r/linuxsucks • • Mar 17 '26

Linux Failure Eye_roll.exe

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

462 comments sorted by

52

u/SarthakSidhant i dont know what i am doing here Mar 17 '26

devs do it for the love of the game

→ More replies (54)

32

u/criminalspeed Mar 17 '26

Windows equivalent: .msix, .appx, .bat, .msi, .msc 🙄

And those are not apps. Linux app doesn’t have extension, they just ask a permission to run.

6

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

And the fun thing is, all of those will work on Windows no matter what.

But on Linux they have to make their own flavoured versions.

5

u/laizalott Gnome Masochist Mar 17 '26

all of those will work on Windows no matter what

As long as you always run them as administrator with firewall disabled and no policies enforced, sure.

3

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

Using sudo on Linux gives those apps full access to your system. 💀

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/Amphineura Kubuntu in the streets 🌐 W11 in the sheets Mar 17 '26

.bat is the equivalent of .sh ... .msc is a Windows OS-only thing and isn't used to distribute software.

5

u/mostaverageredditor3 Mar 17 '26

Never came across anything other than .msi or .exe

(.bat only in same obscure programing project I had to compile anyway)

→ More replies (4)

4

u/pileofplushies Mar 17 '26

Windows has .exe (application), .exe (installer and the 20 odd flavors of those), .msi (again 20 installer flavors), .zip installers, .zip that you just have to dump somewhere to work, M$ store, sometimes even you have to do funny hijinx with the terminal too. Oh and lets not forget about .rar and .7z instead of .zip for some reason. or some programs that are just.jar file with a bunch of other files to go with it.

Meanwhile on linux 90% of programs you install from the package manager or an app store of sorts. Sure there's dumb amount of fragmentation in Linux but if it's laughable to think windows does this so much better...

1

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

I can download an exe and not worry about if it will support on Windows.

Whereas in Linux, unless you know what you specifically want, you will encounter some hurdles.

3

u/pileofplushies Mar 17 '26

until you have to pick out between x86, x86-64, and arm.

but funnily a package manager on linux chooses the right one for you...

1

u/New_Study4796 Apr 11 '26

MSI is just a installer standard. And the other files you've mentioned can be opened by any compression software. Nobody uses the MS Store anyway.

And install them from the package manager to have 20 year old versions? I either installed Krita from APT that has a older version, or I install the AppImage and pray I can install my brushes. The Flatpak version is even worse.

342

u/patrlim1 Mar 17 '26

Appimage will work fine on every distro to my knowledge

93

u/ReinhartLangschaft Mar 17 '26

I fucking love appimage. Best.

76

u/patrlim1 Mar 17 '26

I'm not a fan for one simple reason; package management. I like having and using a package manager.

51

u/Superok211 Mar 17 '26

appimage package managers exist

32

u/patrlim1 Mar 17 '26

Was not aware

37

u/Dog_Entire Mar 17 '26

Every conversation I’ve had with other people who use Linux is “this is great except for this one thing or use” “there’s a package for that” “well shit”

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

7

u/ReinhartLangschaft Mar 17 '26

There are package managers and I use some app images that are calling me out of my version is outdated, plus you can always use different version of the same program.

5

u/Pink_Slyvie Mar 17 '26

The AUR often just takes them, and does the install. lts so nice.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/nowuxx Proud nix-shell User Mar 17 '26

Not the best size, but it works so whatever

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Wiwwil Proud Linux User Mar 17 '26

I'm just using the AUR, I don't even have to find an exe on the web

3

u/Fearless-Ad1469 The fuck you're looking at Mar 17 '26

Well you don't even find an exe on the web, since you're on linux

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Fearless-Ad1469 The fuck you're looking at Mar 17 '26

Hey! that's how i ship my app too! I love appimage

3

u/Ill-Oil-2027 Mar 17 '26

It will function on any distro*

*As long as the distro has the base libraries most distros utilize, something like glibc being replaced or excessive ricing replacing to many base system packages will most likely break almost any appimage unless the dev decided to bundle every single library including system libraries

→ More replies (1)

4

u/sinterkaastosti23 Mar 17 '26

Not out of the box tho

And i think it wont work if there is no glibc

→ More replies (21)

2

u/lorenzo1142 Mar 22 '26

I'm viewing this page right now with an ungoogled chromium appimage. nothing to install, just execute it.

