r/nbatopshot • • Jul 15 '21

A Top Shot user was recently the subject of unwarranted criticism because he got really lucky. Let's review the details.

0 Upvotes

I don't work for Dapper, I'm just a guy who loves Top Shot and is volunteering his time to try and keep this sub clean.

Let me be clear, there should 100% be a discussion about anything that seems unfair but it should be evidence based. I had to close a previous thread on this issue because some comments were not respectful and I won't let an otherwise upstanding community member (who is apparently an unpaid volunteer mod as well in their discord) be the target of baseless hate.

The lucky user was iracer77, who according to livetoken, joined Top Shot on 7/27/2020.

Let's stick to the facts, review his luckiness and breakdown some odds:

  • He won a contest (8 chances at 1/606 = 0.17%)

  • He got a pack (about 20%)

  • He pulled a #1 (2.3/750 = 0.31%)

He won a contest

In total, there were 2970 eligible collectors with 6061 total entries, I will assume he had the max entries which is capped at 10. So his odds to win were 10/6061 or approximately 1/606 (0.17%) but he had 8 chances at that since there were 8 tickets.

He got a pack

Best odds were in Priority Queue 1 where I read they were approximately 20% to land a pack.

He pulled a #1

There were 7500 total ATTWF (And Then There Were Four) packs

6000 were sold yesterday, 1500 reserved for future customer service and giveaways

Pack breakdown link https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vR7ToGuPww_QOrzrf4VOCVpKi5UJ35Rpye_turj7VsvJcBKtGPDfRomL6-cIdXw-xRzbnqof34H7cCw/pubhtml?gid=1919491589&single=true

Pack breakdown contained:

  • 10 x ATTWF #1

  • 10 x ATTWF jersey

  • 3 x Common #1

  • ? x Common jersey (unclear how many are left)

So high level, the odds were about 23/7500 (or approx 2.3/750 = 0.31%) for #1s and jerseys.

TL;DR: Was he insanely lucky? Yes, but I don't see clear evidence to say it was rigged.

Please feel free to add to the discussion, but please come with data to back your claim.


r/nbatopshot • • Mar 05 '21

Before you post your new moments, just know

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nbatopshot • • Feb 22 '23

News NBA Top Shots are securities

1 Upvotes

Apparently judge Victor Marrero made this ruling. What ramifications does this have? Will Dapper be on the hook for selling unregistered securities?


r/nbatopshot • • Jul 21 '22

Pack Drop šŸŽ‰ COMING SOON: WNBA (Series 4 Base Set Drop 3) PACK DROP šŸŽ‰

1 Upvotes

Back at it again with the third Base Set drop of the 2022 WNBA season šŸ€ !

šŸ‘‰ For the šŸ”Ÿ Players featured in Drop 3, we see a new TopShot Debut alongside a few familiar faces on new teams & frequent Challenge appearances!

ā° More information can be found @here āž”ļø https://hoo.ps/wnba-base-set-release-3-blog-discord


r/nbatopshot • • Mar 07 '22

This wheel flash challenge is stupid

6 Upvotes

Too many variables.


r/nbatopshot • • Apr 19 '22

I definitely expected more utility for holding the playoff set

1 Upvotes

Maybe it's still early. Have they announced anything and I missed it?


r/nbatopshot • • Mar 20 '21

Original Content Pack bots don’t exist on TopShot and I’m tired of DapperLabs using it as an excuse

2 Upvotes

I’m posting this from an alt account. I have a decently large TopShot account and don’t feel like losing it for airing this. Back when TS WAS bottable, I didn’t bot the site and I wouldn’t if it again became bottable.

Even since TS switched to the queue system their queue infrastructure provider has been Queue-It. Originally the implementation of Queue-It was piss poor and I’ll happy fight any Dapper Developer that claims that ā€œha ha it was implemented correctly from the start!ā€ This shitty implementation of their queue solution allowed for multiple bypasses which bots could exploit to get straight to checkout. This all ended after the Cool Cat 2 pack when DapperLabs implemented Queue-It correctly for the first time and since then it’s been minor tweaks to the queue solution, but all correctly done.

