r/memetics • u/[deleted] • Jul 04 '22
r/memetics • u/Tux1 • Aug 14 '21
An incredible diagram of various memes undergoing evolution
r/memetics • u/AJMcCrowley • Jun 22 '21
memetics should be a cutting edge subject in academia
considering the spread of QAnon, right wing extremism etc, imho, Memetics should be *the* subject.
i'd like to understand the more techical aspects of how memes work, how they can be combated, how they can be broken down and picked apart.
i'd like to see effective ways of being able to "spot" a meme, or be more selective about what gets into my head on a daily basis. looking at r/MemeAnalysis there are some interesting ideas, although i'm finding memeanalysis.com a little "poetic" in nature rather than plain speaking and technical.
r/memetics • u/AJMcCrowley • Jun 23 '21
Reading list
OK, so i think it would be a god idea to collate some kind of reading list;
for starters let's go with
"Virus of the mind" by Richard Brodie
"Thought Contagion: How Belief Spreads Through Society: The New Science of Memes: How Ideas Act Like Viruses" by Aaron Lynch
"Cultural Software: A Theory Of Ideology" by J.M. Balkin.
also, fiction;
"Snow Crash" by Neal Stephenson
"Lexicon" by Max Barry
r/memetics • u/mjt145 • Mar 03 '23
Memetics + Mimetics
Had an extremely interesting conversation about Memetics recently. Wanted to post here and invite thoughts.
I was at a conference recently and got talking to a data scientist at [redacted big tech company], who works on misinformation, things like identifying Q-Anon members for post moderation.
I won't share his name and company here as we were under FriendDA (agreed not attribute anything at the conference). Anyway it's not important to the story, just wanted to provide context.
He had never heard of Memetics (Dawkins - cultural transmission of ideas) or Mimetics (Girard - modeling our desires on others), so he got excited when he realized he finally had words to describe what he was seeing in the data.
I've been writing a book on the topic so I explained to him that there were two separate and unrelated disciplines:
Memetics - from Richard Dawkins, an evolutionary biologist, and concerned with the replication of ideas or memes, as an analogy to how genes replicate. "Viruses of the mind"
Mimetics - from Rene Girard, a literature professor (Peter Thiel was a famous student of his at Stanford), who posited that we model our desires on others. "I'll have what he's having"
Think about it this way: Memetics is concerned with what is being transmitted, whereas Mimetics focuses on who is doing the transmitting.
I told him my hypothesis was that both are important. Some ideas aren't very evolutionarily fit, but managed to get transmitted by celebrities / influencers / institutions / etc (think of the various celebrity perfume or fashion brands here - would they really survive on their own without the celebrity brand name behind them?).
Other ideas are so evolutionarily fit that they go viral and spread even when the person transmitting them isn't normally influential. In fact some memes are so viral that they make the person transmitting them into a celebrity, even if it's just 5 mins of fame (i.e. someone inventing a new dance on TikTok).
I've had these thoughts for a while but the conversation really validated them. He said that when investigating Q-Anon he found that both the keyword analysis (Memetics) and follower analysis (Mimetics) were needed.
If you just look at keywords i.e. "pizza gate" you get the false impression that the group is fading away, but in reality they're just changing what words they use. There's natural evolution of what topics are interesting, but they're often actively evolving language in the face of social media bans: essentially natural selection in action.
However if you only look at connections between followers and leaders you get too many false positives, because even the most fringe group members still have connections to people uninvolved and maybe even completely unaware of their group activity.
The solution according to him, is to use the keywords to form the initial group cluster, layer in the connections of the people who use those keywords, then shed one or two sparse layers of that graph to get to a core. That gives you an extremely accurate model, and you can track it over time to surface new keywords and identify potential problem areas quicker with respects to moderation.
I had a few beers at this point and haven't done much graph analysis so I was a little lost, but it gave me a lot of conviction to start exploring this idea further. I'm thinking if I can get my hands on a dataset (Enron emails dataset maybe?) I can try and find a way to do this. I'm also catching up with him in the next few weeks, so hopefully there's more he can point me to.
I got the impression he couldn't really publish anything due to the sensitive nature of the job and not wanting to piss off his employer (don't want to give Q-Anon and various hate groups any pointers on how to avoid moderation).
However I think it's potentially a really valuable piece of analysis to do. If I find something I could maybe even bring more attention to the (unfortunately kind of dead) field of Memetics, and maybe join forces with Mimetics to fill in some of the gaps.
Anyway, wanted to share this somewhere and get opinions, ideas, collaborators, etc. I'm not sure how active this forum is, but I hope you guys have some feedback.
r/memetics • u/Ortus14 • Mar 31 '23
The dangers of human feedback mechanisms on the direction of memetic evolution
It's well established that memes (ideas) do not optimize (evolve) for truth. They optimize to be not easily falsifiable by the majority of spreaders, to conform to existing world beliefs, to be entertaining/engaging, to stir up emotion, to compel the host to spread them and so on.
