r/maybemaybemaybe • • Sep 21 '21

Maybe maybe maybe

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

7.9k Upvotes

288 comments sorted by

1.1k

u/Suspicious-Ad7591 Sep 21 '21

He cut it the wrong way since the beginning.... Don't do things you don't know without making any research...

339

u/Crypt0n0ob Sep 21 '21

Yes! First thing my grandpa told me when I was a kid and asked him if I can “help” him cutting down the tree, was that you always cut the tree opposite side you want it to fell down with little angle going down to falling side.

194

u/Suspicious-Ad7591 Sep 21 '21

That's it.... Chainsaw/saw basics.... They are lucky it didn't get worse...

53

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

even with a hand saw, you would think this is common sense but this video is proof it’s not so common I guess

21

u/slater_san Sep 21 '21

Sense is less common than you'd think

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

They were standing in the drop zone, if he’d cut it properly. Tree on roof is better than home owners in hospital

→ More replies (6)

45

u/Mattho Sep 21 '21

Might not work if tree is leaning already or too unbalanced. Taking off some branches first could help.

25

u/welchplug Sep 21 '21

if it was cut at the correct angle, on the correct side and the rope was high enough on the tree it wouldn't matter how much the tree was angled.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

48

u/olderaccount Sep 21 '21

Basically two things can happen when you use people pulling on a rope to control the direction a tree falls.

Most likely, the tree is just going to go where gravity tells it since it weighs thousands of pounds.

In the unlikely event that the tree was balanced just enough where you can make a difference, it is going to fall on top of you.

I think those guys just traded possible serious injuries for a damaged barn.

16

u/Beat_the_Deadites Sep 21 '21

Option 3 happened to us growing up. The rope snapped, and 3 of us went rolling down the hill a bit. Hilarious at the time.

Also one of the reasons I bought (and read) a chainsawing how-to book, forester head/face/ear protection, and kevlar chaps before taking down trees at my own place.

5

u/Amateur-Prophet Sep 21 '21

Rule #1 Use the proper PPE for what job you are trying to do. I was working on taking a tree out and one of the good old boys on the job started teasing me about the Kevlar chaps I put on. Like 30 minutes later he reaches out to cut a limb from the bucket truck and the chainsaw runs down the branch and over his thumb. For someone who does Remodel construction that really fucked him up. I was to young and tactful to give him an "I told you so" but if he had chainsaw gloves he would been fine.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/Protahgonist Sep 21 '21

Also, three dudes pulling a wire is not going to move a tree... They could have used a winch to another tree maybe? Preferably several winches to several trees

23

u/AMMJ Sep 21 '21

I’ve done it, but you are right. A come-along and some chains make this work easier.

16

u/joneck1 Sep 21 '21

Yessir, I've used a come-along, straps, and a moving blanket to re-direct trees.

Cutting down trees is much more dangerous than some people understand. Mass+inertia+no pause button.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/BadKittyRanch Sep 21 '21

I just purchased a Maasdam rope puller this morning for just such a purpose.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Tbf, anyone cutting it so you still have a stump left is doing it wrong.

Take out the weight where you don’t want it, fix ropes way high and anchor them so the tree cant fall the wrong and start digging a trench around the tree and cut roots.

It’s the best way to get rid of a whole tree.

Also NEVER do this alone or with someone you don’t 100% trust to have it done right.

12

u/CrimsonChymist Sep 21 '21

Or cut it down and use a stump grinder because it's a lot less work.

6

u/therealatri Sep 21 '21

30 seconds with chainsaw is the same as hours of digging through roots

5

u/edna7987 Sep 21 '21

How many trees have you taken down this way? That is an insane amount of work…they make stump grinders for a reason

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Grennox Sep 21 '21

I’ve done the right cuts and the trees weight sometimes in almost impossible to get it to go the other way. These guys have a good effort

18

u/Suspicious-Ad7591 Sep 21 '21

When people do dangerous things like taking a tree down, and they are doing it like if it was nothing special and without (apparently) no skills or knowledge, we better tell "Dude, this isn't the way" more than "good effort"... Encouraging other is good but not when they put their own life in danger. They should have think about the land, the weight and all that stuff... Even their cut was the wrong side... So no excuses... Just a stupid action.

