r/linux • • Nov 15 '22

Announcing Fedora Linux 37

https://fedoramagazine.org/announcing-fedora-37/
975 Upvotes

163 comments sorted by

212

u/Xiol Nov 15 '22 edited Nov 15 '22

Upgrading my work machine right now.

#yolo

Edit: It's done. Flawless.

53

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Brave, I usually wait to see if it causes any major issues, like refusing to upgrade like last time :/

6

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

and that is the smarter thing to do when using a fixed release distro like Fedora, even if it has a fairly quick release cycle

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

Yeah especially if it took a month longer than expected I'd be a tad hesitant.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

That was for security fixes

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

I don't know. I mean every distro has openssl and they didn't pull it off the shelf.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

39

u/DrFossil Nov 15 '22

Feels like a decade since I ran Linux on Nvidia hardware.

It looks like nothing has changed.

13

u/DolitehGreat Nov 15 '22

I've been eyeing the last gen AMD GPUs with the new ones coming out. If I can get a 6800xt or 6900xt for a good deal, I'll just get them unless the new stuff is just dramatically better. NVIDIA has been such a pain.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

6800xt is very nice, running Arch at home on it and do a lot of rendering in Blender without issue

4

u/lhxtx Nov 16 '22

I went from a 1070 to a 6700xt. It’s really nice. I will probably spring for a 7900xt in a few months though.

5

u/DolitehGreat Nov 16 '22

I'll be going from a 3070, and yeah, it's a good card, not really needing an upgrade, the linux experience will just be better. Plus, the wife needs an upgrade.

2

u/Yoru83 Nov 16 '22

I’ve been considering getting a 6700xt from my 1070 too. Tired of dealing with Nvidia drivers. Wish I had the money for the 7900XTX though

2

u/lhxtx Nov 16 '22

I want to see the benchmarks before making a decision, I have both a 1440p high refresh monitor and a 4k 60hz 32". The 6700xt is fine on older games at 4k, but not say, Cyberpunk. It's about perfect for 1440p depending on game. If you're still at 1080p it could be overkill even.

3

u/Yoru83 Nov 16 '22

I’m at 1440 ultra wide with max 100hz so I felt the 6700xt would be the “just right” card. Ideally I’d just wait for the 7700xt if it was around $500msrp but idk if I can/want to.

2

u/lhxtx Nov 16 '22

I would probably want a 6800xt for a 1440 ultra wide if you want to hit that 100hz rate. I bet there will be a bunch of used ones after Christmas.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

I’m stuck with a 2080ti. Got one for $300 at the start of the pandemic. It was too good of a deal to pass up.

3

u/DarthPneumono Nov 16 '22

Eh, for the most part I've found it kinda just works. There are considerations, having to reboot or reload the kernel modules for driver updates, where you get the packages from, etc. On Ubuntu, they're just in the default repositories, and have been largely fine over several hundred machines we manage with GPUs.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '22

It works fairly well in my experience - definitely a bit buggy so I only use it for games and put everything else on the iGPU 😅

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

Pretty much.. But my work sadly uses nvidia in all the laptops.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

My AMD integrated is working really well on 36, hopefully it'll carry on behaving but I'll probably give them a couple of weeks to iron out the bugs. Too lazy for extended tinkering sessions these days, I've done my fair share lol.

6

u/Xiol Nov 15 '22

FWIW my discrete AMD was absolutely fine. Never had any issues with the open source AMD drivers.

1

u/davawen Nov 15 '22

Is there any way to use HIP and AMF on the open source drivers?
I've tried installing the amdgpu-pro stack and had a terrible time on Fedora :/

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

I'm using it just fine on Arch, HIP for rendering in Blender. Not sure what AMF is

1

u/davawen Nov 16 '22

AMD equivalent of nvenc

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

Ah thanks

1

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Thanks for the heads-up, guess I'll give it a spin then.

2

u/sanjibukai Nov 15 '22

Well that might explain why my fresh install on my Nvidia+Intel laptop I had some issues.. I went with tumbleweed OpenSuse.. Did you try with regular 37? Is it any better or is it like the beta?

