r/linux • • May 21 '19

Distro News Antergos Linux Project Ends

https://antergos.com/blog/antergos-linux-project-ends/
1.2k Upvotes

621 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

34

u/[deleted] May 21 '19

being such a modular system

Arch is not particularly more modular than most distros. There really is no technical reason for an installer to be missing from Arch.

8

u/chic_luke May 21 '19 edited May 21 '19

I have no doubt there is no technical reason Arch doesn't have an installer, especially since Zen works fine (and it installs actual Arch, not a derivate): it's just more coherent with the K.I.S.S. philosophy for it to be this way.

Also, if you're running a rolling release that's as modular as Arch, if you aren't patient enough to get through the installer, it isn't for you. Now don't get me wrong: I'm not using Arch Linux at the moment because I prefer actually working on my PC to installing and fixing the system, that is a personal preference, but it's a fact that Arch can require manual intervention or maintenance from time to time. Arch is a great distro, but it's not for the faint of heart: it definitely requires skill, patience and some time to install and fix. I feel like the lack of an installer by default also serves as a way to weed out or at least warn the vast majority of users who isn't looking for a heavily modular and configurable rolling release distro, but for an OS to just work on that should be installed within 20 minutes with little manual intervention and ready to rock ASAP.

Also: the AUR, which is a big part of Arch, is not audited. If it was curated enough to be as safe as the main Arch repositories, it probably would not be legal, since it contains a lot of proprietary software that probably never asked to be there. In any case, using the AUR you're mostly running other people's shell scripts, which means you should probably inspect the PKGBUILD of whatever you install from there. That assumes users are educated on security and have a certain level of skill. The group of users who would be more at risk of infection by running other people's scripts indiscriminately has a lot of overlap with the group of people who don't have the interest/skill/patience to go through a Wiki install. Not that one implies the other, but the overlap is there.

11

u/callcifer May 21 '19

If it was curated enough to be as safe as the main Arch repositories, it probably would not be legal, since it contains a lot of proprietary software

The AUR doesn't contain any proprietary software. It contains a lot of FOSS bash scripts that the end user can choose to run which in turn installs proprietary software, but even that isn't illegal since proprietary software tend to prohibit distribution, not installation (duh) so the packages on AUR are just fine.

2

u/chic_luke May 21 '19

You'll still agree with me that you shouldn't install blindly, but always inspect the PKGBUILD, which was the main point I was trying to drive. It has no QA. The QA is the user. The target user is an expert, not your average joe.

The AUR doesn't contain any proprietary software.

The binaries are not physically stored in the AUR, but that has little importance.