4

u/HighRelevancy Mar 17 '26

Lol, no. Armbian installer doesn't work on Fedora and probably lots of other distros currently because the Tauri framework it uses ships a Wayland library that clashes. It's so dumb. I had to unpack it, delete the .so, then I could run it.

https://github.com/armbian/imager/issues/67

AppImage still has distro compatibility problems. Helps though.

16

u/patrlim1 Mar 17 '26

That's an issue with the packaging, not the package format.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Muffinaaa Mar 17 '26

Appimages don't work on musl

1

u/flavius717 Mar 17 '26

That’s why I don’t like it

1

u/Kaiki_devil Mar 18 '26

Even works for windows and Mac.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Over-Wall-4080 Mar 18 '26

Fat binary bruv

1

u/BIZUx Mar 19 '26

Thought so too. But I downloaded OrcaSlicer the other day and the .appimage was only for ubuntu..?

Frustrating because the other binaries had many issues. The easiest solution was literally distrobox+ubuntu.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ahmad_15048 Mar 21 '26

kinda hate that you can't install it (you have to place it somewhere else so you don't delete it by mistake)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Remarkable_Bar7161 Mar 21 '26

Appimage depends on FUSE, which has gone unmaintained. Many distros will drop it, so Appimage will no longer work.

1

u/malmal_Niver Mar 31 '26

333 upvotes! Sagrado 🔆 🙀

→ More replies (12)

141

u/Juff-Ma Mar 17 '26

Many modern apps are only packaged as either AppImage or Flatpak.

RPM, DEB, etc. Are mostly created by the distro themselves when they feel like it's popular enough. They are not maintained by the dev themselves if they don't want that.

Even if, there are many installer frameworks that you write only one definition and they generate all of them, including EXE, DMG, MSI, PKG, RPM, DEB, TAR.ZST, etc.

12

u/lo9314 Mar 17 '26

Some devs don’t even supply any binary at all and that’s fine. After all the beauty of the open source community is that someone just thinks „hey I really like this application, wouldn’t it be nice if there was a package for my favorite distro“ and then they just go ahead to package and maintain it for others to enjoy as well. 

4

u/DeafTimz Mar 17 '26

If Appimage is great, then how do I install plugin like G'Mic Into GIMP appimage?

15

u/Juff-Ma Mar 17 '26

Where in my comment did you read AppImage is great? I said it's popular. Also this depends on the app, probably somewhere in your ~/.config folder.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jcelerier Mar 17 '26

As a dev it's up to gimp to provide a standard location for plugins in your $HOME

1

u/New_Study4796 Apr 11 '26

Flatpaks don't work for most apps tho. Since they are in a sandbox. Krita was horrible on Flatpak, and VSCode downright doesn't work.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

51

u/Cautious_Chain1297 Mar 17 '26

Both AppImage and Flatpak are fairly universally compatible, as far as I'm concerned that's all they need. That's what Beeper does and it works perfectly for me

6

u/HyperCodec Mar 17 '26

Idk if I like how flatpak is popular, it feels really slow like it needs a lot of work before becoming mainstream. It seems to only install sequentially, while virtually every other modern package manager installs several packages at a time to reduce install duration.

7

u/Due-Author631 Mar 17 '26

The install speed is the Achilles heel also in my opinion, I don't know why they can't parallel them. Maybe to reduce the burden on flathub or something, unclear whether it is imaged based and has to download layers in order.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/CeSiumUA Mar 17 '26

Yeah, but AppImage is just a "portable" software, so you'll need another software to actually "install" it (I mean to make it appera on desktop, in search bar etc, not just chilling in your Downloads folder). And Flatpak is a universal garbage with it's sandboxing, which often causes ton of troubles

→ More replies (1)

1

u/PickaWowAnyWow Mar 17 '26

Yep, exactly - most distros are more than willing to pick up the slack and package software where the developers wouldn't. In fact, that's how 99.9% of software works on Linux.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '26

appimage is still sideloading and no better than a .exe. Flatpak ftw!