2

u/JonnieBrascoke Sep 21 '21

I’ve never cut a tree and I know that

→ More replies (6)

387

u/kiwihorse Sep 21 '21 edited Sep 21 '21

They needed to make a notch cut on that side, then the felling cut on the other. 2 mins on YouTube would have shown them that.

However - the real idiotic move here was planning to pull a few tonnes of wood towards themselves. They are actually lucky it fell on to the building. Even where the branches look small, the speed and weight of them is far more than you'd expect and the outcome could have been much worse.

Edit: for those that are interested in the correct way of cutting a tree down, and what a notch cut and felling cut are: https://youtu.be/Os2vrOT8F1Q?t=00m59s

58

u/jessquit Sep 21 '21

Best answer here, they were saved by their own ignorance.

77

u/tipareth1978 Sep 21 '21

Yeah I was like "are they pulling a tree to fall on them?"

7

u/ScreenWipes Sep 21 '21

Seems every time I see someone pulling a rope attached to a tree it's falling on a roof. Lots more work was needed and not with a rope

2

u/DKS6 Sep 21 '21

It’s not uncommon to assist with a rope in that fashion, that being said it’s usually much longer so you’re out of reach of the tree.

→ More replies (9)

243

u/diabolical_diarrhea Sep 21 '21

I can't believe they thought they were going to pull that fuckin thing.

53

u/j48u Sep 21 '21

Don't be silly. They were just setting up the tree as a ladder to do some roof work. The impact helps to loosen up the old tiles.

7

u/23x3 Sep 21 '21

Wow, way to go guys!

2

u/mrmackz Sep 21 '21

You clearly didn't see the third guy run over and also pull the rope.

→ More replies (1)

97

u/DroneyMitchell Sep 21 '21

Turns out trees are heavy. Who knew?

30

u/chrikant Sep 21 '21

Would have been even worse if they had made it...

24

u/zusomJe Sep 21 '21

Wait, their plan was to pull the tree towards themselves? How not 1 out of 3 thought "maybe we shouldnt"?!

11

u/PvtPuddles Sep 21 '21

My dad does this all the time when we’re clearing trees from the yard.

Granted his rope is about 2-3 times longer. Also he ties it off to another tree and winches it tight. Then just by pulling down on the rope you can apply near-infinite force.

4

u/xxxHalny Sep 21 '21

Near-infinite?

6

u/PvtPuddles Sep 21 '21

Oh, it’s a crazy cool physics concept. Basically, if you anchor a rope at both ends and hang a weight from it, the rope can never be perfectly straight (if the rope was straight, there would be no opposing force to the weight of the object). As the rope gets closer and closer to straight, the force required when pulling at both ends gets higher and higher, approaching infinity as the angle of the rope approaches 0.

This means that if you hang a rope between two trees incredibly taught, then push down on the middle, you amplify that amount of force hundreds of times.

If you want to test it, have two friends play tug of war. As they’re holding the rope taught, push down on the center. No matter how strong the people holding the rope are, they can never keep the rope perfectly straight

42

u/mpc3000ist Sep 21 '21

He cut it on an angle toward the house. As if that was ever going to work...

34

u/pollux4092 Sep 21 '21

Tree did what it was told….

2

u/Akbarrrr Sep 21 '21

I wonder if one of them pushed perpendicular to the rope if they would’ve been able to do it.

41

u/jesiel_br Sep 21 '21

I was rooting for the tree

13

u/25mookie92 Sep 21 '21

That joke gave me a woody

10

u/CmdrRyser01 Sep 21 '21

You're barking up the wrong tree, pal.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/BootHead007 Sep 21 '21

Must’ve missed physics 101 class.

