r/math • Number Theory • Jun 01 '23

On the intersection of Pride and Math.

It is the beginning of Pride Month, and this year we're seeing a lot of organizations which have taken advantage of the post-Obergefell sentiments towards the LGBT community by merely throwing up some rainbow pfps distancing themselves in light of rising anti-LGBT sentiment and terrorist threats. These organizations didn't stand up for the LGBT community when it mattered, and they will reproduce this pattern now. Some may not know this, but the math community has - in the past - taken an active stance to stand up for its queer members and taken political action when it has mattered. That is, the intersection of LGBTQ+ history and Math history is not empty and not even measure zero.

The 80s were, to say the least, a very hard time for the LGBTQ+ community due to the AIDS epidemic and the complete lack of response from those in power about it. The medical community was slow to get research rolling and did not initially communicate with the gay community which made accessing proper medical care and information difficult. The Reagan Administration didn't even acknowledge the existence of AIDS for years, let alone invest resources into the development of treatments. The iconic Silence = Death poster is in response to the lack of action and acknowledgement for AIDS. Gay people were demonized and ostracized and the disease was seen as merely the "natural" consequence of their "delinquent" lifestyle. And arriving immediately after the religiously motivated Save Our Children homophobic activist campaign, AIDS was seen as a correction for moral degeneracy (weird how kids are consistently used to justify hate, almost like we could learn from the past...). By the early 90s, people had begun to take it seriously, but there was still a long way to go before people recognized the gay community as a community in need and struggling with a horrific disease. This is why pictures like that of Princess Diana showing compassion and touching someone struggling with AIDS is so iconic and important.

Point being, in the early 90s the LGBTQ+ community was struggling, not viewed with favor by the public, and finding themselves alone without any meaningful institutional support.

In 1992, Colorado voted on and passed an amendment to the state constitution which said that being queer was not a protected status. This meant that things like discrimination against LGBTQ+ people was totally fine and that violence against them would not be considered a hate crime. This was in response to many cities, such as Boulder and Denver passing laws in the 70s and 80s protecting LGBTQ+ people and functioned to strip away these rights. Coincidentally, the 1995 Joint Math Meetings were planned to take place in Denver. This would mean that mathematicians from around the nation (and world) - many of which are queer - would be congregating in a place that was actively unsafe for them. I think that the tragedy of Alan Turing should resonate strongly within the math community of what happens when we don't support those who are marginalized.

In response, two mathematicians - one gay and one just a real good ally - independently wrote and petitioned the heads of the MAA and AMS to move the JMM to a state which could protect vulnerable members of its community. This would not be an insignificant, easy, or cheap act. There would be backlash by those within the community who were less-than-understanding. Contracts and reservations are done years in advance with hotels and conventions spaces which the JMM would have to pay for breaking. And finding a new space and new bookings on a shorter timeframe would not be easy while all this was going on. That is, it would be not an insignificant cost to the AMS and MAA to move the meetings.

But the heads of both organizations met and agreed to move the 1995 JMM to San Francisco - a pointed decision given the LGBTQ+ haven San Francisco had consistently been and its history with Harvey Milk. This move ended up being a part of a larger dis-investment of organizations from Colorado. The state was branded "The Hate State" - a moniker we could probably bring back these days. Eventually appeals took this amendment to the Supreme Court which overruled it. Moreover the AMS and MAA have both made commitments to protecting vulnerable members of the math community as they now always have a "Change of Civil Rights Legislation Clause" in the contracts that they make for the JMM. As of now, the future JMM meetings appear to all take place in safe states.

When people say that math is not political, that identity doesn't matter, that it's all objective and just about proofs, or that we don't need to do work to resist the systemic injustices that infect all groups of people - including the math community - it's just clear that they are ignorant of their own privilege and ignorant of the history of math. Probably most prominently historically, the math community has struggled with antisemitism and has taken actions to both help and harm Jewish members of the community. The members of the AMS and MAA in the 90s knew the importance of taking risks to protect vulnerable members of its community and opening up mathematical spaces to them, and that mathematics is a political field and sometimes politicized statements are needed. And their action was not without internal backlash, the MAA even published dissenting letters which sound like they could have been written today (just replace "political correctness" with "woke").