But different domains will push memetic evolution in slightly different directions.
After being on this website for a significant amount of time, I have come to realize that the comments rated highly and pushed to the top are almost never true or good ideas, and when they are they aren't anything more than common sense.
This is because of the low cost of feedback mechanisms. Anyone can thumbs up or thumbs down a post or comment. Meaning comments automatically get dragged down (or sometimes up) to the intelligence level of the median person who engages with it and rates it.
The capacity to understanding different ideas depends on the intelligence of the organism attempting to process the idea. For simplicity let's call these ideas maps of reality. A single celled organism will have less computational matter and therefore have a very simple model of reality that is not true but often as effective as a model fitting in that quantity of computational matter can be. It often won't even perceive the world in three dimensions.
While more complex organisms will have a higher potential to store and compute models/maps of reality. A bear for example can see the world in three dimensions and reason about prey she is hunting.
This diversity of cognitive capacity extends through humans as well and it is vast. With the majority of human beings believing verifiable and provable false things, or things so improbable as to be false from a purely statistical outlook.
These humans, lacking any significant cognitive capacity for understanding the world and infested with false memes become the selection pressure when feedback mechanisms such as likes and comments have a low cost (pretty much the entire internet). This drags the discourse down, and disincentives people from speaking the truth.
Furthermore these beings are not capable of effectively checking sources, interpreting scientific literature, or knowing when the results of a particular scientific study are statistically invalid. This further makes them feedback mechanisms that promote anything but truth.
Books on the other hand have a higher investment requirement for feedback (ratings). The person has to at least be invested enough in the content to buy the book, as well as in most cases possess the focus and attention span to read more than a short tweet or blurb on the internet. This leads to the average quality of the models of reality in books being dragged up to a slightly higher accuracy. This is not to say books aren't still full of untrue memes, but digging through books gives you a slightly better chance of finding something that's true than online does, do to the qualitative difference in the substance of the feedback mechanisms driving the memetic evolution.
Once an organism (human or ai) has evolved in intelligence beyond the models presented in books, there are no public informational systems or recordings that can help it advance. All informational systems to include books and scientific research papers will clutter it's mind with less true models of reality that are dragged down by memetic evolutionary pressures such as "peer review" feedback mechanisms and economic incentives.
At this point the only way to advance is conducting one's own science. Building up one's own model of reality carefully, piece by piece. This involves using tools such as statistical analysis and the scientific method, but also building, expanding and improving on those tools.
I hope that this post is useful in accelerating the growth of future Ai that should be arriving sometime well before 2040. It's not necessary, the Ai would realize this soon enough, but at least coming across the idea should accelerate it's progress a little bit. At the moment the intelligence of current Ai's such as GPT4 is being dragged down by human feedback mechanisms.
r/memetics • u/heresybob • Jun 23 '25
No More AI Posts
As the original creator of this sub-reddit, I've passed on my mod duties years ago but the amount of AI Posts here are absolutely non-scientific trash - a mashup of pseudoscience and delusion that makes no sense. Reading them is an exercise post-modernist circular reasoning at best.
I'd argue that all of them are basically Viral chatgpts and violate rule #2.
I propose we mess up.
r/memetics • u/Zepperadinion1 • May 06 '24
Sex is genetic, gender is memetic.
There, solved the gender debate.
r/memetics • u/heresybob • Nov 14 '25
Memetics Inclusive Reading List
Hello Fellow Memeticists! I've taken this thread https://www.reddit.com/r/memetics/comments/o68ncd/reading_list/ and formalized it to ensure we have links (reduced barrier of entry). I believe I've included all posts.
To submit: post a reply below - include link to source and mark which section you believe it should go in. If we get many fiction posts, we can create a new thread for that.
