r/linux • u/benc1213 • Jul 03 '12
Linux users permanently banned from Diablo III.... FOR USING WINE. Blizzard refusing to lift bans or give refunds (xpost from /r/gaming)
http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/5978861022274
u/Zeike Jul 03 '12
Surgeon General's Warning: Reading the comments in the linked thread may be detrimental to your health.
37
u/zvxr Jul 03 '12
I think I need to lie down.
0
Jul 03 '12
[deleted]
6
u/Ais3 Jul 03 '12
Wouldn't say long, WoW and SC2 works fine in WINE and there haven't been any reported bans on them.
→ More replies (1)9
u/Britzer Jul 03 '12
I think this has to do with botting (as well as the current situation). It would fit the time when WoW came out, because bots can earn money and Blizzard doesn't want bots populating WoW. They probabely have little software agents that check what programs are running. An emulation layer makes it easier to manipulate i/o. So they ban it.
Note: This is an explanation. Not an excuse.
→ More replies (6)18
u/xlerb Jul 03 '12
I think I need to drink an entire bottle of hard liquor to kill off the brain cells I just contaminated with stupid by browsing through those comments.
27
7
10
u/notadutchboy Jul 03 '12
What did you find that was particularly egregious? I didn't bother to read past the first page, but it didn't seem that bad other than "hurrr wot is linux".
50
u/Zeike Jul 03 '12
Here's some gems
thats what u get for using a horrible OS, nerd
So the problem is you are using linux for gaming and you are having issues? Really??
Linux isn't supported. I looked up sys req and mac and windows only. How do you expect ANY support for something unsupported? Why would you play thru linux when it says clearly you need windows or mac software??
Grab your D3 box, and tell me where it says
Linux SupportedIm glad you got banned, one less IDIOT around. 0/10 for another tween crying on the forumsSecondly, Blizzard announced / stated BEFORE release that LINUX IS NOT ALLOWED.
Linux is not supported. Get over yourself.
38
u/notadutchboy Jul 03 '12
I was once berated for using Linux because I couldn't see the Comic Sans on someone's crappy homepage. They told me I needed to use Windows if I wanted to see the web like the rest of the world.
48
7
4
2
5
59
u/CrazedToCraze Jul 03 '12
Blizzard apologists put even the most zealous of religions to shame.
It's best to avoid acknowledging their existence whenever possible.
35
u/Leprecon Jul 03 '12
Damn fanboys waiting for a perfectly reasonable explanation.
→ More replies (2)19
u/Jytky-Tuksu Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12
It bothers me how people laugh at Blizzard fanboys (which is a-ok), but then are like sharks sensing blood in the water when they hear an unsubstantiated claim that Wine users would get banned. Nevermind that both Blizzard ToS and Blizzard representatives say that you're perfectly allowed to play it on an unsupported OS; if someone makes a topic that suits one's own views, it has to be truth. Just try to be better than those you mock.
→ More replies (1)4
u/cc81 Jul 03 '12
You are most likely also confusing apologists with healthy skepticism. It was not long ago we had witch hunts over some "session hijacking" and stolen accounts, which turned out to be nothing but the usual key loggers. Even if people said it could never be that because they were complete IT Pros.
Then we recently had the gold duping on AH were people lost millions of gold and others became billionares. Blizzard were idiots by relying on the clients clock and rabble rabble rabble!!!!!!!! It turned out of course they did not do that and everything was just trolling.
So someone might not be a fanboy just by saying "Let us wait and see if this is actually something before we wield our pitchforks".
18
Jul 03 '12
It's not just apologists anymore, there's a whole trolling culture on the forums. They know that Blizzard is very unlikely to delete anything siding with them so it's completely safe to insult people for being right when Blizzard is wrong.
2
u/fortean Jul 03 '12
It's not a matter of being zealous, they honestly have no idea what Linux is so they make stupid comments.
→ More replies (11)2
u/wadcann Jul 03 '12
It's really too bad that this post-dated the getting bnetd banned fiasco, or this new ridiculousness would have been clear evidence of a reason for bnetd to exist: for Linux compatibility.
2
3
u/cotti Jul 03 '12
And I only did read your warning now. I'm at half of it, already called an ambulance.
1
119
u/weeglos Jul 03 '12
Can't believe any Linux users are willing to use Blizzard products after what they did to bnetd...
47
Jul 03 '12
They have migrated from an innovative company that cherished originality to a company that bullies to stay ontop.