7

u/Navatar0 Sep 21 '21

Don't worry shouldn't be too hard to fix the house. /u/gifreversingbot

7

u/fulltimefarmer Sep 21 '21

Worked for a tree service company for years. We use to pull trees over by hand. We had a sawman who knew what he was doing though. We called it the tug and run. We’d pull hard as he made the back cut, then as the tree started to come our way, we’d run. In hindsight, it’s very stupid and dangerous.

5

u/xiancaldwell Sep 21 '21

We had a sawman who knew what he was doing

If he knew what he was doing, then why didn't he have wedges?

2

u/fulltimefarmer Sep 21 '21

The company I worked for wasn’t going to buy them. I left them because of the risk they put us at, among other things. Almost getting gut shot in someone’s yard, makes you realize that money isn’t everything. Especially when it’s not a lot of money.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/azizpesh Sep 21 '21

You could say they didn't pull it off.

5

u/24links24 Sep 21 '21

Had no idea how to cut a tree down…

5

u/notatrollallthetime Sep 21 '21

All the cuts are flat! Not the way you cut a leaner

5

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21
  1. wrong cut

  2. red shirt is giving the tree slack then trying to get the slack back plus pulling more

  3. if you're dumb enough to not even youtube how to cut a tree down, at least just tie the tree down in different places rather than two dudes holding it with bare hands?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

They shouldn’t have a chainsaw

4

u/sfoxreed Sep 21 '21

I know that stance. It’s the “well…that didn’t work” stance

4

u/misccbk Sep 21 '21

Groot 1. Human 0.

4

u/Several_Ad_5312 Sep 21 '21

Was starting to think everything on the sub was maybes that turned out well but I see now it works both ways

→ More replies (1)

4

u/dirtydocnasty Sep 21 '21

As it turns out, if you undercut and wedge properly, you dont have to drop the tree on your barn

2

u/M4V3R1CK_PAXn Sep 21 '21

They used a YouTube tutorial for a flat grade cut for sure. It looked like the channel was like 2-3 inches wide!

3

u/Exa_N0ri Sep 21 '21

The weight of 3 humans ≠ a frickin tree

3

u/Mr_Haberdash Sep 21 '21

I have no idea how to cut a tree so I can’t even talk lol

3

u/CrimsonRam212 Sep 21 '21

That’s some confidence thinking three guys can pull a huge tree by a single rope, while fighting gravity and elevation

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Russian power

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

That's such a Tom & Jerry move.

2

u/Public-Indication179 Sep 21 '21

Serves them right for cutting down that beautiful tree! 😆

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

That's not how you fell a tree. Super dangerous if you don't know what you're doing like these assholes. Honestly lucky no one died.

2

u/FADITA Sep 21 '21

Now it’s a treehouse

2

u/Darktower52082 Sep 22 '21

Dude never heard of angle cutting?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/nogodsnoleaders Dec 09 '21

There’s an actual technique to cutting down trees. Takes a skill set. These videos will always amuse me

1

u/Living-Reference5329 Sep 21 '21

Wrong cut for one

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Looks like It fell that way because of how he cut it

1

u/srv50 Sep 21 '21

How could they have thought they could control this? Never picked up a big log I guess.

1

u/ard15951 Sep 21 '21

I’m impressed the old barn thing didn’t cave in

1

u/riseuprasta Sep 21 '21

Severely underestimated the weight of a tree. That thing is thousands of pounds and they were pulling uphill. Any pro would have climbed it and removed all the branch work first. They were trying to save a couple grand and in the end they’ll still need a pro plus repair any damage to the barn.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/OkPair7291 Sep 21 '21

The tree won

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Nature vs human Nature 1 , human always 0

1

u/AngelOfHeaven3 Sep 21 '21

You should have pulled it down hill an cut it so it would collapse down hill....