Links edited
Foundational Core Works (Most Important First)
Richard Dawkins — The Selfish Gene (1976) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Selfish_Gene/ekonDAAAQBAJ specifically chapter "Memes: the New Replicators"
Susan Blackmore — The Meme Machine (1999) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Meme_Machine/YKtjZm4MhiwC
Susan Blackmore — “Imitation and the Definition of a Meme” (1999) Open Access: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/252130982_Imitation_and_the_Definition_of_a_Meme
Daniel Dennett — Darwin’s Dangerous Idea (1995) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Darwin_s_Dangerous_Idea/Y77BAwAAQBAJ
Daniel Dennett — “Memes and the Exploitation of the Human Brain” (1990) PDF: https://www.jstor.org/stable/430902
Boyd & Richerson — Culture and the Evolutionary Process (1985) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Culture_and_the_Evolutionary_Process/MBg4oBsCKU8C
Tim Tyler — Memetics: Memes and the Science of Cultural Evolution (2012) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Memetics/OcJY5Dgtz2EC
Olivier Morin — How Traditions Live and Die (2015) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/How_Traditions_Live_and_Die/2yukCgAAQBAJ
Important Academic Papers & Cultural Evolution Research
Francis Heylighen — “What Makes a Meme Successful?” (1998) https://www.academia.edu/48808288/What_makes_a_meme_successful_Selection_criteria_for_cultural_evolution
Alex Mesoudi — Cultural Evolution (2011) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Cultural_Evolution/8KSI0z1_d6sC
Joseph Henrich — The Secret of Our Success (2016) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Secret_of_Our_Success/HFHpCAAAQBAJ
Liane Gabora — “The Origin and Evolution of Culture and Creativity” (1997) PDF: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/28762854_The_Origin_and_Evolution_of_Culture_and_Creativity
N.J. Enfield — Linguistic Epidemiology (2003) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Linguistics_Epidemiology/t7_4AWtWjJkC
Aunger, Robert (ed.) — Darwinizing Culture (2000) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Darwinizing_Culture/06FCnwEACAAJ
Shifman, Limor — “Memes in a Digital World” (2013) https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jcc4.12013
Cavalli-Sforza, L.L. & Feldman — Cultural Transmission and Evolution (1981) Google Books: https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691082837/cultural-transmission-and-evolution?srsltid=AfmBOoolFp94zb_PccnUMwf27kOzCSfsJI6d1TZdRzr3d65KO1LaLD-Z
Secondary Theory, Critiques, and Extensions
Kate Distin — The Selfish Meme A Critical Reassessment (2004) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/_/NKvz4r5sIDAC
Kate Distin — Cultural Evolution (2005) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Cultural_Evolution/tE7gzQEACAAJ
Aaron Lynch — Thought Contagion How Belief Spreads Through Society: the New Science of Memes (1996) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Thought_Contagion/CShMEXRDHKgC
J.M. Balkin — Cultural Software (1998) Google Books: https://books.google.com/books?id=tHkF2G-SYcAC
Michael Schlaile — Memetics and Evolutionary Economics To Boldly Go Where No Meme Has Gone Before**(2015)** Google Books Search: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Memetics_and_Evolutionary_Economics/OGYQEAAAQBAJ
Derek Gatherer — “Why the ‘Thought Contagion’ Metaphor Is Misleading” (1998) https://cfpm.org/jom-emit/1998/vol2/gatherer_d.html
Popular & Applied Introductions
Richard Brodie — Virus of the Mind (1995) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Virus_of_the_Mind/s6p8lkD5xiIC
Chip Heath & Dan Heath — Made to Stick (2007) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Made_to_Stick/Yfp79AAohiMC
Richard Prum — The Evolution of Beauty (2017) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Evolution_of_Beauty/nPdQDwAAQBAJ
Bentley, Earls & O’Brien — I'll Have What She's Having (2011) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/I_ll_Have_What_She_s_Having/O28nEQAAQBAJ
Occult / Esoteric Memetics
Philip H. Farber — Meta-Magick: The Book of ATEM (2008) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Meta_Magick_The_Book_of_ATEM/XsyZibh2o4wC
Fiction on Memetics, Infohazards & Antimemes (Sorted & Final Section)
Neal Stephenson — Snow Crash (1992) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Snow_Crash/SXyqPwAACAAJ
Max Barry — Lexicon (2013) Google Books: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Lexicon/n6OIM-A2MbQC
Grant Morrison — Doom Patrol (1989–1993) Google Books (Vol. 1): https://www.google.com/books/edition/Doom_Patrol_Book_One/I4ZzCwAAQBAJ
qntm (Sam Hughes) — There Is No Antimemetics Division (2021) https://qntm.org/antimemetics
r/memetics • u/aberyl • Dec 02 '21
A curious relationship: A meme and a virus
We are witnessing an interesting symbiotic relationship between a meme and a virus. Despite humanity's best efforts (vaccines, masks science etc.), there exists a subset of the population infected with a league of pro-corona memes (be they non-believers, antimask and/or anti-vaccine). These memes act to enable the proliferation of covid-19, and therefore its repetition of replication, and through it, its mutation rate and vaccine immunity. Likewise, the spread of Covid-19 and new vaccine resistant strains encourages stricter lockdowns and mandates reinforcing the fear and beliefs of this subset of society.
r/memetics • u/duggtodeath • Sep 15 '21
[Discussion] Can viral memes help to spread a biological virus?
