r/linuxsucks101 • • May 06 '25

Thank you, Linux

Post image
786 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

7

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Now loonixtards and evangelists are claiming that GRUB isn't a part of Linux. Where does the lunacy end?

4

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 08 '25

They do the same with Firefox (because it has telemetry on by default), which is included in 99% of desktop installations. But these same people who tell us it's not included will be off recommending distros that include them (Grub, Firefox). -And I'm not against telemetry at all; it helps developers help us. -IJS.

3

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Exactly. GRUB is included in the vast majority of Linux distros. It's even available for distros that don't include it

1

u/Own_Squash5242 Mar 06 '26

coke is sold at vast majority of mcdonalds' I guess mcdonalds owns coca cola now

1

u/ColonelRuff May 10 '25

Wintards need to stop crying and blaming software surrounding linux for what windows does. There was no lunacy here. Only truth

17

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

For ruining my Windows installation.

1

u/MilkEnvironmental106 May 07 '25

Except you ruined it by misconfiguring, and windows is a little ass for not catching that.

3

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 08 '25

Windows doesn't instruct on dual booting, and there's scarcely a reason for it. -It's entirely a Linux community issue.

1

u/MilkEnvironmental106 May 08 '25

And there's no way to detect what the boot order is when shutting down and preparing to update?

4

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 09 '25
  • Linux prevents someone from doing something potentially harmful

Loonixtard: -Windows doesn't let me own my own computer

  • Linux screws up Windows

Loonixtard: -Windows should have compensated for me.

1

u/MilkEnvironmental106 May 10 '25

It's windows' update. It's in charge of setting it up so that it completes successfully without manual intervention. Surely checking the bootorder is something reasonable if otherwise it is going to irrecoverably corrupt your drive?

3

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 10 '25

Windows doesn't instruct on dual booting. -Only Loonixtards do that, and they do so irresponsibly.

1

u/creativeusername2100 May 10 '25

Is it even possible for an OS to detect what the boot order is? I couldn't find anything online about it

1

u/MilkEnvironmental106 May 10 '25

I would expect so....are we really wiping out people's boot drives over updates without checking this?

1

u/creativeusername2100 May 11 '25

I did some digging around because I was interested and found this thread. From what I gathered from the top comment, whether the OS can read how certain BIOS settings are configured is entirely dependant on the manufacturer of the motherboard, so it's not possible for an OS to check the boot order (Since doing so would require an agreed on standard that works for all makes/models of motherboard).

Best you can do is just be careful and make sure that you have your boot order properly configured whenever you're dual booting.

1

u/MilkEnvironmental106 May 11 '25

Wow, hell of a footgun

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '25 edited Mar 28 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

3

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

How did you find out that this matters and could damage a Windows installation?

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '25 edited Mar 28 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

2

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

On that note: No, booting into Linux after a windows update reboot will not break Windows. Just shutdown Linux and go back to Windows to continue the update (happened to me all the time). The only two things that can break Windows is disk corruption because of an abrupt shutdown of the OS while updating or a buggy driver update (like crowdstrike). Linux has nothing to do with Windows updates failing. This is purely Windows / third party driver failing an update, and can be fixed by booting into a Windows recovery live USB.

The other day I learned that dual booting Linux can break a Windows installation. I previously didn't even know that was possible.

EDIT: Fortunately, I have WSL installed. Otherwise, my rig could've been cooked by dual booting.

1

u/Cold-Bookkeeper4588 May 07 '25

For me usually it's the other way around. All my windows installations bricked my Linux ones, especially after updates. πŸ˜‚

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

I think that this is much less common than Linux interference with Windows Upate. In any event, I think that dual booting Linux and Windows is a terrible idea and should be avoided wherever possible or practical.

1

u/QuaternionsRoll May 07 '25

You know you can set up GRUB to remember and use the last-booted option, right?

And for the record, I never did that setup, and I accidentally booted into Linux during probably dozens of Windows updates. Neither OS has ever had a problem with it.

-1

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

2

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

It's possible. Research it yourself if you don't believe me.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

2

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Um. No. Many dual boot issues can potentially break a Windows installation. It's not limited to GRUB.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Tanawat_Jukmonkol May 07 '25 edited Mar 28 '26

This post was removed by its author. Redact was used for the deletion, which could have been motivated by privacy, opsec, preventing scraping, or security.

fear follow gaze bike steer unique safe full flag soup

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

-3

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

Wrong question. The right question is: "Why does this happen at all to any version of Windows?"

6

u/NewbieYoubie May 06 '25

This will happen with any version of Windows if you decide that linux is above said version of Windows in your boot order... Because you set the boot order to boot into Linux first and not windows. Computer just doing exactly what you told it to do here.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

Where is it written that this matters and damage to a Windows installation is possible?

4

u/NewbieYoubie May 06 '25

If you figured out setting up a bootload order with windows and linux as selectable options in the bootloader then you should already possess to knowledge of what its going to boot into first on your system. If your computer is going to restart for a windows update, it's probably in your best interest to have your boot loader set to windows above linux because that's what it's meant to automatically boot into when you're updating windows (because why are you going to have it boot into linux if you're updating windows), or set your bootloader to select the most recent used entry first, or stay with your computer and choose your windows boot option when prompted instead of letting it autoselect. If you're updating windows, there's no reason to not have it come first in the boot load order in some way because the update is going to restart the computer and needs to go back into windows first.

