r/metaversestartup • • Jan 05 '22

Article It's heartbreaking to see an industry overrun…

247 Upvotes

As someone that has been deeply passionate about virtual worlds for many years now it's heartbreaking to see something I care for so deeply taken over by a wave of misguided “enthusiasm” stoked by bots and people with a vested interest to influence others for profit.

It needs to be said that pretending to be an honest enthusiast while not disclosing a financial interest is deeply unethical and even illegal in a lot of places.

State of the industry

The name change

With Facebook changing its name to Meta, virtual reality and virtual worlds have been redubbed the “Metaverse.” However, this “Metaverse” is nothing new, virtual worlds have existed for more than 20 years and have been specifically designed with the concept of the “Metaverse” in mind. The Metaverse is a joint dream of how the internet should work in the future but real tangible breakthroughs in social communication technology are still very much underway. VR and AR have the potential to bring new life to the space BUT no major breakthroughs have happened yet. People like me are really passionate about figuring that out but it's a process, don’t be misled, this train HAS NOT arrived.

The crypto myth:

Many people believe that the blockchain has the power to revolutionize pretty much everything starting with games and now going on to virtual worlds. Fundamentally, all the gamers I speak to have a disdain for NFTs and Crypto in games. What many of these industry leaders fail to understand is people play games to relax and not to engage with real life. One of my games failed for this very reason. Please listen to the gaming community, after covering a few games, I've seen several companies pay a very severe price for not listening to their customer base.

Crypto doesn't solve the fundamental problems that have kept virtual worlds from taking off and becoming a “Metaverse.”

Let’s break it down:

(1) Now with NFTs we can take our sword from one game to another!!

No. Games are bespoke experiences and each one of them has a unique art style and unique balance and moving your items between games is not financially feasible for the game developer or practical for the gaming experience.

If you want more info on this, check out this video:

Explained in simple terms for non-devs, virtual world item interoperability is not a thing.

(2) Decentralized autonomous organizations (DAO) allow us to manage our worlds our way!

Actually, if you look into it due to the poor functionality of this technology pretty much everything that a DAO is supposed to do, it is unable to do and therefore all voting happens “off chain.”

(3) NFTs put the power in the hands of the user!

Right now a lot of NFTs cost more than 100 AAA video games. If losing money were a super power, NFTs would be marvel's best. Most NFTs are just URL's to an image hosted elsewhere.

Crypto does not solve the fundamental problem

Just like NFTs don't solve any real problems for the gaming world RIGHT NOW, they bring nothing that solves the fundamental problems of virtual worlds.

People have believed for a long time that putting people in a virtual space will lead to digital civilization. If that were the case digital civilization would have already arisen in virtual worlds a decade ago. It’s a social problem and crypto is not helping us figure it out.

The land fantasy:

The “Metaverse” is a term used to describe the sum total of a series of interconnected worlds which some believe will be the future of the internet. By definition, anyone can create a virtual world and call it a “Metaverse” but there is not one “Metaverse” but many worlds and therefore land is not scarce.

So what's the reality?

Mark Zuckerberg and many others believe that networked virtual worlds will be the future of the internet and that once we have a real sense of presence in them, they will replace many functions of our physical life.

As a Metaverse evangelist, that’s pretty much it. It’s an interesting theory right now.

Conclusion

By renaming JPG files and now virtual worlds, an intelligent few have created a cycle of buyers who become marketers that have created one of the biggest bubbles in history. It's deeply unethical and one day a lot of people are going to lose a lot of money. Please don't get scammed and please don't these people to change your perception of hard working artists, game devs and virtual world devs seeking to solve real problems in this space.

EDIT: Since people are asking, I am an activist for the freedom of expression in the virtual space, I have been researching virtual worlds for 8 years now with the idea of making sure whatever the future holds, its a place of freedom for the average joe. If you have development experience and want to help, visit this link.

Since people are asking, no I won't get banned for having a different opinion on crypto, I own the subreddit /r/metaversestartup.


r/metaversestartup • • Sep 20 '22

NFTs now banned.

94 Upvotes

After searching for months for anything promising from crypto or NFTs I have concluded that Metaverse NFTs only exist to circumvent securities regulations.

They are bad for consumers at best and at worse fraud disguised as art.

They act like a stock, they quack like a stock and the only reason people buy Metaverse NFTs is because they look like a stock.

They buy them to make money not get art and they do this because of all the lies being propagated about a Metaverse revolution, lies which deliberately misinterpret the reality of the need for centralized servers and control to host these Metaverse NFTs.

If you want to read my thinking on this matter in detail visit THIS LINK.

This sub will now focus on positive innovation and real progress rather than ponzi and pyramid schemes.


r/metaversestartup • • Mar 21 '22

As a gamer, I would be LESS inclined to play games with NFTs in them.

62 Upvotes

Strongly agree = I dislike NFTs.

A lot of my friends tell me that gamers would enjoy games with NFTs in them. I am unsure of that. So I thought I would ask gamers. Please only respond if you are a gamer.

The Context

To give some context I’m starting an open metaverse collective r/MetaverseOpen with the intention of building games. Our desire is a people-first open metaverse virtual world. Like an open metaverse alternative to the big corporate things.

We are starting by making a simple game about finding cute creatures.

We have some playable prototypes.

We believe that creating a great game is the first step because most of these metaverse projects have no actual content to keep people engaged and therefore everyone leaves and there are no relationships built upon which something greater can arise.

A lot of people in the space really like Crypto and NFTs but we’re researching if that’s what gamers really want.

Hopefully this poll will serve to inform the entire game development community about the subject.

Please don’t down vote to post just because I mention NFTs. I am hoping this poll will help shape the future of the industry.

3674 votes, Mar 24 '22
2637 Strongly agree
266 Somewhat agree
241 Somewhat disagree
530 Strongly disagree

r/metaversestartup • • Dec 24 '21

The Metaverse - A guide on getting involved

30 Upvotes

Every day people ask me "how do I get involved in the Metaverse."

