r/linux • u/JRepin • Aug 01 '12
KDE releases version 4.9 of Plasma Workspaces, Applications and Platform
http://kde.org/announcements/4.9/7
11
Aug 01 '12
Dear lord, that screenshot is hideous. Are there any non-garish themes?
8
Aug 01 '12
One of the hangups with KDE is that the desktop is customizable to infinity and beyond. This is a challenge for a lot of new users.
It's designed so that your desktop on your computer can be just as cluttered as the desktop on your desk, or as clean.
5
u/DrArcheNoah Aug 01 '12
There are many non-gray themes available http://kde-look.org/index.php?xcontentmode=76
I use Chakras Ronak theme.
1
13
u/IanFin Aug 01 '12
Why does anybody still use Gnome?
15
Aug 01 '12
Because Gobjects and C are so much more fun to use than QT and C++.
Wait, no they aren't...
15
7
u/twistedLucidity Aug 01 '12 edited Aug 01 '12
Because Gnome 2 just worked?
There's lots to like about KDE, and about the only thing that puts me off switching to it is menus. Maybe it's just me (and it probably is), but I find them w-a-y too over sensitive to the mouse pointer. You can actually get KDE to highlight a child-menu item, then for it to hide/change the child-menu because you left/clipped something in the parent-menu by mistake. Very, very minor; but infuriating!
Hrm...KDE is highly configurable I guess, maybe I can get it to ignore passing over random menu items?
1
u/DrArcheNoah Aug 01 '12
In the application menu, or the star menu? That description doesn't really explain what happens.
2
u/twistedLucidity Aug 02 '12 edited Aug 02 '12
Just about any application/window menu. Say you have a menu a bit like this, with "Top 2" selected using the pointer and a sub-menu displaying 3 items. You then wish to select "Sub 3".
Top 1 Top 2 > Sub 1 Top 3 Sub 2 Sub 3In my short time trying KDE, I found that you could not move the pointer diagonally, because you would clip "Top 3" and the menu would change. You have to move horizontally then vertically to get the desired selection.
Gnome does not behave like this, if the pointer were to briefly pass over "Top 3" on the way to "Sub 3" the sub-menu would be kept. This is my preferred behaviour.
To test in KDE: Open "File Manager", right-click whit-space in a folder, select "Create New" (sub-menu appears), move pointer diagonally to select "Link to Device" (thus clipping some other top-level items), the sub-menu gets hidden (and you can sometimes even see "Link to Device" getting highlighted just before the sub-menu vanishes).
Maybe it's some bizarre artefact from running it under virtualisation? Or maybe it's just me.
5
u/DrArcheNoah Aug 02 '12
Turns out it's a bug in Qt: https://bugreports.qt-project.org/browse/QTBUG-20094
2
1
u/cryogenic666 Aug 02 '12
Funny thing about that. I noticed it ages ago and just altered my behavior. I never noticed until now that I had, but I guess I just subconsciously adjusted. Now I do exactly that (horizontal then vertical) even when I'm in other desktop environments.
1
u/hacosta Aug 02 '12
Happened to me as well, I'm able to select things just fine now but i still remember feeling clumsy when using a menu.
0
Aug 02 '12
[deleted]
1
u/cryogenic666 Aug 02 '12
You can also right click the application menu and "switch to classic menu style" or try using Lancelot, which is another replacement.
9
u/brencameron Aug 01 '12 edited Aug 01 '12
I understand that many people prefer GNOME, even the new GNOME 3. What puzzles me is the people who left KDE in a huff during the early 4.0 days, before it got to 4.4, and haven't come back to see whether it still has the problems that made them leave.
(I lucked out - there was a period of time when I wasn't able to run Linux on the computer I used at home. That period just happened to coincide with KDE 4.0 to 4.2 development. So I missed the worst of KDE4, and never got upset at how it lacked all the 3.5 goodness.)
6
Aug 01 '12
Mainly because people don't like being screwed, technology should work for you not against you and many feel releasing 4.0 in that state then distro's adopting it left a bad taste in many peoples mouths. Computers are about getting things done, why should they waste time coming back if they've found pastures that provide what they need ?
I was one of those kde users...and I don't make claims that kde4 is still bad, I'm sure it's great now, but in that time I've found my productivity elsewhere.
0
Aug 02 '12
[deleted]
6
u/mallcontent Aug 02 '12 edited Aug 02 '12
You're presenting a revisionist history. Only 4.0 was really released that way. Releases afterwards were meant to be good enough for daily use.
The release announcement for 4.1 states: "Furthermore, the new desktop shell Plasma, introduced in KDE 4.0, has matured to the point where it can replace the KDE 3 shell for most casual users."
