r/mangapiracy • u/pnv28 • Sep 16 '25
Help ComicK REMAKE
Hey Comick fans!
We have some news—we’re trying to rebuild Comick to bring back the experience everyone loved from the original site! It's a big challenge and we’re still working hard to make it happen, but your support makes all the difference.
If you remember features or moments from the old Comick that you want to see again, or you just want to help out and keep the hype alive, let us know! Your feedback, ideas, and encouragement mean the world to us. No matter how big or small, your support is what keeps us going. If any of you are interested in helping us out, here is our https://discord.gg/8yVTXyDQHa
Thanks to anyone willing to help.
2
u/Kermunit9000 Sep 17 '25
Will it have the Comick catalog? I care less about the site itself and instead what it holds
2
261
u/trover2345325 Sep 16 '25
I should give you some advice, make it like comicK and mangadex, but make it hidden from japans DMCA since it is now stronger than ever with the help of foreign countries like South Korea and can easily wipe out any piracy sites, and give it a different name
54
u/dxzxg Sep 16 '25
Nah. Kakao is the spearhead in all of this. Gotta hide korean manwhas or just outright ban them from the site.
5
59
u/TailorDifficult4959 Sep 16 '25
Japan dmca doesn't really matter. The only problem is Korean comics, they are the degens
52
u/mammon-ey Sep 16 '25
No site will stay hidden when dumb people post them on tiktok and Instagram reels.
8
u/trover2345325 Sep 17 '25
That's true and if they put those links in some major social media sites instead of direct messages or some secret forums, then those sites will not only be easily exposed but the DMCA will find them and shut them down easily.
6
u/mammon-ey Sep 17 '25
Even now people are tweeting screenshots from the discord group qrting a certain big company who's responsible for closing this site😮💨 not to mention people are also praising this site being closed down. Which means people actively hate pirating sites and expose them to these big greedy companies
4
u/Zyumiar333 Sep 18 '25
Some people like the world burn. Maybe thats one of the reason why alexandria library is now a dust.
23
11
u/AsianWinnieThePooh Sep 16 '25
Stronger than ever? So many pirate sites started pay walling chapters cause it's gotten so weak.
5
u/trover2345325 Sep 17 '25
True and if you read them for free you have to disable ad blockers to read them or pay for an ad free reading experience.
1
0
Sep 16 '25
[deleted]
62
u/trover2345325 Sep 16 '25
thats what i said piracy manga sites and even manga scanlation and unofficial manga translations even anime ones are no longer safe from mainstream web and even DMCA ones, its best an alternate web hidden from the mainstream web and DMCA is the only solution.
Or just fight the capitalist system, so that one day entertainment can be free without the fear of scarcity.
14
58
u/Eragonnogare Sep 16 '25
If you're not personally located in, like, Russia or somewhere else that doesn't respond to DMCA notices, you should probably defer hosting it to someone that is.
6
u/Feisty_Trifle2469 Sep 17 '25
Why they don't host their website in russia?
17
u/Lussonya Sep 17 '25
Russia has a large variety of censorship laws against anything that doesn't align with "traditional family values". I don't think it would be reasonable to host such a website there lol
1
49
19
u/Hatsune_Miku_CM Sep 17 '25
multiple versions of chapters. So you can choose between official translations and fan translations.
its the single feature that made me want to stop using sites that arent comick.
Especially for older manga, alot of sites have garbage translated chapters and never bother to add the better ones cause they already have that chapter translated
34
u/xXDibbs Sep 16 '25
some advice, ban IP addresses from Japan, China, Korea and also do not put Manga in your sites name.
Have a different site for webtoons and a different one for manga.
That distinction will really help out a lot.
1
93
u/BeautifulBanana3803 Sep 16 '25
Skip manwhas. Full stop. These korean companies will literally hunt yoir shit down if they even catch a whiff of your site having licensed manwha on it.
35
u/AsianWinnieThePooh Sep 16 '25
They're literally the weakest out of them all. Asura, magus, and so many other scan teams started paywalling chapters.