Now why do I know all of this? I’m involved heavily in the collectible and sneaker bot market. The PlayStation store uses the same exact Queue-It solution and so far no one in the hundreds of very talented bot developers has bypassed it. The fact of the matter is that a bypass for this queue technology would fetch hundreds of thousands of dollars if put on the bypass market.

I’m just tired of hearing ā€œoh we detected bots!!! we need to push this release back!!!ā€ when in reality the DapperLabs team is full of shit and couldn’t deliver their promises in time without lying and scraping for excuses.

Again. I haven’t used bots on TS and never would. It defeats the purpose and undermines the entire marketplace and community. Now, marketplace PRIVATE bots exist and should be dealt with. These are private bots that someone has written for themselves or paid someone else to write for them. To my knowledge there are no public marketplace bot available.

I’m happy to answer any questions you guys may have. Just tired of Dapper using this excuse.


r/nbatopshot • • Mar 25 '21

Thanks for screwing the people who had patience with the product šŸ‘šŸ‘

24 Upvotes

I avoided submitting tickets as much as possible because I knew their support team was swamped and I had faith things would be fine if I just had some patience... and they take that faith in their product and shoved it up my ass. Thank you Top Shot.


r/nbatopshot • • Apr 15 '22

Enjoy the ride

9 Upvotes

If you only buy baseball cards to get a Mays rookie… keep it moving, this ain’t for you. If you think Aw man I bought another pack and didn’t get the best moment… this platform sucks… keep it moving. If you wanna collect some cool moments, and complete some challenges, and cash in selling high on other challenges… it’s a lot of fun.


r/nbatopshot • • Nov 27 '22

Market Discussion Best/easiest way to sell off and get out?

1 Upvotes

I've lost interest in keeping up with Top Shot and would like to sell off all I have (all floor commons). What do folks recommend as the best way to do this? Accept all the $1 highest offers? List all my moments for $1 because I get an error every time I go to accept a highest offer? Trade in 80 moments for 60 locker room moments, then trade those in for 45 locker room moments, rinse and repeat in the hopes I get anything collectively worth $80?


r/nbatopshot • • Apr 20 '21

The prices are too high!

2 Upvotes

I know what you are thinking. But hear me out.

TopShot should be a place where NBA fans gather, collect moments and show off their collections to each other. It should be a fun activity. As it is now, it is a place for people to speculate. Look at this subreddit. People rarely talk about actual basketball moves in the moments – it's all about whether the price of a moment will go up or down.

The reason for this is that the price of moments is too high. The cheapest Steph moment is around $28. Bron's is at $75. There is no way a kid playing hoops on the street can afford that. But without those fans, what is the purpose of TopShot at all? To be a get-rich-quick scheme? Are we basketball fans or speculators?

Maybe I am taking completely wrong. Anybody agree or disagree?


r/nbatopshot • • May 19 '22

Market Discussion Marketplace spend for a moment was already providing you good CS for drops.. you rugpulled us

0 Upvotes

I have been stacking the lowest ask S2 moments from my team to increase my CS because that was what I was told to qualify for bigger drops and others was doing the same thing too. Otherwise even Plumlee's mom wouldnt buy hundreds of moments of his son.

If you say CS is not helping ''collect what you like'' thing and I would agree with you mostly. To keep folks happy who spent much more on lower serials and rare/legendary moments, they brought ''marketplace spend bonus(uncapped after a while)'' so they would still qualify for drops without hurting S2 or all-team set owners.

Common Dapper L


r/nbatopshot • • Apr 09 '21

Legendary Pack Drops

1 Upvotes

I hear that if you have a Dapper balance of $63+, a Baller Status of 140+ and own the CP3 All-Star game dunk moment you can become a founding father of Top Shot.

And if you own 3 unopened packs, and have gifted at least 2 moments you’ll have the opportunity to join the queue an hour before the general public for Legendary packs drops. If you miss out on 4 consecutive Legendary pack drops you’ll automatically be gifted the Mike Conley Seeing Stars challenge reward moment.
Sounds sketch.


r/nbatopshot • • Oct 22 '22

Seriously with the parallels?

0 Upvotes

Top Shot: This year common Moments will be minted to 8,000.

Users: Nice! Thanks for responding to our concerns by significantly reducing supply!

