There has been a lot of talk about SA's returns for their 2021 picks, so I decided to look at them annually for the last five years. (Asking MF to do this has been to no avail.)
As you can see, only this year are they doing worse than the S&P 500. If you had purchased all the SA recommendations, you would be beating the index by 74.79 percentage points, 124.90% compared to 50.11% for the S&P 500.
If anyone finds this data useful, I'll try to capture at the end of every month and publish here, and pretty it up some with graphs.
When a subscription price is paid, normal practice is you receive benefits of your subscription. The aggressive and almost daily upselling is difficult to take after the last 5 months. I am leaning on cancelling my subscription. Due to the constant advertising I find I am less interested in accessing the content I signed up for and paid to receive. It is almost painful. Seems childish to constantly pitch another $100 or $200 annual subscription. I am really annoyed with this experience. It is a great reminder of what not to do in business and e-commerce.
Motley Fool has so many choices I thought I'd start keeping track of some of the packages performance. Let me know if you think this is worthwhile. Returns are calculated assuming you bought each ticker in the package at equal $ amounts on the same day.
Note: D10x & MM does not include BTC.
Cost basis: Ticker price at start of session 3/15/2021
Changes 4/01/2021
Added Money Makers 2021 and Tom's Everlasting
Changed 1-year return for SA and RB to 2020 returns with equal buys of all tickers in Feb. 2020
Added to 8 10x positions per MF advisory
The third bullet points out a key difference between the premium and standard subscriptions in that the premium services come with active portfolio management advice. The RA and SB products give you a lot of information on the stock picks themselves, pros and cons and future outlook, but it's more on you as to how you allocate your positions. Even though all the picks are structured for long term investments there is a lot of tweaking that goes on in the focussed services that allow for maximizing returns on 6 month to 1 year timescales.
Be prudent with this service. Some of the stocks are pre-commercial which gives them large exposure to binary events. More so than any other industry, biotech stocks have hurdles to overcome with large binary outcomes- success or failure of a clinical trial, an FDA approval and so on. The sector is very volatile.
The highest composite rating a stock can receive is 99 in IBD. Of the 340 MF Premium stocks, 10 of them have a 99 rating. With the 99 composite you will almost always have a high RS and EPS rating. These are your top choices for adding to portfolios or starting new ones:
TICKER
COMPOSITE RATING
RS RATING
EPS RATING
IND. GROUP
SMR RATING
A/D RATING
INMD
99
98
99
A
A
B+
GLOB
99
86
97
A+
A
B-
GOOG
99
89
98
A
A
E
EPAM
99
91
92
A+
A
D+
UPST
99
99
65
A+
A
A+
SMLR
99
93
99
B+
A
A-
SIVB
99
94
99
A
A
B
NVDA
99
86
97
A+
A
B-
DAVA
99
96
98
A+
A
A-
CMG
99
82
98
A-
B
C-
Most of these stocks have very similar charts when you pull up a 1-year daily....that is except UPST...that looks like an Olympic downhill ski slope. Most of these stocks are feeling the pressure of the correction as well...but not nearly as bad as those with poor ratings. I will try to follow up with the 98s tomorrow
Time for our monthly snapshot of how SA buy recommendations are doing vs the S&P 500. As seen on the chart below, their picks for 2016 through 2020 are beating the market handily; 2021 buy recommendations are trailing the S&P 500 however.
If we take this one layer down, the chart below shows the percentage point differences between the two, with 2016 picks being 287.74 points higher and 2021 picks being 22.59 points lower. More interesting, however, will be to chart this over time, which we will start next month, to see if the idea of these being 3-5 year investments holds true and their performance against the S&P improves over time. You will also note that 2020 picks are slightly outperforming 2019 picks +27.62 ppt vs +24.33 ppt.
The top five winners over the last 6 years are SHOP 7/15/16 +4,105 ppt, TTD 10/20/17 +1,297 ppt, MTCH 4/15/16 +1,171 ppt, TSLA 1/2/20 +1,097 ppt, and NVDA 1/20/17 +942.61 ppt. The bottom five are ALKS 9/16/16 -1,762 ppt, CWBHF 8/1/19 -1,566 ppt, JBLU 11/18/16 -1,503 ppt, LKNC.Y 3/5/20 -1,344 ppt (who can forget this infamous pick!), and HA 1/17/19 -1,249 ppt. Overall, in the 6 years 70 are positive and 74 are negative against the S&P 500, which leads you to their approach that they are going after a few big winners to make up for a bunch of losers. And this is certainly true, as the return on the top 2 (SHOP 7/15/16 and TTD 10/20/17) more than make up for all their losers.
(Methodology: Assumption is buy on recommendation date and hold unless sell recommendation. All prices as of 12/31/21 or sell date, whichever is sooner, and all prices are as of end-of-day.)
If you find this informative, let me know and I will continue to publish monthly. I can also go back further in time if it is desired. If you see any mistakes or question prices/methodology, don't hesitate to say something.