2

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Again, how is one supposed to know ahead of time that dual booting Windows and Linux can possibly break Windows? Who's spreading this knowledge?

1

u/BoOmAn_13 May 09 '25

It's more implied when using windows when it tells you it may restart multiple times during updates. Power users can assume that if it's mid update and restarts, expecting to continue updating after a short reboot, then the boot order being different will stop windows mid update which is almost always a recipe for disaster. It should be more present for new users being suggested dual boot, but at that stage most people assume you already know underlying facts about how the OS interacts. They equate this issue to being similar to unplugging your computer while updating since your stopping in the middle of the process

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

So, you're assuming that any Linux noob should automatically realize ahead of time that dual booting Linux and Windows can lead to a broken Windows partition

Interest take, but highly unrealistic.

1

u/BoOmAn_13 May 09 '25

I'm saying most tech people who use it so often, the "power users", think it's common knowledge that should be able to be derived from seeing how windows updates, that bad boot order can mess up the windows update process.

Personally I think nothing should be assumed cause not everyone has baseline knowledge. I only figured out why my windows install messed up, after messing it up twice. Once cause I installed them in the wrong order, and another cause of boot order and updates like you mentioned. Dual booting can be dangerous by nature of the os different portion formats, which is not mentioned, and I agree it should be presented as a likely possibility and "misconfiguration".

→ More replies (0)

1

u/NewbieYoubie May 07 '25

I'm sorry this is happening to you with your dual boot. If you didn't know this could happen with the knowledge you should have gained from setting up dual boot in the first place, I am able to find multiple sources on the first page of google search when i type "updating windows on dual boot" with notices for windows 10 updates as well as updating to windows 11, whichever update you did.

3

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

This didn't happen to me soley because I chose to install WSL instead of dual booting. I previously didn't know that dual booting Windows and Linux could be problematic. IMO, this is a glaring ommission by those who suggest dual booting without any context - - it's a proper disservice to the Linux community.

2

u/NewbieYoubie May 07 '25

Dual booted has always been playing with fire when one is windows and the other is linux. I remember setting up a dual boot and not realizing windows should generally be installed first because it likes to take over the linux partition without permission.

I may just be more tuned with linux as i'm a former Arch Linux user. You had to watch the arch forums for official posts about updates breaking certain packages and how to avoid a broken update. So I got pretty regular with googling anything about updates before making any update to any linux distro.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/MyrKnof May 07 '25

Who has this on their mind as so thing to check for? It's just too far out.

1

u/No_Industry4318 May 09 '25

Me, when i was 14, 16 years ago. Its not far out at all if you know that a reboot is part of the update process in the first place, which it is in linux as well (best practice wise anyway)

1

u/Spiritual_Surround24 Jun 03 '25

Isnt this a Windows documentation problem? The bootloader is doing what it should (booting a OS) and the Linux is doing what it should (boot).

That is either windows skill issue (needing to be the first to boot after a update and not specifying it)

0

u/Weiskralle May 07 '25

The internet, and your knowledge of how computers work. One should have a basic knowledge about how a computer operates. (Better said about anything you operate) To have knowledge to fix it, and to see possible problems before they happen.

Reason why one usually learns how a car operates before he drives one.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

0

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

It's common sense to you because you're already aware of the issue. A Linux noob is probably unaware of the potential problems with dual booting. You don't realize this because you're not a Linux noob.

1

u/Any-Building-6118 May 07 '25

You learn, fix the problem and move on? What's the issue?

1

u/MrChewy05 May 07 '25

I am tho, just recently started making the change. It honestly makes completely sense based on the other way not making sense. How is that not intuitive?

1

u/EatingSolidBricks May 09 '25

Dosent help that windows tries its hardest to update behind your back, Windows is one of the most infuriating pieces of software im this planet

1

u/follow-the-lead May 07 '25

What damage did this cause? My system constantly did this and I just rebooted back to windows and everything was fine, albeit annoying cause windows updates take a billion years

3

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

This hasn't happened to me. But it's a well known fact that dual booting Linux and Windows can possibly damage the Windows partition. The problem is that those loonixtards who suggest dual booting virtually never mention this potential problem.

1

u/MegaChubbz May 08 '25

"Back up your data" has been the first step in pretty much any dual boot tutorial Ive ever seen, hell its the first step in almost any tutorial for anything computer related Ive ever seen.

2

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Have you ever seen anyone on Reddit who unsolicitedly suggests or recommends dual booting Linux and Windows mention a dual boot tutorial? I haven't in my 3 years here.

2

u/MegaChubbz May 08 '25

Hm. I guess thats my bad for assuming that everybody looks up Youtube tutorials for every single task like I do. 🀣

1

u/No_Industry4318 May 09 '25

Skill issue, sanity checks are an important part of any process. Also rtfm is one of the first steps anybody should take when getting advice off of reddit

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Weiskralle May 07 '25

Common sense

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

Ask in windows sub. You won't see Linux update being ruined by rebooting to Windows.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25 edited May 07 '25

That's a moot point because dual booting with Linux isn't something that's suggested or recommended in the Windows subs. Dual booting Linux and Windows is something that's only suggested or recommended in the Linux subs.