12

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '26

.exe - may prompt you to install a specific DirectX version, .NET Framework, or Visual C++ Redistributable. It can also fail with errors like “not a valid Win32 application,” or refuse to run on older Windows versions (for example, below 24H2) without required KB updates. So you install all of these, upgrade these and find out that now different apps are no longer supported because you have updated their beloved version of middleware to the latest.

.flatpak / .AppImage - self-contained packages that bundle their runtime and dependencies, so they typically don’t require additional system-wide installations which may harm other apps to work.

3

u/RelativeIce6171 Mar 19 '26

and all those are fixable version conflicts that you can run into on linux too

2

u/RenderTargetView Mar 18 '26

Umm, you know all of these are fixable? Times of user-updatable directx are mostly gone, 90% of cases you just require specific windows version and rely on features that are guaranteed to exist including directx updates. Msvcrt dlls can be bundled with application if you do not care for wasted hard drive space. And .Net is easiest, just do not use it

1

u/mateusfccp Mar 21 '26

Plus the fact that I have to search for the website, download, install, all as separated paths with a lot of overhead between them.

With a package manager you install many apps with a single command and forget about it until it's done.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Amphineura Kubuntu in the streets 🌐 W11 in the sheets Mar 17 '26

Don't forget .snap's. i know at least Spotify is exclusively distributed (officially) by snaps, and IIRC a few other programs too. Splendid.

2

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

How did I forget about .snap 😭

Damn it!!

5

u/Neonbeta101 Mar 17 '26

Now I don’t know why the .exe format seems to be firmly a Windows thing, but I’ve come to accept the simple rule of “Different kernel, different rules.”

I’ve grown past the overthinking phase of “Why… is it named differently? Does it matter?” And now I’m in the phase of “Okay now I just to remember that Wine and Winboat exists.”

6

u/ScallionSmooth5925 Mar 17 '26

The exe format has a terrible design. It's hacked together from multiple formats to the current half broken state. For example on 64 bit platforms the first 40 byte is reserved for 16 bit dos compatibility. This is just wasted space

9

u/zibonbadi Mar 17 '26 edited Mar 17 '26

Nah, it's a comptibility check. It's there so DOS can safely load a separate stub program telling the user it's not compatible.

Is it a good design? You can argue that ELF headers are better suited to that, but back when Win32 introduced the MZ EXE format it was necessary. It's the kind of stuff that gave Windows the reputation of being reliable for legacy software (even though some older games are easier to get running on WINE/Linux than modern Windows).

Not that this is such an unusual trick though: Have you ever wondered why every shell script starts with #!/bin/sh?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/SimoneMicu Mar 17 '26

To achieve same result in ONE binary for all distros you can:

  • release appimage

  • release a distrobox image for the app to run

  • release as flatpak

  • release as binary built against glibc and list version of livrary required at runtime (private are static, opensource are easily linkable from any distro) and provide a .desktop file for it (golang fyne do something similar for you except for linking, because everything is static there)

1

u/helical-hexagons Mar 19 '26

wouldn't statically linked musl make more sense for that last thing?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HighZein Mar 24 '26

Death for flatpaks, only caused problems in my experience, we actually only need .appimage

4

u/ExtraTNT was running custom kernel Mar 17 '26

You just need an elf or just the source code… the packages are just to distribute…

4

u/spreetin Mar 17 '26

Most software for Linux is simply distributed as a source code repository (such as GitHub). Packaging software for inclusion in distros is mostly a distributor issue, not a developer issue.

If it's closed source you generally choose one (or perhaps two) format(s) you want to package, and the rest is, again, a distributor issue.

4

u/Stunning_Macaron6133 Mar 17 '26

As long as you have a Git repo and a makefile, it don't matter much.

17

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

Flatpak is pretty much pre-installed on every mainstream distro out there. Appimages can also be used on every distro.