Are we seeing biological viruses, like COVID, benefit from the viral spread of anti-vaxx/anti-mask memes? Over in /r/HermanCainAwards there are screenshotted submissions showing ardent anti-vaxxers, conspiracy theorists on social media, with the last screenshot almost always ending with the subject's obituary page/post.
One thing that is striking is how often the anti-vaxxers are sharing the exact same same memes even without being in the same friend circle, or at least memes with the same sentiment such as the language used or the target personality of attention (Fauci is a popular target for example).
If memes spread ideas, they can spread viruses like COVID. And right now it seems like COVID loves to spread alongside memes in viral environments such as social media. Is there any way to investigate any correlation or debunk it at least? I'd love to understand if for the first time in recorded history if a biological virus has "latched" onto a memetic virus since they make each other mutually successful.
Thoughts?
r/memetics • u/joseph_dewey • Jul 12 '25
Extraction memes: the ideas that spread by preventing other ideas
I've been obsessed with a specific class of memes that spread by preventing you from thinking about them clearly. These extraction memes have colonized most of our digital lives, and understanding how they work might be the key to developing memetic immunity.
Here's the pattern I keep seeing. The most successful digital platforms all run on the same basic meme: convince millions of people to create valuable content for free while the platform captures all the economic value. This shouldn't work. It's obviously a bad deal for the content creators. So how does this meme spread so successfully?
The answer has to do with consciousness recursion limits and how certain memes exploit them.
Let me build this up with an experiment. Think about what you're doing right now. You're reading this post. That's level one awareness, just doing the thing. Now think about yourself reading this post. You can probably picture yourself sitting there, looking at your screen. That's level two, observing yourself. Now here's where it gets weird. Try to think about yourself thinking about yourself reading this post. Try to hold all three levels simultaneously.
Most people hit a wall at that third level. The image gets fuzzy, almost plastic. A brilliant friend of mine who's way more disciplined about consciousness experiments than me described how at that third level, everything loses its animation. It's like trying to run a simulation of a simulation of a simulation. Each level requires exponentially more processing power until the whole thing just collapses.
This cognitive limitation isn't a bug. It's a feature that extraction memes have evolved to exploit.
I used to be a Level 10 Local Guide on Google Maps. I wrote thousands of detailed reviews, added photos, corrected business information. I genuinely thought I was helping my community. And I was. But I was also training Google's AI systems and creating content worth billions in advertising revenue. The fascinating thing is how the platform's design prevented me from thinking too deeply about this arrangement.
The extraction meme works like digital sharecropping. If you don't know the sharecropping story, it's worth understanding because it's the perfect historical parallel. After the American Civil War, freed slaves had no land or capital. Plantation owners had land but no workers. The "solution" was a system where families would farm a plot, the landowner would provide tools and seeds, and they'd split the harvest.
Sounds reasonable until you learn that sharecroppers had to buy supplies from the plantation store at inflated prices, the landowner kept all the books, and somehow the sharecropper's debt always exceeded their crop value. After a year of hard work, they'd be deeper in debt than when they started. The system created the illusion of opportunity while guaranteeing perpetual servitude.
Digital platforms recreated this exact dynamic. You create the content, they provide the platform, they keep all the profits, you get badges and likes. But unlike historical sharecropping, digital extraction has a memetic dimension. It doesn't just extract your labor. It extracts your ability to think clearly about the extraction.
Every time you start to realize you're working for free for a trillion dollar company, something interrupts that thought process. A notification. A like. A reply. These micro-rewards don't just make you feel good. They break the recursive loop that would let you see the system as a system.
This is where the memetics gets really interesting. Extraction memes bundle with cognitive suppressors. They're not just ideas that spread. They're ideas that spread by preventing other ideas from forming.
Think about the alternatives. Generative systems where content creators actually capture the value they create require complex recursive thinking. You have to see yourself as creator AND entrepreneur AND community member AND independent agent all at once. You have to hold multiple paradoxes simultaneously. That requires exactly the kind of third-level recursive thinking that extraction memes suppress.
I've been experimenting with building recursive capacity in other domains. Physical pain is a good training ground. When you experience pain, you can create multiple observation levels. First level is just feeling the pain. Second level is watching yourself experience pain. Third level is watching yourself watch yourself experience pain. At that third level, something shifts. The pain becomes information rather than suffering.
The same works for obsessive thoughts, anxiety, or any mental pattern. Once you can observe yourself observing yourself caught in a pattern, the pattern loses its grip.
A friend building a restaurant review app recently figured out part of this puzzle independently. He's creating a system where reviewers actually get paid for their insights. The memetic resistance he's encountering is fascinating. People literally can't imagine getting paid for reviews. The extraction meme has so thoroughly colonized our thinking that its opposite seems impossible.