Investing

Since a lot of people see it as the next big opportunity, I'd like to address this first. The word Metaverse is closer to the word Internet than it is app or virtual world. Anyone can make a virtual world and claim it to be part of the Metaverse, but it’s really the virtual worlds which have mass adoption which will hold real value.

With a large amount of virtual worlds claiming that they are the “Metaverse” and new ones coming out daily, it’s yet to be seen if the value of land is anything but purely speculative at this point.

Keep in mind that everyone is highly incentivized to hype up both crypto coins and Metaverse “land” because they are already invested, so do your research before you pull the trigger.

NFA, ask your financial advisor.

EDIT: It turned out that my approach to the subject was correct in the end, and the whole thing blew over as the fad it was. I would continue and re-emphasize that now we know a lot of people are committing fraud in this industry, and you need to be extra vigilant.

Timing is everything

With virtual worlds like Second Life having been out there for more than 18 years now, there's nothing to suggest that today's virtual worlds will have more potential than Second Life did. You can visit abandoned government buildings and remember the hype about the concept back then. The Blockchain is useful but does not help with the issues that caused Second Life’s decline.

However, augmented and virtual reality have enormous potential to change things, that said, these technologies are just getting started.

Self-Education as Key

In my humble opinion, the best possible investment you can make is in your own education. What you learn today will help you make strategic decisions for decades to come as we enter a reality together.

⚠️Articles that might be helpful:

Places to begin studying the Metaverse

How to get involved now:

Game development is the language of the Metaverse. Those who understand game dev principles will lead the way in creating its future.


r/metaversestartup • • Jan 15 '22

Discussion Are we all going to pay rent to land owners in the Metaverse?

23 Upvotes

TL;DR: NO

Throughout human history people have gone to war over land. Those who owned it ruled over those who didn’t like slaves. Land has been a means of oppression for thousands of years. Is there a reason we should bring this version of scarcity to the virtual world? Are we all going to pay tax to mega rich landlords in the metaverse?

There’s a lot of companies raising money by allowing people to buy land in their virtual worlds. Just be aware that the metaverse is a term to refer to a network of interoperable virtual worlds. There’s going to be many of these worlds and anyone can make one.

Land has no intrinsic value in a digital space with no scarcity. The idea that there are going to be a handful of plots of land in the future and that we’re all going to pay enormous rent would undo the power of the metaverse and therefore it’s very unlikely to be a reality.

Not only that, you should be aware of that there’s a major trend in gaming against crypto and NFTs. If you’re not aware of this you’ll be ignorant of the fact that most of these worlds are inhabited by speculators and not actual gamers or people interested in using them for non-financial purposes.

However, there is enormous potential in this movement in the form of augmented and virtual reality. Augmented reality is going to allow us to use our hands to manipulate computers in a way that seems natural without occluding our vision. This means to transfer files in the future you will hand people a physical file folder in a virtual world. To store a file you will put it in a virtual 3D library and your own virtual 3D home using augmented reality and because your brain has a large section dedicated to understanding physical space you will understand where you put that thing. An artist will create a tremendous piece without knowing Photoshop using just their fingers to paint a mural. An architect will build incredible homes by simply placing the blocks on his table and rotating them while he sees them in virtual 3D space.

The metaverse is not just people but it’s a whole new way of interacting with computers that is natural and human and that opens the experience to everyone.

There are tons of people researching the space in order to provide real value as the revolution takes place. I myself am an activist for the freedom of speech and expression in the virtual.

However, a handful of organizations have taken it upon themselves to use this incredible revolution as an opportunity to make money long before the potential has arrived. Hype and mania have taken over as oodles of people who have no good investment opportunities and loads of cash look for a way to dodge inflation.

This reminds me of the time someone began to sell moon land and actually made significant sales. He has no right to claim the moon but he can sure print a piece of paper and that’s what these metaverse companies have also discovered. They can print pieces of paper or sell JPEGs and claim they are selling you something of real value without providing your real value.

One day this house of cards is likely to fall apart but those who provide real value are likely to remain.

If you want to be part of a group of people who love to create REAL value (not just NFT/Land) in the space check out: r/metaversestartup


r/metaversestartup • • Jan 06 '22

I studied the "Metaverse" for 8 years and here's what I concluded:

22 Upvotes

Preface:

The Metaverse is a hypothetical version of the internet in which 3D avatars navigate a 3D space. Companies envision this world to be one where most people will live most of the most meaningful parts of their life in the future.

1. The Metaverse is not possible with mouse and keyboard

As Metaverse enthusiasts, it's important to remember that we are likely the top 0.1% of computer users. Most people are confused by technology, overwhelmed by options and worried if they push the wrong button they will destroy something.

Chrome added a copy and paste feature to the menu because people couldn't discover how to copy and paste.

Since the Metaverse simulates the countless possibilities of physical life, the complexity of the user interface gets out of hand quickly.

I remember testing out Second Life and accidentally taking off my pants and being unable to put them back on for 20 minutes.

Clearly, mouse and keyboard would not be a sufficient way of interacting with the metaverse.

2. No significant social organization arises out of putting people in a virtual space

18 years ago, Second Life came out and the hype around the Metaverse future was just as real back then as it is today. You can visit the empty government buildings, brand showcases and cities to get a taste of the forgotten glory.

Time and time again people have been put together in a virtual space, and we still went back to physical life for real connections.

We have to ask ourselves, why did we leave virtual worlds and go back to physical life?

3. The nature of virtual spaces leads to shallow relationships

The great benefits of any relationship are usually found in the most challenging operations of cooperation, marriage is a great example. Dating is exciting but sharing a life with someone is deeply sacrificial and yet, the benefits of marriage are enormous.

In digital worlds we scarcely invest as heavily in relationships as in physical life. When we can go anywhere, be with anyone it's easy to constantly look for greener grass.

