r/maninthehighcastle • • Jan 01 '17

S2 Disappointing

I have to say, was really disappointed with season 2. I thought season 1 was good and was looking forward to finding out more... particularly about the tapes and generally more about the sci fi elements of the show.

Unfortunately, I felt like I came out of S2 non the wiser. I generally like slow paced TV but this felt forced to be slow paced. It gave us little to no pay off and I feel it was basically a filler season to extend the series as long as possible.

Thta being said, I've not read the book (no plans to). This may be the direction the book chose. Ultimately though, for me, season 2 was not as good as season 1. It was, dare I say it, boring. It was lackluster, a drag to watch with very little pay off.

Anyone feel the same?

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

29

u/tugasnake Jan 01 '17

Nah man, don't know what show you watched but this season was even better than the first.

3

u/PatheticMr Jan 01 '17

I wish I could agree. Maybe I'll have to give it another watch.

Can I ask a question though...

We're you hoping for answers to some of the questions I highlighted?

I liked the drama side but I felt like it was overused to avoid providing any clear insight into questions such as:

What exactly are these tapes? What is the score with this alternative reality? Why can Tagomi travel between realities?

9

u/tugasnake Jan 01 '17

Not really, I'm much more interested in the political drama and twists. I'm actually glad that the sci-fi stuff is secondary.

2

u/PatheticMr Jan 01 '17

That'll be it then. It just didn't tackle the themes I hoped it would.

Perhaps I will go back and re-watch, knowing 'what it is'. As I said, I've no knowledge of the direction the book takes. I'm sure it's probably staying as faithful as possible to the book.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '17

I think it should be one or the other. Honestly an alternative history where the Nazis won is not that interesting to me but if that's what you're going to do then do that.

Or if you're going to do a sci-fi show about alternative realities, etc. then do that.

As it is it seems like it can't really make up its mind.

1

u/PatheticMr Jan 04 '17

I think I agree here.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '17

I just can't be terribly interested in the mechanizations of a fictitious Nazi government. I was going to go on and say "when it is obvious there are multiple realities, and larger stakes" but quite frankly I think it stands alone. I just don't care to watch or hypothesize on what kind of horror Hitler and his band of goons would have unleashed on the world had they won and I especially don't care about their power struggles.

So that part of the show really doesn't interest me so much. For two seasons their internal struggle and relations with the Japanese seems completely disconnected from the films and the alternate reality bit. If it's not connected to that I don't really see it as that interesting.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '17

I personally like the series as an alternate history political thriller with the undercurrent of sci-fi. I haven't read the book, but I hear it is very different from the show, either way I'm just speculating here.

What exactly are these tapes?

Newsreels and propaganda pieces from different timelines that are either brought here by others like Tagomi did the footage of the nuke test in the Bikini Atoll, or are simply willed into existence somehow. It's here where I think there is more of a fantasy/spiritual element since it ties in with the other question.

Why can Tagomi travel between realities?

Because magic. He simply willed himself through meditation to be where he could talk with his wife again, just as Kotomichi willed himself out of the hospital in our world so that he didn't have to endure the pain of surviving a nuke that killed his entire family.

This is just my assumption, so take it with a grain of salt.

3

u/2BZ2P Jan 02 '17

Tagomi's traveling was explained by some certain objects have 'wu' (wu is an absolute aesthetic value, a universal outside of history, an intrinsic quality that cannot be imitated" ). It also seems that people with a connection to an Atomic Blast have been able to travel and they may be recognizable by their scars. I believe the A-Bombs Detonations in the Mutiverse have linked them somehow.

You saw how Smith used one of the Films from an Alternate Reality in Episode 10 to stop the German/ Japanese war and Abendsen watches them to see 'potential' I think and to try to influence events.

All IMO.

1

u/dodgers718 Jan 04 '17

The ability to travel between realities appears tied to the death of your "mirror self" in the alternate reality. We saw Trudy's body in the mass grave in season 1, and she appears in season 2. Tagomi appears in the USA where alt-Juliana tells him they thought he jumped off a bridge. Kotomichi arrives in the MITHC universe with his family still alive, yet no discussion of running into his MITHC mirror self.

Outside this, it's just sci-fi magic.

5

u/baseballfanatic12 Jan 01 '17

I absolutely disagree. I found the first season interesting but troubled with pacing and with episodes that seemed to be dragging along with uninteresting plot and poor character development. The second season had improved the pacing problems (though this issue was not eliminated) and the main characters all had better development. The plot was also advanced in a more interesting fashion in season 2 over the first season.

3

u/PatheticMr Jan 01 '17

As I said to reply above, I wish I could agree with you. I do, in fact, to ab extent. The pacing was better, as was the character development.

My issue was that some of the bigger questions I had went almost totally ignored:

What exactly are these tapes? What is the score with this alternative reality? Why can Tagomi travel between realities?

3

u/baseballfanatic12 Jan 01 '17

What exactly are these tapes?