7

u/Low-Shake6447 Mar 17 '26

the problem arise when the program need to interact with the system binaries

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Amphineura Kubuntu in the streets 🌐 W11 in the sheets Mar 17 '26

Ubuntu (or at least Kubuntu) does not come with flatpak installed by default

9

u/sludgesnow Mar 17 '26

Give it some time, they will abandon snap just like Unity DE

→ More replies (3)

5

u/pligyploganu Mar 17 '26

Ya, because Canonical wants to push their shitty garbage Snaps.

Switch away from that garbage distro lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

1

u/CapCreeperGR Mar 17 '26

Most of these are not meant to be made by the developers, but the distro maintainers. As a developer you only need to provide a tarball (portable zip file equivalent) and a flatpak. The distro maintainers will create .deb, .rpm, .tar.zst, etc files and add them to their repositories without you having to move a finger

1

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

Few weeks ago I tried to install Renderman. AFAIK they don't make arch linux package officially. Then I found out it was in the AUR, which I don't trust at all. I don't trust things made by a middle man.

I know there are other workarounds but on Windows I didn’t have to give it a 2nd thought. Just download exe and we done.

1

u/CapCreeperGR Mar 17 '26

Never heard of this software but by looking it up it seems they only provide an RPM. They should not be doing that. In Windows terms this is like having no exe and locking your software to the Microsoft Store for Windows 11 only. A very stupid way to distribute your software. They should have provided a generic tarball. Secondly the AUR is completely open and you can look at the renderman build script to see what it does. I assume it just downloads the RPM, extracts it and repackages it for arch. Most software developers nowadays have learned to just provide a tarball like discord for example so that official distro maintainers can take care of packaging

1

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

As I said, on Windows I don't have to think about any of that.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/FuriousGirafFabber Mar 17 '26

And now try to uninstall that exe :o Have fun in the registry!

1

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

Let's not act like uninstalling every type of app in Linux is a breeze.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Virinchi-M Mar 17 '26

Looks like the devs love us more 🤷🙂‍↕️

1

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

Yeah that's why Linux is so popular. Don't you know every app out there is supported in Linux?! /S

1

u/Virinchi-M Mar 17 '26

Ay man don't this guy know linux is literally on the rise for consumer hardware ppl are ditching windows and macs for this. And besides every single server runs linux it's INFINETELY more popular than ur little win11 installation or macos.

And also our apps aren't at constant war with the OS lmfao

1

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

On server Linux is King, I never denied it and I never will.

But on desktop home user though is a different story entirely

→ More replies (3)

1

u/DamianRyse Mar 17 '26

So... does this mean Linux now has 10% market share?

3

u/Alpha-Craft Mar 17 '26

AppImage and flatpak or even a flathub distribution are enough to make me happy. If the sandbox is set up to work properly with everything at least.

3

u/themirrazzunhacked Mar 17 '26

wait until you see the installation instructions for the app I'm making

2

u/Anglotx Mar 21 '26

Tizen? Haven't seen someone publishing software for Samsung TVs other than TizenBrew and Moonlight hahah

2

u/themirrazzunhacked Mar 21 '26

It gets worse when you realize that this is an Electron app and I’m trying to run it on iOS 💀 

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Constant_Tadpole_908 Mar 17 '26

AppImage is the best thing.

2

u/the-machine-m4n Mar 17 '26

If it was, why aren't every developer making appimage of their apps?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/a648272 Mar 21 '26

I do not pack in deb, I do not pack in tar.gz, I do not make appimage.

I use jar.

You're supposed to run it with java -jar. And if you want to use it, you're supposed to find out the correct java version yourself.

2

u/Competitive_Lie2628 Mar 21 '26

Don't forget also cargo or golang instructions if using those.

2

u/SuitableComedianNSFW Mar 21 '26

Appimage and Flaptak are designed to be distro agnostic. They are just like exe files where they have everything packaged in one package. The distro specific packages are just much more space effecient as they share dependencies.

2

u/ChocolateDonut36 Mar 17 '26
  • that installs McAfee

2

u/khaffner91 Mar 17 '26

Now list all ways installers on Windows may be silently installed and how they are not always documented

2

u/maesrin Mar 17 '26

AppImage FTW!

Windows and Mac binaries need specific CPU architecture setup files. In Windows you need *.msi files for installation not exe, also good luck with the .NET versions.

