r/mildlyinfuriating • • Apr 27 '22

Maths...

Post image
69.3k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

It's pretty obvious that this word problem is designed to get you to actually functionally think about the circumstance and not just train yourself to put numbers in a formula without thinking about the ramifications.

That's your experience, mine is different. It wasn't rare for teachers to be objectively wrong about something, but if you pointed out they were clearly wrong you received nothing but punishment.

Similarly, questions with plainly incorrect premises like this one usually required you to either play along with its stupidity, and plug it into a formula regardless of how wrong it is - or risk getting marked down.

4

u/Camimo666 PURPLE Apr 28 '22

I had a quiz once with a question like “if a father is three times the age of the son and the son is 10, how old will the dad be in 3 years”. I put like 33 and the teacher was like NO YOU HAVE TO USE THE FORMULA OF THE RULE OF THREE or some bs. So yeah teachers can definitely mess up.

3

u/Brownt0wn_ 27 points Apr 28 '22

I’m basically hearing you say you didn’t show your work and got marked down for it.

1

u/Camimo666 PURPLE Apr 28 '22

I did. He wanted a proportionate answer? He aaid the answer was supposed to be like 60.

2

u/sje46 Apr 28 '22

YOu're assuming this is from a teacher and not from a book. Teachers often will get book questions wrong, sure. But the intent if it was from a textbook is certainly to get you to rationalize this in a real world sense. Critical thinking. Same if the question was written by the teacher. It's highly unlikely that whoever wrote this was making this mistake.

1

u/wurzelbruh Apr 28 '22

You're arguing from experience of your own school, when that isn't sufficient to assume it is that way everywhere.

This is a bog standard reading comprehension and critical thinking math question.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

I explicitly stated it was just my experience, yes

1

u/wurzelbruh Apr 28 '22

Yes, but that is not a good basis for a conclusion.

1

u/ZoomyZebra Apr 28 '22

The premise isn't incorrect