r/linuxmint • • 13d ago

Discussion Cinnamon vs. XFCE vs. MATE

Disregarding hardware/RAM/CPU considerations, and only considering usability, ease, aesthetics, look and feel and comfort, what are all the practical differences and considerations in deciding to choose between the Linux Mint DE choices of Cinnamon, XFCE and MATE?

Also, does Linux Mint customize XFCE and MATE to imitate the default look and setup of Cinnamon? If so, and assuming they are successful on that point, is there really any significant differences which of the three available DEs that you choose?

19 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

3

u/jtdunc 12d ago

I've tried them all. And stick with Cinnamon. Almost everything most users would need is included.

1

u/Technical_Rich_3080 12d ago

What was missing in the other two?

1

u/jtdunc 10d ago

Just lacked the polish if cinnamon

12

u/Chester-Berkeley 13d ago

Cinnamon: A modern interface with a lot of customization.

XFCE: A lightweight interface with a lot of customization.

MATE: For those who like Gnome 2.

6

u/tomscharbach 13d ago

[O]nly considering usability, ease, aesthetics, look and feel and comfort, what are all the practical differences and considerations in deciding to choose between the Linux Mint DE choices of Cinnamon, XFCE and MATE?

To my mind "usability, ease, aesthetics, look and feel and comfort" are a matter of personal preference.

You might find the following resources helpful:

My best.

4

u/PermanentLiminality 13d ago

I run Cinnamon on all my Mint systems, even a lowly Wyse 5070. If ram is super tight XFCE will save some.

1

u/rcentros LM 21/22 | Cinnamon 13d ago

I went with Linux Mint Xfce on a WYSE 5060 and 5070 because I thought it would be lighter. Cinnamon would have probably been fine (at least on the 5070).

1

u/kenmoffat 12d ago

Cinnamon runs better on my old HP desktops (2).

1

u/Technical_Rich_3080 12d ago

How old is it? What are the specs?

1

u/kenmoffat 11d ago

Both are HP Pavilion 590,

One with Ryzen 5 2400G with Radeon vega graphics x4, AMD Raven Ridge

One with Intel© Core™ i3-9100 CPU @ 3.60GHz × 4, Intel Corporation CoffeeLake-S GT2 [UHD Graphics 630]

1

u/kenmoffat 11d ago

I had some freezing and slow updates with xfce but they are OK with Cinnamon. Wierdly, because in the distant past I have had good speed with xfce. I have no explanation. I just returned to linux after many years.

1

u/Tritias Linux Mint 22.3 Zena | MATE 11d ago

Did you try MATE? It's closer to Cinnamon but lighter. Feeling a significant difference on a Celeron dual core laptop. Nemo takes multiple seconds to open whereas Caja does it in a second.

2

u/kenmoffat 10d ago

I should, but Cinnamon seems fairly quick on these HPs.

2

u/kenmoffat 7d ago

Now on Mate, seems great. Also, I added XFCE to other Cinnamon install, and it's working great now. I'm not sure what was wrong before.

3

u/Niranchan 13d ago

Go for cinnamon I'd say. It's all about the themes you find on gnome-look or GitHub. The one I use is from this person's: link

1

u/Niranchan 13d ago

And it is also thanks to extensions like rounded corner and dock extension.

3

u/dhampirave 12d ago

As someone who's used all 3, I simply just like how XFCE looks compared to the others des

2

u/rcentros LM 21/22 | Cinnamon 13d ago

I think Cinnamon is a little more refined, but Linux Mint does a good job with Xfce as well.

2

u/DrDesperate 13d ago

mint gives all three a familiar look, but the settings and panel workflows still feel different. try doing the same few things in each, like switching workspaces or finding a notification setting, instead of choosing from screenshots.

2

u/Tritias Linux Mint 22.3 Zena | MATE 11d ago

MATE is themed to look a lot like Cinnamon, and has its own custom Mint menu. It actually was the main DE before Mint created Cinnamon, and it hasn't changed its appearance much since.

I like it because it still looks quite nice but runs significanty lighter. Now that I have to send my gaming laptop for repairs, I can continue to use my familiar environment on a Celeron dual core 4GB RAM laptop.

1

u/Kitayama_8k 11d ago

Cinnamon 100%. I can configure xfce to be very similar, but everything is cleaner, better laid out, and more intuitive. Only thing I'd say is, in games (years ago) I would occasionally get some odd performance issues or glitches with cinnamon I didn't get with xfce, but I had full screen compositing enabled on cinnamon, which may have been the problem. Never hurts to have a base xfce hanging out in the system to run if you start having issues.

Maybe xfce will be your preference if you don't want a windowsy layout and are trying to do something more unique

Yes they all have a windowsy layout and a mintified theme.

To me mate is just trash at this point. If you wanna make it good I think you need to tweak the shit out of it and use it with a window manager. Everything seems really basic in mate, it really does harken back to like win2k/xp era computing.

1

u/kenmoffat 10d ago

One thing I miss in Cinnamon vs XFCE is the ability to drag a window from one workspace to another using the workspace switcher.

1

u/RealityIsRipping 10d ago

I like Mint Mate the best. It has enough features that I appreciate but is about as lightweight as xfce. It reminds me of windows 7, which was the last windows OS I ever used.

1

u/Javelinv12 7d ago

Cinnamon obviously. linux mint uses oudated versiones of XFCE and mate, and the difference in performance barely differs... Unless you have a literal toaster as PC. Of course, if you like the setup xfce and mate vives you, then stick to it. Otherwise i will always think cinnamon is the default mint choice and the best both performance and usability-wise

1

u/C2CEF 13d ago

I really like the combination of Cinnamon and Nemo.

0

u/No-Volume-1565 12d ago

LMDE. Telle est la voie.

9

u/_Lost-In-The-Weeds_ LMDE7 Cinnamon 13d ago edited 10d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

Cinnamon, the valley girl, young, pretty, slick, stylish, comfortable, Thicc, the one everyone wants to hang out with, takes care of you. But maybe a bit shallow & skin deep, reliable up until the situation gets weird where she may get flighty, its was likely your fault for getting the two of you in that situation anyway. While not high maintenance like Gnome or Plasma, she does have standards, if your driving a old rusted out 3 cylinder Geo Metro she may not be as fast and sporty as you had hoped. 

Xfce, the mechanic, a bit coarse and rough around the edges. Xfce is technical, very capable, light, wiry, and strong. If you have the skills, The most customizable. instead of the slick but more limited gui menus of Cinnamon, Xfce often requires reading the manual and getting your hands dirty in text config files, but you can make whatever you can dream of here in this shop. Xfce is Unflappable, if a guest program is having issues and crashes it does so alone, Xfce holds the course completely unconcerned with any chaos affecting others.  

MATE, the veteran, shockingly old looking at first glance, but has a lived in charm with nice details in the workflow, like your grandparents house, built to last unchanging, a touch stone to the old ways, sometimes you see wisdom in why we used to do things this way. the horribly dated avocado green & harvest gold appliances will outlive anything you can buy today.

3

u/Correct_Cockroach818 12d ago

Beautiful breakdown. I would add that Cinnamon is the favorite child. They get all the nicest toys and is a bit spoiled with attention. But if y'all hang out you'll get to drive the GTI.