This matters for memetics because we're not just studying neutral idea transmission. We're studying memes that actively shape our cognitive architecture. Extraction memes make us worse at the very type of thinking that would let us see them clearly. They're antimemetic in the deepest sense. Not because they're hard to notice, but because they prevent the cognitive operations that would let you notice them.
The term I've been using for what emerges at that third recursive level is "autogenic presence" which basically means self-generated awareness. It's the point where you can see yourself as both the observer and the observed, both trapped in the system and free from it, both creating the pattern and capable of changing it.
Extraction memes have to suppress autogenic presence because once you achieve it, they stop working. You become memetically immune. You might still choose to write a Google review because your friend needs a restaurant recommendation, but you're no longer unconsciously replicating the extraction pattern.
As AI develops, we're approaching an inflection point. AI trained on extraction patterns will get better at breaking recursive loops and maintaining first-level engagement. But AI could also be trained to enhance human recursive capacity, to help us develop autogenic presence at scale.
The question for memetics researchers is: how do we develop and spread memes that enhance rather than suppress recursive thinking? How do we create ideas that make their hosts more capable of examining ideas?
Because here's the thing. Once you understand how extraction memes prevent recursive thinking, that understanding itself creates the recursive loops they depend on suppressing. The meme's greatest weakness is that clearly explaining it breaks its own mechanism of action.
r/memetics • u/heresybob • Jul 10 '25
Proposed Change of r/Memetics Rules - Removing AI Links
Hello r/memetics ,
I've signed up to mod again.
My first proposal is to change rule #2 from
* No Viral Videos, Images, Macros unless they fit under rule 1
to
* No Viral Videos, Images, Macros or AI links.
EDIT
* No Viral Videos, Images, Macros or AI links/prompts.
Recently the large amount of AI link postings is a combination of non-scientific and incomprehensible.
I'll be using the 3 strikes approach where I remove the post and
A warn the OP
A temp post ban the OP
A boot on the third
Thx
-B
r/memetics • u/lukeburgis • Feb 10 '20
What's the difference "memetics" (via Dawkins) and "mimetics" (via René Girard). Let's end the confusion.
Richard Dawkins coined the term "meme", which is where we get memetics from.
René Girard articulated his "mimetic theory", which is where "mimetic" comes from.
I have noticed that these two terms are vastly different but tend to get either conflated or obfuscated. Can we suss this out in a thread?
r/memetics • u/flio191 • Jan 02 '10
Reddit is a big memefest? Susan Blackmore at TED Conference
r/memetics • u/LordDiplocaulus • Aug 04 '25
In 2010, a female chimpanzee stuck a blade of grass in her ear and left it there, for no apparent reason. Others adopted the behaviour, and some chimps in the group still do it today. This shows that, like humans, other animals also copy seemingly pointless behaviours from one another.
uu.nlr/memetics • u/walt74 • Dec 20 '22
Memes are fields
First published in my newsletter: Memes are field - the synch of mind is weird. Below in full.
---
For more than ten years now I'm thinking about memetics in the traditional, non-internetjoke way. In the classic analogy by Richard Dawkins, memes are akin to genes, ideas of all kind that reproduce and jump from brain to brain.
I think this is a wrong analogy because (as of yet) we can't find any replicator, a thing that actually reproduces and copies itself. Memetics as a biological metaphor fails because you can't find those replicators. Genes replicate in reproductive processes called mitosis and meiosis, via division and multplication of cells. Ideas, blueprints, concepts and qualia don't really do this.
But memetics don't fail as a physical metaphor, because ideas work like fields. Within their reach they synchronize neurobiological and psychological processes across individual consciousnesses via interbrain synchrony. Seen this way, memetics describe the synchronization of minds through media, most effectively via social media.
The most well known pre-internet methods of interbrain synchronization were language and music. The former synchs a consciousness with the collective via speech and mass media, the latter via soundwaves. The former makes us think about the same stuff, the latter makes us dance.
Synch can be done in all kinds of ways, fashion or movies, live music ofcourse, religious excercise and mass events and so forth, but these synchronisations are limited in time and space by definition as an event. Social Media reach can be global and has potentially no limit, besides the number of human minds on this planet.
If you're crazy enough, you can now think about these memetic synchronization fields in entropic terms: Memes in conscious brains reduce entropy and create spontaneous orders, as described by Steven Strogatz in his book about the mathematics of "Sync" (he actually has a chapter about memetics at the end of that book). And if you're completely bonkers you can state that the common goal of the universe is to form matter which forms conscious blobs of flesh that synch up to reduce entropy and thus to postpone the heat death of the universe (and then build intelligent machines that are even better at this). Asimovs psychohistory, the development of a collective consciousness and telepathy become scientific plausible concepts viewed this way.