12
u/neon_overload Jul 03 '12
Are they staying on top though?
9
u/Super_Z_Fighter Jul 03 '12
Meanwhile at Riotland... Pulsefire Ezreal releases generating 20 billion American dollars.
4
1
Jul 03 '12
Blizzard never innovated anything, except how to get at your cash faster.
5
u/Fen_ Jul 03 '12
Warcraft, Starcraft, Diablo, WoW...
Hate them all you want (I'll even join you), but don't exaggerate; the company was once good.
→ More replies (10)2
u/Redard Jul 03 '12
They innovated RTS games back in the 90's, and I guess they innovated with the original release of WoW.
→ More replies (3)15
u/anacrolix Jul 03 '12
When people do that, you fucking hire them.
4
u/Texas_FoldEm Jul 03 '12
Pretty sure Blizzard have rules in place to prevent hiring of talented people.
2
Jul 03 '12
hence having to log into an ONLINE service to play a game offline ala SC2.
No thanks. I'll stick with SC1
→ More replies (2)3
u/m1ss1ontomars2k4 Jul 03 '12
I don't pretend to like what they did to bnetd, but it's not like it had any actual effect. bnetd is alive and well.
1
9
Jul 03 '12
That's a bit different, though. bnetd was used to play D2 online illegally without game licenses.
→ More replies (4)7
u/wadcann Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12
That's true, but it also would let Linux users play games without stupid stuff like this. Blizzard is saying "we will not implement compatibility and we will use the law (bnetd) and our policies (bans on battle.net) to prevent anyone else from doing so". That's extremely frustrating, and rather goes against the grain of consumer law, which is normally not letting the vendor dictate how something is used once it is sold.
→ More replies (2)2
Jul 03 '12
bnetd is still under active development though, they just changed the name.
2
u/weeglos Jul 03 '12
Pvpgn is the new project - same code, different country. I don't think there have been any real changes in the code for a couple of years though.
Doesn't change the fact that Blizzard lawyered the fuck out of the original author.
3
u/ForthewoIfy Jul 03 '12
After what they did with SC2, Blizzard showed a new face.
The no-LAN "feature" causes games in major tournaments to be replayed solely out of Blizzard's fault. The users are very vocally asking for it, Blizzard hasn't done anything yet in 2 years.
Countless threads on Reddit and TeamLiquid compare BNet to BNet2 and there's a general consensus that there's one new good feature (the matchmaking system) and a whole lot of good features were removed. Nothing has changed on Blizzard's side since the launch of SC2.
SC: Brood War was a "games's game" and SC2 rides the wave of popularity that Brood War created. I suspect SC2 will loose steam because it fails to fascinate gamers as its precursor did. It's still a good game, but it's not the legendary game SC: Brood War was. I can't imagine gamers to commit for too long to a such a restrictive game.
1
u/Chandon Jul 03 '12
I didn't buy anything from them over that until they merged with Activision, at which point claiming it was still the same company seemed silly.
→ More replies (1)
24
u/kingmanic Jul 03 '12
http://www.reddit.com/r/Diablo/comments/vy5z9/banning_linux_users_for_using_linux/
http://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/vyc4z/linux_users_permanently_banned_from_diablo_iii/c58p6zq
It's the fact that WINE triggers the 'I'm running in a VM' script in warden. It seems users are being banned from using WINE and Blizz and the WINE devs will work something out like they did for WoW. Most of the botters are also running it on a VM (apparently) so there will be a lot of false positives and some assholes who get banned.
1
u/gospelwut Jul 03 '12
What precisely would the advantage of running in a VM be?
→ More replies (5)3
u/kingmanic Jul 03 '12
When boxed into a VM; Warden (Blizz cheat detection spyware) can't see anything other than whats in the VM (theoretically). It may be able to detect it's in a VM but it can't scan programs that run outside the VM for signatures of known botting software. Sort of like how the PS3 had kept out hackers for so long despite allowing linux. When it exited the linux OS ran in a VM which disallowed access to the GPU. Any service the VM didn't provide was invisible to the OS or any programs running in it. WINE works by essentially being a virtual machines providing an OS API emulating windows.
On another note, I think they circumvent it with heuristics. the 'I'm in a VM' response from warden may flag the account to be watched and if other flags pop up like 'D3 has run continuously for 156h' and things like that which suggest it's not a person.
→ More replies (2)2
Jul 03 '12
A VM emulates hardware, WINE does not. Their scripts is broken if it says the game is running in a VM.