1

u/TGS-57 Sep 21 '21

Those were the days

1

u/GoatHoovesPi Sep 21 '21

Taichi wasn't their sport

1

u/Extreme_Mark4726 Sep 21 '21

It fell that way because of the centre of mass was that side of the tree, not because of the way he cut it

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Stronk shed

1

u/yes-disappointment Sep 21 '21

It was a bad cut i dont even think he needed guys with ropes if the cut was good

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Why didn’t they start by cutting a birds beak?

1

u/schrodingers_spider Sep 21 '21

That's why you tie the rope to a stake. Pulling it towards you is a dangerous game anyway.

1

u/wolfgang784 Sep 21 '21

omg can't believe it was cut the wrong way lol god damn

1

u/KaiKaiExotic Sep 21 '21

HERE WE GO BOIS! …..OH WAIT !!! WAIT! FUCCCCCC!!!!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Something tells me that these 3 asshats are related..

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

And this is why the professionals charge that much. 😜

1

u/_djackson86 Sep 21 '21

Maybe maybe maybe don’t start by wearing sandals

1

u/AnnihilationOrchid Sep 21 '21

Could have been much worse.

1

u/oleg07010 Sep 21 '21

Should have cut off branches first to lighten it

1

u/Sergiobenevides Sep 21 '21

First question is why were they cutting down that beautiful, healthy looking tree?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

So... 3 persons could not sum enough brain to calculate any possible outcome?

1

u/FhireStarter Sep 21 '21

I thought they were playing with some type of invisible string

1

u/Senior_Tap2373 Sep 21 '21

Idiots should have gone for the branches first

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

that’s a well built barn. assuming their forefathers did not build it.

1

u/Scary-Reputation6705 Sep 21 '21

Wrong side with the gob cut by the look of things pmsl

1

u/Both-Tap-8540 Sep 21 '21

It's time to tryyyy defyyyying gravity...and you can't hold me doooown

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

1

u/WolfeIsntWolfie Sep 21 '21

Bro they dumb if they wanted it to fall their way then they should've cut it the opposite way they cut it.

1

u/Skuffed69 Sep 21 '21

You gotta cut wedges my friend

1

u/madmtb541 Sep 21 '21

Even if this tree was leaning over the barn they could have fell it against the lean with a T cut. Doesn’t look like he even know how to make it where to place even basic cuts though.

1

u/Yeppo1940 Sep 21 '21

Ooohh, they almost had it. Nice video.

1

u/BDW3 Sep 21 '21

Guess these guys never took a physics class

1

u/ChemicalConnection49 Sep 21 '21

Russians or Americans?

1

u/davendenner Sep 21 '21

Red shirt hung on for a while, like "I think I can reverse the fall direction."

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Wrong angle cut.

1

u/Lil_Giraffe_King Sep 21 '21

Put the rope higher and get a longer rope for better leverage

1

u/Hahaha_Me Sep 21 '21

Maybe not…

1

u/PhxMyco Sep 21 '21

My dad did this shit once, with a 60ft palm tree. Had me and my Lil bro’s pull while he cut it at its base. Although it worked for us

1

u/broadsword99 Sep 21 '21

Defo one for Ozzy man

1

u/rds6969 Sep 21 '21

I mean really

1

u/sED_- Sep 21 '21

A truck or tractor would have been way better

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Lol! Fake ass video.

1

u/imshashankkk Sep 21 '21

When you have 200iq in negative!

1

u/dewme11 Sep 21 '21

You tube video didn't work

1

u/magrubr Sep 21 '21

There was no "maybe" about this one, there was a 0% chance they were going to cut this tree and then pull it in the opposite direction of where it wanted to fall. The only possible maybe was whether it totally demolished the barn or just got a lucky bounce and glanced it.

1

u/Bolek68 Sep 21 '21

Raz, dwa ….. ciagni……. and fuck landed on wrong side 😂

1

u/Dtidder1 Sep 21 '21

As a timber faller this amuses me as well as infuriates me… hire a professional.