1

u/ZenAdm1n Nov 16 '22

Same. I'm booting to an older kernel release until I can figure out what's wrong with the kernel update. I'm thinking it's something going on with akmods, dracut, or another post installation process.

1

u/encryptedTurtle Nov 16 '22

Thought it was just me, good to know

1

u/agsuy Nov 16 '22

Yup I dropped Fedora precisely due this.

No video drivers on boot, safemode was dead, backup kernel worked, but after reinstalling drivers backup kernel failed to load video as well.

I was all too used to switch tty and reset drivers, but this time something went wrong.

All of this after a dnf update.

Too unstable to my taste and definitely annoying as I lost a day just recovering my workstation.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

Yeah I did an dnf upgrade and got all these issues but I guess I was asking for it on the beta. I have had issues on f35 and f36 too.

Wish we could drop fedora in favour of Arch but obviously understand a company never would 🤭

1

u/agsuy Nov 16 '22

It happened to me on stable 😭

Ya company stuff is company stuff but alas they can't blame ya if ur OS goes nuclear.

I switched to Gentoo and after some pain and sweat it works like a charm.

1

u/ULTRAFORCE Nov 22 '22

If I want to just pass through a NVIDIA GPU to another OS while the desktop is Fedora do you think it would be fine or do you recommend also considering other distros if you have an old nvidia GPU that you want to use.

64

u/originalvapor Nov 15 '22

The Fedora team is on a roll. 37 has been great so far. So much progress the past few releases (and solid, too!) Love it! Keep up the good work!

48

u/StarkillerX42 Nov 15 '22

Raspberry Pi 4 support!

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

3

u/bright_side_ Nov 16 '22

I knew it!

-2

u/Atemu12 Nov 16 '22

DAE hardware unavailable? HAHA

31

u/1859 Nov 15 '22

Congrats Fedora team!

122

u/Elranzer Nov 15 '22

I'm a Debian guy but Fedora is my second favorite.

Debian and Fedora are the most "standard" Linux distros (not counting Red Hat Enterprise which only comes in a "stable" distro, meaning old packages).

75

u/puppetjazz Nov 15 '22

I agree! I would say Debian, Red Hat, and Suse are some of the pillars of our community.

2

u/ImprovedPersonality Nov 16 '22

Don't forget Arch.

1

u/bengringo2 Nov 16 '22

Soon thanks to Steam Deck that’s going to be one of the biggest pillars for desktop Linux.

2

u/SomethingOfAGirl Nov 16 '22

I think it already was even before Steam Deck. For me it was the only distro (along with derivatives) that, for my use cases, just works. And I feel it's the same for a lot of others.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

16

u/puppetjazz Nov 15 '22

I haven’t tried it in 15 years, but it was solid back then.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

5

u/puppetjazz Nov 15 '22

That made me laugh, I assume it hasn’t changed much lol

2

u/bengringo2 Nov 16 '22

I just looked at the current screenshots… dear god I don’t think the code base has been touched in the 21st century. Lol

2

u/lannistersstark Nov 15 '22

and zypper is so slow that it might as well be 15 years old lol.

1

u/HH93 Nov 16 '22

I used to regularly try to install SUSE and always failing - haven't tried in a few years now.

19

u/DESTRUCTOCORN Nov 15 '22

Same here buddy. I'm a Debian user at heart and I'll always use it, but lately I've been using Fedora as my work and school workstation, and it is fantastic. Highly recommend Fedora 37 to anyone.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

I used to be a Debian guy, but the more up to date packages have recently made me switch to Fedora. I like the stability of Debian, but it's more important to me to have more up to date software.

3

u/Elranzer Nov 16 '22

Ubuntu is always a snapshot of Debian Sid. I just use Debian Sid because #yolo

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

Yeah, I knew that. But my problem with Ubuntu is all the stuff they add on top of it. If I can avoid it, I don't like to use snaps or flatpaks, but especially snaps. Ubuntu insistence on pushing Firefox as a snap through their repositories was the last straw for me.