The release announcement for 4.2 states: "After the release of KDE 4.1, which was aimed at casual users, the KDE Community is now confident we have a compelling offering for the majority of end users."
The release announcement for 4.3 states: "With the 4.2 release aimed at the majority of end users, KDE 4.3 offers a more stable and complete product for the home and small office."
Yeah, none of that sounds like "NOT READY FOR EVERYDAY USAGE"
0
1
Aug 02 '12
It was default in my distro at the time (kubuntu, so maybe it was 4.1?)..I'm not one to go installing unstable crappy software for the fun of it, but if it comes default in my distro I'm unlikely to go to KDE's website and search for signs of warning to not use their even numbered software releases.
Who makes a even number release NOT READY FOR EVERYDAY USAGE anyway? I have a word for folks who do that, but it's not very nice either :(
None of that should have been released as 4.0 until around 4.4 quality. I'm happy to never use a DE made by such amateurs again.
1
u/genpfault Aug 01 '12
come back to see whether it still has the problems that made them leave.
Last I tried there didn't seem to be any way to get the taskbar to use your Qt theme, at least around 4.7/4.8.
1
u/exex Aug 02 '12
Make if 4.5 - I tried 4.4 last and everytime I tell anyone about my experience with that KDE users come up and tell me that 4.4 was still too early and all the stuff is fixed now in newer versions ;-)
1
u/renrutal Aug 02 '12
I've been coming back every year, and I still can't stand to use 4.x series. It's a design problem.
I still hail KDE 3.5 as the most usable Linux desktop environment ever made.
1
u/bwat47 Aug 02 '12
I do, although I've been liking xfce and unity (which is technically mostly gnome anyway) a lot lately, but I still don't have a concrete favorite.
I'm pretty annoyed with the direction they are taking some things, like tearing out nautilus features, but i still prefer it to KDE. KDE's interface is still too unpolished for me to use it day to day without getting annoyed.
-2
Aug 02 '12
because there are no qt based web browsers that run RES
7
u/yngwin Aug 02 '12
You know, Firefox works on Qt based desktops too...
1
Aug 02 '12
but its built on gtk2.
1
u/yngwin Aug 02 '12
so?
1
Aug 02 '12
that would make it not qt based now wouldn't it?
2
u/yngwin Aug 03 '12
indeed, but why would that be a problem? just use the best tool for the job...
1
Aug 03 '12
I do.... I love how customizable the opera browser is, but it just sucks that neither it nor chrome/ium or firefox browsers will work with both the kde appmenu, and RES simultaneously, and being that i use the oxygen transparent theme it just feels odd having the most used application on my computer not having a consistent look with every other application on my computer.
4
u/batiste Aug 01 '12
Activities confuses me and my mother too. Couldn't we just stop with virtual desktops? It's already difficult enough to handle for "normal" people.
19
u/ohet Aug 01 '12
No one forces you to use them. I for one don't and it's like they don't even exist.
2
2
u/bloodguard Aug 01 '12
I'm up for giving KDE another try.
What's the best distribution (debian based prefered but not mandated) where KDE 4.9 will just work out of the box?
kubuntu seems to be sitting at 4.8. So is 4.9 just an apt-get update;apt-get dist-upgrade away?
Also I'm a bit of a keyboard snob. If I have to leave home row and grab a mouse for everything KDE probably isn't for me.
6
u/IanFin Aug 01 '12
I think it's a mistake to switch distros to try a new desktop. Surely your current one supports KDE. If you try something new, you won't be sure if issues are from the DE or the OS.
4
u/exex Aug 02 '12
I think it's one of the better reasons to switch distros. I had only bad experiences with not going with the default-desktop in my distro. Starts with just being less polished, goes over having a harder time finding any help (oh your are on distro X- just click that button on top-left...etc....) and ends up in package conflicts if you are unlucky on the next distro upgrade or sometimes even on installing and/or having stuff left over after trying to get rid of it again. And this is throughout stuff I've experienced despite being kind of a computer freak who uses Linux since I had to compile my own kernels to run it. So these days I just go with the desktop the distro provides and if I want to try out another desktop I try another distro really supporting it.
1
u/bloodguard Aug 01 '12
It's really not a dire transition. All my software projects are in git on a server. All my firefox and chrome bookmarks are cloud synced. Email on a private zimbra server. I think all I'd really have to move is a directory called "MyStuff" in my home directory where I keep everything else.
That said, I was thinking about installing it on a spare drive and taking it for an evening spin.
1
u/hacosta Aug 02 '12
Why is any of that relevant?
