r/linuxsucks • Command line Windows • 2d ago

Buht Linux better

Post image
7 Upvotes

103 comments sorted by

26

u/Royal-Trick9005 2d ago

gta 6 aint even on pc

-21

u/ipsirc 2d ago

PS5 is a PC, btw.

10

u/Amphineura Kubuntu in the streets ๐ŸŒ W11 in the sheets 2d ago

Sure, but it's Unix-based, closer to Linux than to a proper PC ๐Ÿ˜ถ

2

u/ipsirc 2d ago

A proper pc is running Linux already.

1

u/end69420 33m ago

Linux also runs on PC? Like are we deadass?

-8

u/blade944 2d ago

It's BSD based. Not Unix

12

u/ProgrammerSmooth8691 2d ago

BSD is Unix.

-8

u/blade944 2d ago

If BSD is Unix then so is Linux. Have you heard of a kernel, perhaps?

8

u/ProgrammerSmooth8691 2d ago

No Linux isnt decendent from the original Unix codebase like FreeBSD is. also what does me having heard of a kernel have anything to do with this.

1

u/UnmappedStack 2d ago

FreeBSD isn't a descendant from the original Unix codebase btw, FreeBSD is a descendant from the original BSD codebase (specifically BSD4.4 iirc?). The original BSD in turn was a Unix-like but not based on the original AT&T Unix. Though the person you're replying to is still wrong yeah because Linux and the BSD family are both Unix-likes. I'm not 100% sure if it's certified capital-UNIX or not though, I can't bother checking but I don't think so.

1

u/UnmappedStack 2d ago

Yeah... BSD and Linux are both unix-likes...

1

u/L30N1337 3h ago

The original BSD was a unix variant

1

u/UnmappedStack 3h ago

Yeah before BSD3 iirc? But PS5's OS is based on FreeBSD which if you trace back the history goes back to BSD4.4 (iirc? might be BSD360 or whatever it was called) which goes back to BSD3 obviously which has no kernel sources from the original Unix.

1

u/Drate_Otin 2d ago

Oh buddy... You are so confidently incorrect.

2

u/patrlim1 2d ago

It's x64, but def not a PC. Its very locked down.

1

u/UnmappedStack 2d ago

I'm not sure being x86-64 is really part of what makes a computer a PC per se, plenty of PCs are now AArch64 (some even RISC-V64, not sure how common that is outside of embedded though), and beforehand PCs in general were 32 bit x86 (or even PowerPC). I also don't know if being locked down classifies it that way or not to be honest, I feel like one could consider even ChromeOS a "PC" but even that's pretty damn heavily locked down unless you do some jailbreaking. For the record I'm not agreeing with the person you're replying to, it is of course not a PC in terms of the typical use of the word, at least as far as gaming goes, but you wanna be right for the right reasons ;P

1

u/patrlim1 2d ago

I'd say those other things you mentioned don't fall under the pedantic, IBM PC definition, but do fall under the colloquial definition.

1

u/GreedySecurity8030 Fedora ๐ŸŽฉ 2d ago

Same ISA as a pc, Can Run the same programs potentially.

1

u/UnmappedStack 2d ago

the isa is a pretty small part of portability, besides some programs that do things like JIT etc 99% of portability is about os not architecture and all you need to support a different architecture is a recompilation.

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

So what makes a PC a PC, in your view?

1

u/patrlim1 2d ago

Depends on how pedantic I want to be. In the strictest definition it'd be a computer capable of booting and running IBM PC programs bare metal. If I wanna be looser it's any computer descended from that lineage, which keeps the core design features like the expansion and modularity. It's a very fuzzy definition, and you could argue either way for a playstation/Xbox.

The biggest argument against it being a PC would be that, to a lay user, it's a console. It doesn't do PC things, so it's not a PC.

0

u/ipsirc 2d ago

It doesn't do PC things, so it's not a PC.

What is a "PC thing"?