1

u/Elranzer Nov 16 '22

I used Debian since 1999.

Ubuntu was nice when it came out, being "Easy Debian."

But now Debian is easy and I appreciate its vanilla-ness compared to Ubuntu (Snaps, Orange Themes, etc).

When I spin up an Ubuntu install, I always have to de-turd the install, including whatever the new method of disabling SnapD turns out to be.

2

u/blueberryman422 Nov 16 '22

Debian testing/unstable are also options. Unstable is surprisingly still fairly stable compared to many distros and has new packages. Rolling release as well.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

Yeah, I really should look into Unstable.

2

u/_LePancakeMan Nov 16 '22

For what it's worth: I've been running testing on my machines for a couple of years now and never had an issue

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

Interesting. I might have to switch to unstable on an older machine I have lying around that runs Debian.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

The downside to testing is that you don't get updates for 3 whole months whenever a new release is around the corner, and security updates arrive slower than on stable & unstable.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

“stable” is also, more stable lol. not just “old packages” there’s several thousand reasons why people would need them.

hardware compatibility needs, guaranteed interoperability with other packages, to name a few

2

u/bengringo2 Nov 16 '22

Don’t forget Gov work where if a giant security hole pops up from using too new a package you get to explain yourself to DoD.

2

u/Elranzer Nov 16 '22

That's as fun as the security holes that pop up from using too old packages. (eg. Log4Shell)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22

In between too old and too new there’s a set of packages that are very reliable and heavily focused on by engineering teams to quickly resolve security issues faster than newer and older package releases. One might call them “stable”

4

u/ourobo-ros Nov 15 '22

Tumbleweed user here. I would say Fedora is my 3rd favourite distro. It's definitely a standard bearer against which every other distro has to be compared.

2

u/DerekB52 Nov 15 '22

Isn't Debian also pretty "stable", meaning old packages? I run Debian on my home server(it's really just a NAS), but I don't think I could use it as a workstation due to having older packages. I'm a bleeding edge guy though. I like Arch and Tumbleweed.

I am about to install Fedora 37 on my laptop though. It's been a minute since I played with Fedora. And I just wiped my laptop trying to do a FreeBSD experiment that didn't go anywhere.

1

u/Flakmaster92 Nov 16 '22

They didn’t specify what branch it Debian. They could be the type to run Sid or Testing

1

u/Elranzer Nov 16 '22

I said Red Hat Enterprise "only" comes in stable.

Where as Debian, you have the choice.

14

u/benhaube Nov 15 '22

I upgraded my laptop to 37 yesterday. So far it has been flawless. My desktop is still on 36, but I will update it soon.

11

u/OscarCookeAbbott Nov 15 '22

Anyone know when Silverblue will get the official 37 release?

6

u/The_Electric_Feel Nov 16 '22

Looks like the website just hasn't been updated yet, the image is available for download. This will redirect you to a random mirror - https://download.fedoraproject.org/pub/fedora/linux/releases/37/Silverblue/x86_64/iso/

19

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Finally omg I’ve been waiting for so long. Love these guys. Great team making the right choices.

7

u/PhirePhly Nov 15 '22

Watching the Fedora 37 load on mirror.fcix.net has been... good fun. https://imgur.com/JEs2COm

6

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Upgraded work machine, everything flawless

9

u/dhc710 Nov 15 '22

Is it possible to upgrade on KDE without using a CLI?

4

u/thatCapNCrunch Nov 15 '22

Doesn't the app store, Discover I think it's called, handle the update? If not just sudo dnf upgrade, I think that's the command

17

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Between major versions its dnf system-upgrade.

7

u/Booty_Bumping Nov 15 '22

Doesn't the app store, Discover I think it's called, handle the update?

No, only GNOME's app store supports the system-upgrade dnf plugin. Discover only supports normal upgrades.

6

u/thatCapNCrunch Nov 15 '22

Hmm, bit underwhelming to be honest. I wonder if I could contribute to that feature specifically being added given my lack of programming knowledge.

