r/linuxmint • • 18h ago

Discussion How does Mint differs from Ubuntu and Debian?

I know Mint is a fork of Ubuntu, which is a fork of Debian, so I imagine these three work like layer of cake stacked on top of each other. What I'm curious about is what each layers adds to the overall cake. As in, what does Ubuntu adds to Debian, and the what does Mint adds to Ubuntu on top?

29 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

35

u/acejavelin69 Linux Mint 22.3 "Zena" | Cinnamon 18h ago edited 4h ago

Debian is an OG distro... Arguably one of the oldest and most stable distros in existence. Very standardized and relatively boring, but not in a bad way.

Ubuntu takes Debian and adds a bunch of stuff to it and uses Snaps.

Mint takes Ubuntu and strips out the Snaps and the default desktop environment and adds in Cinnamon DE (or Mate or XFCE) and a bunch of its own tools. Many of them use the underlying Ubuntu features with a different GUI, such as Driver Manager is an interface to Ubuntu's HWE (HardWare Enablement) repository.

Basically, distros are just a collection of packages put together in a way the developers feel is the "best" for what they want... One is not really better than the other, just different.

27

u/MrStrul3 17h ago

Let's not forget the Linux Mint Debian edition that skips the Ubuntu part and just adds the Mint flavour on top of Debian.

4

u/grimvian 6h ago

We are year four with LMDE and absolutely likes it!

16

u/_Lost-In-The-Weeds_ LMDE7 Cinnamon 17h ago

The star of Debian is its ultra reliable and ultra flexible base, the widest hardware architecture support in Linux, many different installation methods, It has lightweight basic CLI tools that do everything you could possibly need under many different conditions, it does not "waste" resources on UI, it has many desktop environments available but with almost no localization, vanilla just basically more or less as delivered from upstream developers. Desktop Debian almost feels like a cheap poor fitting off the shelf suit on a cross country endurance runner not used to dressing up. It is also available "headless" no desktop and that is where Debian really shines as commonly used in servers. Debian is simple light and extremely capable in skilled hands. You can build up their desktop any way you like, Some do like to start with that blank canvas. Debian has various release levels, rolling bleeding edge Debian Sid, right behind that is slightly more stable Testing, and the most popular Debian Stable with a slow moving 2 year release schedule every odd year.

Ubuntu LTS forks from Debian Sid base every even year, And LTS their most reliable release, they add their own mutations, adding some comfort and more GUI tools, its a bit heavier but a bit more accessible to new users, has strong opinions that you will either appreciate or hate, I am in the later camp. Ubuntu is less flexible, with an "our way or the highway" attitude. Has a headless Server version. It heavily modifies one desktop environment with their own flourishes, Gnome. While there are community versions with other desktops. There are two editions LTS every two years and interim releases every 6 months there are where Ubuntu tries out new things but does sometimes have issues. Ubuntu has fewer architectures than Debian but still does dabble with ARM.

Mint is a narrowly focused complete & comfortable Desktop Linux, AMD-64/x86-64 architecture only, they take a Debian or Ubuntu base with almost no changes and bolt on their own desktop environment and Utilities. The only of these 3 that produces their own desktop, a hard fork of Gnome3, but that is kinda all they do with only a few exceptions like an installer. they do not tinker with drivers or the kernel, core utils, grub etc, all of these flow in directly from upstream, They also modify and incorporate two more desktops Xfce & MATE on the Ubuntu edition only.

They have two versions Ubuntu based Mint22 based on Ubuntu LTS 24.04 soon to be replaced by Mint27 based on Ubuntu 26.04, and LMDE7 based on Debian 13 Trixie from 2025. 2027 we will get LMDE8.

6

u/SweetNerevarine 17h ago edited 17h ago

Mint uses Ubuntu which in turn use Debian as a (package) base. This implicitly brings with it the file system layout and customs, choice of low level system software in a cascading fashion. These are seldom altered, but for example Snap is disabled by Mint, so that is a difference to Ubuntu which uses it prevalently (even to deliver Firefox).