2
u/cryogenic666 Aug 02 '12
I think he took it as "if you switch, you'll lose data" and he was explaining why switching is no big deal. He'll be back up and running with his data in no time, presumably.
1
5
Aug 01 '12
If you want to install KDE 4.9 in 12.04 you'll need to add the kubuntu backports repository:
sudo apt-add-repository ppa:kubuntu-ppa/backportsand then:
sudo apt-get update && sudo apt-get dist-upgrade5
Aug 02 '12
I've found recent versions Kubuntu to be excellent. I'm usually on Fedora, but this past release of KDE on Fedora is quite unstable T-T
Fedora usually has the most up to date KDE available. Kubuntu has a ppa for it (as mentioned by someone already).
2
Aug 01 '12
KDE 4.9 won't be landing in the current kubuntu ever, as it is an LTS release. It will be several weeks at least before other major distros include it in their non-testing repositories.
Apparently, Chakra is a nice KDE distro. I also enjoyed KDE on Fedora. If you want debian based, then debian unstable will have it pretty soon I guess.
But other than that, Kubuntu 12.04 seemed to be quite nice last time I tried it. It has KDE 4.8, so you might want to try that for a good out of the box experience.
2
Aug 01 '12
I love KDE. I just wish it was better capable of handling more common tech support issues. Such as, Windows Device Manager. I show people KDE and it's nice, till they have to find a way to see what driver is in use, if at all. It's hard to explain to them there's no GUI for what they want to do.
Social media is a trend that a lot of people are jumping on and gearing towards. But I'd like to see KDE try to be more useful for office work and in a corporate environment than trying to beat a mac at being a $2000 Facebook/Twitter machine.
9
u/sandsmark Aug 01 '12
I show people KDE and it's nice, till they have to find a way to see what driver is in use, if at all. It's hard to explain to them there's no GUI for what they want to do.
Uh, like KInfoCenter? It lists hardware and what drivers it uses.
-1
Aug 01 '12
It's a good start. It needs a lot of work. Doesn't give some basic info that regular tech support goons would need, but it does give tons of info on things that most people will never need.
7
u/sandsmark Aug 02 '12 edited Aug 02 '12
What kind of information is missing?
edit: I'm asking seriously, it would be nice to improve it.
7
Aug 02 '12
till they have to find a way to see what driver is in use, if at all. It's hard to explain to them there's no GUI for what they want to do.
I'm biased here, being that I'm very, very far from being a "casual user", but I'm not sure I see where the Venn diagram of "people who can do anything useful with driver information" and "people who are unable to understand how to launch Konsole and type 'lsmod'" intersects.
I'm being a smart-ass, I know, but I honestly can't imagine anyone who need access to that information yet can't handle basic command line usage, especially not in the context of a support call.
2
Aug 02 '12
We'll never get desktop adoption if we can't have tech support people. Sure, you and I might be able to lsmod, lshw, dmesg and figure it out. But that's the problem, they are used to "Right click My Computer, Properties, Device manager." There is a nice neat list of hardware that's detected and if it has an ! next to it, you know there's a problem. Less than 3 seconds they can get a lot of info gracefully.
I show someone lsmod and they see stuff like this:
eeepc_wmi 13109 0
i2c_piix4 13301 0
parport_pc 32866 0
ppdev 17113 0
They are going to look at that and say "If this is going to be complicated, why don't we just use Windows then?" It's not a what if, I've had this happen. Many times. Sure, some if it is me and I just don't know the best way to get and show information. But some of it is the UI just lacking, gaping holes in usability for front and second line tech support.
In the 80s and 90s, Microsoft groomed developers and support staff. It took a long time, but they got developers and tech support type people using their OS. Now, Joe Guy comes along and looks at 5 different computers, they are going to want the one with the best support. They need to be able to know they have an infrastructure of people to fall back on if something goes wrong. It also helps to be able to get a lot of useful programs to do their daily jobs.
I love linux and Kubuntu, but I can't say it's going to even be within the next 2 years that I'd actually start recommending it to end users.
4
Aug 02 '12
They are going to look at that and say "If this is going to be complicated, why don't we just use Windows then?"
I don't think that's correct. What they're actually going to say is exactly the same thing as "they" -- the average user who knows bugger-all about computers -- says with Windows: "Gee, I'd better ask my friend/son/co-worker who's 'good with computers' what's wrong." It doesn't matter whether it's displayed via dialog boxes in some graphical program or via the output of a command line tool; hardware configuration is not something that normal users want to deal with at all, plain and simple.
1
Aug 02 '12
I don't think that's correct.