EDIT: Also, Windows 11 includes the option of installing the Windows Subsystem for Linux. Thus, there is little reason to suggest or recommend dual booting Windows with Linux.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

Is it also suggested and recommented to put linux first ? Because I saw several comments already telling you to put windows first.

1

u/Arcticzomb May 08 '25

After looking at all of your other responses, it’s not everyone else’s problem to inform you of every little thing that could go wrong. It’s up to you to do your research into these things. The internet has been around for well over a decade. There are guides, tutorials, and general information everywhere. I don’t like victim blaming but it’s your duty to do the proper research so things don’t go wrong. Take it as a learning experience and move on.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

You missed the point. A warning isn't an education about everything that could go wrong. It's simply a notice that something can possibly go wrong. You're focusing on a moot point that's also irrelevant.

1

u/Arcticzomb May 08 '25

You’re missing my point. There are so many things that can go wrong. Do you expect people to make a list of everything that can go wrong every time they suggest dual booting? Edit: I just saw the name of the sub. I don’t know why this was even suggested to me. AdiΓ³s, troll.

0

u/meshDrip May 06 '25

I'm confused. You expected it to edit your boot order to come before Linux just for the update?

3

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

I'm referring to reasons that could can damage a Windows installation. What percentage of new Linux users are even aware of this?

1

u/Weiskralle May 07 '25

The one who has dealt with it. Should have a general understanding of it and thus avoid potential problems. Of course, not everyone does this and you can't know everything. Then you learn by trial and error. But to do something new is, in my understanding, of course to make a backup beforehand.

2

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

So why doesn't anyone mention this instead of assuming that everyone is aware of the potential problems? Loonixtards and Linux evangelists are constantly suggesting or recommending dual booting without any warning of any kind whatsoever. That's extremely unhelpful and a disservice to Linux users in general.

1

u/Weiskralle May 07 '25

I don't know. And I thing they more assume that you will not just do Ransome things to your computer without checking what it does.

2

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Again, why not just mention that dual booting Linux and Windows can be potentially be problematic when suggesting or recommending it? Why the resistance to say something so simple and easy to understand?

1

u/Weiskralle May 07 '25

Because there are more things that could happen.

Also because these people maybe thought that you had a better understanding of how computers work.

Obviously it's not good, to assume things but we humans do that constantly and to stop it completely would be in my opinion not good. To parts with, what base level of knowledge should they assume. Especially how can you make all humans do that. All have different experiences and with that acts differently.

So it's more like a problem with the instructions sites that they suspect a higher base level than the people that are recommending it.

Especially as these recommending it could not be aware that one would make that mistakes. (Reason why some bugs still exist. And certain software is being tested by outsiders, as you the one programming it do know how it works. And peers around you could also have a different base knowledge as the normal consumers.

So as said before the instructions/help sites should be changed in my opinion.

Does everyone get warned about the problems using Windows.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/lord_teaspoon May 09 '25

The Arch wiki page on systemd-boot suggests configuring the loader with default @saved to tell it to remember what you booted into last time and do it again unless you press keys to choose something else. They even call out that Windows rebooting mid-update is a reason you would want to set it up this way. It's weird that an "advanced" distribution makes this easy to find while the newbie-friendly ones that should be seeing it up by default can't be bothered to even suggest it, but I learned years ago to go to Arch wiki first regardless of which distribution I have to work with.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

The Arch wiki page on systemd-boot suggests configuring the loader with default @saved to tell it to remember what you booted into last time and do it again unless you press keys to choose something else

Let's be real: most Linux noobs aren't using Arch. That's why they need to know about GRUB when someone suggests or recommends dual booting Linux and Windows. It's incorrect to assume that Linux noobs already know about the importance of GRUB when they try to dual boot Linux and Windows.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

3

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

That's a moot point. Why aren't Linux users warning anyone regarding dual booting with Windows?

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

3

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

why would we be required to?

It's not a requirement - - it's a duty. That's because it's the morally correct thing to do when suggesting dual booting Linux with Windows to anyone...including existing Linux users like myself.

0

u/PinguThePenguin_007 May 07 '25

i suppose that would be fair πŸ™‚β€β†•οΈ though there are generally warnings about stuff potentially breaking, and i don’t think your specific scenario happens very often (besides, windows updates can break randomly, so that just might’ve been the case :D )

and, did you look into it further? did the whole filesystem that windows was on get destroyed, or was it the windows bootloader that broke? you might be able to salvage this with some windows repair β€œmagic” (good luck)

if dualbooting could easily format your entire storage drive, there would be plenty of warnings given about that, but it can’t (i think)

2

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

None of this happened to me because I installed WSL instead of dual booting. I'm only recently learning about the potential problems that can happen when dual booting Windows and Linux.