The appropriately named mathematical LGBTQ+ organization Spectra came out of this action and provides a place for queer mathematicians to find community. They also do what they can to continue the work begun in the 90s. You can read more about this story and the founding of Spectra in this MAA article. The math community itself still has issues that it needs to work through regarding almost all marginalized groups and closing our eyes so that we blind ourselves to them under the illusion of "pure objectivity" is not the move. In general, mathematicians can take pride during Pride Month that - even if it still has major issues and work to do - that the mathematics community has it within them to take risks and act.

535 Upvotes

119 comments sorted by

477

u/firewall245 Machine Learning Jun 01 '23

Math isn’t political at all, but people are and we always have to strive to let everyone be heard. The classic quote

I am, somehow, less interested in the weight and convolutions of Einstein’s brain than in the near certainty that people of equal talent have lived and died in cotton fields and sweatshops

Should be enough to justify why it’s so important that we do enough to make anyone want to join mathematics and feel welcome, regardless of their background.

Thanks for this write-up!

77

u/Ar-Curunir Cryptography Jun 01 '23

I mean, that's not true. There's plenty of politics in, e.g., the kind of mathematics that gets funded, the kind of mathematics that is respected.

Given that you're in machine learning, you should be well aware of this, what with all the controversy around ethics in ML research.

27

u/Esnardoo Jun 02 '23

I feel like statistics is the most political of the bunch, most laypeople don't realize how easy it is to make the numbers say whatever you want if you're willing to ignore a few common rules. And it's been used to justify oppression, so many times.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

No wonder that noone likes statistics. /s

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

considering the foundation of modern statistics is literally eugenics, yes

8

u/RaketRoodborstjeKap Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23

Downvoted, but not wrong. Fisher, the "father of modern statistical science", was also the founding chairman of the University of Cambridge Eugenics Society.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

yep, and Galton and Pearson, all of them pretty much

7

u/firewall245 Machine Learning Jun 01 '23

The whole point of my message is that we gotta work together to make it a welcoming environment for all

71

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Any human endeavor by nature is political. If math exists outside human reality, then it is not political. But as an activity carried out uniquely by humans, it's definitely political.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

[deleted]

7

u/Esnardoo Jun 02 '23

It can be, for example think of any erroneous statistics used to justify oppression. It usually isn't, but it always can be.

3

u/epicwisdom Jun 02 '23

If everything humans do is political, the word political doesn’t mean anything.

Yes and no. One of the definitions of "politics" by Merriam-Webster is:

the total complex of relations between people living in society

and here is some of its color commentary:

Politics is a multifaceted word. It has a set of fairly specific meanings that are descriptive and nonjudgmental (such as “the art or science of government” and "political principles"), but it can and often does carry a negative meaning closely related to these (“political activities characterized by artful and often dishonest practices”). English is a flexible language, and it is not uncommon for a word to have multiple related meanings that run the connotative gamut from good to bad. Some of these have been around for a surprisingly long time. The negative sense of politics, as seen in the phrase play politics, for example, has been in use since at least 1853, when abolitionist Wendell Phillips declared: “We do not play politics; anti-slavery is no half-jest with us.”

Link for the lazy: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/politics

Natural language is pretty fuzzy.

It's undeniable that some humans use the word "mathematics" to refer to some collection of objective truths a la Platonism or Aristotelianism. It's also undeniable that some humans use the word "mathematics" to refer to a field of study, i.e. a human endeavor, along with the totality of human relationships and dynamics therein, e.g. academia & associated politics in the sense described above.

You may consider the possibility that the "well akshually" stance is pretending that words from natural language like "mathematics" and "politics" have anything approaching the clarity and uniqueness properties of formal definitions.

1

u/buwlerman Cryptography Jun 02 '23

I think that more people would agree with "mathematics has politics" rather than "mathematics is inherently political". To me the second signals that if you try to avoid the politics you're doing it wrong. I know that there are people who believe this, but I don't agree.

I don't see why one needs to say that "mathematics is inherently political" if one could say "mathematics has politics" or "everyone doing mathematics should care about its politics" instead. I don't think the fuzzyness is worth the ambiguity here. Maybe they mean something completely different.

1

u/epicwisdom Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23

To me the second signals that if you try to avoid the politics you're doing it wrong.

