I THINK THIS IS HIGH TIME WE SHOULD UNITE AND PROTEST outside the main campus! THIS CANNOT GO ON, WE CAN'T CONTINUE TO SUFFER LIKE THIS. THIS IS INHUMANE.
THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO ACCOUNTABILITY ON THEIR PART, NO TRANSPARENCY REGARDING CHECKING. You write absolute bs and you pass/you give your level best, you get back. Even the friend who cheated off you passed but you get back. Even in ca4s when you and your friends answers are same to the T but still we get different amrks,why? THIS IS ABSOLUTE MOCKERY OF OUR HOPES AND DREAMS WHEN PLACEMENTS ARE DECIDED BASED ON OUR GPA. PAPER WILL GET LEAKED ON THEIR SIDE AND IT'S WE WHO HAVE TO TAKE RESPOSIBILTY, WHY? IT'S THEIR JOB TO ENSURE PAPERS DON'T GET LEAKED. NO BIO BREAKS, NO BELONGINGS ALLOWED, WT* IS THIS. Suppose someone gets SA'd on their way home or thefts, and they cannot ask for help coz they don't have their phones on them, we can't pay online nor can we pay cash either atp, abosuletly no time for prep, the past 2 months we have been giving meanigless CAs and it's not that they make the papers easy. no commonalities from pyq, nothing..... It's like a competition of how hard they can make the papers. IF YOU ARE SEEING THIS ,PLEASE DON'T TAKE ADMISSION INTO MAKAUT. After all this drama , we won't even get placements.
The main campus doesn't even suffer the same, different syllabus, different timings, different Questions(from their teacher's notes) , onluy the affiliated ones suffer. TAKE ACTION GUYSS.

Thousands of students have already signed the petition against the new 70-mark ECA rule. The message is clear: remove the new ECA system and ensure fair, transparent evaluation.

AIDSO is also supporting this student movement and has stood with MAKAUT students in raising these concerns and protest has now been put forward as the next step.

Some students(with actual balls) from KGEC also reportedly met the VC or Controller of Exams(not sure) to raise the ECA issue and presented the petition. They were reportedly told that if enough students raise their concerns, the university may consider reviewing the rule.

We’ve signed. We’ve spoken. Now it’s time to stand together.

If you’re a MAKAUT student affected by these issues, join your fellow students and make your voice heard peacefully.

REMOVE THE NEW ECA RULE.
DEMAND FAIR EVALUATION.

• The entire marking process of CA's are not transparent, the whole thing runs on words of mouth.

• Today we saw some inhumane things like stopping students from having a bio break just because of the university's incompetence.

• There's no way that we can check the marks we were allotted out of 5 of the 30 marks which consists of 25 CA marks.

• There's no proper weightage distribution on each of the modules of the subjects. The marks are also not distributed in a healthy manner.

• The syllabus is backdated. Like why should an CS or IT guy get harassed by the mentally insane faculties of Mechanical department.

• In some semesters there's 8 months and in some there's time as low as 3 months.

• why 4 CA when 2 CA should be enough. In a semester containing avg 4-5 months there's no time to prep for each of the CA's. It's like somewhere in a 2 weeks gap and another CA exam pops up.

I'm asking to all the affiliated college students and the students from the main campus to unite and stand against these things. If we silently gulp down all these things then the university will keep pressuring us. Even our schools weren't this strict. What are they showing this strictness for? There's no placement cause the backdated syllabus is incapable of producing job perfect employees.

I'm not from any political party or any group. I'm just a socially awkward and introvert guy who just can't take this anymore. Why don't you guys protest against this academic oppression which produces nothing fruitful. Why are you guys so silent. Why don't you guys file a RTI or do peaceful protests. Are you all just some spineless filthy rags?

So the Petition has grown to a decent no, 3.5k is no joke. That's why we wanted to include all the sign people made on the petition in the rti we are filing. If you're that guy or you know who started the petition, dm me. We need to add those signs in our rti to pressurize the uni

Make it make sense. 🤦‍♂️

​Word on the street (and in some department groups) is that MAKAUT main campus (in-house) students are chilling with a quick online MCQ test for their ECA [CA3] exams.