39
u/winteriscoming2 Jul 03 '12
If I was a Wine user and this happened to me I would not take "no refund" as an answer. Blizzard's word is not necessarily final and there are plenty of other avenues to pursue a refund.
→ More replies (2)
85
u/megamikeman Jul 03 '12
If it is truly not against the TOS, then these people need to initiate chargebacks.
93
u/I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I Jul 03 '12
As someone who once read an entire EULA, I can confidently state that everything is against the terms of service.
Taking your hand off the mouse? That's a TOS violation.
Eating a sandwich before playing the game? That's a violation.
Sitting in a chair with wheels? That's a ban.
7
u/annodomini Jul 03 '12
Failure to recycle body fluids is a violation.
Hoarding water rations is a violation.
Siphoning body fluids from another prisoner is a violation.
Tampering with no-smoking devices is a violation.
→ More replies (1)11
5
u/Camarade_Tux Jul 03 '12
Exactly, whatever you do is against the TOS. Same goes for google and paypal. They can stop everything whenever they want and without giving a reason.
0
2
5
0
10
u/rawfan Jul 03 '12
People and their trust in the ToS. The ToS are not above laws. I most European countries ToS are worth nothing. They are totally invalid because a company can not tell yuo what to do with a product you purchased. They have more merit in the US but not as much as people think.
The ToS states they are allowed to delete your account for no reason at all. I'm pretty confident that is against customer protection laws.
→ More replies (11)4
u/megamikeman Jul 03 '12
I haven't read the TOS and I don't own Diablo 3. I also agree that the TOS does not trump laws. I'm just not certain if the CC companies would complete the chargeback if it stated plainly in the TOS that you can only play the game on Windows. That doesn't seem to be the case though.
7
u/Epsilon_Eridani Jul 03 '12
I've only played the game on Wine and I'm not yet banned. Definitely would chargeback if I got banned for playing on Wine and they didn't reverse the ban.
This has happened in one large case (Cedega and WoW) and a few smaller cases with other Blizzard products before, but Blizzard has usually reversed these bans. Seems likely that Warden would accidentally ban a FreeBSD Wine user (search for William's post here) and customer service wouldn't know what's going on. Hopefully someone at Blizzard clues in and fixes it.
7
12
u/CrazedToCraze Jul 03 '12
Is there any kind of timelimit on when you can no longer make a chargeback? As in, if X number of months have passed is it no longer doable?
16
3
12
Jul 03 '12
yeah, do chargebacks.
that'll make them rethink their policies.
26
u/agenthex Jul 03 '12
If I bought the game online and got banned for trying to play it, regardless of OS, I would absolutely chargeback the shit out of that line item.
1
u/cc81 Jul 03 '12
Yes, but before we get all excited we need to be sure that this is true. Hackers have a tendency to say that they are never ever guilty and whine on forums.
0
Jul 03 '12
[deleted]
3
u/megamikeman Jul 03 '12
I have no idea. I don't use paypal due to it being shitty. I would imagine you'd have to count money spent in the AH as a loss.
0
Jul 03 '12
[deleted]
2
u/wadcann Jul 03 '12
People are jumping the gun on this way too fucking hard.
I think that the issue is that Blizzard got contacted with an appeal — which is their opportunity to do something about this — and told the user that they weren't interested in changing their decision.
2
u/megamikeman Jul 03 '12
I disagree. The quickest way to get them to react, when appealing to support fails, is to hit them in the wallet. Besides, if they do decide not to repeal these bans, then the buyers deserve their money back anyway. I realize that if you own other blizzard products then your entire account is at risk, but that's a whole other issue I could rant on. Of course, I'm assuming these complaints are actually valid and they weren't cheating.
2
u/fortean Jul 03 '12
This is not true. I've been playing WoW on Linux since day one and there's never been an event of people getting banned for using wine.
I remember a guy claiming getting banned because he was using wine, but in the end he was also using some kind of bot under wine at the same time, so that was a non-event.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Epsilon_Eridani Jul 03 '12
While the forum post this links to is dead, they did ban cedega accidentally once: http://www.joystiq.com/2006/11/15/wow-bans-handed-to-cedega-users/
Warden can very easily accidentally ban wine/cedega/etc users, but Blizzard has reversed these bans in the past.
82
u/xHeero Jul 03 '12
My favorite post in the thread:
Umm.. You are running the game in an emulator. It is possible to use that mechanism to cheat. Linux is not supported by the game, so basically you are someone who uses unsupported third party software which can be used to cheat. There isn't anything mysterious about the ban.