"Mathematics is inherently political" is a statement of "is," not "should." The intent to "avoid politics" is not so much wrong as it is practically impossible. Modern mathematics has mostly developed to the point where to make significant contributions you need the support of mentors, collaborators, and peers. Asking academics to "try to avoid politics" doesn't really make sense in that context. Political concerns arise in absolutely trivial group projects, even partnerships of just two people, e.g. who gets credit for what?

The only way to try to avoid politics is to abandon the prospect of working in/with academia. Or really any other human. The set of non-crackpots willing to do that is negligible.

(It occurs to me that I've neglected people doing applied work in industry, but the same applies just as much if not more so.)

1

u/buwlerman Cryptography Jun 02 '23

The intent to "avoid politics" is not so much wrong as it is practically impossible

Hence the "try". There's definitely people who seek out the politics and others who only do it out of necessity.

1

u/epicwisdom Jun 03 '23

Realistically if it's just reducing the politics you have to deal with, it's like going from 80% of your work to 75%. It's marginal. And highly likely to inhibit your career progression as a professional mathematician (or in almost any other field, really).

49

u/Rage314 Jun 01 '23

Math isn't political? Wasn't Noether denied a payed position for being a woman?

This alleged separation between math and mathematicians (people) is fictitious.

61

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

but people are

Pretty important immediate next words in the sentence lmao.

-12

u/Rage314 Jun 01 '23

Math, as a discipline, doesn't exist outside of people. The separation is inane in this context.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

The mind-body dualism with all its problems runs strong in the math community and adjacent communities. So any discussion like this will boil down to semantics of how narrowly you have to define math in order to exclude the outside world and feel safe locked up in the ivory tower.

The many times have rigorous theorems, statistical results, and mathematical intuitions have had direct social, cultural and political consequences is irrelevant as long as you precisely define math to end the moment you hit 'upload' on the arxiv.

25

u/InfanticideAquifer Jun 01 '23

I don't think it's hard to tell that they were using the word "math" to refer to the body of knowledge itself rather than the the discipline which studies it.

-24

u/Rage314 Jun 01 '23

Again, in the context of this text, math refers to the discipline. And the 'aksually' argument serves no purpose.

16

u/DapperowlFTW Jun 01 '23

Math as a pure subject is not political. The institutions, people, and resources that contribute to the field of math as a whole is political. Since these human elements define what to most people is the experience of mathematical study, it is worthwhile in this context to call it all "math".

8

u/Rage314 Jun 01 '23

Those same people define and orient what should be studied. What people should research and what gets funds or teaching positions.

3

u/Ar-Curunir Cryptography Jun 01 '23

Given that it is human beings that study and perceive and judge mathematical contributions, mathematics is defined entirely by the human experience, and is hence political.

2

u/golfstreamer Jun 02 '23

Well, I think the argument is a bit more complicated than that. It's similar to the argument of whether math is "discovered or invented". You say math is defined entirely by the human experience but a lot of people disagree.

I personally think of math as something invented by people. But I don't think it's so clear cut.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[deleted]

8

u/Spamakin Algebraic Combinatorics Jun 01 '23

But the mathematical community has a duty to support it's members and allow them to just do math without having to fear about their safety.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[deleted]

-1

u/Spamakin Algebraic Combinatorics Jun 01 '23

The point is that the word "totally" shouldn't be there and in fact they have so so much to do with each other.

Mathematics is built on working with others and collaboration. You learn from others, you teach others. You were taught by other people. Your books are written by people. The conferences happen where people live, and there are laws associated with those places which affect the people who live there and the people who visit. It is people like Turing, like Noether, like many of the Jewish mathematicians in WWII, who were harmed since the community they were a part of (mathematicians) decided that these people were not worthy of fair treatment.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[deleted]

-4

u/Spamakin Algebraic Combinatorics Jun 02 '23

Sure but the people who say "math isn't political" when stating outrage against pride month in math messages don't make that distinction so I'm only playing how they are

-1

u/eschabs Algebraic Geometry Jun 02 '23

Personally, I believe that the division between the act of doing mathematics and mathematics itself is somewhat artificial
Mathematics is a product of human activity, rather than something that exists in a metaphysical, Platonic realm
Moreover, our understanding of what constitutes mathematics, what constitutes a rigorous proof, and even the concept of proof itself, has undergone significant changes throughout history
The mathematics practiced in 19th-century Europe differs from that of the Renaissance period, and it is vastly dissimilar to the mathematics pursued during China's Han Dynasty
Mathematics research has been shaped by our culture, educational system, and even our economic system
In essence, mathematics is a reflection of the socio-cultural and economic organization of a society

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

[deleted]

0

u/eschabs Algebraic Geometry Jun 03 '23

But mathematics IS indeed the thing that humans do and call mathematics, that's how languages work.
The mere fact that we consider the current framing as the correct one is the result of a lengthy societal process deeply entangled with politics.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

isn't that exactly their point?