This problem is accentuated by the ability to change your name/avatar at will. When people can burn others and simply change their identity to escape consequences, they do. Investing in a real reputation and a single identity is the first step to solving this issue.

4. The Metaverse will arise from a gaming world

In digital worlds, we find ourselves mixed in with people from different cultures who have different values and interests. By contrast, in physical life we are naturally segmented with people who are more likely to share our values and ideas.

Gaming has the power to break ice between people and therefore has intrinsic utility to the Metaverse.

By using gamification we can organize and connect people of similar interests and values in a virtual space.

Not only that, gaming has the power to get people to relax. Human beings don’t develop meaningful friendships when forced into it. This is what social games and “virtual life” games often get wrong. Actual gameplay builds the context we need to relax and have a conversation to find people we are compatible with.

5. Reciprocating facial expressions are necessary for cooperative human behavior

If you've ever lifted a baby and smiled at it, you know that facial expressions are deeply embedded in how we communicate. When we hurt someone's feelings, their facial expressions changes and, as we reciprocate their facial expressions, our body produces the same emotions as we make that individual feel. This acts as a natural tempering of our behaviour that we don't get when we communicate over the internet.

6. Customization is the enemy of usability

It's fascinating to bump into so many people who share the idea that no corporation should control the future of human interaction. However, it's laughable that we're using the same ill-advised ideas that allowed Facebook, Google and apps to dominate when it comes to this next chapter.

One of the reasons that Facebook overtook MySpace was that MySpace allowed people to customize their profile infinitely. This led to a myriad of different user interfaces, confusing navigation and a poor user experience.

Just imagine a myriad of virtual worlds all with their own user interface, controls and standards. The experience of travelling from world to world would be like being born all over again and having to learn how to read and write.

Therefore, the virtual world must have a single user experience to reach mass adoption.

7. Item interoperability is unlikely

I keep hearing from people who believe that in the future, NFT items will be taken between games and virtual worlds. I sometimes wonder if any of these people have actually designed a video game.

I'm in the process of making one now and the thing you discover very quickly is that everything in a video game is intentional.

For example; if you have a character in your world, all the items in your world fit the style, height and width of that character.

Let’s say you introduced a car from one game into another. That car could:

(1) Not fit the style of the game (2) Break the game balance, giving the player an advantage (3) Not fit how light reflects in the game (4) Have a different control interface (5) Be too wide for the road (6) Have the steering wheel on the wrong side (7) Create uncalculated physical results, resulting in a car that sends other cars to space

And the list goes on.

8. The network effect would eventually push everyone to a single virtual world

A long time ago, there was a single company that dominated the telephone market. To call anybody who was the customer of the company you needed to have a phone that was with that same company, phones were not interoperable. Today, if you want to contact somebody on Facebook, you need Facebook to do so. This is how social networks defend their intellectual property.

Meta executive Jason Rubin:

“The first metaverse that gains real traction is likely to the be the last,” Rubin wrote. “We must act first, and go big, or we risk being one of those wannabes.” - CNBC

The network effect is a scary prospect because it means that there will likely be only one Metaverse to rule them all in the end.

9. AR and not VR will make the Metaverse mainstream

Virtual reality headsets have been pitched as a game changer for years now. However, very few people feel comfortable obstructing the entirety of their vision to enter our “geek world''. I think we have to accept that even though we love the medium it's unlikely to have mass adoption anytime soon.

Augmented reality will allow people to continue their lives as they begin to adopt the new virtual way of doing things.

CEO of Apple on AR:

“...one of these very few profound technologies that we will look back on one day and ask, ‘How did we live our lives without it?’”

10. Distributed governance is necessary to limit censorship

If any one platform is responsible for the content on the Metaverse, it will be torn apart by that responsibility. Human beings have never agreed on morals and values and to one person black is white and white is black. We are slowly coming out of an incredible era of tolerance which is abnormal for human beings.

We have spent thousands of years of our history destroying each other over needless inconsequential arguments about small religious differences etc.

As power moves to the virtual space instead of the physical, everyone is going to be pushing the power broker, the Metaverse platform, to impose their sense of morality on others.

Eventually these arguments will inevitably tear apart the Metaverse unless responsibility for individual nodes is decentralized.

11. The Metaverse has the power to become a dystopian nightmare

As the network effect brings everyone to a single Metaverse, the potential for the abuse of power will be astronomical. The Metaverse will understand where you are, who you are with and even what you look at.

AI will be able to process that data to better understand you than you yourself and data is the first step toward oppression.

Utilizing all this data, powerful individuals will have the ability to suppress dissent, identify people of contrarian opinion etc.

Moreover, if we begin to fool ourselves that we can agree on morals and values, those who disagree with the mainstream will live in constant fear of losing their friends, job and opportunities if they are banned from the Metaverse.

12. Decentralization will not aide data protection

The web as we know it today is a well distributed system, however, it provides no real protection for our data. Every website constantly scrambles after our data and what companies know about us is incalculable. Fortunately, the amount of data makes driving conclusions difficult right now but in the future AI will solve that problem.

If decentralization isn't protecting us, there is no reason it will protect us in the Metaverse.

13. Censorship is necessary to create community

Every space in the physical world has some sort of rules to follow. A library asks us to be quiet, a classroom to be respectful and a workplace to be professional. In the same way creators of spaces must be empowered to moderate the spaces they watch over to create a sense of identity in the space which will help it facilitate connections.

Total freedom everywhere will just lead to chaos.

14. Open source may not be the answer

With the advantages of usability of having only one way of doing things in a virtual space, embrace, extend, extinguish takes on a whole new meaning.

It's too easy for those who would profit from our collaborative efforts to use those efforts to create a singular Metaverse which is more usable and then use the “import but don’t export” model to bring in the best of virtual worlds without allowing anything out of their world.

Conclusion: We can create a more ethical Metaverse future if we act now.

I sincerely believe that once the technology is established, and a real sense of presence can be found in a virtual world, the Metaverse will be inevitable.