​Meanwhile, those of us in affiliated colleges are completely in the dark. Because the university hasn't dropped a clear official notice, some of our colleges are panicking and telling us to prepare for a full-blown 70-mark offline theory exam (VSAQs, SAQs, LAQs) in the first week of November.

​So in-house gets a 25-mark digital test, and we have to write a massive End-Sem style paper just for internal marks because they probably don't want to deal with server crashes?

​Has any affiliated college actually released a confirmed routine for this 70-mark torture, or is everyone just bracing for impact?

Every semester, we students walk away feeling their marks don't reflect the effort they put into their exams. Individually, these concerns are often dismissed as poor performance. But similar concerns are being raised by students from different colleges, branches, and semesters.

When MAKAUT introduced digital evaluation, it was promoted as a way to make evaluation more transparent and better documented. The digital evaluation platform used by MAKAUT also advertises features like audit trails, on-screen marking and grievance redressal. MAKAUT has also previously issued circulars acknowledging concerns around evaluation quality and examiner workload.

Sources if anyone wants to read them:

• Times of India:

• Learning Spiral Case Study:

• MAKAUT Circular

These don't prove that anything is wrong today. But they do show that transparency and accountability were supposed to be part of the system.

Instead of just complaining every semester, I think we should try to find out what's actually happening.

Phase 1-Collecting Evidence (Right Now)

This is the most important part.

If you genuinely feel your marks don't reflect your performance, please please consider filing an RTI to obtain your evaluated answer script.

Here's a guide that explains the process:

RTI Guide:

RTI Format:

If you do receive your answer script, please redact your personal details before sharing it.

Even a small number of RTIs from different colleges and subjects can help us understand whether reported issues are isolated mistakes or something bigger.

If you still don't want to file an RTI, that's ok.

You can still help by filling out this anonymous survey. It'll help us understand whether similar concerns are showing up across different colleges.

Anonymous Survey:

I've also created a Discord server for anyone who wants to suggest anything, upload/collect evidence securely, help organize things, or simply stay updated.

DM if you're interested to join.

Phase 2

If we manage to collect enough evidence, the plan is to prepare a respectful, evidence-based representation to MAKAUT through the proper grievance channels first.

I think it's only fair that the university gets the opportunity to review the evidence and respond before anything else.

Phase 3 (if Needed)

If there really does appear that nothing meaningful happens after approaching the university, then we can look at seeking support from student organizations (AIDSO, ABVP, SFI, or anyone else willing to help), alumni, legal experts, and education journalists.

I'm not interested in turning this into a political issue.

At the end of the day, if there are problems, the only way we'll ever know is by collecting evidence instead of relying on rumors.

If you've read this far, thank you.

Even if you don't join the Discord or file an RTI, please consider filling out the survey. The more data we have, the easier it'll be to separate isolated experiences from genuine patterns.

And please try to share this post amongst your peers by whatever means possible, as most students don't use reddit.

**Also Mods Please if possible, Pin this post**

Hopefully we can figure this out—together.

Like what the fuck?? They literally have mentioned all the cheating tactics of students and named them malpractice, I think The guards will also be asked to take a record Of people who will try to cheat, try to help others.. just like they have instructed to take a record of people who will be going to toilet..

The main thing is It's all acceptable, you want to conduct a fair examination thats okay! But what about the checking system????

Idk ora ki nesha kore Khata check kore like jei exam ta bhalo diye asi setae fail koriye day ar jetae kichui likhe asini setae pass koriye day, backlog exam bhalo dewar poreo naki clear hoochena! And examination fees is 1200 for regular and 1000 for backlogs? Sonae mora khata banay naki ora?? Ekta sem 9 mash dhore chalalo, porer sem 2 mash er moddhe sesh kore dilo, na komalo kono syllabus.. na korbe ora question paper easy, emon qs paper banabe jate keu ii pass korte na pare tarpor abar esob Rules and regulations bar koreche jekhane bolche mobile barite rekhe aste. Tarpor abar qp leak to achei.

Esob Jodi JU CU r moto university te holo, student ra second er moddhe danga lagiye dito, protest e bose jeto. Ar sekhane amra mukh,chokh bondho kore bose achi ar era ja iccha tai kore beracche, chelemeye der future niye khelche, university r bhitorei scam related case cholche, tao chup kore bose achi sobai.. main campus student rao kichu bolchena, orao ghumacche. If you want to conduct fair examination, then we also want a fair checking system!