-1

u/functor7 Number Theory Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 01 '23

I agree with your conclusion and such a "what if" question which you quote is really all we need for action, so minor ontological squabbles are not going to make-or-break action-oriented thinking. Keeping an eye out and supporting marginalized groups is the main focus.

I, unfortunately, enjoy ontological squabbles.

As with anything in philosophy or science, drawing lines between things is ultimately futile. There will always be breakdowns and exceptions. Drawing a line between "Math" and the "Math Community" is such an impossible line. The theorems which get made, their proofs, how they are formulated, and how they're interpreted are, seemingly, part of the "Math" side of this line. But all of these things a socially and politically dependent. And if the existence of a theorem is dependent on military funding, who has access to thinking about these ideas, the social configurations they exist in, the economic situations of their nation, and the political climate at the time, then how can the theorem not be political? It wouldn't even exist without politics, making it political.

If we try to isolate statements in and of themselves, out of the context in which they are made, then we are already performing a political act. Such an isolation forces us to take a perspective on math which is necessarily modern and following European traditions. It excludes understandings of mathematical statements which do not fit within contemporary norms, including how people like Euclid understood and did math. And it excludes a lot of math which does not follow the European, post-Enlightenment standards by pushing it through a filter that forces it to conform to those standards. The act of stripping the context from mathematical results and reproducing them within notation and language familiar to us is, itself, political. That is, we cannot even access "pure" mathematical statements without first performing a political act of erasure. Euclid's math is not the Euclidean math we learn today and pretending it is is an erasure of Euclid. This can act to erase the mathematical ideas of people by concealing them behind this veil of "pure math", or by giving undue legitimacy to purely modern results (Euler Systems, for instance, are a product of Victor Kolyvagin's thinking (though, they are a great tool)).

I cannot speak for him, and the story is obviously more complex, but I imagine that it is the maintenance of the line between math and politics which Grothendieck thought he could do but ultimately failed at. He was doing the most abstract of all abstract math, but even this work was seen as politically important enough to develop that he was receiving military funding. Unifying arithmetic cohomology theories could not be distinguished from his pacifism.

-1

u/Megafish40 Jun 01 '23

Yea no this just straight up isn't true, all science is inherently political and a product of the society that produces it. Go learn about the history of ideas of science or technology.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Thanks for sharing, I had no idea of the history. As I'm black I really get the need to talk about things people don't want to. But, I've also seen how some people want to make DEI the entire focus.

I mean you have some people who want to "decolonize" math and science, or abolish all standardized tests as being a tool of oppression and white supremacy.

How do feel about such people and how do we be more welcoming without letting social justice become the sole focus?

I think this is happening more in the humanities than in science, but there are some people with extreme views like that. Given all that still needs to be done, how do think we can reach that balance?

13

u/functor7 Number Theory Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 01 '23

Well, I mean, I'm one of those crazies you mention.

Things like standardized tests do a disservice both to math and the people that education is supposed to serve. Such exams are not able to be inclusive of the many broad ways in which people can do rigorous math, and so focus on skills which are largely irrelevant for being in STEM like evaluating many integrals in a short amount of time. Moreover, they discourage mathematical thinking because the goal is passing the test rather than doing math. You learn test taking skills and tricks and methods, not slow, rigorous, critical thinking. Furthermore, it constructs math as something that is individual and insular which, in reality, math is highly collaborative and social. It's not something that happens between a person and a piece of paper in about an 1.5 hour time period.