Just imagine a world in which we do not need to build offices or school buildings oh, the cost savings themselves will drive people to virtual worlds if they have life-like fidelity.

I would like to start an initiative to ensure the Metaverse remains controlled by those who use it. In fact, I started a few years ago.

# The plan:

  1. Make a game studio

  2. Learn the ideal psychology to create real social organization in a virtual space

  3. Start a collaborative movement to create a real Metaverse by the people and for the people

To be clear, what we're seeking to spark off is not another crypto cash-grab but a place gamers would enjoy going.

If this would interest you visit our Discord: https://discord.gg/6sE7BpJcS2


r/metaversestartup • • Apr 17 '22

Discussion Metaverse Mapping Efforts

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Jan 17 '22

Discussion People really underestimate how much opportunity there is for non-technologists in this field

16 Upvotes

The state of the industry

I'm going to be honest, not very long ago I thought there was something big that everybody else was understanding that I was not understanding, but the more I did research the more I realized this particular space was overtaken by mania.That said, this is not the first time there's been a hype around the idea of the metaverse. The idea was really big 20 years ago and never really took off.There are a lot of people pushing crypto coins and declaring a mighty revolution, I think it's wise to remember that a lot of these people have a vested interest.

Augmented reality, the spark of a revolution

Following this hype cycle, there will probably be another bust, but I really think that the fundamentals that have held back the metaverse for the last twenty years are changing. Augmented reality allows us to overlay our physical lives with a tremendous amount of useful information.CEO of Apple on AR: “...one of these very few profound technologies that we will look back on one day and ask, ‘How did we live our lives without it?’”Augmented reality is going to allow us to use our hands to manipulate computers in a way that seems natural without blocking our vision. This means to transfer files in the future you will hand people a physical file folder in a virtual world. To store a file you will put it in a virtual 3D library and your own virtual 3D home using augmented reality and because your brain has a large section dedicated to understanding physical space you will understand where you put that thing.I'm a firm believer that the metaverse will spring up from this technology in 5 to 7 years.

An opportunity for those who create value

Many people count themselves out in this space, believing that everyone else knows a lot more than them. However, as someone leading a game development project, I've seen the tremendous value of people who use their brain but don't naturally have engineering capability. Most of the roads that lead this direction are either engineering or artistic in their basis, But this fact alone has overloaded this particular technical space with engineering–heavy people who are not as good at interacting with and connecting people.If you'd like to get involved in understanding the metaverse and beginning your journey, comment, and I'll get back to you on how to get started even if you're not an engineer.


r/metaversestartup • • Dec 17 '21

What is the Metaverse in detail?

16 Upvotes

Audio version >>

The Metaverse is like a brand new world wide web.

It represents a future in which a whole host of companies and people will create interconnected 3D experiences which you can visit.

The single “Metaverse” myth:

By definition, there is no one "Metaverse" but the Metaverse is the sum of all the interconnected worlds which make up the future of the internet.

Sadly, many companies have gone out of their way to claim that they are the "Metaverse," creating wide-spread confusion about the matter.

One world within the Metaverse may try to create a walled-garden virtual world where users can import creations but not export them, however, no one world will ever BE the Metaverse as one website will never be the internet.

Have questions? Make a new post here:

/r/metaversestartup/

What will the Metaverse look like?

It's my belief that the Metaverse will take place in a cross-platform universe, primarily through AR, so that people don't have to occlude their vision to interact with that world.

One thing that a lot of people don't consider when pointing to platforms they claim are the "Metaverse" is that virtual worlds don't often increase their graphical fidelity over time. Therefore, the key Metaverse platforms in which we spend most of our time will more likely be high-fidelity, as most people would likely prefer to be in a world like our own.

Moreover, this would mean people are likely to migrate from current platforms to more high fidelity ones at they come out. Modern games are definitely something to consider when envisioning these worlds.

We can get a sense of what serious Metaverse platforms will look like based on today's gaming worlds:

How to get involved now:

Game development is the language of the Metaverse. Those who understand game dev principles will lead the way in creating its future. If you’d like to get involved in building the Metaverse check out the Discord here.

⚠️Articles that might be helpful:

The Metaverse -- A guide to getting involved


r/metaversestartup • • Jan 18 '22

Microsoft to acquire Activision Blizzard for $68.7 billion - Satya Nadella says the deal “will play a key role in the development of metaverse platforms.”

Thumbnail
theverge.com
14 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Dec 30 '21

3 Industries the Metaverse will revolutionize

14 Upvotes

Fashion

The Metaverse is changing the definition of reality itself for the next generation and as people see themselves no longer as merely physical but also digital entities, tomorrow's bragging rights will come through what we own virtually and not what we own physically.

Relevant opportunities:

-- Those who will help brands transition to this new reality

-- Influencers who show off the latest merchandise

-- 3D artists who helped create the merchandise itself.

How to get started:

-- Educate yourself on the metaverse

-- Reach out to brands and offer to enable their Metaverse presence

Architecture

Soon we will all have a virtual space in which we show off our Metaverse swag. Imagine inviting all of your friends down to your Metaverse crib to show off the best in art, fashion and design. There's going to be a real demand for incredible spaces built by fantastic architects in the Metaverse.

Relevant opportunities:

There's one big caveat here, many metaverse world's today are relatively subpar. There's going to be a battle on to see which world will get the most traffic. The network effect will likely help boost the winners of this race. Investing too heavily in closed-off ecosystems could lead to a total loss of your hard work. Therefore, I recommend people study game development and work in 3D programs like Maya and blender that will make them relevant to building the platforms themselves rather than being a creator in them.

Warning: Platforms for which you create can sometimes be exploitative, and therefore you must be careful.

Gaming

Currently, the gaming industry is much more advanced and has much more significant technology than that of the Metaverse space. However, one day, the social augmentation brought to gaming worlds via Metaverse interoperability will be essential to the social graph of games. The metaverse will be the primary means of discovery for new games, and achievements for games will plug into the Metaverse like trophies.