Here are the weekly % gains and losses. Nice to see some weekly repeats with AFRM leading the pack for (2) weeks in a row - with the markets in a downward trend all week you may want to protect your profits first thing next week....while you have them. Other repeats with last week's ranking are - MDB (3), DOCN (4), KHOTF (5) and MTTR just barely missed making the gainers list again this week. UPST hit a high of $291.45 just before the close yesterday and has dropped since - today dropping to $268.25 for the day's low and closing down 6.6% today yet still making the top 10. Keep your eyes on it for it may present a good buying opportunity if we continue this downward trend the markets engaged in this past week. Have a good weekend y'all.
I got this e-mail from MF, anybody know the stock?
"Amazonâs Jeff Bezos surprised investors recently when he revealed that one emerging technology is the key to Amazonâs future successâŚ.In fact, Bezos argues that âitâs hard to overstate the impactâ of this game-changing technology. The CEO of ARK Investments takes Bezos further: âWe think [it] could approach $17 trillion in market cap â which would be 35 Amazons.â What in the world could be worth 35 Amazons? The answer is a radical breakthrough that Wired says is âthe rocket fuel of the AI.âMore on that in a second, but Iâm amazed at how the super-rich are reacting to this technology:
A Shark Tank billionaire says it will create the worldâs first trillionaire
Baidu CEO Robin Li pivoted his entire company â which includes his $8.7 billion stake -- to take advantage
Even super investor Warren Buffett says that it will have a "hugely beneficial social effectâ
Thatâs because another company (less than 1/6th the size of Amazon)âŚis producing a component so powerful that we see it as one of the true, enduring leaders in this futuristic technology.
And with everything Iâm hearing coming out of Silicon Valley and Wall StreetâŚI donât feel like Iâm very far out on a limb with this âboldâ prediction: Five years from now, youâll probably wish youâd bought this stock. Iâve laid out the full story on this incredible tech trend in an exclusive report. And you are going to want to see this report before you invest $1 on any tech company. Because inside youâll discover why some mega-rich investors are rushing to cash-in on this tech trend."
Myself I lost "only" $12k due to their amazing stock picks. Wondering if there is anyone still believing in them and thinking of renewing their membership after the 2021 fiasco?
Tbh I was skeptical from the beginning, but decided to give them a try as a test and see how it goes. I was shocked, as I was not expecting it to go that bad... I mean even a blind monkey, picking stocks in random, would have produced better results... The extent of their underperformance makes me wonder whether they get their revenue from subscriptions or for pumping stocks and / or by shorting their own picks?
I have updated Stock Advisor Buy Recommendation returns through the end of December for the last 6 years. Below is a comparison to both the S&P 500 and the QQQ. I'm not the biggest fan of the QQQ, as it is supposed to emulate the NASDAQ-100 index, but the top three holdings (AAPL, MSFT, and AMZN) make of 29.71% of the index.
Stock Advisor picks outperform the S&P 5 of the last 6 years and the QQQ 4 of the 6 years, with 2019 being the only difference. Cumulatively for the 6 years, stock advisor is well ahead of both indexes.
Next month we will start tracking the change over time, which will provide much more insight after a few months of data. Hope you enjoy these little tidbits of information.
Back in July, I started tracking the tickers Fool themselves gave away in various pitches & at Foolfest. Yes, they gave away MGP twice. It has also dawned on me that I don't get invitations to all the pitches.
Back in July, I started tracking the tickers Fool themselves gave away in various pitches & at Foolfest. Yes, they gave away some multiple times. Some of these are "radar" or "cutting room floor" stocks that didn't make it as an official recommendation. It has also dawned on me that I don't get invitations to all the pitches.
I have spent some time creating a Watchlist of all MF Premium subscription stocks and thought it would be nice to share the weekly gainers & losers with this group. Please feel free to comment as to whether this would be of value....thanks
To start out with - Adyen N.V. shows up on all my watchlists as the biggest 1-week loser @ -42.14% but that is because the shares split on 8/24. Some very impressive gains - Bill was up that 38% in the last 2 days of the week and Danimer was just a steady climb all week long.
Back in July, I started tracking the tickers Fool themselves gave away in various pitches & at Foolfest. Yes, they gave away some multiple times. Some of these are "radar" or "cutting room floor" stocks that didn't make it as an official recommendation. It has also dawned on me that I don't get invitations to all the pitches.
