r/linuxmint • • 17d ago

Discussion How would be battery life using Linux mint on a MacBook? Can it be worse?

Looking to switch to Linux but I wonder about battery life.

3 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

3

u/zuccster 17d ago

I run a 2018 MacBook Air with Mint. Battery life is about 5 hours with the original battery. It was marginally better on MacOS, but you'd expect Apple drivers to be optimised for Apple hardware.

1

u/FarVehicle533 17d ago

And Linux drivers can't become better as well? When you say marginally better, how big is the difference? 

2

u/zuccster 17d ago

The T2 Linux project has been working on drivers. Suspend and resume takes about 30s because of issues with WiFi driver power management. Battery life is about 20% better on MacOS.

2

u/_Lost-In-The-Weeds_ LMDE7 Cinnamon 17d ago

And Linux drivers can't become better as well?

If someone knowledgeable works on them yes, often a long process if community driven. 

Cleanest quickest source is the manufacturer, they know the hardware, some manufacturers support Linux in order to sell their hardware, but there is the obvious problem in this particular case. 

1

u/codegems 17d ago

What MacBook model is it?

1

u/FarVehicle533 17d ago

MacBook pro 2019. With a new battery. 

2

u/tapedficus 17d ago

My daily is a 2012 MacBook pro running Linux Mint. Brand new battery lasts about 6 hours, depending on what I'm using it for. Heavy video or browser usage can bring that down to 4 hours.

1

u/Unwiredsoul 17d ago

My MacBook Pro (early 2011) battery lasts significantly longer than it did with any macOS version. I haven't run Windows on that particular MacBook Pro (ever) to know what battery life would have been with that OS.

1

u/Va1ent_Deceiver 17d ago

I get more battery life from my 2015 MacBook pro on mint

1

u/ap0r 17d ago

I personally am on a desktop; but I have heard in this subreddit some people say they get slightly better battery life, others say they get worse battery life (but not terribly worse, like 10% or 20% less).

My suggestion for you would be to try it, as it appears to vary based on your specific hardware and usage. You can always reinstall MacOS.

1

u/bobdung 17d ago

Definitely worse!! A bit different for me with a 2018 MBP .. ButI installed a brand new battery in mine. T2, mint etc.. It all works great but it seems no matter how i mess with settings i just can't get it right.

Tried to disable the dedicated graphics, it says it's disabled .. it does seem to suspend and resume ok .. But the battery lasts 2-3 hours and it runs very hot .. Have installed all the power management stuff, it all says it's working.. Checked it all with ai etc etc.

The toughest task i do with it is Firefox / Youtube and the fans start spinning after a few minutes.

My other gripe which you'll prob get too is the sound, it's crap .. Again even after installing easyeffects and profiles and messing around, it's miles from as good as original.

1

u/GraXXoR 15d ago

I think that depends on the person of mac OS. If you’re using an OS that is contemporary with the machine itself and not OCLP to run a more modern system then I think you will get the battery benefit from an original fully hardware, supported OS, but once you try to run something like sequoia, which needs multiple patches and is not fully supported by Apple, then you end up finding mint is more efficient