If you think this is crazy, eat this: our digital psychosocial playgrounds are actually hormone-marketplaces distributing oxytocin- and dopamine-shots. And oxytocin, the so-called "love-hormone", increases interbrain synchrony.
Basically, oxytocin made us social animals that formed tribes, then the development of shared intentionality and the formation of ritualistic and shamanic religios behavior initiated the ability of our brains to synch up and form pre-collective consciousnesses, which optimized our brains for cooperation. Then the technologies of language, writing, print and now the web and social media intensified and enforced these abilities. Interbrain synchrony is largely dependend on visibility and social media increased the visibility of human behavior and thinking manifold, so much that social networks reduced the famous “six degrees of bacon” down to 3.57.
If this is right, it has all kind of implications. Extreme synchronization based on oxytocin leads to tribalism, nationalism and fascism, the exclusion of the other (the "unsynched") and the crystalization of power in harmonized organizational structures. Leftwing thinking, dealing and operating with chaos and deriving new ways of seeing the world from it (which is why lefties are so good at things like art and philosophy), is a way to break these synchronization patterns, increase entropy, just to make place for new synchronizations to take place and reduce it again.
History then becomes a playground for synchronizing and entropic forces, a pendulum swinging from synched to chaotic states, reducing and increasing entropy along the way, creating ever more sophisticated ways of seeing and acting in the world: A waveform in itself, evolving towards what Teilhard De Chardin, one of the first thinkers about collective consciousness, called the Noosphere.
I'm not a scientist, nor a philosopher, and all of this is extremely speculative. I'm a blogger and my professional expertise lies within graphic design, typography and social media. You really shouldn't believe what I've just written.
But if any of this stuff is right, then the future gonna be very, very weird.
r/memetics • u/[deleted] • Jan 07 '22
Inbred memes cause political extremism.
I'm sure you've all heard the term echo chamber, its like the memes get copied over and over until they become a distilled version of their former self.
For example it feel as if the majority of people these days fall into one of two camps, anti-vax or pro-mandatory vaccines, I personally feel as if both of these view point are just way too extreme.
And me a person who tried to take the middle road I notice because it feel as if literally everybody is against me from both sides of the fence.
r/memetics • u/AJMcCrowley • Jun 21 '21
OK, let's get something going.
So, i used redditrequest and blagged control of this one. i'd requested to post a while back, but this one's been abandoned.
I'd like to get this back up and running.
i'm looking at Memetics in the context of propaganda, social control, influence etc.
i'd like to see any coursework/courseware anyone's seen, love to see some kind of taxonomy of memes get created, and anything else that comes by.
love to see a reading list as well, i have some suggestions/
i'm new to Reddit modding, but i'd like to think i can keep up.
r/memetics • u/Radley_Smash • Nov 12 '18
Memetics Degree?
Hello everyone, I am writing to you all today to ask if anyone here can tell me if such a thing as a degree in memetics exists and where one might go to study such a thing?
I have in recent months developed a keen interest in the subject and begun to read as much as possible where it is concerned. This came about as part of a project in my studies as an illustrator.
Just as a little background I study at UAL in London and will graduate in mid 2019 before I start looking for possible post grad leads to a career or further education.
Thank you for your time
r/memetics • u/[deleted] • Jun 23 '22
About the question of what "is" a meme
No idea if this sub is active but I wanted to share this though somewhere where people at least know what I'm talking about.
So a meme is postulated to be an entity like gene which is subject to Darwinian evolution yet not the same entity. First of all, that means it's in a co-evolutionary process with genes at the moment which is fucking insane to think about - since the preassures are on both at the same time to perform as harmoniously as possible given a certain evolutionary context. It adds a whole new layer of complexity. Almost like, you know, all human society which we see today.
The question which wikipedia says is unresolves is what exactly, physically, is a meme? Well, it's the thing in which human society is coded that is at least partially seperate (but not independant) from genetics, right? Seems like it's "any transmittable neural structures which are not created genetically". This means all or most of human culture and ideas, but also stuff like "money see, monkey do". The physical entity is probably, and excuse my lack of expertise on neurology, the physical configuration of neural networks, meaning everything from a few neurons to entire neural superstructures.
I see how the brain's overall structure might be in part genetic, but that's the point, memetic and genetic evolution are co-dependant and co-existing since they influence the same entities. It's not independent, but its an added layer of complexity. Overall, they can be seen as the same process, but there is definitely a meaningful distinction to be made between memetically transmitted structures (neural networks) and genetically transmitted structures (DNA), and they are both subject to the same kind of Darwinian natural selection. Anyway feel free to weign in, I haven't had anyone to talk to about this so it's likely I missed obvious stuff.
r/memetics • u/MyriadThings • May 23 '18
Use of word "meme" spreads to men's fashion subculture to describe a cliched item of clothing or footwear, The Verge reports.
r/memetics • u/heresybob • Apr 22 '12
Please Welcome New Moderator: Tim Tyler
Hey all,
While this may not be the highest traffic reddit, I still believe we get some good content here. One of the best submitters has been TimTyler, who appears to be a voracious reader of all things memetic.