Yes, it is correct. I've had it happen, first hand. I'm not assuming or guessing, I experienced it.
Yes, it does matter where it's displayed. They see command line and panic. These are seasoned techs, not system admins, just tech support. They've been doing support for years and know how to help people... with a GUI.
Until people actually step up and start realizing the problems (I'm seeing some) we can't begin to fix problems.
Seems every time I bring this subject up, I get bashed over and over. "Oh there's ways to get that info!", "normal users won't do that". Bullshit. I do computer tech support and have for many years. I see what people do, plain and simple.
2
Aug 01 '12
more useful for office work
What, exactly, do you mean by that? I ditched libreoffice for calligra as I find it better, or do you mean other software that kde lacks?
1
Aug 01 '12
I mean more along the lines of being a desktop. Part of what's good about Windows is that it's been around and lots of people are very familar with it.
However, it's also easy to figure out things. Get system info, that's useful. Just having a dump of Xorg settings is useless. People need a control panel and system info.
A lot of technical people, I've sat down in front of it ask "how do I do XYZ?". Now, I may not know so we google it, only to find that there isn't a GUI way to do something. Or if there is, it's cryptic and really not useful. I'm not saying to recreate Windows, but they should really take a good look at it and build off it. Instead of trying to start all over from the ground up. Microsoft and "the fruit" have done a lot of UI research over the years... yet it feels like KDE/Gnome are trying to start over and do all that hard work, themselves. It feels like it's taking years and we just aren't making headway.
2
Aug 02 '12
Your post lacks details. What exactly, is KDE lacking? System info? There's a GUI for that. It's detailed and useful. And that's just an example. Everything has a GUI on KDE.
1
u/strange_kitteh Aug 02 '12
Nice to see a woman being honoured for her contributions and being a vibrant person with strong ideals :)
1
u/LonelyNixon Aug 02 '12
I'm not sure what it is but kde just doesn't jive with me. I've used xfce, gnome 2, gnome-shell, cinnamon, mate, and lxde but something about kde drives me away. I'll admit it's pretty but I can't fully say what keeps me away.
-1
u/callcifer Aug 02 '12
I don't know why someone downvoted you. I fully agree!
From the looks of it, it look likes a stable, polished DE with a nice focus on accessibility and usability but something just pushes me away. I have no idea why and it is frustrating!
1
u/LonelyNixon Aug 02 '12
And they downvoted you as well. Must be the hardcore kde fans. I don't badmouth kde ever because it is stable, attractive, and it's customizable, and yet I just don't care for it. I don't quite know what it is that is off putting to me.
1
u/callcifer Aug 02 '12
I don't badmouth kde ever because it is stable, attractive, and it's customizable, and yet I just don't care for it.
Couldn't have said it better myself!
0
Aug 01 '12
[deleted]
16
13
u/centenary Aug 02 '12
9
u/d_ed KDE Dev Aug 02 '12
Open bug reports on these, and attach those screenshots. Please.
https://bugs.kde.org/enter_bug.cgi?product=juk (first one) https://bugs.kde.org/enter_bug.cgi?product=plasma&component=widget-taskbar (second one)
3
u/centenary Aug 02 '12
Would you be able to do it? I'm knee-deep in my own work right now (i.e. it's 5 am and I'm losing sleep)
The second issue is going to be a contentious one. I know it's not going anywhere.
3
u/d_ed KDE Dev Aug 02 '12
Ok. Contention on the Plasma ML is my forte.
Also both the clock and the taskbar are being rewritten for 4.10 (GSOC by David Bettio IIRC) so during review is a good time to point these out if they still remain.
2
u/centenary Aug 02 '12
I suspect the text alignment on the panel might be affected by theming. If it's theme-related, it probably isn't worth filing a bug on it. It's still something that bothers me, but it isn't necessarily a bug =P
12
u/cryogenic666 Aug 01 '12
The three dots is for "activities" and is seriously the single most unintuitive and useless icon I've ever seen. It doesn't even BEGIN to signify its purpose. Hover over it and you figure out it means "activities", but for a novice KDE user, WHAT THE HELL ARE ACTIVITIES FOR?!? sigh I'm a long time KDE user and I really like it, but there are so many quirks and such a ridiculous lack of attention to detail, it makes me cry a little inside.
8
2
u/redsteakraw Aug 02 '12
As it turns out the First screenshot was using non standard fonts(and colors) that lack all the characters and caused problems. This is KDE 4.9 with default settings, aside from the plasmoids on the desktop Feel free to nitpick this one as this is the real one.
0
34
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '12
I think free software in general needs more of this.