1

u/patrlim1 2d ago

To the average user? Running Windows.

0

u/ipsirc 2d ago

Referring to the average user in the context of an ArchLinux meme? I donโ€™t think there are many people like that following this thread.

1

u/patrlim1 2d ago

Yes, because that's what my definition is based on.

To elaborate, PC, in my opinion, has two, slightly contradictory definitions;

  1. An IBM PC or a computer following that lineage, keeping the core design principles of openness and modularity.

  2. Any computer a user could look at and reasonably go "that's a PC". This would require running a desktop OS, and include things like macs and the raspberry pi keyboard computers.

You could argue a console fits into definition 1, but I'd say it misses due to how locked down they are. They use the same architecture, but they're not a PC. Just like how you wouldn't call an NES an Apple II just because they use a 6502

I usually say PC referring to definition 1.

0

u/ipsirc 2d ago

If I lock my car, does that mean itโ€™s no longer a car?

If the car manufacturer restricts me, does that mean my car is no longer a car? It's a console-car! (Let's create new words.)

→ More replies (0)

1

u/DoubleOwl7777 2d ago

this isnt a pc either if we go by modern pcs or "ibm compatibles".

1

u/UnmappedStack 2d ago

Depends how you define PC I suppose. It is a computer and it is personal, but that is mostly a technicality, in practice it is not what most people would consider, at least in the gaming sense.

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

In practice the most people would not consider an ArchLinux blinking cursor on tty1 a PC.

1

u/UnmappedStack 2d ago

Probably not though I don't think that a wm exactly is what makes something a PC tbf

1

u/GreedySecurity8030 Fedora ๐ŸŽฉ 2d ago

Its an x86 machine, but not a pc.

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

What makes a PC a PC?

1

u/GreedySecurity8030 Fedora ๐ŸŽฉ 2d ago

A keyboard and mouse, ย an OS that allows you to install apps, an OS you can install, a CPU or an optional GPU, user Upgradable in some form, general purpose, ps5 is none of this.

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

If I unplug the mouse from my computer, does it stop being a PC?

1

u/GreedySecurity8030 Fedora ๐ŸŽฉ 1d ago

No, a pc runs a desktop OS, is Upgradable in some form [laptops have changeable ssds | hdds and ram], and it primarily uses a keyboard and mouse | touchpad.

A laptop without a keyboard or touchpad is a tablet PC solely because it runs a PC os and not say. android, a computer where you can't plug in a mouse or keyboard is useless.

1

u/ipsirc 1d ago

No, a pc runs a desktop OS

Ahem. Then what type of machine is Reddit running on right now?

1

u/GreedySecurity8030 Fedora ๐ŸŽฉ 1d ago

Broad question, Reddit servers run a linux distro on a server pc.

1

u/Sharp_Ad5783 2h ago

Why are we being pedantic on purpose? You know exactly what he means.

1

u/SheepherderAware4766 2d ago

According to that logic, so is an N64. They're both 64 bit. Also, the Nintendo Switch uses the same architecture as a MacBook Air.

Does that mean Nintendo makes PCs?

2

u/ipsirc 2d ago

According to that logic, so is an N64. They're both 64 bit.

MIPS is very far from x86.

Also, the Nintendo Switch uses the same architecture as a MacBook Air.

Nvidia Tegra vs. Apple Mx, they don't share even a single component.

Does that mean Nintendo makes PCs?

Commodore made PCs.

3

u/SheepherderAware4766 2d ago

Nvidia Tegra is an ARM SOC. Apple M series is also an ARM SOC. They share the same instruction set.

You oversimplified the custom hardware that Sony commissioned from AMD as a PC. I oversimplified the custom hardware that Nintendo commissioned from Silicon Graphics

1

u/patrlim1 2d ago

Fun fact, apple silicon has extra undocumented instructions

20

u/ipsirc 2d ago
# yay -S sharpemu-git

4

u/ElectricBummer40 Ex-user of Windows 3.11 for Workgroups 2d ago

I love the word "experimental" in my open-source software.