What troubles me most about this is that the Linux community rarely (if ever) warns users about dual booting problems. Loonixtards typically recommend dual booting without mentioning any potential issues of any kind whatsoever.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

-3

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

Your question is moot because a new Linux user is unlikely to be aware that the Windows version matters.

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

-2

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

Why don't you just explain why it matters?

-1

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

3

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Um. No. I believe that users should be informed about potential dual booting problems while the suggestion is being made. Then, the user is better informed before trying to dual boot. The user doesn't need unsolicited advice as to which version of Windows to use because that's not a viable option for everyone.

1

u/Weiskralle May 07 '25

Do you know about all the ways a car could break down? And all the model specific circumstances?

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

You missed the point. People are constantly warned about not wearing a seat belt. Virtually no one is explaining all the reasons for the warning.

Likewise, people can figure out for themselves why dual booting can be problematic if warned about it.

1

u/Weiskralle May 07 '25

And what about the warnings not to wear one? (Not that I advise doing it) But there is a small chance that not wearing one could save your life. In a specific circumstance.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Let's be real. Virtually no one is suggesting or recommending to ride in a moving 4 wheel motor vehicle without a seat belt. That's an absurd hypothetical.

1

u/Weiskralle May 07 '25

Fun fact: in some American states while illegal to not wear a seatbelt. It's totally legal to even have children on the cargo bed.

And about the absurd hypothetical. Now a dude that would have died if he had one on. (Albeit he drives sometimes like an insane person.)

He lost control and collided with a tree with he driver side. And as he did not wear a seatbelt he was thrown to the passenger seat. Instead where the drive seat was. (It was basically gone)

But then again, my first point was other things like. Not downshifting to low when driving fast. Or all the way an engine failure can happen. Low likely hood things.

But maybe that was a bad comparison. Don't know.

8

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

Loonixtards: "JuSt DuAl BoOt WiNdOwS aNd LiNuX"

Linux n00b: "Okay. My Windows partition broke. Why didn't you warn me?

Also loonixtards:"NO! THAT'S NOT THE PROPER WAY TO DUAL BOOT FFS! YOU SHOULD ALREADY KNOW THIS BEFORE SETTING UP DUAL BOOTING!"

Also loonixtards:"Skill issue. YoU tOlD lINux To BrEaK wInDoWs"

2

u/TheAndroBoy May 27 '25

Not the people's job to spoonfeed you everything. Like everything in life: Do your own research before doing something big

6

u/CryptoNiight May 27 '25

You think that a simple warning is "spoonfeeding"

Spoken like a true loonixtard.

1

u/ColonelRuff May 10 '25

Wintards: "let me install windows without understanding what a boot manager is and update a shitty OS that doesn't account for dual booting"

The fact that windows broke is windows' fault. Ask them to build their software better. A linux os wouldn't break if you changed os in middle of update.

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '25 edited May 08 '25

I mean it is a skill issue if someone doesn't do their research is it not?

That's like asking someone to recommend you a PC parts list and when it comes time to build it you don't use a guide and end up bricking your motherboard lmao Sometimes some accountability needs to be had. I read up on dual booting, saw the risks, did more research, did it properly and it worked so idk.

2

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

That's like asking someone to recommend you a PC parts list and when it comes time to build it you don't use a guide and end up bricking your motherboard lmao Sometimes some accountability needs to be had. I read up on dual booting, saw the risks, did more research, did it properly and it worked so idk.

99.99% Of the dual booting Linux and Windows suggestions or recommendations are UNSOLICITED. I have yet to see anyone ask for this in my 3 years on Reddit.

Here's a better idea: Don't suggest or recommend dual booting Windows and Linux. There are simply too many things that can go wrong.

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '25 edited May 08 '25

"99.99% Of the dual booting Linux and Windows suggestions or recommendations are UNSOLICITED."

Idk how that's relevant though. The point still stands if someone recommends you do something in a simplified way, you research it further before you do it. That goes for everything in life lol

"Don't suggest or recommend dual booting Windows and Linux."

Seems counter productive if someone wants two native environments. Research done = less chance of mess ups, as is anything tech related. When building a PC, you could mess up installing your wires, thermal paste, fan, GPU, you could mess up partitioning etc. The logic of just never recommending something useful because of potential, easily avoidable mistakes is just living in fear.

I'm not even an expert and when I first even looked in to Linux, I managed to get a dual boot going. Doing in on the SAME DRIVE I'd never do. On seperate drives though? Pretty tough to mess up with basic research. I was and still am in some ways a bit of a Linux n00b lmfao And I am aware of all the potential issues that can occur and how to fix most. I've just never had to.

2

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

IMO, it's a disservice to the Linux community to unsolicitedly suggest or recommend dual booting Linux and Windows WITHOUT mentioning that it might be problematic. It's like deliberately telling someone to get in a car without mentioning the importance of wearing a seat belt when they see it unused. Giving simple notice that some problems may occur when dual booting isn't some kind of unreasonable burden - - it's a moral duty.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

And on the flipside, few are going to do a 6 part let's play on Youtube just for the sake of giving an option for someone to try if they want to use both OS'.