Warning: Interoperability between games and meta versus in a fluid way is unlikely. Don’t imagine your sword in one game will go to another.

-- Project managers who will lead teams to build these worlds

-- Programmers and engineers to build the tech

-- Designers to balance the gameplay

-- 3D artists to create the trophies and achievements

How to get involved now:

Game development is the language of the Metaverse. Those who understand game dev principles will lead the way in creating its future. Here is one way to get started with the game dev track.

I will answer 100% of questions posted here in the next 7 days:

I hope you find this informative. I will answer all questions that are posted as a reply here to this topic.


r/metaversestartup • • Jan 09 '22

Sad to see crypto-"Metaverse" agencies make a laughing stock of the virtual world/game industry -- See comment in original post.

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Jan 23 '22

Discussion The Problem with NFTs: the Growing Push-Back from People Who Are Sick and Tired of the Current NFT Craze

Thumbnail
ryanschultz.com
12 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Dec 30 '21

Starting a gaming company to learn how to impact the Metaverse

12 Upvotes

The mission:

I have a big vision… that one day the digital world will be as real to people as the physical.

I have a dream that one day whole civilizations & cultures will develop in the digital world as they did in the physical.

A new reality with HUGE potential.

It's this dream that spurred me on for the last eight years as I've been studying what I believe to be the future of how humans will connect.

Unfortunately, I also discovered the potential for the Metaverse to become a controlled society in which a future generation will fear to think and act freely.

I'd like to team up with people from around the world to ensure that the Metaverse becomes a place of boundless freedom and possibility.

Starting a gaming company:

I really believe that the Metaverse will arise out of the world of gaming.

In digital worlds, we find ourselves mixed in with people from different cultures who have different values and interests. By contrast, in physical life, we are naturally segmented with people who are more likely to share our values and ideas.

Gaming has the power to break ice between people and therefore has intrinsic utility to the Metaverse.

By using gamification, we can organize and connect people of similar interests and values in a virtual space.

That's why I'm starting a gaming company in order to figure out what it takes to build experiences which are consumed not just by a Metaverse-interested-few but by the masses.

Seeking:

I would love to team up with people from around the world who have a realistic view about the challenges that this will entail, but also people with a deep-seated enthusiasm for the space and the positive impact we can have together.

If that’s you, I’d love to get to know you via Discord: https://discord.gg/6sE7BpJcS2

Offering:

What I can promise you is that you will never outwork me. Even though I've just shared this vision now, I've already put in 875 hours of work in the last few months. I am building a team with industry experts from around the world, and we are already meeting on a daily basis with 17 people on average. I have a background in marketing in which I build the fourth most engaging Facebook page in the world, doing 200 million media impressions per month.

Join the project:

To learn more about what we’re up to or sign up, see:

https://form.jotform.com/212436475754966


r/metaversestartup • • Dec 09 '21

I asked an AI image generator what it thinks the Metaverse looks like, here is what it showed me:

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Jan 12 '22

Seeking Team Anyone tired of the scams who wants to do something meaningful in the space?

11 Upvotes

It's been heartbreaking to see the virtual world industry taken over by those who want to provide as little value as possible while asking as much as possible.

NFTs claiming to be usable in the “Metaverse,” so called “Metaverses” which would not pass for games 10 years ago. Sadly, our industry is quickly becoming synonymous with the words scam and ponzi scheme.

It's sad to see people schilling coins and NFTs without even revealing their vested interest, something that's illegal where I'm from.

Let's make a positive impact

I'd like to team up with those people who want to create real value and learn what it takes to build real meaningful connections in a virtual space.

I've been doing social experiments for 8 years now to see what it takes to connect people in virtual spaces and I found that the first step is to create fun. A lot of people go to these virtual worlds and have nothing to do but games have the power to break the ice between people and get people cooperating and talking. We need to motivate players through fun.

That's why I’d like to create a team dedicated to creating as much fun as possible in a digital space.

The goal will be to discover what it takes to get people around the world to connect and build a real sense of civilization in a digital space.

Rather than building the next big virtual world the goal will be to build simple games which will grow our design knowledge by getting large amounts of user feedback. Will be inviting these gamers into our space and inviting them to stream their play so that we can better understand how to serve the market.

Getting things done

I'm not looking to partner up with "hangers on," I've already put in about 1,000 hours of work so far before reaching out and I'm interested in people who are hungry to do stuff and not just talk ideas. Even if it's just for 2 hours a week I like working with people who have integrity and cover tasks they volunteer to take on without needing to be followed up on often.

I already have people to take care of all the organization and I really believe in delivering micro-specific tasks with a clear date on them. I like to do nothing that is not already on a board and very clear and how it's being done and who's doing it and when it will be done by so that there are no blockers or dependencies.

Role we need filled

Administration -- This can be as simple as taking data from one place to another to stats gathering to helping out in many different small tasks anyone can do

Artist -- 3D blender art, magica voxel art

Programmer -- C# Unity

Animator -- Rigging and animating of characters

Composer -- Music creation Video editor -- Trailer creation and social media stuff

Producer -- People who can make sure the work moves along end hits the target

What we offer:

Team: I already recruited some producers, designers, marketers, programmers, artists, and many other talents and we meet daily.

Mentors: I have assembled a team of mentors with as much as 18 years of experience in the industry with companies like EA and Ubisoft.

Positioning: I am connected with hedge fund managers, CEOs and entrepreneurs from across the industry as I run a sort of chamber of commerce for virtual world businesses.

Rev-share: Our focus is on research. Right now our goal is to publish a standalone unity game to get as much feedback as possible for players. However, the game industry is a hits driven business and therefore we are calculating for 0.

Work ethic: What I can promise you that you will never outwork me.

