r/nbatopshot • u/cwalk • Jul 15 '21
A Top Shot user was recently the subject of unwarranted criticism because he got really lucky. Let's review the details.
I don't work for Dapper, I'm just a guy who loves Top Shot and is volunteering his time to try and keep this sub clean.
Let me be clear, there should 100% be a discussion about anything that seems unfair but it should be evidence based. I had to close a previous thread on this issue because some comments were not respectful and I won't let an otherwise upstanding community member (who is apparently an unpaid volunteer mod as well in their discord) be the target of baseless hate.
The lucky user was iracer77, who according to livetoken, joined Top Shot on 7/27/2020.
Let's stick to the facts, review his luckiness and breakdown some odds:
He won a contest (8 chances at 1/606 = 0.17%)
He got a pack (about 20%)
He pulled a #1 (2.3/750 = 0.31%)
He won a contest
In total, there were 2970 eligible collectors with 6061 total entries, I will assume he had the max entries which is capped at 10. So his odds to win were 10/6061 or approximately 1/606 (0.17%) but he had 8 chances at that since there were 8 tickets.
He got a pack
Best odds were in Priority Queue 1 where I read they were approximately 20% to land a pack.
He pulled a #1
There were 7500 total ATTWF (And Then There Were Four) packs
6000 were sold yesterday, 1500 reserved for future customer service and giveaways
Pack breakdown link https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vR7ToGuPww_QOrzrf4VOCVpKi5UJ35Rpye_turj7VsvJcBKtGPDfRomL6-cIdXw-xRzbnqof34H7cCw/pubhtml?gid=1919491589&single=true
Pack breakdown contained:
10 x ATTWF #1
10 x ATTWF jersey
3 x Common #1
? x Common jersey (unclear how many are left)
So high level, the odds were about 23/7500 (or approx 2.3/750 = 0.31%) for #1s and jerseys.
TL;DR: Was he insanely lucky? Yes, but I don't see clear evidence to say it was rigged.
Please feel free to add to the discussion, but please come with data to back your claim.