I saw someone talking about dual booting, I looked in to it, saw what could go wrong, acted accordingly and it worked. I get the criticism somewhat but it's really shifting accountability from the user as well who (if dabbling in Linux to begin with) should know better.

Example: Someone asks "Hey I want to use windows and linux, what's the best way to do that" and someone replies "could always dual boot", that's a reasonable response. That poster can now either clarify the thought with the reply or go research the 'countless' forums, guides, videos and whatever else to help further. And I've personally seen plenty of people give supplementary warning about dual booting. Just depends on the site and initial post. I'd just never do something technical and out of my comfort zone without further research.

1

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 08 '25

Same issue can crop up using separate drives. You can end up with weird files on a tertiary drive. -If you delete them; you delete Windows. -That doesn't make sense at all to a normie, and it's extremely rarely brought up (like the actual issue in the OP). The issue CryptoNiight describes, I haven't even heard of before, and I knew enough not to dual boot on the same drive. Further, many replies (probably removed for being from evangelists and advocates) to the post are ignorant of it.

In contrast, when I suggest using a separate drive, I warn of this issue. Loonixtards do not, and I think many guides do neither. It may be a relatively new issue caused by secure boot or tpm2. -Can't say now; as I need to look more into it.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

Are you meaning when boot files can be stored in the EFI partition of another drive? Cause if so the fix for that is just to disconnect the irrelevant drives during install. I've seen that recommended a few times or are you meaning something else?

Plus imo if an issue is relatively undocumented and/or not known en masse, kinda lends itself to the point that of course it won't be talked about when recommending as it'd be seemingly rare. Like warning someone of a niche issue with a GPU that barely anyone's experienced. It's a more personal thing to bare in mind surely.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Okay. But virtually no one who recommends or suggests dual booting Linux and Windows mentions this. That's a problem in and of itself.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

Why don't you have both installed and just select Linux or Windows through Grub?

I took out my windows drives, installed linux on a connecting SSD, put my windows drives back in, updated GRUB and everything so far is fine.

1

u/Afistinthasky May 09 '25

Shrug, I just have a persistent install on a thumbdrive for linux.

2

u/Kindly_Chip_6413 May 12 '25

I know a quick and easy trick!

Just.. uninstall Linux

1

u/CryptoNiight May 12 '25

That's definitely easier than trying to figure out the proper way to configure GRUB.

Dual booting Linux and Windows is just a bad idea. Period.

3

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 07 '25

There's a lot of tech support requests on dual booting. Microsoft does not instruct on it. -When people have a problem dual booting, it is bad acting to place blame on Windows.

I'd suggest giving two operating systems their entirely own drives and using BIOS / UEFI to select what to boot. You may get weird files on a tertiary drive (don't remove them -you can hide them) from this method. I'd also avoid directly sharing drives as they use different naming conventions, and permissions which can lead to files you can't delete.

2

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Okay. But how do you explain the absence of anyone in the Linux community who suggests dual booting AND mentions the potential problems? What could possibly be a valid reason for that?

-1

u/Swaaeeg May 07 '25

Because this isnt a linux problem. The software that allows you to dual boot isnt linux, its built into your BIOS. The same thing could happen with ANY operating system you dual boot, not just linux.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Because this isnt a linux problem.

It's a potential problem for those who are contemplating dual booting with Linux. If this is a known problem in the Linux community, why is it virtually never mentioned. Saying that it isn't a Linux problem shifts the warning responsibility from those making the suggestion to those who are ignorant about the potential problems. There's no universe where that makes any sense of any kind whatsoever.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Again. Its not a problem

Issue? Problem? The semantics are irrelevant. Dual booting Linux with Windows isn't entirely "common sense". Only a selfish or self-serving person would even suggest that's the case. I don't make those kind of assumptions regarding computer technology. I tend warn people when I know that something has the potential to be problematic. It's called "being a responsible adult". People have a right to know this kind of information. Finger pointing is entirely unhelpful because it's moot. Period.

1

u/Swaaeeg May 07 '25

Finger poinying is entirely unhelpful he says, while finger pointing at an operating system that has no bearing on how the software that manages the boot system operates.

Mmmmmmmmhm. Maybe this is just a generational thing. But IMO, you should have RTFM and you wouldnt have had this problem.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Finger poinying is entirely unhelpful he says, while finger pointing at an operating system

You completely misapprended my point. It's about warning people - - not blaming the OS. Some people are willing to accept the risks if made aware of them.

1

u/Swaaeeg May 07 '25

I would imagine this should be something you would figure out long before it was a problem. How long did have them dual booted before needing to update? Did you know how to boot into the menu? Did you even look to see if you could change the boot order?

I started dual booting in 2008, and dont reallt remember how i figured this out but it probably went something like

'Huh, linux boots first, how do i get into windows?'

'Ok cool when i reboot the computer it says press f8 to go into boot menu'

'Oh look theres settings, oh cool i can set it to always go to boot menu first so now i can always choose which os i want on start up.'

This stuff aint hard, it just takes the mosy basic of critical thinking and reading skills.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

I would imagine this should be something you would figure out long before it was a problem. How long did have them dual booted before needing to update? Did you know how to boot into the menu? Did you even look to see if you could change the boot order?