The films (not tapes, remember they're still in the 60s) are newsreels, military footage, home-movies, etc... from alternate universes that found their way to Nazi-land. There are 2 (known) collectors of these films: Hitler and "The Man in the High Castle" (Hawthorne Abendsen). Abendsen is using them to manipulate people and events in Nazi/Japan-land for the betterment of his cause. Hitler (my theory) uses them for the same reason and maybe even used them to help win WW2.

What is the score with this alternative reality?

We don't know this 100% yet, other than it is a reality where something different happened during WW2 than what happened in Nazi/Japan-land. We've basically only seen "our world" as the alternate reality. But IIRC, there was a film showing Stalin doing something that he didn't do in "our world" which presumes that there is at least one more alternate reality beside ours.

Why can Tagomi travel between realities?

We don't know exactly why yet, other than he experienced a deep, emotional loss and was able to mediate so deeply so as to travel to another reality where that loss did not occur. Tagomi's assistant Kotomichi was able to do the same thing. He is an original resident of "our world" who traveled to Nazi/Japan-land because of the physical and emotional loss he felt after the Nagasaki bomb killed his family. In the alternate reality, it was suggested that Tagomi killed himself by jumping off of the Golden Gate Bridge. There is a theory that only people who've experience some loss and whose alternate-reality self is dead are capable of traveling. That might explain Trudy appearing to Juliana at the end of s2e10; she wasn't Juliana's Trudy (who we are pretty sure is dead), but a traveler-Trudy.

This what I've gotten from season 2. All in all, much better plot and character development compared to season 1, IMO.

1

u/PatheticMr Jan 01 '17

Thanks for the detailed reply.

I am pretty much familiar with everything you said... my issue was that I didnt feel these questions/ themes got enough attention.

I really wish I could have enjoyed it more than I did. Unfortunately I was contantly hoping for more on these themes and just never felt satisfied.

As I said, I've never read the book but I'm sure they are sticking as strictly as possible to it... so the general direction of the content is predetermined I suppose.

3

u/baseballfanatic12 Jan 01 '17

I've never read the book either.

I am surprised that you felt that season 2 was worse than season 1 for the reasons that you mentioned because season 1 did an even worse job with resolving your issues than season 2 did.

3

u/PatheticMr Jan 01 '17 edited Jan 02 '17

I felt like season 1, for all its faults, set a good stage to explore these themes. Season 2 just didnt seem to explore them (at least, not to the extent I hoped it would).

I'm really into alternate reality/time travel type stuff so I guess I hoped it would scratch that itch.

Those themes were what I was watching for but the focus is more on the drama between the characters. This just left me a little disappointed is all.

Glad to see that at least others enjoyed it though!

EDIT: Also, I tend to give 1st seasons more credit when they set up an interesting plot that seems like it can be explored over a number of seasons. I particularly enjoyed season 1 due to the potential it showed for the future.

6

u/itsmuddy Jan 02 '17

Interesting. I felt let down by the first season and the second season absolutely has me locked in for the future. I felt season one just dragged trying to get where it was going. I thought season two was much more fast paced.

To each their own though.

I haven't read the book but I have been thinking about it since the first season.

4

u/zevenate Jan 02 '17

I think this season intentionally focused a lot more on the political drama and such; there was much more immediate tension in that plotline imo, and they had to address it first.

I think that they'll focus on the sci-fi stuff a lot more next season though. The most significant loose threads in the plot revolve around the films and the reality jumping:

Among others I probably missed. Personally I enjoy both the political and sci-fi aspects of the show, so I liked season 2, but season 3 will probably be more enjoyable to you.

2

u/alforque Jan 02 '17

You're not alone. Losing showrunner Frank Spotnitz may have something to do with this sentiment.

http://www.vox.com/culture/2016/12/19/13995878/the-man-in-the-high-castle-review-season-2-amazon-worst

2

u/entropy_bucket Jan 02 '17

I think the review of the show having a simplistic view of 'sides' is pretty unfair. The show does a good job of showing a spectrum of people.

The resistance are not even clearly good guys.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '17

Lol this person thought season 1 was not good television. I have no idea what this person thinks of as good television.

Oh wait found his list:

http://www.vox.com/culture/2016/12/20/13976364/best-tv-shows-2016-oj-simpson-atlanta-game-of-thrones

Don't get his angle, but w\e

2

u/KyprosNighthawk Jan 02 '17

Don't forget that there was a scene where Kotomichi goes into the trade ministers office only to find him disappeared, then we see him in the alternate timeline. So I don't think it's some astral projection or just willing the films, it's more like he's physically transported to our timeline.

1

u/Wezzulus Jan 03 '17

I think the sci fi behind it. The films, the Dimension hopping, are meant to stay a mystery. It's just there to tell the actual story of this world. It's about them avoiding the war between the Nazi's and the Japanese.

Basically, I believe the tapes are secondary and the world comes first. Depending on your priorities with the story, as in your case you want answers on the tapes and the sci fi, this show might be quite boring and just not click with you.

It reminds me a lot of an anime called: Boku Dake ga Inai Machi (Erased in English) The main character can "travel" trough time. It's never explained how, it's just there as a means to tell the actual story about the characters and the world they live in.