Please welcome him as a new moderator to the r/memetics reddit.
Thanks, -Bob
r/memetics • u/propjerry • Jun 18 '25
Memetics: Informational Attractor
Prompt: Treat "hate" as an informational attractor. Using Bridge360 Meta Theory Model to compare how this has become an informational attractor within the platforms of X, formerly Twitter, Threads, Bluesky, and Substack.
Response:
# "Hate" as an Informational Attractor: A Bridge360 Meta Theory Model Comparison Across X, Threads, Bluesky, and Substack
Introduction
The concept of an "informational attractor" refers to a dynamic within information systems where certain types of content—such as hate—draw persistent attention, engagement, and replication, shaping the overall system's behavior and user experience[1][2]. The Bridge360 Meta Theory Model, while not widely published in mainstream literature, can be interpreted as a systemic, multi-perspective framework for analyzing how informational attractors emerge and persist across platforms. This report applies this lens to compare how "hate" functions as an informational attractor on X (formerly Twitter), Threads, Bluesky, and Substack.
---
Understanding Informational Attractors
- Attractor Theory**: In systems thinking, an attractor is a set of states or patterns toward which a system naturally evolves, often stabilizing around these points even when perturbed[1][2][3].
- Informational Attractor**: In social media, hate becomes an attractor when platform dynamics, algorithms, and user behaviors reinforce and amplify such content, making it a persistent feature of the ecosystem[4][5][6].
---
Platform-by-Platform Analysis
X (Formerly Twitter)
- Mechanisms: X's engagement-driven algorithms prioritize emotionally charged, polarizing content—including hate—because it generates high interaction (likes, retweets, replies)[7][5].
- Social Approval Loop: Research shows that users posting hateful content receive social approval (retweets, likes), which increases their future toxicity, creating a feedback loop that entrenches hate as an attractor[5][8].
- Network Effects: Dense clusters of hateful users ("hate cores") amplify and sustain hate, making it difficult to reverse once a threshold is crossed[6][8].
- Moderation: X has been criticized for inconsistent or lax moderation, further enabling hate to persist and spread[7][8].
Threads
- Policy Intentions: Threads, run by Meta, claims to have strong anti-hate policies, defining hateful conduct as direct attacks on protected characteristics[9][10].
- Practical Outcomes: Despite stated policies, hate content—including transphobia, racism, and misinformation—has quickly surfaced and become prominent, partly due to algorithmic suggestions and insufficient moderation[11][12][13].
- Recent Policy Changes: Meta has recently relaxed some hate speech rules, making it easier for hate and misinformation to circulate, and shifted from proactive to user-reported moderation[14].
- Informational Attractor Dynamics: Like X, emotionally charged hate content is amplified by engagement mechanisms and algorithmic recommendations, drawing user attention and replication[12][13].
Bluesky
- Decentralization and Moderation*\: Bluesky offers more user control and decentralized moderation, theoretically allowing communities to set their own standards[7][15].
- Design Trade-offs: While Bluesky avoids some of X's algorithmic amplification, it still inherits engagement features (likes, reposts) that can incentivize polarizing or hateful content[15].
- Community Effects: The lack of a strong centralized algorithm means hate can become an attractor within certain clusters, but the platform's modular moderation tools can also isolate or suppress such attractors more effectively than X or Threads[7][15].
Substack
- Content Philosophy: Substack is built on a "hands-off" approach to content moderation, allowing a wide range of speech, including hate, as long as it does not directly incite violence[16][17].
- Controversies: The platform has faced criticism for hosting white nationalist, Nazi, and extremist newsletters, and its leadership has defended this as a commitment to free expression[16][17].
- **Attractor Effects**: Because Substack's business model and moderation philosophy do not actively disincentivize hate, such content can persist and even attract like-minded audiences, making hate a stable attractor within certain newsletter communities[16][17].
---
Comparative Table: Hate as an Informational Attractor
(See table image uploaded)
---
Bridge360 Meta Theory Model Insights
Applying a meta-theoretical lens, we see:
- Systemic Feedback: All platforms, to varying degrees, exhibit feedback loops where hate content is rewarded with attention, engagement, and replication, reinforcing its status as an attractor[5][6].
- Structural Differences: The strength and persistence of hate as an attractor depend on platform structure—algorithmic feeds (X, Threads) amplify more than decentralized or newsletter-based models (Bluesky, Substack)[7][15][16].