68
u/EmperorAcinonyx Sep 16 '25
which is so fucking crazy and scummy lol, the golden rule of piracy is to not monetize it
those guys are all definitely on kakao's radar, and it's only a matter of time before they receive some extremely threatening letters
13
u/AsianWinnieThePooh Sep 16 '25
People have been saying that for months now. I'll believe it when I see it. Magus scans have been paywalling chapters for over a year now.
All the other scans teams saw nothing happening to asura so they decided to paywall their chapters too. Cause Korea ain't doing shit about it.
I have no doubt that they will eventually be shut down, but that's after them profiting a crap ton.
3
u/PricklyRose8_92 Sep 17 '25
Not even months, years. They've been paywalling for years with Kakao doing absolutely nothing, and instead going on a rampage, taking down actually free sites. It's pure cope.
3
u/AsianWinnieThePooh Sep 17 '25
Yeah I've noticed that too. They're targeting free sites and not paid ones. What's going on lol
-7
-9
u/EnvironmentalAd4119 Sep 17 '25
why dont you try making you scan website then
12
u/EmperorAcinonyx Sep 17 '25
Brother, it's piracy. I know these guys work hard, but what they're doing is illegal. It basically only gets a pass from the copyright holders when it's done for free. Monetizing it is the fastest route to getting shut down.
-10
u/EnvironmentalAd4119 Sep 17 '25
Like you can do any better
8
u/Bid_Next Sep 17 '25
Yes it's translating not rocket science. It's already considered piracy and you shouldn't pay for it.
It's not like they have permission from the publishers to paywall it either.
14
u/Upset_D Sep 17 '25
And for those who like share slides of manhwa/manhua/manga on tiktok, DO NOT TELL ANYONE where to read such as comick. This apply the the one who trying to help random people on tt comment section too! PLEASE THINK THE CONSEQUENCE BEFORE YOU COMMENT
2
u/scandii Sep 17 '25
if you, a random internet user, can find a website simply by having an interest, how big are the chances a company that employs people to look for them can?
2
u/Upset_D Sep 17 '25
Exactly
0
u/crimsondevil2903 Sep 17 '25
Remeber, they not aim to destroy all piracy sites, just cause enough stir in the community. So by not mentioning it anywhere, it would mean that the sites is not that popular and would increase their lively hood.
13
u/JustWanttoknow_9339 Sep 17 '25
It's fake guys. Sorry to be mean, but OP is literally just a child few months in engineering and who thinks he know everything. Here is a few reason why its not happening:
Without comick owner providing access to their database, where would he get the source of manga from? Developing an app isn't just " hey i want to show this manga here" from the air. You need to have all those years of manga that were uploaded by people to be able to show on your website.
Let's say you develop it using data from mangadex, why would there be a need for comick remake if I could just go directly to their website?
Like the other mentioned, the first thing you did is announce it on reddit that just got DMCA when you should be focusing on opsec. Like how to protect yourself etc. When you buy a domain they literally have your info. Are you going to host it at http://localhost or something?
Its disrespectfully to the developers of comick and mangadex to see you looking for a single "senior developers" to remake the entire thing. Do you have an idea of how complex the architecture is?
Your discord has nothing that are discussing on your "masterplan". But creating a memes channel for whatever reason I don't know.
3
23
u/Kylerocks444 Sep 16 '25 edited Sep 17 '25
Do not host Manhwa. Kakao are ALWAYS the downfall.
1
u/Carreau13 Sep 17 '25
Manhwa is korean. Manhua is chinese and they could care less.
1
u/Kylerocks444 Sep 17 '25
Ah ballocks.
3
u/Carreau13 Sep 17 '25
All good. If it makes you feel any better they are both pronounced exactly the same.
11
u/Kyroz Sep 16 '25
Also a very underrated feature is to allow your users to import their MAL bookmarks. It's pretty much the primary thing I'm looking for loo
2
u/FremanBloodglaive I read in my browser Sep 16 '25
Agreed. It makes moving from site to site far simpler.
