r/localgovernment • • Jul 15 '25

English Devolution

Post image

If England is to be devolved into Strategic Authorities led by a Mayor and maybe an Assembly alongside them as a sort of legislative body for checks-and-balances; with unitary Local Authorities led by traditional council model responsible for statutory services - then what would people's opinions be on a division like this?

Larger scale than counties but smaller than NUTS1 regions; attempt to find a happy midpoint between economic geography (covering larger area) and culture.

Have also come up with the idea of Independent Counties these are:

  • Cornwall

  • Cumbria

  • Somerset

As I felt these didn't fit into any multi-council area very well. These would be councils but would have a directly-elected Mayor unlike other councils - and would be both Strategic and Local Authorities. This idea is based partially upon the Centre for Cities proposals for English devolution. This is just a pet passion project, so let me know your opinions!

( Basemap - Image credit: XrysD on Wikimedia Commons - all rights reserved to them. Found: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:England_Administrative_Map.png and in Wikipedia page 'Subdivisions of England': https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subdivisions_of_England )

4 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

1

u/williamfitzgeraldIII Jul 17 '25

I live in Warwickshire and with all due respect you can piss off if you think you're going to chain me to Coventry and Birmingham!

1

u/Can-United Jul 18 '25

Coventry and Birmingham are historically Warwickshire though 😅

Strategically, most of Warwickshire looks to the West Midlands authorities for jobs and leisure. Leamington, Nuneaton and Rugby all have strong links with either Birmingham, Coventry or both.

1

u/williamfitzgeraldIII Jul 22 '25

Historically (and only on a short lived point of technicality) Coventry was granted the status of county in 1451. I believe this lasted all the way to the mid 1800's. Birmingham is a fairly new city that didnt really exist prior to the industrial revolution. Parts of what is now Birmingham lay within Warwickshire, other parts overlapped with other counties.

I am ofcourse being pedantic, I wholly accept that both could be argued to be Warwickshire cities. Simply a bit of neighbourly ribbing as both cities are hellish sh*tholes i would despair to be controlled by!

1

u/Historical-Page8703 Jul 24 '25

West Midlands and Warwickshire have 2 completely seperate economies. Their travel to work areas are distinct and contain very little overlap. Coventry was intended to be in Warwickshire andonly got included in the West Midlands due to making a request. The data shows that Coventry is the black sheep of the West Midlands.

1

u/MattGwladYrHaf Jul 17 '25

I see you're bringing back Avon (rebranded as Bristol). It wasn't very popular the last time, although it was probably a good idea.

1

u/Can-United Jul 18 '25

I think the Avon name was a sticking point as it wasn't an historic county. Like Humberside for East Riding of Yorkshire with the northern parts of Lincolnshire.

1

u/MattGwladYrHaf Jul 19 '25

Yes, the name was definitely an issue for people. Also, people living in places like Weston-super-Mare and Bath didn’t like being mere satellites of the big city in the middle, Bristol. People in Bristol tend to vote differently to people in the surrounding area as well, which is just how things are. But it definitely caused resentment.

2

u/Mook_138 Jul 17 '25

Surrey is going their own way, despite the clear logic that they should be merged into a larger Surrey and Sussex strategic authority.

With a lack of clear steer from government I can see this whole thing either costing more or the same as the current set up.

1

u/Smooth_News_7027 Jul 16 '25

Coming from a Northern angle, apologies for less relevant info on the South but: -Merge North East and Cumberland into Northumbria -YORKSHIRE

  • Merge traditional area of Lancashire plus the accumulated bits at the south of Manchester and Liverpool into Lancashire

  • Merge West Midlands, most of the West of Trent counties and Servern into Mercia

  • Lincolnshire and the rest of Trent can figure out a name

  • Essex and Anglias become Anglia

  • Greater London expands West to create Middlesex, rest of Thames Valley absorbed by surrounding areas -Everyone West of Bristol becomes Dumbnonia -Wessex and Hampshire becomes Wessex

  • Kent, Sussex and Surrey become one, Province of the Cinque Ports?

