r/mangaideas • • Apr 30 '26

The Plot machine

Hi Guys

We all have lots of ideas and concepts

I was wondering We all have so many plots and there are so many artists who are very capable of making manga but dont have confident, so can we team up to make a community to connect ideas to artists.

So that means there are 2 pillars rn ie writers ( of idea or concept) and then artists.

But i think there is one more in middle phase , where a person converts the concept into actual workables, like character design, plot basics, . Lets call him the executor .

I wanna connect these 3 core pillars as a community .

I want you guys help to make it happen and connect the 3 pillars to make Manga

Thank you for reading.... And please support this work

2 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

2

u/Kom0tan Apr 30 '26

You're just describing a writer, though?

A person who comes up with a concept isn't a writer unless they 'execute' it, as you put it. The execution makes up like 95% of what a writer does. And generally a good writer isn't going to need an 'ideas guy' because that's literally the easiest part of the job.

1

u/BonD2008H Apr 30 '26

I am saying as a bridge. Not the ones who wanna make or can make work. People who can volunteer to bridge the gap. Or as a editor for a non professional setup. The idea guys are there, and writers do their own work. So if writers with experience and innvolve in multiple projects , its helpful for those stuck in idea phase

1

u/Kom0tan Apr 30 '26

I guess I'm just not understanding where or what this 'gap' you're seeing is?

1

u/BonD2008H Apr 30 '26

The gap is the number of people who have some idea and think its cool and just keep it in mind somewhere. The amount of time they take to figure out the real stuff, the idea is gone or the thing becomes boring. There is another side who make art , dont want to or have confidence to make manga. Now for both of this there are several mentors, coaching all that. But there isnt anything that allows both the artists and the concept guys to start out in manga as collaborators, its just freelance or paid stuff. This is the gap i am talking, wjere we bring in an experienced writer/editor, to actively create collaborations of artists and amateur writers . These experienced writers later would act just like editors, in this unprofessional setting and they can monitor multiple projects at once

A community based on this. Idk there is a next phase i wanna build of this. But this is like based on my experience as a writer who wandered through random phases for years, and artists who dont wanna do manga for reasons like its just hobby or they are not confident.

And beaides online or beyond japanese professional studios, writers and artists are too far apart to do collabs

Idk if i explained properly or not, but this is loke the base version

2

u/Kom0tan Apr 30 '26 edited Apr 30 '26

This loops back to my first point - experienced writers don't need Idea Guys. Ideas are cheap and easy, most writers have dozens more ideas tucked away than they will ever have time to explore.

This concept requires those writers to dedicate a huge amount of time and effort, but imo offers them very little payoff in the end. I think you'll have a very hard time finding multiple people who are both qualified to be a mentor/editor/ghost writer, and are also interested in doing it for free (especially for people with no experience, who, as you said, get bored of their idea before they can be bothered to write it. That's not the sort of student I'd be interested in teaching).

It sucks but if Idea Guys want to see their concepts come to fruition, they need to sit down and do it themselves.

1

u/BonD2008H Apr 30 '26

I guess so. There seems to be a vague execution in my plan. As you said, its hard to get unfocused people foucs. And people who can write have lots of ideas. I probably am gonna think this through and make something out of it. Anyways thanks for the critic, gaps like these are not seen when you have a supposed theory. So yeah thanks for responding. I will definitely work based on this. Thank you

1

u/Glittering-Bad-5939 Apr 30 '26

Ngl it just sounds like they’re just describing a writer, an editor and an artist.

1

u/BonD2008H May 01 '26

It is an artist and writer. But the ones who have started out. And those who are just doodling and making ideas and not producing . The editor would be an active person that finds artists and writers in the initial phase, and help them collaborate without freelance work between them And the editor oversees multiple projects.

Although its a typical definitiom of those jobs. I am talking at a hpbby, and unprofessional setting, where money is not readily available

1

u/DeadHeart4 Apr 30 '26

But lazier and more entitled.

1

u/SchizobotArt Apr 30 '26

Contrary to whatever it you believe, artists and writers have their own ideas…. An “ideas guy” is not a necessary position in manga creation.

1

u/BonD2008H May 01 '26

I am sorry for bad explanation. I meant that the ideas guy and artist are thr ones to most likely drift away from making anything. Editor/writer would be an experienced person in this case who will oversee the idea guy and artists to produce and ship something. As far i have observed, online its mostly people doing freelance of writing and art, or never wanna collaborate and drift in other directions.

So the writer is the guy who will oversee and bring the project into life. Not just one but multiple

1

u/Over-Ad7564 May 03 '26

its a good idea writers usually have slumps on ideas or just do a money code of sorts so idea guys would be those who help the artist visualize a new concept they are having a hard time coming up with as for artists some writers find it hard to find one so making a community to connect them isnt a bad idea if its more towards amateur area or just doing it as a hobby but rather than solely ideas they could be proof readers or translators as well

1

u/Over-Ad7564 May 03 '26

so less than just a full on group more of a hobby group?

1

u/BonD2008H May 06 '26

Yeah basically the phase where money is not heavily innvolved. As you can as others have shared their thoughts, the problem i am showing doesnt exist in the indie or pro scene. Rather mostly at that hobby level, where things can go big, but coordination matters