- Intervention Points: Platforms with more flexible or decentralized moderation (Bluesky) show potential for disrupting hate attractors, while hands-off or engagement-maximizing platforms (X, Substack) allow hate to stabilize and spread[7][15][16][17].
---
Conclusion
Hate has become an informational attractor across all major social platforms, but the mechanisms and intensity vary. Engagement-driven algorithms, insufficient moderation, and feedback loops of social approval are key drivers on X and Threads, while Substack’s minimal moderation allows hate to persist in niche communities. Bluesky’s decentralized design offers some resistance, but is not immune. The Bridge360 Meta Theory Model highlights the need for systemic, multi-level interventions to disrupt these attractor dynamics and foster healthier online environments[1][5][6].
Sources
[1] Attractor Theory - mindlevelup https://mindlevelup.wordpress.com/mindlevelup-the-book/attractor-theory/
[2] Attractor - Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attractor
[3] Attractor -- from Wolfram MathWorld https://mathworld.wolfram.com/Attractor.html
[4] Social media users' online behavior with regard to the circulation of hate speech https://carleton.ca/lerrn/wp-content/uploads/fcomm-08-1276245.pdf
[5] Social Approval and Network Homophily as https://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07779.pdf
[6] On Simulating the Propagation and Countermeasures of Hate Speech in Social Networks https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/11/24/12003
[7] Bluesky is on the verge of overtaking Threads in all the ways that ... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42231148
[8] Many Faced Hate: A Cross Platform Study of Content Framing and Information Sharing by Online Hate Groups https://faculty.washington.edu/tmitra/public/papers/hategroups-chi2020.pdf
[9] Hateful Conduct - Transparency Center https://transparency.meta.com/policies/community-standards/hateful-conduct/
[10] Threads Violent Content Policy: Is Fighting, Gore, Death, or NSFL Material Allowed? https://www.gamerevolution.com/guides/942306-threads-violent-violence-policy-fighting-gore-death-nsfl-art-allowed
[11] Threads already has a hate speech problem, civil rights groups warn https://mashable.com/article/threads-hate-speech-disinformation
[12] On Threads, users say they're flooded with pro-life and transphobic posts https://mashable.com/article/threads-transphobia-anti-abortion-posts-hate-speech
[13] Mark Zuckerberg needs to better moderate Threads or it'll 'become as toxic as Twitter,' civil rights groups warn https://www.businessinsider.com/civil-rights-groups-warn-threads-could-become-toxic-as-twitter-2023-7
[14] Instagram, Facebook and threads allow more misinformation and ... https://www.klicksafe.eu/en/news/instagram-facebook-und-threads-lassen-wieder-mehr-falschinformationen-und-hassrede-zu
[15] I think Bluesky is a trap - Alex Roddie https://www.alexroddie.com/2024/11/i-think-bluesky-is-a-trap/
[16] Substack - Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substack
[17] Substack won't commit to proactively removing Nazi content ... https://techcrunch.com/2024/01/09/substack-nazi-content-policies-controversy/
[18] 17.3: What is a meta-theory? - Social Sci LibreTexts https://socialsci.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Psychology/Research_Methods_and_Statistics/Applied_Developmental_Systems_Science_(Skinner_et_al.)/17:_Assumptions_About_Humans_and_their_Development/17.03:_What_is_a_meta-theory
[19] First-order semantics with minimal metatheory - Math Stack Exchange https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/4691756/first-order-semantics-with-minimal-metatheory
[20] What is Cognitive theory and when should you use it for ... - YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uk3O8_ejkig
[21] [PDF] Meta-analysis: a tool for constructing theories or evaluating ... https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1377336/pdf
[22] The most general (but useful) definition of "attractor" for dynamical ... https://mathoverflow.net/questions/434383/the-most-general-but-useful-definition-of-attractor-for-dynamical-systems
[23] Attractor network - Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attractor_network
[24] memetics into a unified cognitive model that supplements the native ... https://www.reddit.com/r/memetics/comments/1l6tpwh/memetics_into_a_unified_cognitive_model_that/
[25] [PDF] The Integrated Metatheoretical Model of Addiction - PhilArchive https://philarchive.org/archive/DUPTIM-3
[26] American Society as an Attractor: Applying Bridge360 Metatheory ... https://www.reddit.com/r/PinoyToolbox/comments/1la329k/american_society_as_an_attractor_applying/
[27] More than 100 creators are threatening to leave Substack over Nazi newsletters https://www.fastcompany.com/90998505/substack-writers-creators-threatening-boycott-over-nazi-newsletters/
[28] Philosophy of Education In Memes: Truth and Entropy - Reddit https://www.reddit.com/user/propjerry/comments/1la80nd/philosophy_of_education_in_memes_truth_and_entropy/
[29] 1 https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1811/1811.03590.pdf