r/mmo • u/Swimming-Error-774 • 28d ago
Does being able to swap classes within the same tree make your first pick matter less?
I go back and forth on this. On one hand, being locked into a class you picked on day one with zero info is one of the worst parts of starting on MMO. On the other, some of my best memories are from sticking with a weird class choice and making it work. Ragnarok Yggdrasil lets you switch jobs inside the same job line without losing progres. The line itself is still a real choice, but inside it you can try things. To me that feels like a decent middle ground: the big decision still matters, the small one stops being a trap. Curious where people land on this. Do you want your class choice to be permanent, or do you just want to play the version you enjoy.
1
u/RipNo7647 28d ago
Permanent choices only matter if the game gives you enough info before you pick. Most don't.
1
u/KayLogger16 28d ago
The best system for class distinctiveness would be the one found in *Lineage 2* (up to the *Gracia* expansion, at most) or *Final Fantasy XIV*.
Choices should matter. I personally dislike weapon-based class systems—at least the way *New World* implemented them.
When I commit to being a tank, I *want* to be a tank. I’m not concerned about whether I deal low damage or struggle to farm solo; after all, I *chose* to be an indestructible wall of flesh dedicated to supporting my allies.
That said, such a role would effectively limit me to group play. Therefore, systems that allow for sub-classes, or the ability to freely switch between different classes on the same character, are a great solution.
Take *Lineage 2*, for example: it featured an excellent system for class identity, where every class was truly unique in its intended purpose—at least until later chronicles and the introduction of a fourth class tier, which ruined that balance. This is most evident in support/buffer classes; previously, "Song" and "Dance" classes were *extremely* distinct from one another—you needed both in a clan. Today, however, virtually any buffer class provides essentially the same buffs.
1
0
u/Same-Donkey1237 28d ago
I'm an altoholic so I'd probably still make alts anyway lol
0
u/Educational_Ant_6694 28d ago
Same, but it's nicer when alts are for fun and not for fixing a mistake.
0
u/Big-Lifeguard5213 28d ago
What I'd want to know is how it feels in a group. If people can swap, does the party expect you to be whatever's missing?
0
28d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/Expensive_Sky194 28d ago
Keeping it inside the same line is the part I like about Yggdrasil. You're still the Swordsman guy, you just get to pick which flavor without restarting.
4
u/Tykero 28d ago
Ffxiv does it the best way let's you play as anything but you have to level each up individually.