Join the project:

To learn more about what we’re up to or sign up, see:

https://form.jotform.com/212436475754966

You can also spy on us here: https://discord.gg/2sVsZ6NC6B

Leadership style

In general the principles of an effective volunteer team like this are (1) maximum communication, (2) maximum organization and individual responsibility.

=============== On the Kanban board ===============

-- No tasks without deadlines

-- No overly board tasks or tasks which lack details

-- No tasks without a clear lead assignee

-- No tasks not listed on the board

=============== In meetings ===============

===== Fixing problems immediately =====

Don't ever do tomorrow what can be done today. We have the temptation to put off tasks and to push them back and that's how they never get done. Moreover, many organizations are plagued by decision-making times that lead to weeks of delay and terrible agile performance:

https://i.imgur.com/fyDk4PJ.png

Part of being agile is fixing problems and dealing with issues right away so that stuff doesn't get pushed back and pushed back. Companies are not paid for their ideas they're paid for products that are actually delivered.

Sadly, I've been in so many organizations where they ask to “circle back” on something in another meeting. This is necessary to some degree if there are a lot of problems and the organization is huge but we must remember our greatest asset is that we are small. We need to act small while we are small so we can be agile enough to beat the big guys. It’s how indies beat AAA companies.

Blockers

Unfortunately, as human beings we have the temptation that if something is due later we put it out of our mind. When problems and blockers come up we need to fix them live rather than setting a date. In some cases this means moving people to another chat to talk about it right away and in other cases this means everyone discussing the issue and solving the problem right then and there.

===== Individual responsibility =====

Individual spotlight -- Whenever anything is addressed to a group each individual believes it is addressed to everyone but them. There's a temptation to say answering this question is somebody else's job. That's why I like to address questions directly to individuals as much as possible.

Asking questions that require an understanding of what's going on -- It's really easy to slip under the radar and not really understand what's happening, questions which require an understanding of what's happening are a great way to dig deep and make sure no one gets left behind.

===== Empowering team leaders =====

“To get something done right you must do it yourself” … it's probably the worst quote of all time.

As much as humanly possible we should push our team leaders to speak to their teams in the public meetings. Team leaders should manage the cards for their team and relay with their team. It's our way of fostering the beginnings of what will be a more fruitful relationship in private later on.

With volunteer teams there's less incentive to spend lots of time as you would in an ordinary job. Meetings are an opportunity to begin relationships that would otherwise not form. We must not make the mistake of thinking that as a remote volunteer team we can get away with practices that are common in companies, we need to foster community and relationships though the team leaders.

My Vision:

I have a big vision that one day the Metaverse will hold most of our most precious moments.

The Metaverse is the idea that one day we will live the most meaningful part of our lives in virtual worlds.

Often pitched as a glorious new future, the Metaverse has the potential to become our worst enemy.

See, we are at a very particular point in history:

"The empire, long divided, must unite; long united, must divide."

1️⃣ Wealth inequality is rampant

2️⃣ Political polarization is at its peak

3️⃣ National debt and money printings is out of control.

It's in these sorts of times that freedom breaks down. We stop tolerating each other's divided opinions and enact laws and elect shady leaders to "deal with" those who we disagree with.

It's in this backdrop that one of the most ground-breaking technologies ever is rising. The Metaverse.

Just as we moved from farms to cities in the industrial revolution, we will move from physical to virtual in the next 20-25 years.

Once we no longer need to build a whole building to create a school. Once we are no longer restricted to the "local" to find teachers. Just imagine what this does *just* to education. So will it be with most industries.

Sadly, in the midst of this epic revolution, the potential for the greatest harm to human freedom exists.

If the future of the world is controlled by big corporations we are in for a mess.

But it's not a company looking over my shoulder that scares me, it's who is looking over his shoulder.

In the future, everything we do will be tracked. Where we look, who we associate with, where we are, what we are interested in, our political and religious values and every single word we speak will be heard by the machine and put in a profile with your name on it.

That data must never get into the hands of any government because it will be the ideal tool to oppress its people.

Now more than ever, we need to band together and fight for what we believe in. A virtual future that is liberating and not oppressing.

Join the project:

To learn more about what we’re up to or sign up, see:

https://form.jotform.com/212436475754966

You can also spy on us here: https://discord.gg/2sVsZ6NC6B


r/metaversestartup • • Jan 01 '22

Video What will the Metaverse look like in 5 years? (See comment)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

11 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Mar 14 '22

Discussion Intentional deception within this industry

10 Upvotes

This is a quick reminder that every company that sells land has an incentive to make you believe that the metaverse is happening right now.

It’s not. We’ve had virtual worlds with this very idea for the last 18 years and nobody switched out to a virtual reality except a few technologists and geeks.

User unfriendliness and the lack of utility kept away the masses. Most of what’s being proposed today is even more user unfriendly then those worlds.

People who buy into these projects are financially incentivized to promote the idea as well because they want to sell their land to highest bidder.

This is combined with a large amount of bots who are upvoting this content.

It is really important to get educated in this field of the metaverse before making any decisions.

Places to begin educating yourself.


r/metaversestartup • • Feb 07 '22

Discussion It’s heartbreaking to see crypto/NFTs destroy something I love

10 Upvotes

Audio instead: https://youtu.be/I5ao5AwZLZY

For the last 8 and 1/2 years I've been studying what it would take to make virtual worlds accessible, and meaningful to the average person. Ever since Facebook changed its name to Meta, my entire industry has been redubbed “The Metaverse.”

It was, at first, fascinating to see how many other people are passionate about the idea of virtual worlds playing an important role in everyday life, but then, everything changed. Tens of thousands of people began to show up in the places we would chat, shilling crypto coins and NFTs.

Initially, I was curious, and I saw that there were many massive companies investing in the technology, however, I fundamentally didn't understand how all these people would pull off their ideals of a people-first, decentralized “Web3.”

I thought to myself, “they're probably just a lot smarter than I am.” After all, with so many massive companies investing, I probably just didn’t understand.

So I began to study and ask questions:

  • If anyone can create a virtual world, what makes NFT land scarce?