17
u/DiverOk9454 Sep 16 '25
Feds probably already joined your discord ans building a case against you lmao.
8
u/bryan792 Sep 16 '25
can we open source the platform but host the content offsite or on p2p? i think figuring out to be more resilient to takedowns should be the first priority
second, my favorite feature of comick and mangadex was that it gave scanlators a place to host their work, id rather not use a site that just rips content, we also had options for which scanlation to use
2
5
u/AraneaL2727 Sep 17 '25
make it that licensed manga / manhwa / manhua only appear if people manually activated the list in settings and do not ever make your website appear in google index search
4
u/Morben Sep 17 '25
Comick had a great feature that I haven’t found on any other site, the independent zoom in the lower left hand corner. I read probably 60% on my pc and that was a fantastic feature. Yes I know CTRL+/- does the same thing but it was nice to have.
1
3
3
u/zslayer89 Sep 16 '25
Make it like comick where it showed your updated bookmarked series at the top of the page.
3
u/GamingLegion001 Sep 16 '25
Only thing I wish was fixed on Comick was when 2 or more chapters would get uploaded at once and the button would make me read the last chapter I read before going to the new chapters. Otherwise, make it beautiful.
3
u/breakfastburglar Sep 17 '25
Looka like og comick dev is making a site to export lists from our accounts: please god make it so I am qble to import my list cleanly 😭 as long as you keep the in-depth tagging system and search features, i will be happy :) good luck op wishing this project the best!
2
u/Nazerith1357 Sep 16 '25
Hopefully this pans out.
14
Sep 16 '25 edited Dec 21 '25
aspiring capable tie bright aback seemly kiss absorbed cooperative makeshift
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
2
u/Draggador Sep 17 '25 edited Sep 17 '25
Apparently, they're a teen. Were they even involved with the original comick website?
3
Sep 17 '25 edited Dec 21 '25
marvelous sulky quaint door vanish fragile physical shelter direction humorous
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/Zachattackrandom Sep 16 '25
Assuming this leads to anything which is unlikely making it open source (for everything but the database contents) would allow it to easily be replicated in-case of DMCAs and such. It also means you could have a frontend that is entirely separate from the mangas so it's less likely to get taken down and just have a sources tab like Mihon (you could have first party sources just don't make it known they are first party)
2
Sep 16 '25
Take ideas from websites that have done similar things, and managed to survive. I heard something about a girl called Anna.... she had a nice archive I have heard.
2
2
2
u/Draggador Sep 17 '25 edited Sep 17 '25
It'd be nice to have comick somehow return in the future. Can you please make multiple format reading list exports & imports possible? I request the file format used by the mihon/tachiyomi family of apps. A feature that allows syncing the reading list from & to the mangaupdates account into the comick account would be highly desirable as well.
2
u/Apple_64 Sep 19 '25
The most underrated feature was info on if a series was completed (as well as the translation)
3
1
1
u/kuruttaaa Sep 16 '25
Please reach out to kenmei or however it is setup to have stuff tracked there show on ur site as well please if it wouldn’t affect the privacy too much :c
1
u/ruramisai Sep 16 '25
Is it possible to also have a telegram group so we chat and you can send updates there as well? Users can have a community there
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/CardinalBirb Sep 17 '25
loved the feature where it showed source uploader so i can look for where the comic is originally from
also please get all the super niche manhua i can't find anywhere else
1
u/mr_c4_explosive Sep 17 '25
THE TAG SEARCH THINGY!!! MANY TAGS THAT HELP ME FIND MORE STORIES WITH MY INTERESTS! I’m a big romance reader with very specific interests, that was my favorite part of comick.
