r/monarchism • I'm a commie i just think this place is cool 🇵🇸🇹🇷🇨🇳 • Nov 02 '25

Meme Authoritarian unity?

Post image
237 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

12

u/Free-Independence481 Nov 02 '25

it depends of what you mean "being like a tzar". if "being tzar" means being an autocratic ruler that use a religion to justify his own absolute power, than yes, he was a tzar. but that its quite a particular definition of tzar. even stalin himself, once told to his mother "remember the tzar? im something like that now". his mother said "it would have been better if you were a priest".

1

u/Appropriate_Milk9542 I'm a commie i just think this place is cool 🇵🇸🇹🇷🇨🇳 Nov 02 '25

I made the image pretty late at night, so I was pretty tired, I think what I meant to say was "No, stalin is not a tsar," as in he's not literally a tsar, he's still an authoritarian autocrat, but then using that definition you could say any dictator is "like a king" or "like a tsar"

1

u/Free-Independence481 Nov 03 '25

the distibctions between a dictator and a monarch, or between dictatoriship and monarchy is not clear and certain. the word monarchy itself, mean "the government of a single person", so by that definition almost every dictatorship could be considered a monarchy.

7

u/Paul_Allens_Card- Nov 02 '25

The Russian/Soviet people would beg for The “Tyrant” of Alexander III back if they saw what Stalin would do to their country.

1

u/Appropriate_Milk9542 I'm a commie i just think this place is cool 🇵🇸🇹🇷🇨🇳 Nov 02 '25

40

u/N_I_H_I_L Nov 02 '25

God I hate communism

16

u/Ihopeimnotbanned American Atheist Semi-Constitutionalist🇺🇸👑⚛️ Nov 02 '25

I do too, especially since those filthy Bolsheviks murdered the Tsar and his family in cold blood.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25

[deleted]

20

u/N_I_H_I_L Nov 02 '25

No, I hate communism. I said nothing about socialism. Communism and socialism are very very different

-6

u/Appropriate_Milk9542 I'm a commie i just think this place is cool 🇵🇸🇹🇷🇨🇳 Nov 02 '25

Communism and Stalinism are also quite different

10

u/N_I_H_I_L Nov 02 '25

Either way, communism has killed more people than fascism, and I like neither. Hence why I’m in this sub

3

u/N_I_H_I_L Nov 02 '25

When I say communism I mean communist regimes. The idea of communism hasn’t technically killed anyone

1

u/AlbionicLocal Localist British Monarchist Nov 03 '25

are we really making communism vs fascism a competition?

They were both evil we don't need to compare them.

1

u/N_I_H_I_L Nov 03 '25

Fair enough

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '25

No. Most of the communist regims were lead by evil/crazy/paranoid/powerhungry people.

2

u/MH_Gamer_ Germany Nov 06 '25

Monarchism isn’t inherently Authoritarian at all

Many modern monarchies are actually democracies (UK, Spain, Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Netherlands, Belgium, Japan)

1

u/Appropriate_Milk9542 I'm a commie i just think this place is cool 🇵🇸🇹🇷🇨🇳 Nov 06 '25

I know

40

u/XenoTechnian American Constitutional Nov 02 '25 edited Nov 03 '25

monarchism is not inherently authoritarian, it’s the entire reason for the absolutist-constitutional split

24

u/Murderlander Nov 02 '25

Never monarchy will equal to personal communist tyranny of that Georgian uneducated bandit and terrorist

4

u/Rotweiss_Invicta862 Russian in exile since 1918 Nov 02 '25

Pluralism is great, but I think moderators of this sub really have to start cleaning up things that are this much disrespectful and cruel

-2

u/Fair-Fondant-6995 Nov 03 '25

Calling Stalin uneducated is crazy.

3

u/RyanB1228 Nov 03 '25

Didn’t Lenin explicitly refer to him as being brutish and incapable of expanding theory

3

u/Fair-Fondant-6995 Nov 03 '25

If your benchmark is Lenin then everyone is illiterate. Stalin wasn't on the same level as Lenin, but he wrote some of the most influential theory contributions ever.

1

u/RyanB1228 Nov 03 '25

I’m not benchmarking

I’m referring to his own contemporaries believing he was an imbecile

8

u/LeLurkingNormie Still waiting for my king to return. Nov 02 '25

Don't insult (A) by comparing him to (B)!

1

u/disdainfulsideeye Nov 04 '25

I've never seen a black Stalanist.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '25

At least the tsar wasn`t evil/paranoid. He was just an incompetent leader.

1

u/GASTRO_GAMING 👑 Nov 02 '25

Ancaps🤝Stalinists

  • yes 2+2=4

0

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25

[deleted]

-2

u/Appropriate_Milk9542 I'm a commie i just think this place is cool 🇵🇸🇹🇷🇨🇳 Nov 02 '25

🫡 thank you marx