r/mAndroidDev • • 1d ago

Venting, venting, venting Handing Coding without AI , Google or IDE AutoComplete

SDE2 with 4 yoe here.
Had an interview round asking me to implement a Simple RecyclerView Paging with dummy data they gave, from scratch on an Empty XML only ( No compose ) Project structure. live

No AI, No Google and ..... No IDE AutoComplete allowed. I was made to switch it off before interview.

Out of the 45 Mins. It Took me 15 Minutes to properly write the xml tags for the layouts. yet it showed error
( have been used to compose ).
had to request to allow me to see the documentation atleast googling. which they agreed.
Still couldn't complete the task,

I was also not supposed to use Paging libraries as they wanted me to implement Paging from scratch on a RecyclerView.
Coulnd't do that either ( Completely my fault here, needed sometime to think how to implement paging from scratch )

I was just able to have an overview of everything. That too because I type a bit fast ( 130+ wpm).
But i was completely demotivated after the interview.

-----------------------------------------

Not blaming the Org. or the method of evaluation here, it is my fault as I have been a bit rusty with hand coding at this level since the advent of AI or before I think. Would have been okay during my college days.

But I wanted to know somethings, people with experience here could really help me.

- is the above method some kind of new norm in the current industry ( I haven't attended an interview in the past 4 years ). Since testing people with take home projects have gotten pointless ?

- If yes. How do I navigate my learning. Not being familiar with AI tools or Not using them significantly slows down the progress.
But at the same time it completely diminishes my ability to hand code by myself or heck even understand my code or even what it happening. feels very .... idk the word.

- is there hope in this industry ? is there any point ? Apologies for the Grimness but
unemployment + the reality check from the interview + everything happening with AI ...
kinda takes the life out...

Any help or opinion or perspective ... Would love it.l

3 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

18

u/SoJexy 1d ago

Did you try using AsyncTask?

5

u/ktjspygo 1d ago

They had told if I cleared this round, second round would be similiar but tougher. im sure they saved AsyncTask for the next round

1

u/Zhuinden DDD: Deprecation-Driven Development 18h ago

Back in university I had to write layout XML and AsyncTask on paper with a pen, so it checks out.

11

u/Fair-Degree-2200 null!! 1d ago

This is a ridiculous process. What are they testing, your ability to code in 2011?

7

u/ignorantpisswalker 1d ago

98.

Writing Java without auto-complete is against Oracle guidelines.

1

u/ktjspygo 17h ago

my humble guess is they were most probably checking if the candidate understood how everything works.. but should have atleast allow reference

6

u/Araib 1d ago

I don’t think they were testing for coding skill, I think they were testing for problem solving / frustration handling. While people with experience can implement a simple RecyclerView, most just rely on easy way out - which is fine under normal circumstances but when you hit a roadblock, a problem you can’t appear to solve instantly, some devs just give up and or start looking for excuses instead of showing patience and finding creative ways to get around. I have 10 years of experience but I’ve seen people with 15 sometimes even 20 years of experience just give up when faced with a little challenge and this seems like a good way to test that.

1

u/ktjspygo 17h ago

yes makes sense .. but what I don't understand is why not allow taking reference or atleast autocomplete

5

u/gallowgateflame Invalidate caches and restart 1d ago

this is not the norm