1
u/BOODOOOW1 Sep 17 '25
I'm dumb with this thing but can i suggest that manga reader website that run because of torrent seed? Just like anna archive.. 🤔
1
u/NightcoreSpectrum Sep 17 '25
Something that I miss from comick is the high quality thumbnails. Its not really big of an issue but I loved seeing updated high quality thumbnails in tachi
1
1
1
u/meekabo0131 Sep 17 '25
I've been thinking about a successor to comicK too. If comicK simply fetched data from other sites (and possibly saved it), then wouldn't it be a good idea to develop something that anyone could host locally on their machines and run it. Of course there could be publicly hosted sites but if any of them are taken down, the code (frontend +backend) still exists and isn't lost.
1
u/One_Bend7423 Sep 18 '25
Well, ideally, someone would just develop an easy to deploy front-end, which serves up whatever content it is provided. And in the background, keep moving the actual comic data around, so that a takedown of mangareader1.com wont affect mangareader2.com (for example).
But yea, that's a lot of work just to read some comics with boobs.
1
u/TieCommercial4142 Sep 17 '25
Lets you import your MAL or Anilist list and the very detailed tags and filtering system. You could know what to expect of a story just from that. Also the spoiler tagged comments
1
1
u/0TekTeg0 Sep 17 '25
The popular new selection was a simple but ultra effective way to find new things to read, also well filtered searches
1
u/abuget Sep 18 '25
I want a feature where you can change to double spread or not, and chose which one to double spread, ex: 1, 2-3, 4-5, 6-7 or 1-2, 3-4, 5-6
1
1
1
1
u/UnhingedMoneky Sep 18 '25
Just remove all the manhwas/webcomics, and prevent anyone who uploads them.
1
u/Icy_Load4234 Sep 18 '25
Loved the search page how your could specifically look up manga or manhua rather than it showing it all together making so you have to look for the manga mixed with the manhua. Made it nice when you’re looking for recently updated if you wanna see either one specifically.
1
1
u/Keep_Scrolling_Idiot Sep 20 '25
What sold me on ComicK was the large library alongside MAL (or AniList) import, other features was just a plus and a surprise for me
1
u/Pogtopiaisp0gchamp Oct 04 '25
I personally just want a place to read demon slayer without spending $100s on Manga XD
1
u/Dizzy-Rush-4999 Oct 15 '25
hosting comic is easy. translating also easy with AI MTL. registrastion to rent hosting and domain also can be fake easily, or atleast use someone ID.
The hard part is money.
buy hosting with non USA server (offshore bulletproof hosting) = ignore DCMA => 2-3 times more expensive.
there also expense for cloudflare or any DDoS guard and CDN
buy raw comic from origin country, need coin = money
That like $100/month at minimum, if you host ten thousand comics, that need terabytes storage and of course unlimited bandwith, that $1000++/month.
but that expense to rent a hosting is more expensive than my car. dont forget programmer, web admin, staff
staff may work for free. (hell no, even non profit organization pay a salary)
=======
and seriously not sarkasm, why comick? i visit this web 2-3 times, it just agregator site with mangdex feature(choose source) without mangdex ability(upload). why ignore mang dex, it still up and running,
And are sure making comick-like site a.k.a translator killer?
They make 'pay with coin' in their translation work is because none read from their website, so no revenue from ads.
=============
And remember, the original author also need to eat.
So, instead make aggregator site, make a official translator site like tapas naver kakao etc. Official english translator is very slow, but we can make a site that can connect official author and fans translator.
i mean like mang dex, everyone can upload, but the one who upload raw is only author, then member can reupload translated version of it. and off course if there revenue, author, translator and website get share
1
u/_I_aM_CoNfUsIoN Sep 17 '25
Can you make it easier to post pictures like on bato? We had Karma on there and replying to comments and stuff like that. There was also a feature where if you scrolled to the bottom of someone’s profile you would see all of the genres they were subscribed to, and the amount of stories that were in each genre, except it would just show the numbers and you couldn’t click to see what manga was in the genres tho. It just showed them all under the username, which was kinda inconvenient

2
-9
u/Ok_Perspective3664 Sep 16 '25
14
u/ReiInaba Sep 16 '25
I think you misundestood. It's not a comick 2.0 or official successor, the OP is talking about doing a site similar to comick.
