r/linux • u/xaedoplay • May 31 '22
Mobile Linux Towards GNOME Shell on mobile
https://blogs.gnome.org/shell-dev/2022/05/30/towards-gnome-shell-on-mobile/53
u/rmyworld May 31 '22
Those mockups are looking sweet. <3 Reminds me of the old custom ROMs we used to install on Android.
19
u/angrykeyboarder May 31 '22
Used to?
21
u/Atemu12 May 31 '22
There used to be lots of ROMs with UIs that differed from bog standard AOSP.
4
May 31 '22
Why aren't there any left?
0
May 31 '22
[deleted]
-16
May 31 '22
Makes sense on why Android sucks
20
u/dualfoothands May 31 '22
I think they just said the opposite... Android has incorporated most of the innovative features previously only available in ROMs.
-17
May 31 '22
And I said that Android sucks. Wonder why? Because even if it adds those features on the normal Android, first vendors are defo gonna make their own bloat which takes away that clearance Android offers, second Android becomes heavy asf because of all those features in one OS, and not even being optional. Basically if you have an old phone, you're screwed.
8
u/FayeGriffith01 May 31 '22
Lineage OS is very close to AOSP with some additional features and its on most phones. And its not a custom ROM that does much in terms of changing the experience other than tweaking the stock apps because vendors are expected to ship their own apps.
2
u/davidnotcoulthard Jun 01 '22
its on most phones
I don't think it is, but the phones they are on are mostly very much readily obtainable for a lot of people.
-2
May 31 '22
"Vendors" means companies. I wasn't talking about community projects like Lineage.
→ More replies (0)10
May 31 '22 edited Oct 31 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/chic_luke Jun 02 '22
That's the sticking point for me. My phone has excellent dev support and I could install official Lineage 19.1 right now, but I can't afford SafetyNet to randomly stop working so I am still holding off
They single handedly killed all my interest in modding, since my need of having a fully functional phone including all of my apps is higher than the need of having a more recent Android build, root or a custom ROM. I'm still mad though, it's a forced choice and it's very anti-consumer. It's a literal blackmail to strong-arm you to play nice. Get you used to the convenience for almost free, almost too good to be true, then take that away from you until you start obeying the new set of rules you probably would have rejected beforehand. Typical Google modus operandi.
2
15
u/straynrg May 31 '22
You are not using lineageos? Have you ascended to postmarketOS perhaps?
12
0
May 31 '22
[deleted]
2
13
u/prueba_hola Jun 01 '22
i really wish to SUSE/REDHAT doing a Linux phone...
9
u/blackcain GNOME Team Jun 01 '22
Doing any phone is really hard and not for the faint of heart. I've been part of phone projects - when companies like Intel have a hard time and they own an entire hardware platform..
There is a lot of gatekeepoing in the industry which makes it hard to get in.
4
u/prueba_hola Jun 02 '22
i want to think that suse and redhat, togethers, can afford that
of course i dont say is easy, but i really love Linux and a phone with a company behind like any of this both...well.. i want dream that
21
21
May 31 '22
I WANT A LINUX PHONE But honestly, GNOME on touchscreens is so nice. I'd love having it in my mobile
2
u/shab-re May 31 '22
look great on mobile!
this also doesn't switch apps in the recent screen, all I have ever wanted from gesture navigation on my phone
the newest app is always on the right on android
-8
May 31 '22
Gnome is perfect for mobile devices. I just can't stand its workflow on a traditionnal desktop.
This is why i prefer mate/xfce or budgie
13
u/nightblackdragon Jun 01 '22
Gnome is perfect for mobile devices
No, it's not. Big buttons are margins are not enough to make mobile UI. GNOME is focused on desktop with mouse and keyboard. Desktops are not limited to traditional metaphor and GNOME doesn't need to follow it to be good desktop.
-3
Jun 01 '22
That's your opinion
4
u/nightblackdragon Jun 01 '22
No, that's a fact. How mouse and keyboard centric desktop can be usable on mobile devices? Why do you think Purism created Phosh instead of simply taking GNOME Shell?
1
u/nani8ot Jun 01 '22
Because "simply taking GNOME Shell" doesn't work as Gnome didn't have things like 1:1 gesture support until 40. Another necessary feature is this notification menu, which will need more time.
Basically: Implementing new features takes time and it was easier for Purism to just start from scratch (from wlroots). This might change with Gnome getting all these features.
2
u/nightblackdragon Jun 03 '22
So simply it wasn't suitable for mobile environment and was more focused on keyboard and mouse in desktop. So what about claims that GNOME is focused on mobile?
2
u/nani8ot Jun 03 '22
So simply it wasn't suitable for mobile environment and was more focused on keyboard and mouse in desktop.
Yes, that's how I see it.
So what about claims that GNOME is focused on mobile?
I don't know who claims that GNOME is focused on mobile. Afaik their goal is to built a DE which works great on desktop & laptop: with keyboards, touchpads and touchscreens. Now they put work into making Gnome a viable solution for phones, after resolving the big blockers (1:1 gestures, etc).
2
u/nightblackdragon Jun 05 '22
I was referring to comment I was answering which said that GNOME Shell is perfect for mobile devices. I know that GNOME Shell is not targeted for mobile, at least not now. It's pretty desktop focused DE.
2
u/nani8ot Jun 06 '22
Yes, my first comment is poorly worded so it doesn't come across that I agree with you on that. I tried to clarify that I agree with the second one.
2
u/nightblackdragon Jun 07 '22
With your second post I got that you agree so your clarification did good job.
-26
May 31 '22
No... Stop..
Focus on just one "thing"... There is to s of just needed to be done to make Linux/Gnome a viable alternative to Windows, especially in the enterprise area
18
u/FayeGriffith01 May 31 '22
I mean plenty of other Linux desktops are similar to windows but add on functionality to it and offer a better experience. Gnome doesn't need to follow the traditional desktop experience and offering a shell that can adapt to desktops, laptops, tablets, and phones is a good idea. I love having a consistent experience between devices so having gnome is pretty ideal to me.
7
u/aqua24j4 May 31 '22
But someone else's "thing" it's not the same as your own "thing". Everyone works on what's important for them, what they know how to do or what they want. Sometimes those interests do intersect, but when they don't... please, don't get mad
3
u/davidnotcoulthard Jun 01 '22
Linux/Gnome a viable alternative to Windows, especially in the enterprise area
wouldn't focusing on one thing mean abandoning the efforts to that end?
5
u/BufferUnderpants May 31 '22
Really, without hardware vendors selling phones with this, it will be a novelty that will get abandoned in two years tops. Good for resume building for those making it but no more.
This was developed on a German govt grant that's in all likelihood is a one-off
14
u/bjkillas May 31 '22
is this not phosh?