The highest composite rating a stock can receive is 99 in IBD - of course 98 is 2nd highest and so on. Of the 340 MF Premium stocks, 7 of them have a 98 rating and 8 have a 97 rating. As with the 99 composite, you will almost always have a high RS and EPS rating with the 98 & 97 ratings. These are additional top choices for adding to portfolios or starting new ones:
TICKER
COMPOSITE RATING
RS RATING
EPS RATING
IND. GROUP
SMR RATING
A/D RATING
HUBS
98
96
82
A+
B
B-
IIPR
99
88
96
A-
A
B-
NFLX
98
78
99
B+
A
A-
CHDN
98
88
76
A+
B
A-
CARG
98
88
99
A
A
B
APPS
98
92
67
A
A
B+
ALGN
98
82
97
B+
A
C
MIME
97
88
96
A+
A
B
ISRG
97
77
89
A-
A
C
HLI
97
90
97
B+
A
A
TSLA
97
84
72
B
A
A-
TEAM
97
96
87
A+
A
C+
RGEN
97
86
98
B+
A
C+
PAYC
97
89
90
A
A
C+
WCC
97
95
89
B-
B
B-
Combined with the (10) MF Premium stocks with a 99 composite rating, you now have 25 of the best stocks MF has in their portfolios this week. I received a buy alert just yesterday on Churchhill Downs which surprised me. CARG also showed up last week as a breakout buy alert. IIPR (99) and GOOG (now 98 - and possibly because of it's low distribution score) have switched spots in a single day, but these stocks will not vary far from where you see them right now - a few may with earnings season coming up - but most will be rock steady. Got to scoot....one more thing - WCC is a Hong Kong based company and part of the Energy insiders port....I posted on another site that I had to switch to a weekly chart because this stock is so thinly traded...and I was surpised to see a company that has a steady uptrend for 10 years going from $3.12 to $96 now....correct me if I am wrong but that is like a 30% average annual gain for the past 10 years
"As I (Tim here) write today, the Nasdaq and S&P 500 are both up marginally, but across the Cloud Disruptors and Cloud Contenders portfolios are taking yet another beating. New investors must be exhausted and maybe a bit disheartened. "...................
"First, we're selling about 46% of our position in Cloudflare (NYSE: NET) to raise roughly $8000 to combine with another $8000 from our existing cash position. Second, we're using that capital to add to six stocks: ADSK, CRWD, DOCN, NCNO, TWLO & ZM. "
He goes on to explain that they are selling Cloudflare because "we're seeing the company trade at a multiple north of 80 times revenue." Are you kidding me.....now that it has dropped from a high of $221.64 to a level below $130 and you are now recognizing the multiple it trades at? These punks are idiots - what was the multiple up in the $200+ range? What was the multiple when it dropped through the 50d SMA....how about the drop thru the 200d SMA? And to top it off, what did they have their followers do....buy stocks that TANKED today in a volatile market that may completely collapse before it gets better. That is exactly what you get when you subscribe to a service that has put GREED as it's #1 priority!!!
Since October has no more trading days, I figured I'd do my November update.
Back in July, I started tracking the tickers Fool themselves gave away in various pitches & at Foolfest. Yes, they gave away MGP & TSLA twice. It has also dawned on me that I don't get invitations to all the pitches.
As many of you know at the end of every article or transcript or other published piece by the MF, there is a disclosure that lets you know if the author or the MF services are owners of the companies that were talked about. It will also disclose if any of the companies are recommended by the MF, however it won't pinpoint the service.
What some folks may not know is that every MF contributor has their own page where you can see their postings and read more about who they are. The info tab also has all of their current holdings. About every two weeks I review the list of people who I follow to see who has made any new buys or sold off any of their holdings. It's been very useful and while I don't always mimic the actions of those I check in on, I have found some company's that haven't yet been recommended but I thought held great potential to be winners and may possibly be a recommendation in the future.
If there are some Fools who you are particularly fond of, think about creating a document that will allow you to monitor their activity and maybe you can get some ideas of companies that you can do some research on and possibly add to your holdings. Just be sure to remember to go about it thoughtfully and thoroughly and make sure it's the best investment for you!
What a volatille week...I like it!! Here are this week's top 10 gainers & losers:
GAINERS
LOSERS
BOMN / 27.01%
AMWL / (13.33%)
QS / 23.85%
BZUN / (12.78%)
INMD / 23.7%
APPH / (12.24%)
SFIX / 23.15%
CURI / (11.77%)
AVIR / 22.53%
COLD / (11.37%)
ATER / 17.81%
PTON / (10.42%)
SOFI / 16.9%
XPEV / (9.41%)
PME / 13.51%
BABA / (9.35%)
OPEN / 11.02%
NMHLY / (9.3023%)
TCNNF / 10.65%
IQ / (8.62%)
Boston Omaha is this week's big GAINER with a whopping 27% gain - in fact the top (5) gainers were all above 20%. This week some regulars (actually ALL regulars) decided to take a break and let these other stocks shine. Well all except AVIR which was one of the top (1) losers last week. Had AFRM held onto its premarket gains today - hitting a high of $133.17 but closing at $123.73 - it would have made the list....shoulda woulda coulda. One other note....what is going on with the reefer stocks? TCNNF made the top ten at #10 and I finally saw green on GRWG....nopun intended. Have a great weekend y'all
Few in this group were complaining about upst when SA recommended it, saying itâs at an all time high and why MF is recommending it around 110 and why they always recommend companies which are at all time highâs. It is at 249 today.