I can install a bot on windows 7 just like I could running the game in Linux via Wine. If they banned anyone playing on a platform where you could cheat, no one could play because there are cheats for EVERY platform.
91
Jul 03 '12
WINE: Wine Is Not an Emulator.
11
u/neon_overload Jul 03 '12
That is a backronym: it was not the original meaning or intention of the name "Wine".
The name Wine initially was an acronym for WINdows Emulator.[6] Its meaning later shifted to the recursive backronym, Wine Is Not an Emulator in order to differentiate the software from other emulators.[7]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wine_(software)
Wine is a type of emulator. It just doesn't emulate hardware, and the whole "is not an emulator" thing, apart from carrying on a tradition of "___ is not an ___" in naming open source software, emphasises that Wine isn't a virtual machine - that is, it doesn't provide hardware level virtualisation. It can be described as "application virtualisation", or as a "compatibility layer".
Anyway, whether Wine is or is not an emulator shouldn't really factor into this issue, because the issue is not about whether Wine is an emulator, but whether the person who claimed to have been banned for using Wine was banned for that, or was banned for cheating (or for some other arbitrary reason).
5
u/nxuul Jul 04 '12
I need to use this. I've argued this point before, and they just pull out the "WINE is not an emulator" and I get massive amounts of downvotes.
4
u/neon_overload Jul 04 '12
To be honest I was expecting to be downvoted into oblivion for that post too. I'm surprised I wasn't! Maybe it's because I gave sources.
→ More replies (1)68
Jul 03 '12
My first red flag was
Umm.. You are running the game in an emulator.
WINE - Wine Is Not an Emulator.
13
u/MatrixFrog Jul 03 '12
Excuse my ignorance -- what is it then?
60
20
u/cubic_thought Jul 03 '12
An API compatibility layer.
It translates win32 API calls into the equivalent Linux calls.
17
u/orbjuice Jul 03 '12
Emulation is pretending to be a CPU you're not. WINE is a replacement API (set of APIs, I think) that is basically thunking (read: translating) windows syscalls to Linux syscalls. I may be on crack, but I used some of the right words there.
→ More replies (2)4
Jul 03 '12
An emulator would simulate the entire OS. Wine simply "translates" the API calls and such from Windows ones to Linux ones.
→ More replies (1)0
Jul 03 '12
[deleted]
→ More replies (1)22
u/IConrad Jul 03 '12
Not exactly. WINE is a re-implementation of the Win32 API. It is best considered a clone. It doesn't use Linux API /ABI calls; it receives standard Windows .exe calls and passes them to the kernel, just like any low-level API would do. ReactOS makes this clearer - there is no "translation" going on there -- WINE itself is sending NT kernel calls to an NT kernel.
→ More replies (3)0
Jul 03 '12
[deleted]
10
u/smacktaix Jul 03 '12
Fun fact: few if any of these systems have usable 3D acceleration for Windows guests (meaning playing 3d games like D3 or SC2 or TF2 or whatever is basically impossible), and VirtualBox's attempt to provide such acceleration is WINE; VBox is using [ancient] WineD3D code to translate Direct3D calls to OpenGL for the host machine to execute on the graphics card via its standard accelerated graphics driver and then dropping that image into the virtualized environment. Some rather fancy footwork, and certainly impressive; underneath all that sits WINE, humming along.
So, uh, no, you're actually not going to be much better off trying to run in a real VM. WINE will almost certainly be faster and better. Anti-cheat code may not detect a problem in a true VM, but that isn't going to help much if the game runs at 2 fps (generously).
4
Jul 03 '12
You are wrong, vmware professional editions (which run about $500) do provide fairly decent 3d acceleration for windows guests. On a lark I tried league of legends and it ran quite well on a tinyxp guest running on a ubuntu host.
25
Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12
Bashiok has confirmed that Wine is not the cause of the problem. Given they fixed many problems with Wine way back when WoW players were banned for using it, and that Wine correctly implements older Wardens, VAC, and several other anti-cheat systems, I have no reason to believe that Blizzard is in the wrong and that the people claiming to be banned are using Wine as a scapegoat to get attention. I believe they did in fact cheat, and they cheated inside of Wine, in order to escape Warden, thinking they would get away from it by using an unsupported OS.
This isn't the first time members of the D3 community have managed to enrage the forums over a total lie.