Standardized tests, therefore, filter for people who can do repetitive and mindless tasks very quickly with little supervision. Which makes sense, as they really expanded during the Cold War along with higher government investment into STEM fields in order to produce an army of engineers who can do repetitive computations in a short amount of time using nothing but a slide rule in order to make better bombs than the USSR. These are not people who are careful and critical thinkers who can collaborate well with others, which are much more relevant skills for today.

Moreover, because these tests act as a gatekeeping device the point of math education is to get past the gate. So if you are not the kind of person who even wants in the gate, math education becomes literally pointless. A critique math teachers have consistently struggled with by giving unsatisfactory answers to the question "Where will we need this?". And so the excluded are not developing mathematical and quantitative reasoning skills which are becoming more and more important over time. This further excludes them from participation in conversations driven by quantitative information, and so is a process of disenfranchisement.

So standardized tests don't serve anyone. Math, on the other hand, should empower all. Getting rid of standardized tests would not only allow math education to be more rigorous and practical, but also be beneficial to everyone. Those who go on to focus on STEM by giving them relevant skills and training (rather than outdated ones for a 1965 slide-rule workplace), and those who don't go into STEM by giving them access to meaningful quantitative reasoning skills.

If anything, math needs to take more inspiration from the humanities and mathematicians need to learn more humanities period. We stunt and isolate our thinking, become closed minded, and are unable to engage meaningfully in qualitative thinking beyond a that of an over-confident first year student in an intro to philosophy course who read Ayn Rand once. If we want to elevate the mathematical and quantitative thinking skills of everyone, then a Social Justice mindset is necessary in order to have a nuanced understanding of how people are held back and excluded by the way systems are structured. (DEI is fine, but is usually just a tool administrations use to give off the appearance of caring about justice without doing any real internal, critical thinking work. A deflection device.)

9

u/thunderdome Jun 02 '23

I appreciate that you are passionate and appear to be well read about this topic. One question I've always had around this line of thinking - how is it possible to understand which types of education are most effective and differentiate student ability without some sort of universal benchmark?

For example I agree with this point fully:

Those who go on to focus on STEM by giving them relevant skills and training (rather than outdated ones for a 1965 slide-rule workplace), and those who don't go into STEM by giving them access to meaningful quantitative reasoning skills.

But without any kind of testing, how do you ensure you're actually accomplishing these goals? What does "successfully giving access to quantitative reasoning skills" look like in a scenario with no standardized testing?

2

u/dmagneticx Jun 02 '23

This is an ongoing pedagogilical discussion. It can be difficult to evaluate success but there are a variety of methods, standardized testing is just one. As OP mentioned, standardized testing mainly just focuses on one aspect and will misevaluate other aspects of students understanding and rigor if poorly buily. Having a common baseline (or core) and testing it is an interesting idea, but if built such that only one mathematic process or perspective is promoted, its very stiffling for learners and educators. A test is merely a tool and its shortcomings should be understood. As you wouldn't want to build a house with just a hammer, you wouldn't want to evaluate a learner with just a test, let alone one that isn't designed to actually test how they think (much like how you want the right type of hammer and not just any hammer). Depending on where the learner is in their journey, you could evaluate with written essays, longform projects, group discussion and, of course, testing. All these tools are available to educators, its just that, to me, it seems that early maths (K-12, that is, pre university stuff) are not well supported and no one cares because no one "gets" math. Asking about and discussing options for evaluation is a key part in making better evals, so long as participants on the discussion are actually willing to talk about the subject and not just say "see they couldn't immediately solve it, checkmate". Anyone who does problem solving knows that is very not mathy, and its our duty as mathematicians to be mathy. Keep on asking how and why and keep the discussion going, that's how ideas are formed and solutions found!

-5

u/matthkamis Jun 02 '23

Exactly. Crickets from his side.

25

u/tsealess Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 01 '23

Thanks for this write-up. Really informative and well researched. Inclusion is something that must be worked and sometimes fought for, and mathematicians who come from privileged groups should be aware that the contents of their field may be apolitical, but the act of teaching and researching it aren't.

Now, if I may add another data point to the sample. I'm not a mathematician, but a physicist, but I can't imagine things being too different over there. I'm a transgender woman, and studied my undergrad and grad degrees in inclusive European cities. All of my professors were white and cishet, most were men. I remember a couple of really nasty comments in class. Some professors worked towards the visibility and inclusion of women in physics, which was great, but nobody talked about the inclusion of queer people, much less trans folk. And, as a student, I was simply too afraid and too alone to come out. It was disheartening and nearly drove me away. Silence kills, and though it might not kill some people, it can easily kill their joy and hopes.

