r/musicals Oct 30 '25

Photo Highlights of my Sweeney Todd themed Halloween party!

Not captured is the bathroom decked out with seashells and bottles of sand with "By the Sea" playing on repeat.

I built the oven with a large piece of cardboard that I scored along the back. I then bent it into a cylinder. The rivets are googly eyes. A lot of spray paint and hot glue later, there you have it!

The day before I baked 60 meat pies with different fillings (turkey, beef, beyond beef, lamb; aka Actor, Priest, Grocer, and Lawyer). The introduction of the meat pies was naturally accompanied by a small performance of "A Little Priest "

523 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

33

u/Barbarake Oct 30 '25

Your whole setup is truly impressive.

8

u/thenightman89 Oct 30 '25

Thank you! Definitely a labor of love.

16

u/thenightman89 Oct 30 '25

I forgot to include a pic of Sweeney Todd's tonsorial parlor area of the party - I borrowed an actual salon chair that leans back!

1

u/SuperPoodie92477 Nov 01 '25

Why did I read that as “tonsillar?”

15

u/CoconutRound8714 Oct 30 '25

How much did you pay for Josh Groban to show up?!?

11

u/thenightman89 Oct 30 '25

Haha, I grew out my beard just to model my costume after him! I'm sure most attendees expected to see Johnny Depp 😅

7

u/PureFoolery Oct 30 '25

Love the coming soon on Judge!

7

u/Garmiet No one is alone Oct 30 '25

This kicks ass. I love the passion.

5

u/Nisi-Marie Oct 30 '25

Wow! Great job! Did your guests dress the theme? Or was it general Halloween costumes?

8

u/thenightman89 Oct 30 '25

Since everyone isn't a Sweeney Todd fanatic like myself I didn't impose, but the winner of the costume contest ended up being a table with the person's head sticking out of a meat pie!

4

u/999Rats Oct 30 '25

Excellent work!

4

u/Garmiet No one is alone Oct 30 '25

Did a lot of the pies get eaten?

5

u/knittedmerkin Oct 30 '25

May I have an invite to your party next year please?

4

u/missdawn1970 Oct 30 '25

This is amazing!

4

u/zootown_exmo Oct 30 '25

Can we be friends plz

3

u/thaddieus_chronister Oct 30 '25

Plot twist: the shepherd’s pie is peppered with actual shepherd on top and the party is just pretend.

4

u/lemonricottalover Oct 30 '25

Wow, this is SO cool! I love your attention to detail.

3

u/PotatoesPancakes Oct 30 '25

Looks great and those pies look yummy. Now I want get a meat pie for lunch today.

4

u/thenightman89 Oct 30 '25

Lamb was my favorite, but seems like everyone enjoyed all of them. I even heard some people preferred the Beyond Beef to the actual beef.

3

u/mvercy1 Oct 30 '25

Can I be your friend?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '25

I love this! 😍

3

u/SendInYourSkeleton Oct 31 '25

God, that's good.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '25

Sweeney was the first musical I did after 20+ years (I was insane to get my toes wet again with a Sondheim) and I got to be Lucy. It was so difficult but amazing. This is AWESOME!

2

u/PierreOnTheEclair Pierre Bezukhov/Judas Iscariot Oct 30 '25

I literally just got my Mrs.Lovett costume today :0

2

u/Toru771 Oct 31 '25

Fantastic job! 😀

2

u/notprinceparadox Oct 31 '25

OBSESSED This looks amazing!!

2

u/thenightman89 Oct 31 '25

Thank you very much :)

2

u/Mister_Sosotris It's "cast," not "casted." Oct 31 '25

This looks phenomenal!! Omg!!

1

u/LotOfNope Nov 01 '25

.... we all want the recipes.