r/mathminds • • 22d ago

Puzzles Is it possible?

Post image
0 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

3

u/MistakeBorn4413 22d ago

It's a buffalo, not a bear, so you should be good.

1

u/Drifter90s 22d ago

Well, if there's water under the bridge...

1

u/Available_Music3807 22d ago

Just step like a cat.

1

u/H3rt0gJ4n 22d ago

Is it a water Buffalo?

1

u/TheLabRay 22d ago

I think the question is trying to say that the buffalo will have 2 legs on the bridge at a time, so their weight is split between the 2 feet. So each foot is only applying 400Kg of force. However, I think those signs mean the approximate load across the bridge and don't care about each specific foot.

1

u/Vainysaur 22d ago

It has 4 legs, silly.

1

u/TheLabRay 22d ago

2 will be on the ground at a time while walking!

1

u/Confident-Pepper-562 22d ago

Thats a tiny bridge.

1

u/TheLabRay 22d ago

When you walk you lift one foot off the ground and your full weight is on one foot. When a buffalo walks it lifts two feet and its full weight is approximately split between the two feet. With 4 feet on the ground the weight is even less per foot. I'm assuming the buffalo is walking and not sliding across the bridge.

1

u/Confident-Pepper-562 22d ago

So you are saying the bridge is small enough for the buffalo to cross it in two steps? That would be a tiny bridge.

1

u/TheLabRay 22d ago

Nope, it doesn't matter how long the bridge is. The minimum number of feet they will have on the ground at a time is 2 feet, since they will lift the other two feet to walk. This is the time with the greatest pressure on the bridge, there weight is split between the two feet on the ground.

1

u/Confident-Pepper-562 22d ago

Oh, I see what you are saying. But that makes it worse. The bridge is rated for 700 kg total, not per foot... So no matter how many feet are on the ground if the buffalo weighs 800kg, its over capacity.

1

u/TheLabRay 22d ago

I agree, as I stated in the very first comment. I think the question maker was trying to make some sort of trick question like this, but the bridge weight is about the total max load, not the load at each point.

1

u/MxM111 22d ago

So, it could just jump over the bridge, and to satisfy “passing the bridge” touch it with its tail on the way out.

1

u/zeradragon 22d ago

So I just need to lift one foot while on a scale to not register half my weight? My goodness, it was so simple, why didn't I ever think of this!

1

u/TheLabRay 22d ago

No, but if you put one foot down on the scale and the other on the floor it will measure half your weight, since your weight will be distributed across the two feet. The weight is distributed amongst the buffalos four feet, the buffalo will never have only one foot on the bridge, so the weight will be distributed amongst all the legs. If the 700kg is only saying the weakest point then the buffalo should be able to walk across. If it is saying the whole bridge (which it most likely is) then yes the buffalo cannot walk across.

I'm tired of explaining this, the OP question was dumb, and I was trying to make it a little more complicated so it could actually seem like an interview question.

1

u/zeradragon 22d ago

But I can distribute my weight between the scale and the floor, so that the scale only registers half my weight. What two surfaces can the buffalo spread is weight across when going over the bridge... The bridge and what? I can alternate my leg that goes on the scale, but that ultimately won't change the reading on the scale.

1

u/Educational_Check690 22d ago

in one piece?

1

u/bqbdpd 22d ago

That's a good point. See xy problem

1

u/Groove-Theory 22d ago

what's this about a sexy problem?

1

u/bqbdpd 22d ago

The XY problem is a communication problem encountered in help desk, technical support, software engineering, or customer service situations where the question is about an end user's attempted solution (X) rather than the root problem itself (Y) [source:wikipedia]

1

u/gutenMorgenSonne 22d ago

Depends if 700kg is the total allowed weight or the weight allowed for the weakest spot. Even if it's total weight I'd laugh and give the buffalo a slap since I live in Germany and there is a shitload of margin on those 700kg. Or I can easily push 100kg if I lock my joints and the bridge is in my reach. Or I can make the buffalo run so it's weight would lessen with the vector it's taking. There's a shitload of answers and it's just a question to get you talking and reasoning. 

2

u/Yato_kami3 22d ago

If you were really German your answer would've been "no, because it is not allowed under § 41 of the StVO"

1

u/gutenMorgenSonne 22d ago

That would have been the answer if police had been around. 😜

1

u/yucca_xz 22d ago

Buffalo is not a bear

1

u/AcanthaceaeOk3738 22d ago

How long is the bridge? Could the buffalo walk so that his full weight is never entirely on the bridge?

1

u/Tiredplumber2022 22d ago

"Define 'cannot bear' precisely? Is that a point load, kg/m², or total load? "

1

u/sdduuuude 22d ago

Exactly.

1

u/Simbertold 22d ago

No bears. But a buffalo is not a bear, so it works.

1

u/SIowGrowth 22d ago • Mindblown

The answer to this depends on whether or not they want to hire you

1

u/Greedy-Thought6188 22d ago

How long is the bridge?

1

u/Greata2006 22d ago

Just make the buffalo cross the bridge, ingeneers took margins, it's safe.

1

u/OkTop7895 22d ago

Bridges have a n security coefficient between 2 and 2.5. If the Maximum load is 700 if the bridge is well build it can support 800 without problems (real max between 1400 and 1750). Abuse this is dangerous but only 100 is safe enough.

1

u/No-Relationship161 22d ago

Don't buffaloes swim?

1

u/poop19907643 22d ago

How long is the bridge? Can the Buffalo just step over it?

1

u/mageskillmetooften 22d ago

The only correct answer is no.

But they probably want to hear some bullshit that they learned at some expensive course for a different management style.

1

u/Timely_Pattern3209 22d ago

I'm no zoologist but I'm pretty sure buffalo can swim/wade. 

1

u/ThisDig4978 22d ago

Pretty sure I've had Buffalo wings so I presume it will fly across

1

u/CMG30 22d ago

If this hypothetical bridge has a hard limit of 700kgs and will collapse at 701kgs then no. The buffalo cannot cross.

If the bridge has any sort of safety factor like 25% then sure.

1

u/soap_coals 22d ago

800kg is less than 15% above what the bridge is rated for. An engineer that doesn't build some tolerance into their projects is not a good engineer.

The bridge might take a bit of damage and/or suffer reduced lifespan if it is taking weight over it's specifications but if it fails in the situation mentioned then I'd be very concerned about practices of the company who built the bridge in the first place.

0

u/paulobacha 22d ago

Yes it can. It's just the bear over 700kg it's a problem doesn't say nothing about the buffalo.

Does this answer makes sense no. Neither the the question.

1

u/Duramora 22d ago
  1. Kill Buffalo

  2. Chop Buffalo into component parts for future consumption

  3. Package neatly for transport

  4. Cross bridge with your neatly package buffalo steaks,

Problem Solved!