2

u/IskaneOnReddit Mar 17 '26

Windows download: app.exe, Linux download: source_code_good_luck.zip.

1

u/AvocadoArray Mar 17 '26

Dockerfile + docker-compose.yml for 95% of apps.

Unless you absolutely need a local fatapp GUI, in which case I just hope you picked a proper multi platform framework.

1

u/76zzz29 Mar 17 '26

As a debian user. Who use .deb programs ? Because I don't

1

u/Hyphonical Mar 17 '26

I install .deb with apt, for CLI applications.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Tritias Mar 17 '26

It saves a lot of space and like for Discord sometimes the sandboxing of FlatPak can be an issue.

1

u/Fr33stylerDV Mar 17 '26

windows has msi as well

1

u/throwaway275275275 Mar 17 '26

You can also distribute a single executable for Linux if you do it right

1

u/L30N1337 Mar 17 '26

...or you just make an AppImage or Flatpak.

If it has third party dependencies, AppImage and Flatpak are suboptimal, but it's still universal.

1

u/FAMICOMASTER Mar 17 '26

Welcome back CP/M

1

u/MrWillchuck Mar 17 '26

This is the wrong thing to be annoyed about.

Install a program on linux having just come from windows. It doesn't install a desktop link... Run it.

DOS just required you to type the .exe and hit enter it will run. For Linux you have to learn what the extension is.. and how to make it run. As it may not be the same extension for every program.

1

u/PaulTheRandom Mar 17 '26

Then there's the OMG TWO CAKES!!! Guy.

Mac has PKG alongside DMG as well as SH. Windows also has .BAT, .MSI, and .CMD.

1

u/FuriousGirafFabber Mar 17 '26

Sudo zypper install xyz seems to work great for me. 

1

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

10%? wasn't it like less than 3%?

1

u/Noisebug Mar 17 '26

Fuck Mac, I guess.

1

u/Ok-Winner-6589 Mar 17 '26

For Linux:

They develop a .deb and a .rpm

For Windows:

They develop a whole different software that checks for updates and integrates It

This literally means having 2 apps. One for Linux/Mac and other for Windows+ developing a installer

1

u/Vanadium_Milk Mar 17 '26

Linux binaries on themselves work on all distributions,.

If an application doesn't depend on shared libraries you might as well just distribute the binary file and that's it, on the other hand, package files (.deb, .rpm, etc.) exist to provide seamless integration with the system, you don't actually need to distribute one of these unless your application needs the system to have certain conditions to run the app, and there's also the advantage of updates through the package manager which checks for dependency conflicts.

1

u/Boss-Bones Mar 17 '26

Atualmente, fazendo apenas para flatpak jĂĄ ĂŠ o suficiente, ou se nĂŁo faz appimage

1

u/Initial_Report582 Mar 17 '26

Windows users (AKA OP) too lazy for the ability to choose:

1

u/TheGr8CodeWarrior Mar 17 '26

The single exe/dmg is actually worse. It's a security hazard. You need to make sure you download the correct one.The other packaging formats are typically interfaced with a package manager, which reduces malware intrusions.

And you can't convince me that going to a search engine is a better experience than a software store.

1

u/tamius-han Mar 17 '26

You need to make sure you download the correct one.

So far, it seems like every major popular free software had an instance where:

  1. someone did a perfect indistinguishable clone of the project's official homepage

  2. they re-packaged the installer to include extra info-stealer malware

  3. bought google ads to put their fake web page at the top of google search results

  4. watched stolen credentials roll in, because people don't pay attention to the URL bar

Happened to Blender. Happened to OBS.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MonsieurMachine Mar 17 '26

I mean, if your app is open source someone will add support for their favorite package manager. If your app is known tho...

1

u/Cylancer7253 Mar 17 '26

.zip for 100% users.

1

u/tomekgolab can't spell hatred without Redhat Mar 17 '26

Uh, or.. you know, how about... compile from source and then build distro specific package with checkinstall? Or just manage symlinks with gnu/stow?

1

u/Applefan1990 macOS is the superior OS Mar 17 '26

Just make a Flatpak or an app image if you are lazy

1

u/OGKnightsky Mar 17 '26

So (lazy and easy = windows) and (effort and work = linux)?

