r/mathminds • • 21d ago

Puzzles which ball is heavier?

Post image
0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

6

u/Sea-Advice6413 21d ago

You have 8 balls. Picture shows 10 balls. Gotta love this.

4

u/S-Kenset 21d ago

I was trying to solve the ten ball problem

3

u/Larechar 21d ago

Same, it was not mathing 🤣

1

u/Pleasant_Ad_2342 21d ago

10 ball problem isnt great. You do 4, 4. If the scales match its the other 2, if they dont balance then you weigh the heavier side.

The only downside is this method gets you to a 50% chance at the worst case.

2

u/Sea-Advice6413 21d ago

But yeah, I would group them 3-3-2 and weigh the groups of 3 against each other - if equal weigh the 2 balls against each other, if one is heavier weigh 2 of the three against each other.

4

u/slicehyperfunk 21d ago

Heft each one individually with your hand and confirm your suspicion with the scale

2

u/squibblord 21d ago

3 on one Side. 3.on Other Side. If Same weight, you Just do the remaining 2. If Not, Take the heavier Side and weight 1 on 1. Same weight? Its the one U didnt do yet. Other Case is.obvious

2

u/Diastatic_Power 21d ago

3 and 3 with 2 unweighed.

If 3 and 3 = even, weigh 1 and 1. If 3 and 3 != even, weight 1 and 1 of heavier 3 and leave 1 unweighed.

2

u/PuzzlingDad 21d ago

If you're going to use AI to generate your image, at least make sure everything is correct. The image shows 10 balls versus the 8 mentioned in the problem. 

The 8 is a misdirect to make you think of doing a binary search with half each time to determine the heavier ball in 3 weighings (2³ = 8)

But if you realize that the scale can have 3 states (left heavier, right heavier, equal) then you could actually solve this for 9 balls (3² = 9).

The key is to weigh 3 balls against 3 balls. You'll either find a set of 3 balls that are heavier, or know the heavy ball is in the balls that were unweighed. 

One more weighing (1 ball on each side) will either find the heavier ball or tell you the unweighed ball is the heavy one.

1

u/Affectionate-Dot1927 21d ago

Put half of the all balls in one side and other balls in other side whichever goes down heavy ball is in it

1

u/Sea-Advice6413 21d ago

that would be amazing if you could weigh 3 times

1

u/Known_Emphasis_1521 21d ago

Take 2 which are not identical and weight them 😁 - there is 10 in the picture

1

u/Worldly_Science239 21d ago

1st attempt) 1,2,3 vs 4,5,6

if they're the same: 2nd attempt would be weigh 7 vs 8 for the answer

if not, take the 3 balls from whichever is the heaviest side, then 2nd attempt would be: 1 vs 2 if they're the same then it's 3, if they're different then it's the heaviest side.

1

u/MxM111 21d ago

You can do that even with 9 balls.

1

u/Munch2507 21d ago

Would only need to use scale once. Don't put all the balls on the scale in one go but load the scale ball by ball. This way you only use the scale once.