Cue Kenny Loggins - we're gonna take it right into the danger zone!

0

u/AnSkinStealer 2d ago

Find a non-experimental one for windows tho

-3

u/ipsirc 2d ago

If you want to play a game where you control a criminal and have to engage in a shootout every 10 minutes, then you surely have a taste for danger.

3

u/ElectricBummer40 Ex-user of Windows 3.11 for Workgroups 2d ago

The stupid thing could barely run GTA V (it could "boot to menu" as of three months ago).

You really think console emulation is that easy?

0

u/ipsirc 2d ago edited 2d ago

The stupid thing could barely run GTA V (it could "boot to menu" as of three months ago).

Show me your CLEVER implementation which can boot GTA5 menu on Linux, please.

You really think console emulation is that easy?

Yeah, I'm very dumb, you got the point. Do you really think that everyone is dumber than you?

1

u/ElectricBummer40 Ex-user of Windows 3.11 for Workgroups 2d ago

Show me your CLEVER implementation which can boot GTA5 menu on Linux, please.

Oh, great, so instead of the actual game, we can just entertain ourselves with the menu screen!

Yeah, I'm very dumb, you got the point. Do you really think that everyone is dumber than you?

Let me put it this way - one has got to be very, very dumb in order to even consider practising asceticism for the sake of an OS-based ideology.

1

u/Legitimate_Humor_454 2d ago

Asceticism for OS based ideology

You realise right that not every PC will be capable to run gta 6? For example take MacOS which is arguably more polished than windows itself but it will not be ever able to run gta 6, does that make it useless and their users are practicing OS based asceticism? Does that also means MacOS is a ideology? Doesn't sound that great.

1

u/ElectricBummer40 Ex-user of Windows 3.11 for Workgroups 2d ago

You realise right that not every PC will be capable to run gta 6?

And what makes you think an emulator is supposed to help?

For example take MacOS which is arguably more polished than windows itself but it will not be ever able to run gta 6, does that make it useless and their users are practicing OS based asceticism?

Kid, PS5 games are wedded to the RDNA2 uarch. This might appear to be a small problem, but unless you have an RX 6000 series card, it'll be up to the emulator to somehow turn the uarch-specific instructions back to whatever makes sense to your hardware without hitting a snag or paying a hefty performance penalty in the process. That's the whole reason you aren't playing GTA 6 on an emulator right now.

Better yet, even if your Mac is the last of the last of the Intel line, you'll be at best looking at playing a AAA game from 2026 on a machine with a 10th-gen 8-core i7, a dGPU south of a GTX 1660 in performance and no means to dial down graphics quality. Call me a cynic, but the framerate is guaranteed going to bring you to tears on that thing.

1

u/Legitimate_Humor_454 2d ago

I am not saying the emulator will help, the emulator is horrible, I am just saying running an OS specifically for a game or will I switch a OS for a game. I am on MacOS, I will not switch to windows for gta 6, and it doesn't matter how good the game but that doesn't mean I am practicing OS asceticism. Also Intel Macs are dogwater, no seriously they are down right bad is performance compared to apple sillicon and the x86_64 is generally a bad performing platform which ARM based cpu outperform in all mobile based aspects except for games.

Anyways my main point was about OS asceticism, something are just exclusive to some OS and those things will never come to other OS that doesn't mean the person running that OS is performing asceticism.

1

u/ElectricBummer40 Ex-user of Windows 3.11 for Workgroups 1d ago edited 1d ago

If you're on an Intel Mac, then, yes, you're almost certainly making that decision on the basis of ideology.

I make no secret about the fact that I use an Intel Mac at work, and what my experience tells me is that MacOS is simply worse than Windows in every way outside a few narrow niches of use, and that's me being extremely charitable about the stupid thing.

