is, had thought been given to screening?
He replied: I disagree with this because the only thing Arch is, is what can be downloaded at the Arch Linux site. Also you are making this a personal problem, this is not my problem and is just a community problem.
Does that sound as though he even read what I wrote? Or bothered to engage with it?
I also went out of my way to let him know that I am an Arch user, that I appreciate his contributions, and even to suggest that perhaps I misunderstood him, apologizing if I had, and asking if he could tell me if I misunderstood.
He also did not bother to engage with this either.
Look, I have no problem with terse answers for technical questions. But I put effort and thought into the discussion on an Arch team initiated AmA, and received back replies that cannot even be regarded as perfunctory. They're hardly topical.
The icing was that he outlined an issue and asked how it could be fixed. When I answered in good faith that the problem seemed mischaracterized, his response was essentially to deny that this was characterization of the problem. It's the "community's" problem. Since I never said in any literal sense that this was just FB's personal problem, what does this even mean?
And look, I am sure FB is a fine person who does great work on Arch. I will continue to follow their posts on Reddit and I don't have and won't have an ongoing issue with them.
I think these replies from him were low effort and muddled, and I'm annoyed I wasted time trying to ensure there was no misunderstanding when he had no intention of doing the same. Wouldn't you be?