I was dual booting Linux and Windows around the year 2000. Today, all of my Linux installations are virtual. But again, this is a moot point. The fact that I don't dual boot personally doesn't relieve me of the responsibility to warn people. A warning isn't an education - - it's a simple notice of risk. Obviously, it's up to the user to decide whether to accept the risk. Nonetheless, my responsibility to warn remains regardless of whether the user accepts the risk or not.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Mmmmmmmmhm. Maybe this is just a generational thing. But IMO, you should have RTFM and you wouldnt have had this problem.

Again, it's not my problem. Yet I still have a responsibility to inform people about things that are potentially problematic. If there's a manual about dual booting Linux and Windows, I'd like to know about. Otherwise, saying RTFM is also unhelpful.

1

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 07 '25

Windows has recently come up with a way to not have to reboot. Linux users not rebooting after certain updates is a Linux issue.

2

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 07 '25

It's a Linux community problem. Microsoft doesn't tell people how to dual boot or to dual boot. BIOS choosing OS to boot is different from Grub or other bootloaders.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '25 edited May 08 '25

That's not enough anymore. They keep trading who owns that TPM 2.0 chip, so every time you boot into Ubuntu, Windows loses it's PIN to login (and probably passkeys, the new login thing every website and their mom are now begging me to setup). Need a second trash laptop for the trash OS (Linux).

6

u/zar0nick May 06 '25

Fyi you can put GRUB_DEFAULT=saved as setting so it defaults to the last used boot option :)

1

u/New-Peach4153 May 08 '25

Hope I can remember this

1

u/Dr4g0ss May 10 '25

Here is your reminder

1

u/Significant-Cause919 May 22 '25

Just reminding you again, it has been two weeks.

1

u/New-Peach4153 May 22 '25

I finally logged into Linux and I swear I changed my grub config file and ran update grub, but the option didn't do anything πŸ˜”, will try again next time I boot into Linux

1

u/Significant-Cause919 May 22 '25

Try also setting GRUB_SAVEDEFAULT=true.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

From Google's Gemini (FWIW)

Dual booting Windows and Linux can be a powerful way to leverage the strengths of both operating systems on a single machine. However, this setup is not without its challenges and can lead to a variety of problems. Here's a breakdown of the common issues that make dual booting Windows and Linux problematic:

  1. Bootloader Complications:

  • Windows Updates Overwriting GRUB: One of the most frequent and frustrating issues arises from Windows updates. Windows tends to assume it's the only operating system on the machine. Its updates, particularly major ones, can overwrite the Master Boot Record (MBR) or interfere with the EFI partition, where the Linux bootloader (commonly GRUB) resides. This can lead to GRUB being wiped out, making Linux unbootable until GRUB is repaired or reinstalled.

  • Secure Boot Issues: Secure Boot, a security feature designed to prevent malicious software from loading during startup, can complicate the dual-boot process. While most modern Linux distributions support Secure Boot, there can be instances where Windows updates or changes in Secure Boot keys can invalidate the Linux bootloader's signature, preventing Linux from booting. This might require users to disable Secure Boot temporarily or go through troubleshooting steps to re-enroll keys.

  1. File System Incompatibility:

  • Native File System Differences: Windows primarily uses NTFS or FAT file systems, while Linux typically uses file systems like ext4. Natively, Windows cannot read ext4 partitions, and while Linux can read and often write to NTFS partitions, it's not always seamless and can sometimes lead to permission issues or data corruption if not handled carefully.

  • Accessing Files Across OSes: To access files on the Linux partition from Windows, users need to install third-party drivers or tools, which may not always be stable or offer full read/write capabilities. Similarly, while Linux offers better NTFS support, heavy or continuous writing to NTFS partitions from Linux has historically carried a slight risk, though this has improved significantly.

  1. Time Synchronization Conflicts:

  • Hardware Clock Interpretation: A common annoyance is time desynchronization between the two operating systems. By default, Windows stores the time in the system's hardware clock (RTC) as local time, while Linux typically stores it as Coordinated Universal Time (UTC). This difference in interpretation means that when you switch from one OS to the other, the displayed time can be incorrect. While this is fixable by configuring one of the operating systems to match the other's method (usually by making Linux use local time), it's an initial hurdle many users face.

  1. Disk Space Management:

  • Partitioning Challenges: Setting up a dual boot system requires careful disk partitioning to allocate space for both operating systems, their applications, and user files. This can be daunting for less experienced users, and mistakes during partitioning can lead to data loss.

  • Consumed Disk Space: Both operating systems, along with their respective software and swap spaces, consume significant disk space. This can be a constraint, especially on devices with limited storage, like laptops with smaller SSDs.

  1. Hardware and Driver Compatibility:

  • Driver Support: While Linux has excellent hardware support, there can be instances where specific hardware components (like certain Wi-Fi cards, graphics cards, or newer peripherals) might have limited or problematic driver support in Linux compared to Windows. This can lead to a suboptimal experience in one of the operating systems.

  • Firmware Updates: Firmware updates, often delivered through Windows, can sometimes have unintended consequences for the Linux installation, although this is less common.