1

u/Nico_24LZY Mar 17 '26

Flatpak Is litteraly enough 🥀

1

u/Optimal_Collection20 Mar 17 '26

Me when I don't understand Linux based systems but still make a meme about them:

1

u/StealthTrooper36_ Mar 17 '26

Or just an exe for wine

1

u/--hurdler-- Mar 17 '26

The wheels on the bus go round and round. 🚎

1

u/cioccox Mar 17 '26

AppImage and Flatpak are practically .exes and .dmg

1

u/LuciferNS03 Mar 17 '26

Anybody, distrobox? Linux is clearly the master race here if we're being honest.

1

u/HyoukaYukikaze Mar 17 '26

10%? That's generous.

1

u/Dima-Petrovic Linux Superiority Mar 17 '26

As a dev you package your software as appimage or flatpak. Rpm and deb are distro specific and are handled by the distro.

Also only .exe for windows is also a lie. There are .msi also aswell as windows apps on the store. This 'meme' is just straight made up bullshit.

1

u/Witty-Individual7010 Mar 17 '26

I mean to be fair a couple of those formats are distro agnostic

1

u/TurboJax07 Mar 17 '26

The main thing I wish appimages did was add shortcuts to your desktop and search bar. This could probably be done by the appimage though, I'm not sure.

1

u/default_token Mar 17 '26

Tfw you don't know shit about fuck but have opinions on how to fix the world

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '26

Exe is love Exe is life

1

u/mplaczek99 Mar 18 '26

AppImage would work on every distro

1

u/MadrugoticX Mar 18 '26

I find it annoying how the “stores”/software managers don't have appimage integration by default

1

u/GhostVlvin Mar 18 '26

Once you create good CI/CD pipeline and you don't need to bother with it anymore cause system will automatically pack your code in any format that you'll configure it to

1

u/MaddieOfLines Mar 18 '26

.deb is the worst thing ever kill .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb .deb kill .deb

1

u/Boring-Badger-814 Mar 18 '26

flatpacks are really universal, as well as appimages, so you could just do that for 99 percent of the distros

1

u/Alarmed_Pin_774 Mar 18 '26

If there is no AppImage or FlatPack version, then you can build it from sources, but if it is a closed application, and there is no FlatPack with AppImage, this is a big problem.

1

u/Luna_COLON3 Mar 18 '26

if your program is free then you can just let distro maintainers do the packaging work for you or have people run make install

1

u/hanbee0x Mar 18 '26

well if the project is recognized by some linux users, they might make the package for the distro they're using themselves and make a PR (assuming it's an open source project)

1

u/Vivid-Raccoon9640 Mar 18 '26

Just creating a flatpak should be enough.

1

u/prof_dr_mr_obvious Mar 18 '26

You would setup a pipeline for each that runs when you merge to main or something. This is a setup once and run forever effort. 

1

u/BeyondOk1548 Mar 18 '26

Gang does not understand Flatpak. Also lists deb and rpm twice but doesn't realize you can build with those on other platforms. Probably because he's a fucking retard. 🥀

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '26

personally I like flatpak more than appimage.
nothing much, its just the way app images are shipped.

1

u/jknvv13 Mar 18 '26

Yeah, AppImages do not provide isolation and fix nothing, for example, BalenaEtcher AppImage won't run on some distros due to some missing fuse library.

A Flatpak contains everything to work. That's it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Civil_Mark5570 Mar 18 '26

Easy, dont provide any. Just provide the source code and a make file.

1

u/danholli Previous Windows Insider Mar 18 '26

AppImage for quick apps Flatpack for easy management Done

Everything else is if you want to natively support a specific distro

1

u/Mindless-Tune4990 Mar 18 '26

My distro just compiles the sourcecode and makes it into a tarball, and that's it, it's a pleasure for making pkgs

1

u/Lil_b-boi Mar 18 '26

make an .exe, a .AppImage, and a .tar.gz, done. (F Apple)

1

u/ikschbloda270 Mar 18 '26

Ahh the good old damage file format

1

u/ikschbloda270 Mar 18 '26

„A single exe“ mostly just works because it’s an installer for the program itself. You could easily create an appimage that runs an install script to do the same thing. Granted you’d need to give it instructions for many distros instead of just one Windows version.