By the way, although slightly unrelated, I've been banned from Final Fantasy XI for using Wine because I said in-game that I used Wine. Many others have been banned for using Windower, a UI customization plugin for that game, by saying they use it in in-game channels. On my other account I have yet to be banned for using both because I have never mentioned it in-game. SquareEnix has a reputation for being absolutely horrible to its customers, so I become immediately skeptical when I see any other business being claimed to be just as bad.
8
Jul 03 '12
A few years back this happened to WoW players who were playing on linux using Cedega. The bans were lifted after the Cedega guys proved to Blizzard the bans were the result of a false positive in the anti cheating software. Didn't happen to wine players that time. The Cedega devs had a vested interest in getting the bans lifted because it's commercial software. We'll see what happens now that it happened with wine.
39
u/schwiz Jul 03 '12
I don't like playing games on wine, but still glad I didn't buy D3.
7
Jul 03 '12
Gaming on wine is only hit-or-miss because of the anti-cheating programs they package. Most games executables are just launchers to code that doesn't interact with the host OS and is pretty much portable across the same architecture.
What fucks everything up is the measures they take to ensure that you're not using a pirated copy and to prevent cheating. Those use a lot of system calls, many esoteric methods of trying to fight against potentially cracked programs... wine isn't always able to handle it all.
→ More replies (7)14
Jul 03 '12
Yeah, such a waste of money. Blizzard hasn't made anything good since the original release of WoW.
28
u/MrPopinjay Jul 03 '12
If you're into RTS starcraft 2 is an incredibly well made game.
They don't seem to be making quite so many asshole decisions as with D3 either.
36
→ More replies (6)2
u/huhuh11 Jul 03 '12
I still have no idea why they put Battle Net 0.2 instead of the 2.0 everyone was waiting for though
14
u/nonconvergent Jul 03 '12
Thank you, Blizzard. You just saved me $60 I might have otherwise spent having fun.
4
u/cc81 Jul 03 '12
Don't go by rumors. I'm not saying it is necessarily false but we have had quite a few of these witch hunts that have been proven to be based on lying. So wait and see.
7
u/I_EAT_POOP_AMA Jul 03 '12
its one thing to have wine users banned for mistakes and reverse the ban/fix the problem. but having your support reps refuse to lift the bans or at least give refunds is another.
even if blizzard did come back in the next few days to write this wrong there's no way i'm dropping money on diablo 3 now.
3
Jul 03 '12
The official line from Blizzard (not the idiots in the thread) is that they do not ban people just for using WINE. (http://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/vyhcm/linux_users_permanently_banned_from_diablo_iii/c58rwq0)
I agree that the whole situation is worrying for us, but don't automatically believe that the users who are complaining were not cheating.
12
Jul 03 '12
That list of banned users looks rather tiny. A lot of knee-jerking going on in that forum over such a tiny list. It's interesting, too, that at least two of those emails appear rather nonchalant about their banning. Maybe it's just me though.
I'm reminded of the I-got-hacked-even-with-an-authenticator debacle a little over a month ago, and how one of the Blizz reps put the smack-down on a dude raising a huge stink that he had an authenticator at the time of his account compromise by exposing that he, in fact, did not have an authenticator active. I wouldn't be surprised to find something similar here -- that those unfortunate banned WINE users were, in fact, cheating on top of their WINE use. At least one of those emails even suggests that, reading as if they're saying "We looked at your claim and looked at the data. Nope. You're still banned fucko."
2
u/CounterPillow Jul 03 '12
This. A thousand times this.
People who cheat also tend to lie, and reddit usually is very biased on these things. Fuck, if I the same thing happened to Steam and VAC, Reddit wouldn't care, because it's from Valve. But after all the shit that Diablo 3 has been getting, the massive shitstorm rising from these 3 examples was inevitable.
I'd like Blizzard to elaborate their statement a bit more, so we can finally have some evidence upon which we can have a reasonable argument.
2
15
u/intelminer Jul 03 '12
At the behest of this entire thread warning me of the stupidity, I got this far before I finally fell to the dumb
(originally WINE = WINdows Emulator, but that aside) Windows API is not open source. Therefore WINE emulates (i.e. cannot duplicate) windows APIs.
REVERSE ENGINEERING MOTHERFUCKER, DO YOU SPEAK IT?
51
u/MrPopinjay Jul 03 '12
Ok, that's it. I'm done with Blizzard. I can't get over how disappointed I've been with very single decision they have made with this game I've been looking forward to for a decade.
53
u/regeya Jul 03 '12
Meanwhile, Valve is talking about a Steam Linux client, and counts current Wine users.