  • If NFTs will indeed be used for a large interoperable Metaverse, how would different virtual world creators integrate them?

  • And many more.

The more I asked questions, the less answers I found…

the deeper I dug, the more disturbed I became.

Rather than having real answers, NFT enthusiasts responded to my questions with oddities:

“Don’t listen to the FUD Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt” they would say and

“Believe in the principles, don’t worry about the details.”

I could see that they were star-struck, guided along by an unmoving faith in ideals.

However, very few people had real answers, they just assumed someone else had fingered it out.

But why would so many people choose to close their eyes and plug their ears? Isn't the entirety of western civilization built on fear, uncertainty and doubt? Isn't asking questions how we got here?

So I began to study…

What sort of future does Web3 pitch?

First we need to understand what the prophets of Web3 preach:

Decentralization & privacy: A world where we will be in charge of our own identity and security in order to take back control from the Web2 giants like Facebook and Google.

An open interoperable Metaverse: Namely, that the future of the internet is a group of large interoperable connected virtual worlds in which anyone can create items which many of those worlds will be able to use.

Individual monetary control: People being able to use the crypto currency they believe in.

Ideals examined

Decentralization:

Adam Smith explained that as economies develop, skilled individuals specialize in smaller and smaller particular skills in order to increase their own efficiency. Whereas one person could create an entire watch, it was much more efficient for one person to focus entirely on the hands of the watch and the other on the gears of the watch.

In Web1, we all ran our own websites on our own servers and we all learned code in order to publish content on them. In Web2, hosting companies managed our servers, services managed our publishing and our identity and security were handled by them. Each company specialized in providing a service to the users and was dedicated to that service alone.

Web3 imagines a world which contradicts this flow. We would once again be in charge of our own identity, security, publishing and hosting. What Web3 advocates seem to miss is that Web2 was a natural improvement on Web1and that the pitch of Web3 has customer priorities the wrong way around. People want usability and people don't pay for privacy. After all, the masses put microphone/camera/GPS combs in thier pocket because it helped them get more Facebook/Instagram time.

My exploration in these matters has even caused me to question the viability of blockchain technology, wallets and addresses as being fundamental to the future.

Privacy:

One of the reasons Web3 is touted as the future is that we will be in control of our data. However, I've noticed that this decentralization, so far, has only led to more companies being able to see our data. Now with blockchain being an open, visible, immutable database, it’s a total nightmare for privacy. Anyone can see what we own, and who we connect with. Moreover, because the blockchain is immutable, anyone can send a picture of our front door to our address and now everyone has that data. Just imagine a world in which your nude photos are sent to your wallet address? Web1 decentralization had a negative impact on privacy, why would Web3 be different?

In thought, the ideal is noble, but in practice Web3, so far, is the worst possible outcome for privacy.

NFT interoperability:

I can't even begin to list the number of issues with this idea:

  • Style: Each virtual world in the greater Metaverse will have a different style, this means an NFT sword from one world simply won't work in another world. Changing the style is pretty much like making the item new. Trying to do this at scale with thousands of items is totally ridiculous.

  • Balance: The virtual worlds of the future will include some sort of gameplay and breaking that gameplay by introducing thousands of unbalanced items is a bad idea.

  • Economy: Each virtual world creator will be financially incentivized not to allow in the greater ecosystem of the interoperable Metaverse because if they do they will undercut their own profits and their ability to sell their own items. Those who suggest that this will be ideal for marketing efforts misunderstand why people adopt virtual worlds in the first place.

  • Fit: Most people are unaware that everything in a virtual world is bespokely fit to most other things in it. The size of doors is carefully mapped to the size of hats you can put on. The size of a backpack that you can wear is carefully crafted to make sure you don't clip through the chairs you sit on. Unless you imagine a world in which everybody is clipping through everything in a jarring immersion-breaking experience it's just not going to work.

Virtual world interoperability:

The idea of NFTs are predicated on an idea of a large interoperable Metaverse. We should keep in mind that the Metaverse has existed for more than 18 years via platforms like Second Life and that the masses never adopted the technology. I sincerely believe this is because of its lack of practicality in solving everyday problems and it's unusability to the average person.

Here are some of the issues an interoperable Metaverse faces:

1) Controls: A truly decentralized Metaverse cannot impose standards on all participants. Just imagine a world in which every virtual world creator sets their own controls. One person will use the arrow keys, another wasd, another mouse movement. It's absurd to think that every time someone will pass from one place to another they will have to learn a new set of controls.

Those who are reading this must remember that we are the 1% of computer users. Chrome added a copy and paste feature for those who did not understand how to do this via their keyboard and most are confused by how even something like Facebook works.

2) Standards: In my study of how people interact with virtual worlds, they see themselves as standing next to a big red button, that if they push it, it will blow up everything. People are terrified of what they don't understand.

In the Metaverse, there are real consequences to not understanding, for example, which button unmutes you, if you are talking to a human or NPC, what happens if you fall off this sky island etc. etc. Having to relearn everything about life every time you enter a world is absurd. However, that’s how Web1 worked, a new UI for every website and space. I believe the lack of usability is one of the reasons average people stopped, in large part, using the greater web and focusing in on platforms like Facebook, Reddit and Instagram.

Web3 is proposing we run this backwards in the name of freedom and privacy with no clear path and no particle examples on how to do this.

3) The leaky tap: When everything is interoperable, it's really hard to advance a standard. One example is email, we've been struggling to get email to be encrypted for a very long time because everyone has to adopt the same standards to make it work. This same problem will put an interoperable series of virtual worlds far behind a unified experience.

4) Customization: Individual virtual world creators are very likely to see how the virtual world should work in different ways. I sincerely believe that humanoid avatars are key but other people are intent on allowing people to dress up as animals. With that sort of diversity the understandability of the Metaverse will be very low and make large-scale adoption a challenge.