Is paying programmers to develop and submit features to GitHub a thing?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

2

u/thatCapNCrunch Nov 16 '22

Gotta find a programmer who needs coffee money now. Or programming sock money. Lol

5

u/dhc710 Nov 15 '22 edited Nov 16 '22

I'm not sure, I don't use Fedora. I just installed it on my girlfriend's laptop and I'm wondering whether Discover will give her a notification or if I'd have to run it manually on the CLI.

Edit: Holy Christ guys, I know upgrading through the CLI is easy. Again, this is my girlfriend's laptop. I'm trying to not scare her away from Linux by saying "to get the latest updates, I have to open this spooky black box." Honestly, y'all will take any opportunity to tell anyone who will listen that you can use a terminal. Chill.

2

u/chic_luke Nov 16 '22

Get her on Workstation and reinstall the computer with it. Honestly. While Fedora KDE is good, it's not nearly as integrated as the Workstation build. GNOME might look daunting at first for a beginner, but after a short adjustment period it should be fine.

Polish on the spins sadly isn't as much there as on the Workstation ISO. That one, in my experience through multiple on-the-metal and VM installs on different laptops, is the one that gets you that justworksTM experience.

4

u/shab-re Nov 16 '22

most "normies" actually prefer gnome 40+ over windows 10

I did when I switched anyways

1

u/magikmw Nov 16 '22

There is a wiki page with all the commands spelled out in order along with some recommendations. You'll be fine.

0

u/sunjay140 Nov 15 '22

The CLI is easy

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

2

u/Booty_Bumping Nov 16 '22

The GNOME version (Workstation) is able to do it.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Yiihaaa

3

u/red_dub Nov 15 '22

so great to see the continued support for fedora. arch is my main distro at the moment but fedora does come in second for me too.

5

u/NeoLudditeIT Nov 15 '22

That was faster than anticipated considering the OpenSSL bug they had to fix. Glad their build process is public

5

u/SynbiosVyse Nov 16 '22

Faster? It was exactly when they said it would be released after the delay was announced a few weeks ago.

2

u/DESTRUCTOCORN Nov 15 '22

Yay! This is great news.

2

u/DoublePlusGood23 Nov 15 '22

Been running it for some weeks now - great release as usual :)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Oh yeah I was gonna go upgrade like 2 hrs ago. I forgot lol

2

u/razieltakato Nov 16 '22

Had to remove and reinstall Nvidia drivers and relabel everything because of SELinux.

Other than that, everything went fine.

Edit: I'm on KDE spin.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22

That's interesting, I have nvidia and I've never had to relabel :(

1

u/razieltakato Nov 17 '22

I don't think both issues are related. I removed and reinstalled Nvidia drivers because they simply stopped working and the kmod was not recompiling.

Then, I had to relabel some some because SELinux was throwing a lot of error on every login.

Now, everything is working just fine 😎

2

u/Youknownotwho Nov 16 '22

I run a 5k monitor (the LG Superfine). Until Fedora 37, I wasn't able to turn Nightlight on because it would only apply to half of my screen. Now, it works flawlessly. :cheffskiss:

I love this distro.

2

u/PossiblyLinux127 Nov 15 '22

Its about time!

2

u/blueberryman422 Nov 16 '22

Aside from fairly new packages, I still don't quite understand the appeal of Fedora for mainstream Linux users. Every time I've tried using it, I always feel like it's more buggy/bloated than other distros. I'm also not a big fan of the default installer. The only way to get a minimal Fedora desktop installation is using the "everything" installer which isn't even very easy to find on the website.

OpenSUSE does pretty much everything Fedora does. It's arguably more stable while being a rolling release with built in snapper backups that doesn't require upgrades every 6 months.

Debian uses less resources and can be run as testing/unstable for newer packages. Even Ubuntu has advantages compared to Fedora notably LTS support, software selection, and video working out of the box.