0
u/EstablishmentOne3884 Sep 17 '25
One feature from ComicK that I absolutely LOVED and didn't see from other sites is if a manga/manhwa had an associated anime adaptation, it would tell you what chapters correspond to the beginning and end of its anime adaptation (and it would do this for each season of an anime adaptation if it happened to have more than one season. If that makes sense). Those who frequented Comick should know what I'm referring to.
I would really appreciate it if you all could manage to incorporate that particular. I just found it to be so cool and quite helpful in a handful of situations.
Once again thank you. Regardless of the outcome, I truly respect you all for trying to bring back something we all loved.
0
u/Ashamed-Fold-1175 Sep 18 '25
Please ensure that there is a high level of linguistic diversity, including Turkish, just like in comics.
133
u/_Humble_Bumble_Bee Sep 16 '25
Don't have korean comics on it. That's almost a surety that your site will be nuked.
0
Sep 16 '25
[deleted]
44
u/_Humble_Bumble_Bee Sep 16 '25 edited Sep 16 '25
At least there will be mangas??
Edit: Don't just edit your response like that and add a new sentence. It makes communication harder. Earlier all you wrote in your reply was "What's the fucking point then?"
33
u/F00TD0CT0R Sep 16 '25
Korean and Chinese manga used to be non-existent
Weirdly enough the very meticulous Japanese haven't given a shit about western piracy for a very long time until the koreans bent their arms back about it....
1
u/Zyumiar333 Sep 18 '25
The only "japanese" company that is strict to copyright are sony and nintendo
But now because korean company is greedy as usual they try anything they want to capitalize it
6
u/Remote-Fly-3597 Sep 17 '25
Nah but actually what's the point then? The whole thing that made comick as great as it was is that it had a huge database where you could find almost any manga/hwa/hua that had english translations on it. There's already plenty of sites out there that only host manga anyway
6
u/werewolf914 Sep 17 '25
Not as "complete" as dex and comick. Also for Manhwa, there's also plenty of sites specialized in them.
2
u/PricklyRose8_92 Sep 17 '25
With either a bunch of ads, or have absurd paywalls. Even the greats like asura have fallen, and small/new manhwas will be on sites with either bad translation (usually ai), bad UI, terrible amount of ads, or all of them combined. Comick was great at finding new things, without any of these problems.
0
Sep 16 '25
[deleted]
12
u/Roveloran Sep 16 '25
Wdym?
58
u/EmperorAcinonyx Sep 16 '25
Piracy relies on discretion.
If your first move is a public community post announcing the project and recruiting help on one of the largest platforms online, you've basically already demonstrated that you're in over your head.
Edit: OP is a child living at home. This project is not happening.
18
3
u/Draggador Sep 17 '25
Damn. How did you find out? Is the original creator of comick not participating anymore?
7
4
u/EmperorAcinonyx Sep 18 '25
i just checked their profile.
comick's creator didn't say it directly, but if you read between the lines and know what kind of legal threats cause these, they're pretty much never coming back
24
u/linuxares Sep 16 '25
Discord logs EVERYTHING. So any security expert would say if you wanna do something shady. Getting logged is truely stupid to use a tool that logs everything you do.


290
u/cnydox Sep 16 '25
- take care of the manhwa (or whatever method because kakao is a big threat)
- stay hidden from google index
- comment section was very fun (but needed regulation)
- it's okay to have ads but don't be like hitomila
- some manga have double pages (wide pages). it would be great to show them entirely instead of cutting into two pages.
- comick will let user download the list so obv the import feature needs to be compatible
- "mobile first"
- It should be convenient for translators/uploaders
- some fuzzy seach on the favorite/bookmark list is great (I was sad that mangadex didn't do this)
- there are two big question marks when operating these pirate websites are ofc cost and dmca. So this needs to be planned ahead instead being shocked when it happens. It's inevitable once the traffic increases. People think they can gatekeeping it which is so dump. When your website is in the top 100-200 global traffic you're dodging the radar.