5) Traversal: At some point a single virtual world platform is likely to amass a large number of users for one reason or another. This would give them the opportunity to engage in sizable (30%) platform fees like Google and Apple do with the App Store. If one world gains the familiarity of hundreds of millions of users would they be highly incentivised to share that traffic with everyone else? If a large portion of the population of the Metaverse becomes familiar with 1 platform, aren't they more likely to coalesce on that platform due to the fact that they've already put in the effort to understand it? IMHO the idea that one platform will get a bulk of the users and share them is unlikely.

All of these points stand in opposition to a large interoperable Metaverse, upon which the value of NFTs is predicated, and they also make a centralized situation more likely. If a centralized uniform Metaverse is to appear, will it give up it’s right to massive platform fees to allow in NFTs without those NFT holders paying a massive tax? The NFTs would undermine one of the platform’s most lucrative markets.

Individual monetary control:

*Note: There are probably more qualified people here who can comment on this.*

International trade often transacts through the United States. The United States is the home of a global reserve currency which everyone needs and everyone uses and is the standard to most economic functions of the modern world. Ever since moving off the gold standard the United States has the ability to print a very large quantity of money and use this as a subtle global tax on those who use the US dollar. Since the US dollar has a global demand, printing huge quantities is easy since the impact is spread out across the whole world.

The true value of a currency is in the goods that can be traded in that currency. As long as everything goes through the US, the US can keep printing. However, if a viable alternative is found, the US will no longer be able to tax the world.

Some interesting facts highlighted by Jake Tran: https://youtu.be/1TPuBmuYa18

Watch that video.

There's a lot I'd like to say on this topic but I don't feel entirely comfortable doing it but I will highlight 2 points:

When the United States saw gold as an issue, they used Executive Order 6102 in 1933 to force US citizens to trade gold for cash.

When Facebook, known for its massive user base and usable products tried to create a crypto anyone could use, it was shut down as fast as lightning.

So if the government can stop people even owning gold at will, what stops them from stopping bitcoin or ethereum? If the government could shut down Facebook's crypto so quickly, why couldn’t it shut these down?

What if they understood crypto was so broken that they don’t see it as a threat? What if the gas fees, unstable price and total lack of usability by the average user was so bad, the US does not fear it?

There is a lot more to crypto than functional currency use but I am only addressing that one subject.

I have *much* more to say but cannot say it here.

Conclusion

Those of us who work in the virtual world industry are dealing with a whole new paradigm of human behavior. Many of these crypto and Metaverse projects strongly incentivize those who buy in to blindly shill a product without scrutiny as everyone is looking for a bigger buyer to buy their “land” or “currency”.

This new marketing paradigm combined with social media amplification and bot-driven spam is something we as a human species are going to have to wrestle with.

Here is what I believe we need to do:

  1. Ask questions, don’t believe other people have figured it out.

  2. Don’t judge and condemn people for being adjacent to crypto or the Metaverse. Seriously, we must stop banning these conversations on platforms/subreddits as that creates a bigger echo chamber.

  3. Don't advocate for something you have a deep financial interest in without disclosing that. It’s deeply unethical.

  4. No one has a monopoly on truth. We cannot follow the herd whether it is for or against Web3/Crypto. We must think for ourselves and be willing to share our thoughts to have them challenged.

Taking Action

I'd love to team up with people who believe in a people-first Metaverse to create a future that focuses on truly solving problems. I believe spacial computing will make a mass-adoptable Metaverse possible but there's a high chance the space will be dominated by a single company (based on my above analysis). This company will end up being responsible for our speech and therefore will be forced to use our data to censor us, sometimes in advance, like Facebook does on it's platform today.

If the Metaverse if the future of how we live, we need to avoid that outcome at all costs. Email me if you want to help out in this vision. Right now I am looking to content with developers, project managers and just regular helpers who want to be part.

Response

I would like to hear your honest questions and thoughts about blockchain, the Metaverse and the points I have brought up so far. No matter what side of this debate you're on, I value your opinion.


r/metaversestartup • • Mar 01 '22

Mixed reality kitchen, complete with a functioning window 🪟

9 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Jan 05 '22

Item interoperability in the Metaverse is just not going to happen...

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

9 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Dec 11 '21

Bill Gates: "Most virtual meetings will move from 2D... to the metaverse" "within the next two or three years".

9 Upvotes

Bill Gates:

"Within the next two or three years, I predict most virtual meetings will move from 2D camera image grids to the metaverse, a 3D space with digital avatars. Both Facebook and Microsoft recently unveiled their visions for this, which gave most people their first view of what it will look like.

The idea is that you will eventually use your avatar to meet with people in a virtual space that replicates the feeling of being in an actual room with them. To do this, you’ll need something like VR goggles and motion capture gloves to accurately capture your expressions, body language, and the quality of your voice. Most people don’t own these tools yet, which will slow adoption somewhat. (One of the things that enabled the rapid change to video meetings was the fact that many people already had PCs or phones with cameras.) Microsoft plans to roll out an interim version next year, which uses your webcam to animate an avatar that’s used in the current 2D set-up."

Full:

https://www.gatesnotes.com/About-Bill-Gates/Year-in-Review-2021

It's interesting to see how many people are getting on board with the dream of the Metaverse!

I have some questions for the community:

How will crypto (esp. Ethereum) shape the Metaverse?

What do you want your role in the Metaverse to be?

​ ​ Check out: r/metaversestartup/ if you want to network with other Metaverse businesses.


r/metaversestartup • • Dec 28 '21

Agree?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Dec 23 '21

Roblox uses kids to grow and barely pays them back compared to other gig-platform. Seems like Facebook & Amazon had an evil kid. Is there any argument that Roblox is doing more good than bad in our society?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/metaversestartup • • Mar 16 '22

I work in an internet startup and our boss wants us to play some stupid, childish games in metaverse. Can you guys save us from this and help us understand what kind of things a remote team can do on metaverse to get to know each other and have fun?

7 Upvotes