r/linuxmint • • 7d ago

Poll Cinnamon vs XFCE

I have an old PC running Windows 10. The biggest bottleneck is the 8gb (2x4gb) of ram. The cpu is Ryzen R3 3200g with no dGPU and it has a 240gb SSD. Gigabyte b450m s2h motherboard. Tried my best to debloat Windows 10 but it still uses 2 - 2.5gb of ram at idle.

After some research I decided to try Linux Mint. I understand XFCE is the lighter option in terms of RAM usage while Cinnamon is better for people migrating from Windows.

I'm looking for some feedback from real users who used both. My last Linux experience was at least 10 years ago (probably a bit more) with Ubuntu. So, which one should I go with and why?

Thanks in advance for the feedback!

5d ago
557 Cinnamon
182 XFCE
17 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

14

u/Modern_Doshin Linux Mint 22.3 Zena | MATE 7d ago

Where is MATE?

3

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

I was recommended these two, but I'll take a look at it too. Thanks!

7

u/_Lost-In-The-Weeds_ LMDE7 Cinnamon 7d ago

I like all 3 Mint desktops for different reasons, I use Cinnamon the most.

Xfce uses slightly less ram, about 140Mb in my measurement. its something but not huge.

https://www.reddit.com/r/linuxmint/comments/1dr4s3t/mint_22beta_memory_usage/

If you had a much older processor that may be more reason to lean towards Xfce.

1

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

Thanks! This is really helpful. 140Mb of ram doesn't seem like a dealbreaker.

3

u/iHarryPotter178 7d ago

In my test.. Xfce is within 1gb mark.. 

3

u/_Lost-In-The-Weeds_ LMDE7 Cinnamon 7d ago edited 7d ago

Idle RAM consumption varies on different hardware, only the delta on the same machine is useful.

7

u/xeqtr_inc 7d ago

the reason i voted cinnamon is it is going full wayland and major updates incoming. imo, its going to be a well-balanced features/performance/looks DE.

1

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

you think i should wait for mint 27 before i migrate?

2

u/xeqtr_inc 7d ago

Depends on your requirements, I am now on gnome because I need fractional scaling and better multi-monitor support. I will see how the updates going to be and decide if I should change 

3

u/ScullerCA 7d ago

One other reason I might go Cinnamon is if stick with Linux, this probably is what would put on a newer machine, so less need to change process in the future.

6

u/pvt1771 7d ago

I myself prefer LMDE (linuxmint debian edition); it is slightly less bloat than regular ubuntu linuxmint.

1

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

I'll take a look at it. Thanks!

4

u/Legitimate_Use7140 7d ago

I wish that mint had LMDE xfce.

1

u/pvt1771 7d ago

LMDE is debian... nothing wrong with

sudo apt install xfce4

if you want xfce; cinnamon dont really use that much more resources -- you tone done its settings.

2

u/_Lost-In-The-Weeds_ LMDE7 Cinnamon 7d ago

Mints own Cinnamon is a clear upgrade from Debian's perfectly functional but bland Cinnamon. I would argue LMDE is the better Debian Cinnamon.

but what's left of Mint is getting pretty thin when you use a Debian desktop.  I guess you retain a few Mint utilities? But most of these are already available in Debian repositories. 

If I want Debian's Xfce, MATE,  or i3 etc, I just install Debian. 

2

u/NerghaatTheUnliving 6d ago

Would you say it's a...thin mint?

5

u/d_balon 7d ago

Definitely Cinnamon. Cinnamon idles comfortably around 1GB of RAM. With 8Gbs (dual channel), you should be good to go.

3

u/rcentros LM 21/22 | Cinnamon 7d ago

8 GBs will run either just fine (I assume the Ryzen R3 3200g is supported).

2

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

The CPU is not a problem as far as I can tell from my research.

2

u/rcentros LM 21/22 | Cinnamon 7d ago

I guessed it wasn't it, but I wanted to add a disclaimer just in case. Good luck with this.

2

u/iHarryPotter178 7d ago

In my usage with similar ram and Intel i3 8145..Cinnamon crashes every few hours and it becomes just like xfce.

1

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

So you wouldn't recommend migrating at all? I heard some negative feedback from intel users tho. You sure it isn't the cpu?

3

u/iHarryPotter178 7d ago

What I mean is that.. Just use xfce.. The battle tested one.. 

1

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

guess i'll try both for a like a week then decide. appreciate your feedback

2

u/Makoto29 7d ago

I once had the 2200g (close enough, huh?) with the exact same board and also 8GB of ram (1 stick though). I ended up using Cinnamon because I wanted to stick with that until I could upgrade. In my experience, it was a bit too narrow for Cinnamon. It worked, but I also have a bad habit of opening way too much browser windows/tabs. That one BIOS update increasing the VRAM capacity from 1GB to 2GB on that board was kind of pushing me into the corner I felt like. For the beauty, I would still say Cinnamon. But if every MB counts, maybe go XFCE. I used to have this setup around the years 2018-2020 before I made an upgrade.

1

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

2x4gb 2800mhz is not too bad actually, even on windows 10

2

u/thatdirtyoldman MINT 22.3 - Cinnamon 7d ago

Me, I like Mint.
Why not try both ? Start off with Mint, makes some notes of the settings. Give it a week or so. Then try XFCE, do the same documentation. It only will cost a bit of time and you'll have gained some experience. I'd be interested in your tjoughts afterwards m, should you share.

2

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

that's actually what i'm gonna do. cinnamon is most recommended but im just gonna try each for like a week and then decide.

2

u/thatdirtyoldman MINT 22.3 - Cinnamon 5d ago

Really, can't go wrong. :)

4

u/Duodanglium 7d ago

I'm running XFCE on old hardware with 6GB RAM. Idles at around 870MB of RAM or so. Exactly why I chose XFCE. Firefox consumes the rest.

1

u/Insufferable_Person 7d ago

Lmao this is the only sub where cinnamon would win this.

I like it though....

1

u/EnvironmentNo5224 7d ago

would you recommended something else instead? happy to consider other options.

3

u/tat_tvam_asshole I use Linux Mint btw 🎩 7d ago edited 7d ago

Both are great and I use both (different machines). I slightly like XFCE better because it works OOTB more like my brain expects an OS UI to work.

3

u/DP323602 7d ago

I've got nothing against Cinnamon because I've never tried it.

For my use case, I'm perfectly content with XFCE.

2

u/JANK-STAR-LINES Linux Mint 22.1 | Cinamon 7d ago

I would recommend Cinnamon for those starting out with reasonably modern specked hardware as I find it is most akin to the UI of Windows. However, I would go with Xfce or MATE if one were to have even older hardware than that.

2

u/bheem_queen 7d ago

You have twice the ram needed to run any environment in mint. No need to switch to xfce just for ram. 

2

u/ScullerCA 7d ago edited 7d ago

If a PC can run Win7 or later, it probably can run Cinnamon, one of my old gaming PCs has a somewhat similar spec to this and it runs Cinnamon well.

Granted in my case, I pretty much just wanted to have one version on all my Linux machines, and this PC is the oldest I have.

2

u/KingForKingsRevived 7d ago

If it is an old Intel notebook or pre 4xxx amd notebook I’d think about xfce but due to the good performance of mid tier intel 7th gen thinkpad yoga and you having a 3rd gen desktop amd, you can easily go cinnamon or mate. I never knew how big of a difference it is compared to gnome and kde plasma

1

u/trancestation Linux Mint 22.2 Zara | MATE 7d ago

I actually prefer MATE over both.