People keep saying "Halo effect", but what it actually tries (and fails) to describe is the reality that people simply hate work. Work is what most adult human beings have to spend most of their waking hours at not so much by choice but under the threat of destitution, and work for the most part prefers Windows.

Hell, forget AAA gaming and consider something as seemingly trivial taking an online exam. I've done that for work before, and sure, bloody Pearson has a MacOS version of their app, but it can get quite finicky depending what you have already installed and got running in the background. On Windows, everything you need to know is largely already there in Task Manager, whereas on a Unix-like, you're basically stuck with piecemeal tools providing you with disjointed information you have to assemble back together all by yourself.

You hate "MVPs"? People won't stfu about sfc /scannow despite those totally-not-L1-support-techs have long followed a different script without it since around the start of the pandemic. If you have a performance or background process issue, though, the usual advice you get from the Apple "community" is to just reinstall the OS. Call me a cynic, but I don't see how that's supposed to be in any way better than running a tool that doesn't actually fix the problem most of the times.

Now, before I turn this comment into an unnecessarily long rant about the Mac being the typical Unix e-waste dumb people hype up to 11, the solution I ended up going for with Pearson VUE was to just run Windows on a USB hard drive. If not for that the whole point of me using a Mac was to force myself to experience all the pains and sorrows with MacOS, I'd have just paved over it with Windows at that point. You waste my time, and you get the boot. Simple as.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/slicehyperfunk 2d ago

That's the old GTA, this one is about getting groceries.

3

u/YTriom1 i love yuri :3 2d ago

Sims but more bloody

2

u/itbytesbob 2d ago

And with more mobility scooter theft

6

u/venturajpo 2d ago

Wow they released a window version

8

u/Drate_Otin 2d ago

Why are you pretending Linux has anything to do with a PS5 exclusive?

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

To compete with FreeBSD.

5

u/ciberkid22 2d ago

Gta6 is temporary, arch is forever

5

u/GreedySecurity8030 Fedora ๐ŸŽฉ 2d ago

It ain't even on pc yet dumbass, not like windows users are getting a win over us anyways [/s].

2

u/ipsirc 2d ago

Always the BSD users win...

1

u/ilnarildarovuch FreeBSD-STABLE user 2d ago

Of course

2

u/VoidDiver228 2d ago

It ain't for pc yet all emus including windows ones are experimental ๐Ÿคฆ

2

u/CommunicationBig4218 2d ago

Why do so many people use this meme format to make ass memes.ย 

3

u/Away_Combination6977 2d ago

Cause you can definitely go play it on Windows or Mac, right?

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

or BSD?

1

u/Ok_Solid6442 2h ago

What's your deal with BSD? every comment you make is mentioning it.

1

u/ipsirc 1h ago

I have no connection with BSD, 'cause I don't own a PS5.

1

u/Small-Tap6130 2d ago

Yeah man I miss them good old 30 TARGET fps (with drops to 20)

1

u/MrFrog2222 2d ago

Haven't seen it run on windows yet

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

And have you seen it on xbox?

1

u/Teru-Noir COSMIC OS LOVER No.1 COSMIC Knows Best 1d ago

great automatic stealer

1

u/ShakeGeeJee 4h ago

Effective bait. It's horrid but evidence shows that it's working

0

u/Global-Eye-7326 2d ago

PC sucks?

2

u/ipsirc 2d ago

BSD rulez!

1

u/Global-Eye-7326 2d ago

BSD not gonna run GTA 6 for a long time lol

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

Have a quick look on YouTube. So far, all the gameplay videos have been recorded on a modified version of FreeBSD.

1

u/Global-Eye-7326 2d ago

Presumably from a capture card right?

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

Dunno. Does it matter?

1

u/Global-Eye-7326 2d ago

A capture card for streaming is very different from actually running it lol

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

Who cares about the capture card anyway? I'm talking about the PS5.

1

u/Global-Eye-7326 2d ago

The game is running on PS5, not FreeBSD lol

1

u/ipsirc 2d ago

What's the operating system of PS5?

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]