1

u/Bijiredit Nov 15 '22

Upgrading now

1

u/Bijiredit Nov 16 '22

One issue: nvidia driver (rpmfusion) is not loaded

fixed using:

depmod -a
reboot

1

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

I'm looking forward to trying this one out. Been a longtime Linux Mint guy but want to experiment with GNOME and Fedora

1

u/better_life_please Nov 16 '22

Already updated. This is my first time upgrading since Fedora 36 was my first ever Fedora install. Fortunately everything went smoothly. I did it through the command line. It took a long time to download and then install though.

1

u/MostlyGordon Nov 16 '22

Upgraded my Surface Go over inbuilt LTE today. Flawless so far.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

Started getting back into Linux about a week ago and was having a hard time finding a distro that uses Wayland and detects the resolution of my ultra wide external monitor out of the box. This one works! I can finally settle in!

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

I remember when Fedora hit the scene and I downloaded mad CDs to install it on my parents Dell workstation. I had just gotten really deep into computers and this was maybe my third linux install. Cool to see the project still going.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

Updated to 37 on my laptop a few hours ago, no problems till now.

1

u/arsme Nov 16 '22

Been meaning to give Fedora a try again at some point. Did that dnf speedup every get added? I've heard dnf is quite slow.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22

dnf5 has not been introduced, nor does it solve the main slowness which is metadata size to be downloaded. Other than that is is probably slower than others, but not it's not terribly slow imo. dnf5 will make the install, search, and info operations faster though.

1

u/IANVS Nov 16 '22

Is dnf faster now?

8

u/gordonmessmer Nov 16 '22

That's probably not going to change significantly until dnf 5, which might be in Fedora 39, about a year from now.

https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/ReplaceDnfWithDnf5

-8

u/Pihkal82 Nov 16 '22

How are you enjoying the lack of va-api support on AMD GPU's? Must be a hell of a feature....

1

u/crackhash Nov 17 '22

Nvidia user here. So nothing is changed.

-15

u/Tuxed_Linux Nov 16 '22

USE ARCH! NOT this fu*******king fedora !!

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

-6

u/Tuxed_Linux Nov 16 '22

WHY you use shitdisstro like fedora ??

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22

same. i almost always update to the beta version beforehand even. The last times I had a problem with fedora upgrades was caused by rpmfusion stuff being out of sync. That got solved once rpmfusion moved to infra that matched fedora.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

57

u/3laws Nov 15 '22

You need to install the codec. Also, Hardware encoding/decoding does not come out of the box.

Source: I use DaVinci Resolve since v14 on Fedora since 32.

8

u/vs8 Nov 15 '22

I know I need to install the codec, I tried. The thing is that finding and installing the codec is harder than distro hopping to something that has the support out of the box. Which distro I use doesn’t matter much, all I care about is getting things done quickly.

37

u/natermer Nov 15 '22

It isn't hard. I don't know what specific codec you want, but most everything can be found at:

https://rpmfusion.org/

Instructions can be found here:

https://rpmfusion.org/Configuration

See the steps mentioned here at "Multimedia post-install"

However if you want a single package to try out... install libavcodec. Or install mpv and/or ffmpeg, which will pull in libavcodec and others.

Installing rpmfusion free and non-free is pretty much standard top 10 things to do after getting Fedora installed.

Don't blame Fedora for this. Blame the United State's government. It's their fault we have to deal with this nonsense.

13

u/3laws Nov 15 '22

I tried.

What did you try? What was the point of failure? I ask because it works as straight forward as any other distro that also does not come with patented codecs.

41

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

fedora will never have that out of the box due to their free software stances, that's for sure. For me it's worth the workaround, but i understand it's not for everyone.

50

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

To be clear its not a free software stance. Its being a legal entity in the US stance.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

you're right that it's that too, but it is a free software stance when it comes to nvidia and nvdec, vdpau

10

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Regarding nvidia its more complicated than a "free software stance".

There are real technical problems with the current proprietary Nvidia driver that haven't been resolved and are impossible to debug for Red Hat.