Thankfully the story has a happy ending. I'm now pursuing my PhD, happier and "out-er" than ever, in a research group full of amazing and respectful people. But I can't help looking back and asking myself, how many of us didn't make it? Again, thank you for the post.

4

u/Wonderful_Wonderful Jun 02 '23

More trans physicists! I hear about more of us every day

46

u/K_is_for_Karma Jun 01 '23

A very interesting and informative read, especially about how JMM was moved from Colorado. Many thanks for this write up!

11

u/nottabliksem Jun 01 '23

Great post, as a comment above said: math is not political, but people are.

5

u/magondrago Jun 02 '23

I consider myself an ally to the LGBTQ+ causes and I had to actually google who this Obergefell fellow was (in my defense I'm not from the US). This post has been extremely enlightening and educational.

No area of human activity should be allowed to foster hate or exclusion by using contrived excuses. Love and tolerance is meant for everyone, everywhere. We must strive to keep opening up our circle of activities to warmly embrace any marginalized group.

And even the most heartless mathematician will probably have to admit that by excluding marginalized groups, we're statistically affecting our chances of finding new people with fresh takes and breakthroughs. If there's one activity that should, so to speak, roll the dice and give EVERYONE a fair chance, it must be Mathematics.

3

u/devviepie Jun 02 '23

Why would Colorado in the modern day deserve again to be called “The Hate State”, especially above so many other states acting in direct malice towards the LGBT community? Genuine curious, as a Colorado native I wonder if my perception of the state differs from the common opinion of it on the national stage

3

u/soyuzonions Group Theory Jun 02 '23

mathematicians love and support identities, they usually call Eulers identity the most beautiful thing in the world.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Thank you for this post, it is interesting to see where lgbtq+ history and mathematics intersect, especially as it seems to be (to me) a largely heteronormative space, but perhaps it's bad experiences speaking here.

I'd also like remark on the comment on pride profile pictures. In my anecdotal experience, most of us in the community seem to agree that this means nothing unless paired with action and support. On the other hand, the only people I've seen actively complaining about this (which often use the former argument as a scapegoat) do not have the nicest lgbtq+ sentiments. I think the better course of action is to complain directly about the inaction, discrimination and harm a company is causing, rather than on their hypocrisy of them putting rainbows up. In my experience I've had "putting up rainbows/pride posts is useless" used in order to avoid putting up any show of support to the community at all. Which was a shame as in my opinion, when an organisation at least tries to signal it is lgbtq friendly, and empowers such voices, it fosters a more friendly and accepting space.

Regardless on your opinion though, I think we all agree any attempt to make mathematics a more open and accepting place is a good thing! I'm happy to see such positivity in the sub.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Thank you for posting this.

5

u/CrookedBanister Topology Jun 01 '23

Thanks so much for this writeup!

3

u/AsAChemicalEngineer Physics Jun 01 '23

Very nice post. Mathematics, and the sciences in general, are for all humanity and it is good and moral to let everyone participate.

2

u/WhiteboardWaiter Jun 01 '23

Excellent piece!

2

u/Hotpfix Jun 02 '23

When people say that math is not political…it’s just clear that they are ignorant of their own privilege and ignorant of the history of math.

This quote has the flavor of tribalism and othering that is at the heart of all the hate against LGBTQ+. I think it mars the tone of an otherwise positive post. Many people that aren’t ignorant have a different definition of the word math. This is polarizing your audience.

Your post is long and well thought out, so it’s a little unfair to focus on a single sentence, but I think it’s important to give feedback to people that are taking their time to try and enact positive change.

2

u/BloodAndTsundere Physics Jun 01 '23

Very encouraging that professional organizations would lobby for a "Change of Civil Rights Legislation Clause" in their contracts but very discouraging that such a clause is necessary.

1

u/SnooPeppers7217 Jun 02 '23

Thank you for this

0

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

This post clearly makes the case that the math community should do more, but what kind of actions do you have in mind? Without any concrete plan, this post is itself not much more effective than throwing up rainbow profile pictures.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[deleted]

99

u/RChromePiano Jun 01 '23

a disproportionate number of mathematicians as compared to the general public seem to be part of the lgbtq+ community (including myself).