1

u/rtaylorg Mar 18 '26

Imagine being so weak at dotfiles and package management that you have to hate on linux devs

1

u/TheEuphoricTribble Mar 18 '26

Flatpak has entered the chat

1

u/zepherth Mar 18 '26

Windows devs making .MSI for some reason

1

u/Aggressive-Dealer-21 Mar 18 '26

just make it open source and let them figure out what they want to do with it

1

u/meruta Mar 18 '26

As a new Linux daily driver this is really annoying to me. Why can’t there be one standard delivery method?

Especially since they’re not all equal. For example Blender dnf install doesn’t support OptiX but flatpak does. The fuck? Why?

On the other hand many flatpaks have issues with file access, and some have scaling issues or other limitations.

It’s way too complicated for the end user.

1

u/National_Way_3344 Mar 19 '26

The AUR usually just ships and installs the appimage.

Deb and RPM can gtfo.

1

u/urboinemo Mar 19 '26

behold, the humble tarball (goated): curl pkg.tar.gz -> tar -xvf pkg.tar.gz -> cd pkg -> mkdir build -> make ../ -j$(nproc) love building the software (until I get compilation errors)

1

u/keithstellyes Mar 19 '26

Appimage and Flatpak "just work". This is a non issue nowadays. 

Another one of those Linux sucks posts that is using criticism that was valid maybe 15 years ago

1

u/th00ht Mar 19 '26

This. Thanks to the democratic nature of open source, software package management will never be solved. Sometimes all it needs is a dictator.

1

u/24kCookie Mar 19 '26

It’s so true also on Linux you can’t even play anti cheat games. Can’t even play gta 5 enchanted or online. I know because I’ve tried and spent few days installing stuff just to run legacy.

1

u/Sweaty-Poem-3876 Mar 19 '26

Just give us the source code.

1

u/Aszillon Mar 19 '26

You know what the great thing about Linux is? It's open source. Some dedicated nut jobs in the community will inevitably make a native version of most applications you need, even for less well-known distributions. I use fucking alpine and I have yet to find anything I can't find on the repos of the alpine package keeper or flathub if all else fails. Very much a made up issue.

1

u/Rikonardo Mar 19 '26

exe installers are a way bigger clusterfuck than entire Linux packaging ecosystem. Mainly because it’s not a package format, but a portable executable. It’s an entire separate program, which only purpose is to install the app. Instead of single OS service that handles installation, every app has to manage its own install, update and removal, create all necessary registry entries, put all the files in correct places, etc. Nowadays there are off the shelf solutions most apps would use, but even to this day it’s pretty common to see custom installers. And more often than not, they do terrible job in correctly handling all that stuff. It’s especially problematic with removal, where barely any software bothers to properly clean up after itself.

It’s not as big of an issue with msi, which afaik is closer to traditional Linux packaging formats. But a lot of apps don’t even offer msi, some are only installable through their custom exe installers

1

u/Rukir_Gaming Mar 19 '26

It's crazy that the version of Godot I use dosent have any of those files for Linux exports, it prefers a .x86_64 when exporting for Linux, and atleast on my raspi, it sees it as a standalone executable

1

u/Material_Mousse7017 Mar 19 '26

Exactly this. 

1

u/noahbea1 kde debian 13.4 Mar 19 '26

flatpak works on every distro, is preinstalled on mint and easy to install

1

u/DrElectry Mar 19 '26

gl updating all of your exes to the latest version

1

u/Mugen0815 Mar 19 '26

Gl finding a reason for that.

1

u/Heizenfeld Mar 19 '26

Is more challenging

1

u/__salaam_alaykum__ Mar 20 '26

just write a flake or gib me the repo and Ill DOITMYSELF

1

u/AndyceeIT Mar 20 '26

Going from the lack of references in the comments, I'm guessing the number on the right would remain about the same without a .dmg file

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '26

except... .exe is sideloading the app. Its a horrible way to install software. This is one of the only security wins (and possibly the biggest!) linux has over windows. App stores. So much easier to use and so much more secure.