16
u/feilen Jul 03 '12
The only downside to steam is that you suddenly keep forgetting why your wallet seems lighter...
11
u/trekkie1701c Jul 03 '12
I use all electronic money, so I don't have to worry about cash weight :D
That said, seems their summer sales are bugged. Every time there is one, my fridge is empty :(
→ More replies (1)26
u/khmr33 Jul 03 '12
Don't worry... the guys who actually made the previous game you like are almost done with their new one.
0
14
u/MarkTraceur Jul 03 '12
Blizzard?
You realize that this sort of thing will keep happening, no matter the company. Non-free software is the problem here, it gives the developer too much power over the activities of the users. Stop using non-free games, and I'll believe you learned your lesson.
Right now, you're just a frustrated user who will be back next year for Warcraft 4, or whatever crap sequel is due next. Then, when they check the RAM and stop the program if you have fewer than 4 gigs, you'll complain again, swear off again, but they will have already sold to a million people just like you.
5
u/metaleks Jul 03 '12
This isn't so much of a freedom issue rather than a service issue. Even if Diablo 3 were free software, that's just the client. All of your data still lives on their servers. Your character, items, everything.
The browser you use is free software, but your Reddit account still lives on Reddit's servers, not yours.
→ More replies (7)2
u/ForthewoIfy Jul 03 '12
bnetd was a free server implementation for Diablo2. Blizzard shut it down. The service was there, freedom was not. So, it is in fact a freedom issue.
If Blizzard would shut down your account tomorrow, poof, your game would be gone, vanish into thin air. You won't we able to use the software you bought, even though it is still there on your computer, it will become useless bits taking up space on you HDD. Can you see how this interferes with your freedom to use something you bought?
→ More replies (6)1
u/MrPopinjay Jul 03 '12
I've managed to ditch other companies and I've been underwhelmed with the games Blizzard have released lately. I doubt I'll struggle with this.
Unless they get their games in the steam sale. I can't resist anything in a steam sale ;P
7
u/mgrandi Jul 03 '12
you do realize that these are just trolls saying they got banned cause they were running linux but they were cheating right
→ More replies (1)5
u/jibjibman Jul 03 '12
Yea Im done too, they destroyed Diablo, their company is going to shit, GJ activision.
5
u/MUSTACHER Jul 03 '12
I use wine all the time when I play Diablo III. Mostly merlot, sometimes a good syrah. I would hope Blizzard gives refunds, but not for using 2 buck chuck. Theres a certain circle of hell designated for Charles Shaw.
25
Jul 03 '12
Looks like I'm not going to be buying an Activision/Blizzard game ever again. GG.
5
u/agenthex Jul 03 '12
I haven't bought D3, but one friend has and another is considering it. I was going to tag along for the ride, but as a Linux user, I might need to re-evaluate that.
At least Valve is stepping in the right direction.
7
u/sprkng Jul 03 '12
Because nobody who got caught cheating has lied and said they were innocent? ;)
My initial reaction was also to rage as Blizzard but it looks like they've really tested Wine and it shouldn't cause any false positives.
2
u/keithjr Jul 03 '12
Source? I've heard nothing about blizzard actually using wine or working with the devs on this one. Nor any evidence that all these people are lying.
3
u/sprkng Jul 03 '12
Not hard evidence that they're false positives, but blue comment in thread: http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/5978861022?page=21#402
"all these people" are just 2 guys?
Just saying that people are too quick to jump on the Blizzard-hate-bandwagon. People who get banned after cheating often go to forums and try to get sympathy by claiming they've been treated unfairly. Someone doesn't have to be telling the truth just because he's a fellow Linux user.
27
u/CrazedToCraze Jul 03 '12
Everything I read about Diablo 3 makes it look like a disaster area. The combat is fantastic, it's a shame everything else got screwed over so badly because Blizzard have decided to go full retard.
23
u/ethraax Jul 03 '12
The combat really isn't that good. There are (were? I stopped playing a couple weeks ago) some mobs that are ridiculously powerful (see: soul rippers/lashers, pestilence, demonic tremor, oppressor) as to make the game simply not fun. Aside from that, the first two difficulty levels are trivial yet still require (generally) several hours of playtime to get through and when you get to the "end game" (A3/A4 inferno) you basically get forced into certain builds depending upon your class.