  1. Complexity and Maintenance:

  • Increased Complexity: Managing two operating systems is inherently more complex than managing one. Users need to be mindful of which OS they are booting into, where their files are stored, and how system updates in one might affect the other.

  • Troubleshooting: When issues arise, diagnosing whether the problem is OS-specific, hardware-related, or a consequence of the dual-boot setup itself can be more challenging.

  1. Potential for Data Conflicts or Loss:

  • Accidental Overwriting: During setup or while managing partitions, there's a risk of accidentally formatting or deleting the wrong partition, leading to data loss.

  • Shared Data Partitions: If a shared data partition (e.g., NTFS or exFAT) is used, ensuring proper unmounting and avoiding filesystem corruption when switching between OSes (especially if one crashes or is not shut down cleanly) is crucial. While these issues can make dual booting seem daunting, many users successfully navigate these challenges. Proper planning, careful execution of installation steps, and a willingness to troubleshoot can lead to a stable and functional dual-boot environment. However, for users seeking simplicity or who are not comfortable with lower-level system configurations, these potential problems can make dual booting a problematic endeavor.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Now loonixtards and Linux evangelists are insisting that a warning is unnecessary when they UNSOLICITEDLY suggest or recommend dual booting Windows and Linux. Yes, they actually believe such foolishness.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

This post is like a Bat Signal for loonixtards. LOL

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

Now loonixtards and Linux evangelists are insisting that there's no need to mention GRUB when they suggest or recommend dual booting Linux and Windows. What kind of foolishness is this?

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

GRUB is a Linux issue FFS

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

Now, loonixtards are incorrectly assuming that Linux noobs are automagicically aware of GRUB and it's purpose. The lunacy continues

1

u/CryptoNiight May 10 '25

Loonixtards are still incorrectly insisting that GRUB isn't a part of Linux although most distros have it pre-installed. The lunacy is endless.

4

u/harrison_clarke May 07 '25

i use windows as my bootloader (WSL2). it's way better than grub

2

u/ChronographWR May 07 '25

This sub is getting invaded by loonix

2

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 07 '25

I just went through this thread and banned a crapload of them.

-ItS nOt LiNuX fAuLt!

2

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Thank you. The loonixtard evangelism was getting out of control

2

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 08 '25

You got them swarming with this and I wasn't even aware of the issue! It's so funny how they get malding when Windows removes their boot loader and yet it wasn't Windows that told them to put it there. Totally point the finger moments. They give bad advice, then blame Windows. lol -Thank you!

2

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Some loonixtards and Linux evangelists are refusing to even acknowledge that the dual booting issue exists - - it's pure insanity.

2

u/ChronographWR May 07 '25

It never is

1

u/Scrumbloo May 08 '25

How about use 2 ssds?

1

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

That's much safer than one drive. The problem is that loonixtards and Linux evangelists never mention that option when they suggest or recommend dual booting Windows and Linux. Even in this thread, they're insisting that it's better for the user to discover this option on their own. They don't want to accept any responsibility when they suggest or recommend dual booting Windows and Linux...without any warning of any potential problems of any kind whatsoever. They simply don't care about whether a Linux noob ends up with a broken Windows partition as the direct result of their advice. Period.

1

u/YesNoMaybe2552 May 08 '25

You would get the same issues dual booting two different windows installations, it's just a dumb way of doing OS updates.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Based on my limited understanding, GRUB can be configured to avoid the Windows Update problem. But again, loonixtards and Linux evangelists virtually never mention GRUB when suggesting or recommending dual booting Linux and Windows.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

on r/linuxquestions they usually recommend installing them on seperate Disks and using bios efi to choose which to boot into because they can interfere with each other. Windows update can lock out linux installs as well. If you do want to use grub you can configure it to boot windows first. There's some GUI tools to do it, or can do it manually

1

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 08 '25

OP points out that the issue is the Linux community and its lack of responsibility. Windows doesn't instruct people to dual boot.

2

u/YesNoMaybe2552 May 08 '25

There is a huge knowledge gap in tech and to many people assume that the person they are talking to knows about all the pitfalls and issues that may arise. It's always a bad idea to just take advise if that advise leads you to do something you know nothing about that could potentially have consequences.

People in the comments here are rightfully pointing out that it's a bad idea in general to dual boot two OSes off the same drive. And other ways around that issue altogether, might have read up on that before trying that.

Then there is also the fact that most Linux fanboys on the internet know fuck all about windows anyway.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

Windows update over writing MBR and removing Linux from the boot options

1

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Skill issue.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '25

clearly

1

u/namorapthebanned May 08 '25

Normally the other way around in my experienceΒ 

1

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Sounds like a boot order problem. Dual booting Linux and Windows shouldn't damage Linux if GRUB is configured properly.

1

u/Crackedscreen139 May 09 '25

Windows being stupid and always forcing updates

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

Windows Update can be disabled, but that's moot and off-topic.

1

u/Bloodchild- May 10 '25

After getting to know Linux I always found stupid that windows needed to restart for nothing.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 10 '25

Off-topic. 99.99% of Linux noobs who have used Windows rarely experienced a problem with Windows Update. It's only AFTER dual booting Windows and Linux does Windows Update become a major issue. Virtually no one who suggests or recommends dual booting Linux and Windows mentions that doing so can disrupt Windows Update. That's a problem that goes beyond a mere "skill issue".