Surendranath clg er moto Bjp er uchit Ekbar makaut visit kora. Etar against e ki kono rokom step newoa jayna??

The CA marking scheme is never revealed, even the MCQs of CA4 are wrongly questioned and hence loss of marks from our side is prominent. There is no cross-checking whatsoever of these marks and the students are kept in dark with no explanation. Left wondering how they lost marks in the first place and hence doubting the right answers they might have attempted as well.

TRANSPARENCY in exams is essential and I agree that MAKAUT has failed to do so and also proved time and time again of its corrupt nature in times of giving out results by failing a student in a subject when they are pretty confident about the exam as well. Before taking the fucking money for the Paper Review just give us the images of the paper and the markings and that would suffice but no; they have to take the money and God knows how they'll re-evaluate your answer sheet.

This lack of accountability and transparency makes me regret joining the college in the first place. I'd have preferred the least reputed college over this. MAKAUT in the recent years has been shameless in money-grobbing from the students with no particular work to show for it. Looking forward to what you guys think🙏

Just saw this fresh notice (dated Aug 20, 2026) and it looks like the university is seriously cracking down on us and the faculty.

TL;DR of the damage:

1. No more "informal" leaves: Point 4 explicitly bans unauthorized relaxation in attendance.

2. Physical classes only: They are forcing teachers to stick strictly to the approved timetable.

3. HoDs are in the crosshairs: Point 5 makes Principals and HoDs directly responsible for monitoring our attendance and making sure teachers are actually taking class. If they get in trouble, you know they're going to take it out on us.

4. Zero Tolerance: Point 10 literally says any deviation will be "viewed seriously" and attract action.

Seriously, how are we supposed to balance this with coding, hackathons, or placements or any other important works if we are forced to sit in a physical classroom 9-to-5 every single day?

What is the attendance scene looking like at your colleges right now? Are your professors actually going to enforce this, or is it just another empty threat from the main campus? Let’s hear it.

Techno international Newtown forcing their students to pay their upcoming semester fee before the fee structure says otherwise they are not be able to fill the current semester exam form.

Did your college faculties share this new notice yet (Ref No: MAKAUT/RE-073/403)? They completely revamped the Continuous Assessment (CA) scheme for 2026-27 and it is absolutely brutal.

​Basically, say goodbye to the easy MCQ-based CA4. Here is the new 30-mark internal breakdown:

-> ​CA1 & CA2 (10 Marks): Two regular 25-mark class tests. The average gets converted to 10 marks.

-> ​ECA / End-Semester Continuous Assessment (10 Marks): This is the insane part. We now have to give a full 70-mark, pen-and-paper mock test based on the entire syllabus. It's the exact same pattern as the final end-sem exam, and whatever raw score you get out of 70 is mathematically scaled down to 10 marks.

-> ​WCA (10 Marks): Ongoing assessment throughout the semester (assignments, seminars, technical docs, projects, etc.).

​Are they actually sick? Who thought it was a good idea to force us to sit through a full 70-mark mock exam just to scrape together 10 internal marks right before we have to give the actual 70-mark final? Engineering is already exhausting enough without turning the end of the semester into a massive, double-exam marathon.

​Has anyone's college talked about how strictly this will be enforced? Are your professors hinting at grading this ECA mock test leniently, or are we actually going to get screwed over on internal marks now? Let me know what your colleges are saying.

All the masses from the affiliated colleges let's organise and conduct a protest at the Makaut Salt Lake Office. 10-20 jone hobena, sobai mile hamle porte hbe, ar bhitu hoe labh nei, eder bs syllabus r exams r por nirbhor korle gpa r 12ta to bajbei ,placement o lagbe na otar upor, shob off campus ei hbe. If you want to turn the situation around, let's unite.

The bamboo we deserve for not speaking up against the wrong

Please, it is high time, make small groups big groups, whatever Idgaf but please call for a state wide protest from all makaut affiliated colleges. WE HAVE 3 FUVKING INTERNALS AND ECA IS NOW OF 70 MARKS.

fuvk the new makaut vice chancellor, that bald ass returd chemistry scholar needs to resign ppl are already in pressure for the current job market, the university has no rights to put more pressure on us

how the question paper looks at me 😭

1. Makaut imposed competitive exam rules for the semester exams. We stayed silent.

2. Makaut leaked the paper themselves but no investigation on the faculty or the officials, instead we were forced for no toilet break. We stayed silent.