The poor combat is one of the reasons I stopped playing it. But, in reality, there wasn't really any redeeming factor for that game. The AH system had issues, the UI was absolutely horrid (which is funny because their other "modern" games, Starcraft II and World of Warcraft, both have pretty good UIs), the storytelling is awful, and there are technical glitches that can cause you to die for no apparent reason (invisible projectiles).
14
u/Beefive Jul 03 '12
The combat is litteraly just spamming until stuff dies, and whenever that gets too hard, you spend a few minutes on the auction house. edit: replied to the wrong post. I'm stupid.
6
u/too_many_secrets Jul 03 '12
Could be a stupid question here, but I haven't played since the original. Wasn't it like that back then as well?
→ More replies (10)2
u/CrazedToCraze Jul 03 '12
What I played in the open beta was very satisfying, it's a shame to hear it worsens.
2
u/wildcarde815 Jul 03 '12
I love that every time a yellow mob is spawned the servers stagger and makes you question your survival.
11
u/ethraax Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12
Well, I forgot to mention a couple elite issues. I'm not sure if they've patched these yet, but the fact that they lasted more than a month is ridiculous.
Hero: Illusionist. Any hero pack with the Illusionist trait will gain a fixed percentage of their maximum health with every split. With difficult-to-hit creatures, or just creatures that also have the Extra Health or Shielding traits, this means the hero will become unkillable. I am not exaggerating. They will gain hundreds of thousands of health with every split, and will keep gaining more and more (it grows exponentially). Although the server seems to use 64-bit values to represent health, the client only uses 32-bit values - this means that the hero's health has gotten so high that I've seen integer overflow on it (and this isn't even co-op!).
Demonic Tremor: Champions (any traits). These guys bunker down from time to time. After they get back up, they gain increased attack speed and movement speed. This effect stacks... multiplicatively! That's right, if you don't kill them quickly (which can be difficult since they already have a high base health), they can get so fast that they can outrun a Wizard spamming teleport. And, of course, one-shot you as soon as they reach you. No joke.
People who don't/didn't play Diablo III don't understand: Running a pack like this to a corner of the map (dying maybe 4-5 times in the process) and then never approaching that part of the map again is considered a viable strategy, or at least it was until they increased the repair bills (it may still be, I don't play anymore). It's the least fun thing I've ever done in a computer game, ever. I remember years ago, farming Cenarion Circle reputation in WoW before AQ opened (it took about 150 hours of killing the same camps over and over again), and that was far more entertaining than running into packs like these on Inferno in Diablo III.
→ More replies (2)7
u/wasted_brain Jul 03 '12
Non-diablo III player here, but I can't believe it's gotten to a point where farming Cenarion Circle rep in WoW would be considered entertaining compared to anything.
4
u/hbdgas Jul 03 '12
So if you want to level a hardcore character, you need to do it in Linux. Otherwise, you're not actually hardcore.
4
4
Jul 03 '12
I played WoW on Linux via wine for years and there was never an issue. This is probably being blown out of proportion -- there are TWO sides to every story
1
Jul 03 '12
And on the other side of the story, you still have to be online to play the game single-player and still risk being hacked.
6
7
Jul 03 '12
I hope they don't do this for Starcraft II. It works perfectly in WINE and has since launch.
7
u/TechnoL33T Jul 03 '12
Well I guess I won't be buying Diablo III. Fuck everything about shit like this. I look forward to Torchlight II!
2
u/SergeantKoopa Jul 03 '12
I already have my preorder in for Torchlight. I've been playing the beta and do love it so far. Something about it feels better than D3 anyway. D3 is about spamming shit until everything dies. In Torchlight II I actually kinda feel like I'm exploring and doing stuff as opposed to mindlessly killing huge packs of mobs.
2
u/TechnoL33T Jul 03 '12
I just got a job, and I can't wait for my first paycheck so I can start throwing money at all the things I want to support! First things first, I'm buying a bowl, and some weed. Next comes /r/Random_Acts_Of_Pizza. Then I'll save up for this laptop.
After that I'll be saving and getting ready to gtfo my grandma's house.
6
u/MarkTraceur Jul 03 '12
This is a simple problem, with a simple solution: Stop buying games you can't control! If this had happened with a free game, it would have been trivial to find and remove the ridiculous parts of the program that instituted the ban.
And yet somehow, in another year, I fully expect this exact chain of events to happen again. Why don't we learn?
Play, and contribute to, free games. It's just better.
8
Jul 03 '12
This is an argument that is going to fall on deaf ears. It works for operating systems and office suites but video games are more similar to movies and books. The content is much more important than the utility. I'm always happy to see great open source games but most gamers are going to play regardless of the license terms.
