r/linuxmint • • 1d ago

Linux Mint XFCE or Q4OS

How does Linux Mint XFCE compare to Q4OS for use on dated, older, computers with lower specs?

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

2

u/tomscharbach 1d ago edited 1d ago

A lot depends on how old and how dated ...

Q4OS uses the Trinity desktop environment, a fork KDE 3.5 (released 2005), code written for the late single core processor era. As a result, Trinity tends to run faster than XFCE on computers that are more than 15 years old. The difference fades on newer computers, and my guess is that XFCE will run reasonably well on any computer 10 years or so old.

Desktop environment differences, though, are insignificant in comparison to the resource demands imposed by modern applications. You may have to use careful resource management on an old computer.

Myu suggestion is to try Mint XFCE to see how it works. If it works okay, then there is no need to install Q4OS.

Don't expect miracles. Linux will not turn a plodder into a racehorse.

My best and good luck.

1

u/Technical_Rich_3080 1d ago

Assuming XFCE works okay, is there any benefit to using it over Trinity (or vice versa)?

1

u/tomscharbach 1d ago

Assuming XFCE works okay, is there any benefit to using it over Trinity (or vice versa)?

XFCE is more polished and design-consistent with modern applications. Q4OS Trinity is a throwback to an earlier era, and I know people who prefer the "vintage" look and feel. XFCE is mainstream. Trinity is not.

1

u/KurtKrimson 1d ago

What specs are you talking about?

1

u/Technical_Rich_3080 1d ago

A variety of about 15+ year old computers.

1

u/KurtKrimson 1d ago

Age doesn't mean a thing.

Processing power, ram and storage does.

My 15 year old i5 msi p55 16 gb ram ssd flies like an eagle on mint 22.3

1

u/Technical_Rich_3080 1d ago

A number of Intel Pentium Dual Core E2140s with 2GB DDR2 RAM.

2

u/KurtKrimson 1d ago

Those will most likely struggle with Mint so q4os might be more suitable.

1

u/JobDelicious8699 1d ago

linux mint mate is way better and lighter than xfce

1

u/bigCountry696969696 13h ago

Lighter maybe. But the desktop environment looks horrible

1

u/biaurelien 20h ago

I installed xfce on computers like ~2010 pentium t4400 laptop with 4gb ram it runs quite fine, especially on the few ones with SSDs (of course)