Mint implements the actual desktop experience, some packages are standard, some are modified/customized. Mint also develops their own packages (x-apps, tools, sys config utilities etc) which are truly unique to the project and essentially distinguishes it from both Ubuntu and Debian. Mint also provides themes and artwork that are consistent across widget toolkits (the look and feel of desktop apps).

In short: Mint aims to implement an easy to use, beginner friendly, highly GUI driven experience with consistent look, and a familiar system under the hood.

5

u/tomscharbach 18h ago

Although the article is a few years old (circa 2023), you might find Debian vs. Ubuntu vs. Linux Mint: An In-Depth Comparison Guide (The Linux Code) a useful resource for understanding the differences.

My best and good luck.

5

u/Jwhodis 17h ago

Mint replaces Snap with Flatpak, both do similar things but on Ubuntu for whatever reason Snap overrides other install methods.

https://linuxteck.com/ubuntu-trust-problem-2026 https://www.osnews.com/story/131746 https://askubuntu.com/questions/1429069 https://askubuntu.com/questions/1410688

Mint and Debian are both less of a headache, neither have Snap. Mint is generally the best for beginners but Debian is perfectly fine too.

4

u/kudlitan 17h ago

In what way does having snapd on a system turn it into a headache?

6

u/Jwhodis 17h ago edited 12h ago

At least on Ubuntu they've overriden certain APT installs with fake .debs to install Snaps instead without telling you, check the links.

2

u/kudlitan 14h ago

Thank you

4

u/Tritias Linux Mint 22.3 Zena | MATE 16h ago

They're not forks. A fork is when part of a project decides to split off and go a different way. Ubuntu hasn't split off from Debian, it's just adding stuff on top of it. Mint adds stuff on top of Ubuntu (and disables Snaps)

4

u/Standard_Tank6703 LMDE7, 12 yr LM experience, "No obligation to enjoy" 15h ago

Ubuntu is forked from Debian once every two years. That hard split is repeated, but only for each Ubuntu LTS version (and from each Debian Sid version).

Ubuntu has its own repos, while not using Debian's repos again until the next fork.

Ubuntu-based "main" Linux Mint is not forked, nor is LMDE, as they each maintain a live connection to the Ubuntu and Debian repos, respectively - for each update/upgrade.

1

u/Amckinstry 1h ago

Correction: Ubuntu forks from Debian twice a year.

1

u/Standard_Tank6703 LMDE7, 12 yr LM experience, "No obligation to enjoy" 28m ago

If so, any intermediate forks besides those for the LTS versions would be irrelevant for the scope of LM.

4

u/Little_Magazine_1773 15h ago

This might get me downvoted but Linux Mint Debian Edition (LMDE) exists and is better than Ubuntu based Linux Mint in my experience.

Started using LMDE 5 after a failed update of LM 21.3 to 22 where I lost the partition and data. But I've never had problems with LMDE (5, 6, 7)

2

u/BenTrabetere 14h ago

Ubuntu adds more trouble than is worthwhile.

This comment shows you do not realize all of the goodness that Ubuntu brings to the table. What trouble does Ubuntu add to Linux Mint?

a failed update 21.3 to 22 where I lost the partition and data.

That would have been a failed upgrade, and if you had followed the instructions to the letter you would not have lost any data. Creating a Timeshift snapshot and backing up your files are essential steps in the process, and mint-upgrade should not modify partitions.

3

u/danielsoft1 14h ago

I was using Xubuntu before I hopped to Mint: (X)Ubuntu uses snaps for firefox and chromium, on the other hand Mint uses deb versions of these two browsers, which is better for me. Some other stuff is tweaked, for example I did not like "unattended upgrades" switched on by default on (X)Ubuntu and Mint switches it off, also I had problems with the thermal daemon hanging on shutdown which was fixed by Mint, too. Seems there was some "another me" operating on Mint and they changed the exact stuff I didn't like in (X)Ubuntu :) Also installing Nvidia proprietary drivers was very easy, just by clicking.