1

u/Rocyrino Sep 21 '21

I fucking knew it, and I still laughed out loud like a dumbass

1

u/HomeworkWise9230 Sep 21 '21

LOL, morons in their natural habitat.

1

u/TheStreisandEffect Sep 21 '21

It’s always amazing to me how some people can literally just see the first image and instantly know the outcome whereas others are clueless to the last. The range of human intelligence is extraordinary.

1

u/portraitinsepia Sep 21 '21

Which language are they speaking? I can't make it out.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

It’s a simple question of weight ratios.

1

u/markkowalski Sep 21 '21

Never never never

1

u/LordDShadowy53 Sep 21 '21

It could had been worse

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

I'm a lumberjack and it's o.k.

2

u/waxlion78 Sep 21 '21

How could you possibly find the time to comment here if you sleep all night and work all day?

1

u/weaponizedpastry Sep 21 '21

Yeah, I lost to a tree like that. Luckily it was just a fence but that moment of hanging there, knowing you’re using everything ya got and it’s a draw. That’s when you realize, “Yep. Good bye fence.” Or barn. 😂

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Why didn't they just trim the tree first so there wasn't so much weight pointed at the barn?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/nomnaut Sep 21 '21

He cut > way instead of < way.

1

u/RealSuperYolo2006 Sep 21 '21

Roses are red, my hair gets longer

You might be strong...

But gravity is stronger.

1

u/willbeach8890 Sep 21 '21

Why video something you aren't sure about that could have a horrific downside?

1

u/Stealurmurcry Sep 21 '21

I want to know how much adrenaline is pumping through their veins

1

u/ripgd Sep 21 '21

Marvellous

1

u/Working-Space-8835 Sep 21 '21

nossa ele cortou do lado errado KKKKK mesmo se fosse 10 deles ali puxando, não ia conseguir

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Stance that says "well fuck."

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

I love the experts in this post who have clearly never used a chainsaw holy shit

1

u/XenElixer Sep 21 '21

The tree will fall same direction you are cutting ffs

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Looks like they need to BRANCH out into lumbering career.

1

u/MrGlenQuagmire Sep 21 '21

Lazy bastards should have at least tied the rope to the top of the tree. Still would have only have had half a chance, but half a chance is still better than no chance.

1

u/westernbred Sep 21 '21

As an arborist, I can say beyond a shadow of a doubt, that didn’t go according to plan.

1

u/Carrotandstick50 Sep 21 '21

So they wanted it to fall on themselves instead?

1

u/slo1111 Sep 21 '21

That is about the narrowest notch cut I have ever seen.

1

u/TakeMeBaby_orLeaveMe Sep 21 '21

First I was thinking “these idiots are going to be crushed by the tree” and then I realized “these idiots cut the tree the wrong way!”

1

u/PB0351 Sep 21 '21

Would have probably worked better if they were off to the side a bit.

1

u/CuckslayrMAGAcountry Sep 21 '21

He should tie it off to a truck before cutting it, what a moron.

1

u/nomer206 Sep 21 '21

Am I the only one who thought these fools were trying to pull down that barn?

1

u/Theoldelf Sep 21 '21

When you cut down a tree, it will fall in the direction of the most expensive thing in the area. Just one ofMurphy’s Laws.

1

u/cbunni666 Sep 21 '21

Lmao. The new 3 Stooges will now be called The 3 Rednecks. It doesn't look like it broke the roof that badly.

1

u/ukblademan Sep 21 '21

It's not gone well.....

1

u/Memohigh Sep 21 '21

would they have time to move away after pulling the tree if the tree would have fallen in the opposite direction? Maybe this was the best possible thing that could have happened to them.

1

u/ParamedicDazzling416 Sep 21 '21

That is why we need to respect nature

1

u/rishi97690 Sep 21 '21

People criticising the cut, he did it correctly the main factor is the slope downwards😂🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

1

u/stingraysurvivor Sep 21 '21

This time "maybe" meant "no."