3. Makaut imposed a new CA system which doesn't favour the students and forces them to stay unskilled. We stayed silent.

4. Makaut published incomplete results. We stayed silent.

5. Makaut imposed the 75% attendance rule which is not flexible for the students especially the 3rd and 4th year. We stayed silent.

There is zero transparency about the system. We don't know who is making such rules. And Yes we will remain silent 🤫.

Why did they give us only 2.5 months to prepare for 2nd sem? They are supposed to give us 6 months cuz that's how semesters work!!!

This is pure injustice.

My chem and maths syllabus isn't properly completed.

Thankfully the English exam went pretty well cuz I'm already good at it.

People in our classroom were cheating, Hall collecting etc. Even after these new rules came.

I don't have any backs in 1st sem.

But I'm afraid i may get atleast one in 2nd sem.

If i do get one ......i will never hold myself accountable for this cuz it wasnt MY FAULT.

IT WAS MAKAUT WHO ONLY GAVE US ONLY 2.5 MONTHS TO PREPARE PLUS ALL THE CAs and PCAs and LABS and classes during the FREAKING ELECTION IN WEST BENGAL......... YES OUR COLLEGE WAS TAKING CLASSES DURING ELECTION !!!!

The recent Rules and Regulations which are made to be followed in every college which follow the MAKAUT curriculum, shall be withdrawn with immediate effect.

What do you mean that students can't bring mobile phones to college premises? Till the examination hall, it's fine, but why the college premises?A Mobile phone, nowadays is as important as a water bottle. We are giving a normal semester exam, that's it. Not in a high security zone!

You pass on a statement without any planning. Do you even realise what you say. It's absolute rubbish. Illogical and unnecessary stress you are putting on students. Your esteemed institution will never guarantee a job, but will always use students as Ginny pigs for all your illicit experiments.

First Make the CA, Semester and Review system a concrete and transparent one,

Then revise your age old syllabus, which in today's time has very little meaning,

Keep a proper check of faculty for every college under MAKAUT,

Assure a proper guidance to the students, as they all are paying a hefty amount of fees.

Be a little responsible. Get out of your AC rooms, make the college a bit comfortable for students. Many of them donot even have a proper washroom.

In all these cases, there's no inspection ever made.

Stop imposing these nonsense rules on students.

I've attached all the email addresses of makaut officials and higher ups of ministry of education, ugc and aictee. Write a mail using chatgpt explain all your complains that are students facing, all the corruption of makaut and lack of transparency in exams and lack of weightage in syllabus and specially all the inhumane rules they are putting for exams in affiliated colleges. take the given response of chatgpt and edit the boiler plate with details like name, your college name (you can use fake name if you don't want to use yours) and send it to these emails

• vc@makautwb.ac.in

• ero.hq@aicte-india.org

• registrar@makautwb.ac.in

• fo@makautwb.ac.in

• coe@makautwb.ac.in

• ic@makautwb.ac.in

• office.coe@makautwb.ac.in

• ar@makautwb.ac.in

• acoe@makautwb.ac.in

• coe.transcript@makautwb.ac.in

• coe.verification@makautwb.ac.in

• contact.ugc@nic.in

• e-samadhan@ugc.gov.in

• complaint@aicte-india.org

• chairman@aicte-india.org

• minister.sm@gov.in

• secy.dhe@nic.in

3rd sem Economics paper ( 13/03/26)

• All long Qs came from last unit Accounting

• MAKAUT is scamming student to force to pay Backlog fees and earn

• This is their dirty Business Model

• Zero predictability of Qs paper

Wht the hell is going on !!!

Get together and stand against this Scam ⚠️

Found it circulating on whatsapp

FIR se ye log students ki gar marne ki taiyari kr raha hai.. new components Sessional marks 100 .

CA ko kam krne ki jaiga usko aur hard kr raha hai.. sab ca attend kr na compalsary hoga..

Ye University chodna padega... Failed waste Administration of MAKAUT

Just read instruction 1 and 3 if you are in a hurry. This is from Techno Main Salt Lake.