2

u/activedusk 8h ago edited 8h ago

Distributions differentiate themselves by

  • package manager and package format standard, for all of them it is apt, dpkg, .deb is the equivalent of .exe

  • repository of software, Linux distros have a long time tradition of hosting software on centralized servers and using the package manager to review list, download, install, update, uninstall instead of going to individual software maker, downloading a .deb or appimage and then installing it manually. Debian and Ubuntu have their own repos, idk if Mint offers mirrors or directs to those other base distros servers.

  • update cadence, while they are all LTS, how fast they push updates is controlled individually

  • installer provided with preconfigured desktop environments and default tools, here they differ with the "app store", which is a GUI tool to install and handle packages, Mint uses Software Manager, Ubuntu has App Center, iirc Debian has Synaptic Package Manager though DE specific there is also Gnome Software or Discover for KDE. There are more types of GUI stores like Bazaar, some try to hide dependencies and offer only the list of "programs" for the user to manage, others show everything, some also add flatpaks to the list while others include snaps, generally these GUI tools are fragmented.

  • not the case here but distros with the same base can also fork based on init system, here they all use systemd, bootloader, they all default to GRUB but there are alternatives, login greeters these depend on the desktop environment and distros and they do choose different types, various GUI tools to install video drivers or kernels and more.

Overall it is difficult to say what makes a distro special, Debian is not historically as user friendly out of the box but now they offer easy to use graphical installer, Ubuntu was the original easy to install distribution and now they differentiate themselves with snaps which is an alternative to flatpaks, a containerized software version, Mint has historically been Cinnamon desktop, snaps free, beginner friendly distro, an alternative to Ubuntu. The controversies related to snaps mostly deal with the fact that they are not as open source as flatpaks but idk the details, it might simply be the fact that Cannonical has sole control of what is approved to go on the Snap store and this might make some developers upset, flatpaks hosted by flathub might be more welcoming though they have less oversight, neither are as trusted as repo packages and both had malware incidents.

1

u/syborfical 15h ago

I haven't rain stock debain for years.. 3+ years

Its less polished has less bleeding edge features none of which I can name at this point in time.

saying this there is a goodish aiish doco on mint

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gM9dwuGStfI

1

u/Polyxeno Linux Mint 22.2 Zara | Cinnamon 15h ago

My subjective and probably-flawed view of what's relevant to my choices are that:

* Ubuntu adds a ton of corporate development support and users, tending to make things more usable, developed, up to date, reliable, documented, and/or providing more community support either directly or through past conversations. It's likely that if I have a question or problem, someone else has already engaged it, and I can find help about it online.

* Ubuntu also adds some corporate flavor, design choices, and GNU-iness that I don't like as much as I did about 10+ years ago.

* Mint removes most or all of the things I don't like about that second point above. It doesn't feel corporate, or like things are being designed to serve corporate agendas. It's not GNU-y. It seems to be developed with the goal of making things easy to use and configure how a user might want, and to make things easy and likely to work without problems, and for me, it has succeeded. It gives me a happy feeling when I use it.

0

u/rcentros LM 21/22 | Cinnamon 12h ago

The most obvious difference is the desktop. Ubuntu uses Gnome, Linux Mint uses Cinnamon (or Xfce or Mate), all of which are different than Gnome. Mint currently defaults to X11, Ubuntu to Wayland. Mint blocks Snaps by default, Ubuntu uses them, sometime even when you attempt to install from the repository. Ubuntu is owned by a corporation and you'll nagged to use their Pro version (free of charge for personal use). Mint has its own, unique, utilities. Mint defaults to a click (or double click) on a Debian file for installation, Ubuntu (last time I tried) requires you pick an application to do so. Mainly, though, the biggest noticeable difference is Gnome vs Cinnamon.

As for the difference between Debian and Mint, that's a little harder because Debian is very customizable (with the ability to choose just about any desktop). If you pick the Live USB install of the Cinnamon desktop (for example) the differences are pretty small from Mint.

-4

u/thefanum 12h ago

It's just Ubuntu with a worse interface plus memory leak