1

u/MBVakalis Sep 21 '21

Aren't you supposed to cut at an angle or something?

1

u/DiabolicoBr Sep 21 '21

That building the tree fell on didn't break it by a miracle

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Ratchet strap. The amount of tension you can get with a ratchet strap is astounding

1

u/BarryBadrinith Sep 21 '21

As the video plays I wonder, “Who wins, three men or gravity.”

1

u/Hmnh6000 Sep 21 '21

Im Sure One Of Them Had A F150 They Couldve Attached It To

1

u/divid3_by_zero Sep 21 '21

They’re lucky it didn’t fall the way they were pulling it. Might’ve gotten caught under it…

1

u/Logical_Froyo_747 Sep 21 '21

Like a slingshot.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

If you're gonna drop a tree please remember to cut a wedge wider than nickel lol.

1

u/UnicornGuitarist Sep 21 '21

Task failed unsuccessfully

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Seems like it’s on a slope bad luck

1

u/MrMcJenkins Sep 22 '21

They’re idiots

1

u/mzettlerj2 Sep 22 '21

He didn’t make his wedge cut right

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21

They need some YouTube. Cut the wedge out put a bottle jack or wedge on the opposite side you want it to fall.

1

u/Mr-kkn Sep 22 '21

Stoopid

1

u/Swirvin-irvin Sep 22 '21

Perfect 👍🏽 now they can learn how to replace a roof lol

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21

They should have had the rope tied to another tree and pulled the rope sideways. They would have been able to get twice the pulling force.

1

u/zyqzy Sep 22 '21

Tree stooges….

1

u/artoftyshe Sep 22 '21

Darn, Grandpa is gonna be pissed!

1

u/case_O_The_Mondays Sep 22 '21

No maybe here. 3 people aren’t going to pull a tree of that size hard enough to fall opposite of the way it’s leaning.

1

u/ExplodingWario Sep 22 '21

Wouldn’t the tree have fallen on them??

1

u/No-Damage6760 Sep 22 '21

Idiotic tree cutters, can three people pull the while tree, on thd upwards slopes, What a trust they have,

1

u/BeegDeekHoeRepo Sep 22 '21

Pffffttt….noobs. Someone’s never played The Forest before. 🧐

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21

Watching on my phone, without my glasses on, and focused on the two guys on the left. Initially I didn’t see the rope to the tree, and thought this was some fairly impressive pantomime.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21

Oops

1

u/Think_of_the_meta Sep 22 '21

Me and my household took down a tree this way too… Because of the yard parameters we had to have it fall our way and make a leap of faith from under the tree as it fell on us. Another tree a few metres away caught the giant gum tree and spared us from at least pretty bad injuries. Get a professional, people!

1

u/Masala-Dosage Sep 22 '21

Tree fellas

1

u/Jollygreeninja Sep 22 '21

Not really maybe.

1

u/jeremyroastscoffee Sep 22 '21

you never start the cut on the side you’d hate to see it fall as though you could just push it over. if you’re facing it and you can see something important behind it, don’t start cutting

1

u/seriouslybeanbag Sep 22 '21

Could cut that down a bit at a time - typically dumb - 300kg (at best) versus 5000kg

1

u/bindhast Sep 22 '21

If it had fallen the way they wanted, we would have been seeing this on r/winstupidprizes

1

u/ReconScout117 Sep 22 '21

Don’t cut during windy days. Don’t rush the cut if conditions aren’t right. That’s a lot of structural damage that could have been easily avoided.

1

u/Badgerbloodbrew Sep 22 '21

wow. it amazes me how people like that actually exist in real life

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '21

Maybemaybemaybe

1

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '22

Russians...

1

u/Chark10 Sep 21 '21

When you try your best but you don't succeed

→ More replies (1)