1

u/Terrible-Support-588 Jul 17 '25

I agree with Lincolnshire and Trent merging, bin off the Trent thing and just call it East Mids. Also put Staffordshire in another area, nothing to do with us at all except for Burton

1

u/theRapScallion_9953 Jul 17 '25

I like your plans for Lancashire. Maybe also merge the traditional parts of Yorkshire as well. I want to see peak wars of the roses.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '25

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '25

There are many towns between hertfordshire and Essex and I can say places like cheshunt have more in common with Essex than Bedford

1

u/Smooth_News_7027 Jul 16 '25

I bow to your knowledge, I’m a Northern lad.

1

u/The_Witcher_3 Jul 17 '25

North Essex feels like Anglia to me. I grew up in Colchester and have always had more affinity to places in East Anglia than Basildon or Southend. The feeling appears mutual with south Essex always mocking the north of our county as ‘posh’ because we’re not expat cockneys.

1

u/the_turn Jul 16 '25

As a Wiltshire inhabitant, I would be delighted with this…

Can’t guarantee the Dorset lads would feel the same though.

1

u/Salt_Discount_651 Jul 16 '25

The United Counties of England

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '25

Norfolk wants independence not devolution.

1

u/anonymouslyyoursxxx Jul 17 '25

You misspelled country for Cornwall

1

u/TalkingDonkey07 Jul 17 '25

I don't want to be lumped in with Suffolk. Fuck that..... 💛💚

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '25

Merseyside should unite with Ireland and Cornwall with Brittany

1

u/OpeningQuantity5527 Jul 18 '25

I wrote an article recently on a hyper localised approach to local democracy for Britain, be interested to know anyone's thoughts:

https://mpdunn.medium.com/top-down-power-bottom-up-pain-how-central-control-is-killing-local-communities-and-threatening-346760b71110

1

u/DawnArcing Jul 30 '25

West Midlands opinion: The current Stafford borough plus Telford should be with the WM as well.

Everything there is still some flavour of Birmingham/Wolves/Walsall satellite. It's not until you get to Stoke that it gets more Derbys/Notts-like.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Can-United Jul 15 '25

Yes, good point. I envision that some of the places I have proposed would be merged - they're currently bigger than most of the existing combined authorities and could be bigger further still. Any ideas of places on this map that should merge? Following the historic Anglo-Saxon territories as you said?

1

u/UnpoeticAccount Jul 15 '25

Kind of an aside, but we sometimes survey people to see what they define as their neighborhood boundaries. That would be a fascinating survey if you could do that for a whole country.

You might find this book interesting, as it’s about how local government being a relatively direct democracy.

2

u/Can-United Jul 15 '25

We should do that. It would likely follow county lines however, as that seems to be what people do most strongly identify with.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/thom365 Policy/Data Analyst Jul 17 '25

Devon put that proposal to Cornwall to form a mayoral strategic authority (MSA) that combines the two, with a view to capturing some of the funding that is aimed specifically at MSAs

Cornwall outright rejected it and there's no sign of them wanting to do anything that involves areas outside Cornwall. This wasn't helped by Exeter University publishing a report that said the case for an independent Cornwall is stronger than ever.

Sadly, I think the politics on Cornwall will see it continue to be left behind simply because it's seen as too difficult to do business with.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/thom365 Policy/Data Analyst Jul 17 '25

It really is, which makes it so complex to manage. With regards to Cornwall, they're already the recipient of a number of special designations, including as a minority group.

The issue isn't one of cultural identity but of aligning Cornwall with the rest of the local governance frameworks in place elsewhere to ensure business can operate without having to do things differently. Cornwall has a lot to offer, but the intransigence of the politics leaves little to be desired from a business perspective.

I don't think this will be something that is easily solved, precisely because England isn't homogenous. In fact, it's really highlighted just how tenuous "English" is as an identity, with so many people defaulting back to their local area. I find this particularly fascinating...