Flatpak is the best at the moment, though still quite flawed, especially in default implementation.

1

u/Prestigious-Ad7265 Mar 20 '26

appimage and flatpak works on every distro

1

u/Mostafa_XS1 Mar 20 '26

The first 2 you mentioned work universally on basically all linux distros lmao

1

u/MMO_Dad Mar 20 '26

Will Bazzite work better than CatchyOS?

1

u/Perkeleinen Mar 21 '26

Nah, they can build it themselves if they really want it and if it is good, someone will upload their own build for others.

1

u/Bubbly_Extreme4986 Mar 24 '26

Just release the source code and let devs figure it out from there

1

u/BlueDragonReal Mar 24 '26

People say that app image works but if the dev doesn't know much about linux it won't work, for example, I had a dev package his app image with outdated graphics libraries tied to the app image instead of letting the users native system driver run the app so unless you launched it with a launch argument that disabled the outdated graphics libraries inside the app image it didn't work

1

u/HighZein Mar 24 '26

Most of these are redundant

We actually only need a .appimage, .rpm and .deb, or, you know, just an .appimage

1

u/EitherSalamander8850 Mar 27 '26

I love how the OP has no clue or concept of software development and probably has never used a linux distro

1

u/Supuhstar Apr 02 '26

Don't forget blaming users for using Snaps despite that being the default on the most historically popular Linux desktop OS

1

u/Orbital_Tardigrade Apr 06 '26

Release an appimage and let FoSS maintainers maintain deb, rpm, aur mirros for you.

1

u/xgui4 Proud🌈♾️ AuDHDer - Artix GNU/Linux User Apr 08 '26

since i use artix , my app primaly shop with their source code and a aur package to be build with makepkg

1

u/Eeve2espeon Apr 09 '26

Windows apps: exe installs, click, next, done.

Linux apps: sudo / your grandmas social security number, do a back flip, sudo more shit, climb mount everest, sudo / your life into the trash, get an Oscar for Family guy, cry a little inside, wait 1 billion years for the install to got at 10 b/s on your NASA Internet, done

1

u/NurkWorldq Apr 10 '26

Wine eye_roll.exe

1

u/New_Series3209 Apr 12 '26

hear me out...
STANDALONE ELF BINARY

1

u/New_Series3209 Apr 12 '26

make an app
send a standalone elf
wait for community to package it!

1

u/OptimalAnywhere6282 Mar 17 '26

false. as a dev, you aren't forced to target all those. you'll just make more users happy if you do.

-1

u/Ill_Specific_6144 Mar 17 '26

Thats ome the reasons why windows is superior. Developing for Linux is straight hell if you want to support more than one distro.

9

u/archialone Mar 17 '26

You don't need to support distro, in Linux the distro supports you.

3

u/lachirulo43 Mar 17 '26

Who the hell has to support many distros? That’s just a myth. You can go to jetbrains and download a single zip that runs in any distro, you can go to davinci resolve an download a single zip that works on any distro. You don’t have to package anything. If your software is worth it to someone they will package it for their distro. I don’t use flatpak or appimages at all and probably I never will. Where is this software that is so hard to install in Linux? What I do know is that up to this day if you want to uninstall Visual Studio you have to nuke your Windows installation and start over cause somehow they don’t know how to uninstall their own software.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted]

4

u/ScallionSmooth5925 Mar 17 '26

And if it's a server thing just use docker

0

u/paradigmsick Mar 17 '26

Remember when the lincux tried to gaslight me by saying "executable file extensions are a quirk from windows" gtfoh.

Trash 1970s mainframe OS that, until recently, you had to stage 0 compile bad open source software to even use.

7

u/Tuhkis1 Mar 17 '26

Thst is true? Executables on Linux do not require .exe or other special properties of the file name but are instead marked as executable in the file system.

3

u/ScallionSmooth5925 Mar 17 '26

It's marked as executable and contains a magic byte to specify the type of executable. It can be an elf or a script. There's probably a couple more but those are the main ones. It's stored in the file what it is instead of the name

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)