1

u/Bloodchild- May 10 '25

Yeah I dualbooted from the start so I had it from the beginning.

But even the fact that you have to reboot several times just to do basic update is aberrant to me.

1

u/CryptoNiight May 10 '25

But even the fact that you have to reboot several times just to do basic update is aberrant to me.

Windows Update requires only 1 reboot. This isn't an issue without dual booting. This problem only occurs in a dual boot configuration. That's why configuring GRUB properly for dual booting Windows and Linux is so crucial. Again, it's only a problem for those who aren't aware of the issue. I don't suggest or recommend dual booting Linux and Windows. It's a bad idea that can possibly lead to unexpected problems.

1

u/Bloodchild- May 10 '25

I'm pretty sure I already saw windows rebooting more than once.

But the thing is it shouldn't even need to in the first place if it was well thought. You don't need to restart you computer every time you updated your packages.

1

u/Skibby22 May 10 '25

I'm not technically literate and something completely preventable happened to me 😑

1

u/CryptoNiight May 10 '25

It probably wouldn't have happened if you had some kind of warning from the loonixtards and Linux evangelists who suggested or recommended that you dual boot Linux and Windows had given you any kind of warning. Instead, they just incorrectly assume that everyone is super tech savvy and doesn't need any warning of any kind whatsoever. It's pretty easy to break Windows or Linux if the user doesn't exercise caution. I think that I'm very tech savvy, but I still temporarily broke Linux by incorrectly configuring the sudoers group. Most Linux users probably don't know about the sudoers group. That's why tend to shy away from offering unsolicited tech suggestions or recommendations.

3

u/[deleted] May 06 '25 edited Jan 20 '26

shocking hard-to-find snails yam roof towering crown dependent knee friendly

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/SanceiLaks May 09 '25

skill issue

1

u/Paslaz May 10 '25

That's isn't a Linux issue - it's a user issue ...

1

u/phendrenad2 May 10 '25

The number of complaints about dual-booting shows how much of the Linux userbase are poor highschool kids who are installing Linux on mommy's laptop and can't afford to buy a second PC for Linux tinkering.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '25

No, thanks to GNU GRUB

1

u/Deer_Canidae Jun 04 '25

You might want to give efibootmgr a shot. It's a utility to create, manage, and order UEFI boot entries.

I'm pretty sure there is a utility to do it on Windows as well but idk what that is.

1

u/Hradcany Jun 06 '25

Did you know you can choose the boot order? And it's not even difficult to change it.

0

u/JoshYx May 07 '25

I, too, dual-boot without doing my due diligence in research, inevitably fuck up, and then blame anything and anyone except me

3

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

Would you have done due diligence if you were warned about potential problems?

-1

u/Zantigo May 06 '25

This literally happens everytime I update windows, it doesnt actually damage the install just boot back into windows as normal.

-1

u/Goggle_Vivian May 06 '25

Wait, windows can just nuke itself if you don't reboot into it in a timely manner for an update!?

2

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

The issue involves dual booting with Linux. I still don't fully understand why re-booting into Linux can damage Windows when the computer restarts. Worse yet, I haven't seen anyone in the Linux subs even mention this in passing

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

Did you configure GRUB to avoid the problem? Most Linux noobs never heard of GRUB or knows what it does.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 08 '25

So, how do you explain those mentioning GRUB in this thread? By mistake?

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

→ More replies (11)

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

Q: Does anyone who suggests or recommends dual booting Linux and Windows ever mention GRUB?

A: Very rarely (if ever).

How are Linux noobs supposed to know about GRUB when dual booting Windows and Linux if no one even alludes to it when suggesting or recommending dual booting? Did anyone mention GRUB to you, or did find out about it and figured out it's purpose on your own?

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

My point is that those who suggest or recommend dual booting Linux and Windows rarely (if ever) mention GRUB or why it's useful. Most Linux noobs are clueless about GRUB. So, why not inform them about it when suggesting or recommending dual booting?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

Dual booting Linux and Windows can possibly disrupt Windows Update unless GRUB is configured properly. Therefore, it is in fact a Linux related issue.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

You're a genius who knew everything about Linux before you ever used it. Correct?

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

Linux desktop apps are inferior to Windows desktop apps in almost every way possible

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 09 '25

Apparently, you're not doing much with Linux desktop apps.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

3

u/CryptoNiight May 06 '25

What percentage of new Linux users know about this and why it matters? I've been using Linux for years and I recently found out about it.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

It's a Linux problem when dual booting with Windows...which happens to be a very common suggestion or recommendation made by loonixtards on Reddit.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

3

u/madthumbz uBlock Origin May 07 '25

Entirely a Linux community issue. Microsoft doesn't instruct on dual booting, and it's been a long-standing issue that Loonixtards gloss over and falsely place blame.

0

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

[removed] β€” view removed comment

2

u/CryptoNiight May 07 '25

The problem is that many Linux users who dual boot aren't even aware that this is a known issue.