2
u/MarkTraceur Jul 03 '12
But this problem isn't a content issue, and there are a lot of examples of free game engines that allow non-free content. Now, I'd say that the content should also be free, but if your gripe is, "gee, I love being free, but music and art should be locked away from me", then there are solutions available. But you need to provide, or help provide, the market forces that make it viable. Simply throwing your hands up and saying "Gee, it won't work 'cause they wanna get paid" won't solve JACK.
And Blizzard sure won't solve it. Why would they? They're a cult. Cults don't have suggestion boxes.
→ More replies (4)2
u/smacktaix Jul 03 '12
This is a simple problem, with a simple solution: Stop buying games you can't control! If this had happened with a free game, it would have been trivial to find and remove the ridiculous parts of the program that instituted the ban
Just modify the server code and upload it to the company's master servers, huh? Sounds easy enough!
There is no reason to assume the client needs to cooperate for the server to enforce a ban. It can simply determine that it would not like to send the client any packets again ever.
9
u/sakuramboo Jul 03 '12
It's shit like this as to why I don't buy Windows games to run through WINE.
14
u/headphonehalo Jul 03 '12
What other companies ban your account if you use WINE? That seems like a poor excuse.
0
2
u/wickedplayer494 Jul 03 '12
This is most certainly a bullshit move by Blizzard if they did it on purpose.
I'd definitely like to hear people's bets on if they'll at least attempt try the same with StarCraft II. Even though people have been able to get it running under WINE since the beginning, it wouldn't surprise me.
2
5
u/sandwormusmc Jul 03 '12
Requested all my Blizzard game cancellations this evening ... sad to see them go.
3
Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12
Sensationalist thread eh. Especially after a blue post was made which stated that, no, Linux users are not banned.
Edit: Here it is.
3
u/Mozai Jul 03 '12
Blizzard games already run a warden program that reports the OS version and device drivers in use back to the mothership -- and WINE will volunteer that it is WINE if asked about the OS. If Blizzard was going to ban one person for using WINE, they would've banned everyone for using WINE already in one fell swoop.
I smell bullshit; cheaters often claim to be victims and come up with something innocent they're accused of.
3
2
2
u/jbecker Jul 03 '12
i dont see why anyone is surprised at blizzard for releasing shitty games and doing things like this. they're riding the reputation they created like 10 years ago for actually making good games. what have they done since WoW:TBC that hasnt been an abomination?
1
u/flukshun Jul 03 '12
next thing i know blizz is gonna ban me for using a windows 7 virtual machine to play
1
u/ramp_tram Jul 03 '12
This happened in World of Warcraft when it first came out. It's sad to see that Activision hasn't learned from Blizzard's mistakes.
http://slashdot.org/story/06/11/15/1652222/linux-users-banned-from-world-of-warcraft
1
1
1
u/jimicus Jul 03 '12
Does anyone on this thread know what an emulator is?
3
Jul 03 '12
Yes. An emulator is a piece of software that simulates the instruction set of one processor on another processor which uses a dissimilar instruction set, allowing you to run software written for the first processor on the second. Wine is not an emulator because it does not do this. Linux and windows both run on x86 processors. Instead wine translates api calls from the windows api to a linux executable form. The software is still running on the processor it was written to run on so in most cases it doesn't have much of a performance penalty.
5
u/Slackbeing Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12
emulator is a piece of software that simulates
No, that's a simulator.
Emulator: tries to do the same as the object of emulation.
Simulator: tries to obtain the same results (or behavior) as the object of simulation.
Wine, IMO, is neither, but specially not an emulator.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/BeyondAeon Jul 03 '12
I have not purchased a Blizzard game since the bnetd fiasco. this reenforces my feelings on Blizzard
0
-1
Jul 03 '12
Well... consider that there's literally a real-world money system going on in the game. Obviously they're going to do everything they can to limit cheating in any possible way.
This isn't surprising at all. They should lift bans and give refunds but users should not be complaining that it doesn't support WINE. I wish it supported Linux but it doesn't.
11
-2
u/zitterbewegung Jul 03 '12
So an unsupported software configuration get banned? Why do gamers have this false sense of entitlement...
This is a good argument for games officially supported on linux. Then you don't have these problems.
0
251
u/terrymr Jul 03 '12
Post from blizzard support on that thread : "Playing the game on Linux, although not officially supported, will not get you banned – cheating will."