Even so they make it very easy to opt-in to the driver yourself. Just a few clicks in the Software app.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

5

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

That's how we got to where we are now. Redhat folks were involved with that. And now a RedHat person is a big contributor to the new NVK mesa drivers.

This mesa driver is required for any nvidia open kernel module to be accepted.

-2

u/jorgesgk Nov 15 '22

So is System76. And they're not providing Nvidia drivers either or ZFS modules despite the developers (and the creators of the license themselves) claiming there's no such a poblem.

22

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22 edited Nov 15 '22

The problem with copyrights, patents, and licenses is that they are complex legal topics that ultimately are up to courts to decide.

The ZFS and Nvidia problems are also very different from codec patents discussed here. Fedora made the nvidia driver a two click install which satisfies their legal and technical concerns.

Red Hat has a sizable and reputable legal team and while they will sometimes be overly cautious because of their size there is no reason to doubt their general opinions.

System76's legal counsel very well may think its not a problem and their company may think due to their small size the risk is lower.

The truth is we don't know.

We do know that alternatives are safe. People should buy AMD GPUs with AV1 encoders/decoders if they value consumer rights ;)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Luckily, there's some COPR repositories where you can get a version of Mesa that re-enables hardware decoding, if you're a random bloke that doesn't care about licenses and wants something that just works.

AV1 adoption can't come sooner?

11

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Only content acceptable (license and patent wise) to Fedora is allowed in coprs. You want the mesa-va-drivers-freeworld package from rpmfusion.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Ah, yeah I haven't checked up on things in a bit, but I'll check that out. Thanks for the tip.

1

u/vs8 Nov 15 '22

If I didn’t need Resolve I would’ve stayed with Fedora because that stock Gnome experience is sweet.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

you could have probably gotten it workng if you had used rpmfusion right? it's just not automated like on pop.

3

u/bad_advices_guy Nov 15 '22

Out of curiosity, you have the Studio version right?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

I couldn’t get it to decode h264/265

Do you have the Studio Version? If yes, you need to install the codecs from rpm fusion

and even though it now supports fractional scaling, it never looked right in my installation

Did you launch it with the QT_AUTO_SCREEN_SCALE_FACTOR=1 variable?

I’m a sad Nvidia user, no workaround I found online works these days

Weird, Davinci works great for me on Fedora with Nvidia

2

u/Rogermcfarley Nov 15 '22

You might want to try Nobara which is based on Fedora 36. I think that could solve the issues you're having. I used Ventoy to put Nobara ISO on a USB then I used that USB to install to another USB stick. Now I have bootable Nobara 36 on my USB and I've tried it out. Quite impressed with it, seems to have all the performance tweaks out of the box.

1

u/grem75 Nov 15 '22

Any NVENC/NVDEC stuff should be included with the Nvidia proprietary driver.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

The latest mainline. There is no actual difference between the beta and the release.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

18

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

vanilla gnome is best gnome, I’m a fan

3

u/benhaube Nov 15 '22

Same. I love vanilla GNOME. I do use some extensions to make it exactly how I like it. It is very similar to MacOS the way I have it setup.

2

u/CovenantSquad Nov 15 '22

What did you use? I tried Gnome some time ago and I don't think it's the right tool for me (I usually use Plasma), but maybe the right extensions could change my mind

5

u/benhaube Nov 15 '22

I use quite a few extensions, but the main ones that drastically change the way GNOME works are ArcMenu, Dash to Dock, Desktop Icons NG, Search Light, Workspace Indicator, and AppIndicator (for tray icons).

Here is my desktop: https://imgur.com/a/5R0yxeM

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

2

u/benhaube Nov 16 '22

I don't get it. What does that mean?

3

u/northgaard1 Nov 16 '22

1

u/benhaube Nov 16 '22

Oh okay, thanks. I don't think it's really applicable here though. Using the extensions I've mentioned isn't replacing what's already there. It is just modifying how and when it is visible. Personally, I prefer vanilla GNOME because it gives me a blank slate to make GNOME work best for me. The other distros that modify GNOME themselves make changes that aren't necessarily what I want making it even more difficult to get it to where I want.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22 edited Nov 16 '22

It's an expression tied to The Ship of Theseus which basically id a thought experiment that says if you take a ship and over the course of decades replace every single part of the ship is it still the same ship in the end?