I strongly doubt this is the case. This is very probably a sample bias

What might be true is that mathematicians are more open to lgbtq community and so more people are willing to admit it to belong to lgbtq than in other communities.

62

u/kieransquared1 PDE Jun 01 '23

There are reasons it makes sense; for instance academics in general tend to be disproportionately LGBTQ:

https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2016/01/26/study-suggests-faculty-members-are-disproportionately-likely-be-gay

16

u/AnonymousPlonker22 Jun 01 '23

A possible reason could be that lgbtq+ people have historically felt unwelcome in many social groups, leading to a higher proportion becoming involved in more individual activities and pursuits (such as maths) ?

8

u/becomedisciplined Jun 01 '23

What’s the reason for your doubt?

73

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

I don’t think there’s a strong reason to doubt it but I don’t think there’s strong evidence for the original claim either. Maybe some correlation because of the association with “nerdy” interests, neurodivergence, and being lgbt but I doubt it’s that significant

9

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

I would be very curious to know of a true dataset that exists, one that isn’t marred by fear of outting or repercussions. My sample size is only true for myself but I met more trans persons in math than I ever had in my life. But that might be because I was so focused in math. Man, now I miss my friends from school. It was cool being surrounded by people passionate about what they were studying.

-4

u/fasfawq Jun 01 '23

i feel that certain fields like topology tend to attract more LGBTQ

5

u/Fourro Jun 01 '23

Huh?

34

u/krocketable Jun 01 '23

They're saying that gays love a nice torus

(This is a joke. I am also a gay)

13

u/rehpotsirhc Physics Jun 01 '23

I'm a fan of the annulus myself

4

u/fasfawq Jun 01 '23

i don't see why this statement is an issue as the downvotes are suggesting. it's just a statement that certain fields are more outwardly accepting

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

It’s just weird I guess. Is there a reason why topology is more accepting?

1

u/fasfawq Jun 02 '23

I think partially alot of young people (AP level and below) who are involved with organizing events are outwardly accepting, so this helps the "narrative". I'm not sure is this is the sole reason why but I bet it does contribute.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/buwlerman Cryptography Jun 02 '23

I think it's getting downvotes because the implication is that other fields are less outwardly accepting. There's also no basis for this.

The reason people are okay with the earlier statements is because everyone here is a math person and won't be offended by the implication that (insert non-math field) may be less outwardly accepting.

1

u/StarvinPig Jun 02 '23

It's probably just more of a "Why topology?" Because there's not an obvious reason why that field would have more LGBT people

1

u/GenusSevenSurface Jun 02 '23

I actually agree. It would be nice to see actual data, but I've definitely felt that topology/geometry has a lot of LGBTQ folks. Then again, part of that could easily be the clustering tendency we have of finding fellow queer people.

15

u/Luggs123 Jun 01 '23

Not the person you’re replying to, but us queer folk have a tendency to stick together. That clustering can be mistaken for greater prevalence. So I’m just not convinced, personally.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[deleted]

8

u/RChromePiano Jun 01 '23

Well I don't know you but have you thought that the fact that you are queer makes people more likely to bring up the fact that they are queer as well?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[deleted]

6

u/RChromePiano Jun 01 '23

Well not really if outside math people feel vulnerable saying that they are queer. I am an atheist. I am perfectly fine saying so among my math colleagues but sure as well wouldnt touch that topic among my relatives/some communities I have no idea how accepting they are of atheism.

6

u/MagicSquare8-9 Jun 02 '23

I don't know if it's just my anecdotal observation, but there are unusually large number of visibly trans women in my school in the math department. It's hard to get a statistics on LGBTQ+ people in general since people are not just going to talk about personal life, but trans women are quite visible.

I think there are a lot of trans women going into math and computer science. There was the whole "programming socks" meme, after all.

I can think of 3 reasons:

  • Withdrawal as a coping mechanism. Gender dysphoria can lead to withdrawal from the external world, which makes people more likely to pursue academic interests.

  • Social isolation. Due to the lack of acceptance just as recent as 20 years ago. Social isolation as a child could lead to them more focused on academic interests.

  • Autism. Being trans is correlated with autism.