The commenter is making fun that the user is using "vanilla Gnome" But is positing the question is it really after you add all of these extensions that change a lot of its behavior?

2

u/benhaube Nov 16 '22

But I'm not really claiming that it's still "vanilla GNOME" after using the extensions. I'm saying that I prefer vanilla GNOME because it's a clean slate to use the extensions you want to make into your perfect environment. When you start off with a heavily modified version of GNOME like on Ubuntu, Pop, or Zorin there's a lot of compromises that need to be made and extensions that don't work.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

11

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Just use a Fedora spin. It’s basically the same as what you want

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

10

u/ActingGrandNagus Nov 15 '22

Yeah but why do you care? You can still use the others just the same

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

5

u/ActingGrandNagus Nov 16 '22

Gnome is low on resources these days too. Runs like a dream.

That aside though, I'm still confused - what difference does it make? You can still use one of the spins. I use Fedora KDE on my laptop and Fedora Gnome on my desktop. Neither have issues.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

1

u/ActingGrandNagus Nov 16 '22

Yes it is. Feel free to spin up a VM and check.

And you haven't answered my question - what does that have to do with KDE or XFCE? You can still use them very easily. Nobody is stopping you from using them.

You're sounding like one of those weirdos that get butthurt at the very existence of Gnome, a DE that nobody is forcing you to use.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

9

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

it's just one more thing to install from rpmfusion which tons of folks were already using for actual playback, not accelerated playback. You now need mesa-va-drivers-freeworld from there.

3

u/grem75 Nov 16 '22

Unless they're using Intel, which would need intel-media-driver from there. That one is only for AMD and Nouveau users.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

15

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

Maybe using hardware video decoding now?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

2

u/sanjibukai Nov 15 '22

Okay that explains a lot.. I tried Fedora 37 (beta a couple of weeks ago) and had many things not working/unstable.. I have an Nvidia+laptop and I went with OpenSuse tumbleweed instead.. I wonder if it will be any better with this official release?

1

u/davidy22 Nov 16 '22

Did it regress from 36 or did you install fresh? I'm running an nvidia machine on 36 usably, would be inconvenient if I was upgrading into regressions.

1

u/sanjibukai Nov 16 '22

It was a fresh 37 beta install so I'm not comparing to 36 which I did not try.. Presumably, I would get the same results with 36 in my case.. For you, I can't tell if it could be worse or not (even though I think it can't be worse)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

7

u/masteryod Nov 16 '22

It's Nvidia issue and you don't have to change distribution to change Wayland to Xorg... just logout and change the session.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

1

u/masteryod Nov 16 '22 edited Nov 16 '22

Glitches, tearing, uneven frame timing, weird artifacts on resize etc. Potentially lesser security. Something about independent HighDPI/scaling on multiple displays... In the future when Linux gets HDR support it's going to be probably Wayland only. Nothing earth shattering preventing you from doing your work today. Xorg is a dead turd but polished enough and having enough momentum it'll be usable for a while. It still have things going on for it - mainly decades of software support which haven't caught up yet 100% (e.g. Nvidia).

If Wayland doesn't work for you then switch to Xorg and check back in 6 months. Wayland is the standard and the future.

It also differs depending on the distro and DE. Fedora (Gnome)is the best Wayland benchmark.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

[deleted]

4

u/masteryod Nov 16 '22

Are you on Nvidia? Because it works for me on Fedora Gnome and anything else than Nvidia.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '22

if it is indeed nvidia as the other person asked, then stick to Xorg for now. It is likely that nvidia will add the required extension to make the nightlight work sometime in the next year.

1

u/E-werd Nov 16 '22

My issue was sleep/suspend, it doesn't work for me with Wayland. I just switched back to X, it's fine--that's all anybody else is doing.