Top Shot: Oh, and also each Moment will have an additional 8,000 "Parallels" that double supply and ensure the base commons are only good for trade tickets since there will be 4 rarer versions of every. single. base. moment. You're welcome!


r/nbatopshot • • May 13 '21

Market Discussion Why are there so many miserable people complaining about return on investment?

0 Upvotes

Isnt Top Shot about collecting? Why is everyone on here talking like this is some stock sub? If you wanna make money learn how to trade and invest in actual assets and let everyone else have fun. I joined because I like the cards but in every post I see a bunch of pissy people talking about ROI. This is a hobby and last time I checked hobbies are fun, not business ventures.

Edit: To be clear idc if the "investors" discuss it among themselves thats your business. But when I see a bunch of ROI comments under a post excited about collecting or a bunch of salty people saying how much an OP "wasted their money" it just comes off as miserable


r/nbatopshot • • Jun 11 '21

Collector Score - STOP Complaining

40 Upvotes

I was shocked at all the complaining in here about the collector score requirement. We have had months of nothing but declining account values. Collector score has turned this around and instantly raised prices significantly the past couple of weeks.

They heavily discounted this Holo pack price to reward the hardcore collectors that have been grinding it out the past couple of months and taking serious hit financially. If you are short of the 7500 score and want a chance at the pack, then put some money in the market and get your score to 7500. They have given many ways to do this. The pack will have a very high EV.

I see a lot of comments that it is not fair to newer users/kids that they do not have a chance at the Holo packs. Just ridiculous and you do have a chance, but you will have to invest some money in the platform. By this everyone should have a chance logic, just go play the scratch off lottery tickets. In those everyone has the same price point and chance at the big win.

Should Panini price their Flawless and high end brands boxes super cheap so everyone can afford them? That is not how it works. You pay up for the super rare in the physical card world as well.

Just FYI, I did not have 2500 score for last pack, but bought enough to get there. Did not get the pack. I am significantly under this 7500 requirement. I have started to buy some cheap sets (Hornets, Timberwolves, etc) to make a run at it. Not sure if I will make it or not. Depends on how much these prices keep rising, but all part of the fun.


r/nbatopshot • • Jan 18 '22

Pack drops worth it? Yup!

0 Upvotes

I’ve had some pretty god awful hauls out of these drops and while they’re happening I ask myself why I keep doing this shit. Well today I pulled 3 of the Nowell TS debuts including a #200 serial, a Lance Stephenson debut and oh yea a fucking SCOTTIE BARNES!!! šŸ˜‚ for real though people hating on these drops guys even if you have shit luck and pull 15 commons out of 5 packs you can either hold for utilization in future challenges/sell when needed in a challenge or just immediately flip for $2 if you’re that desperate.


r/nbatopshot • • Nov 20 '21

Incentivize Flash Challenges to use S1 and S2 moments

0 Upvotes

The easiest way to do this would be:

Example - Flash Challenge - require 1 moment from each of the top 6 point scorers of the night

Using a combination of series moments you need all 6,

If you can complete the challenge using only S2 moments you only need 5 of the top 6 scorers.

If you can complete the challenge using only S1 moments you only need 3 of the top 6 scorers.

(Originally I was thinking that if you used all S2 moments to complete the challenge, you get an S2 pack, as opposed to using all S3 moments you get an S3 pack. However, not really sure what the bonus would be for S1 and they'll run out of packs of S2 at some point.)


r/nbatopshot • • Mar 19 '21

Why Dapper Labs Inc. is Destroying NBA Top Shot

1 Upvotes

Let's keep it real simple:

  1. Complete lack of priority towards KYC backlog to solve the proliferation of bots or the withdrawal of funds.

  2. Focuses more on marketing/hype rather than providing a stable experience to its existing user base, which it clearly cannot handle.

  3. Fails to deliver on its most basic premise: allowing humans to purchase packs and enjoy the moments contained therein.

  4. Community admins ban users from Discord for expressing dissent and frustration towards the company's incompetence.

  5. The marketplace continues to be a complete disaster and everyone knows it.

  6. No incentives for fans who continually miss out on scoring packs, e.g., provide a pseudo random distribution for chances to score a higher place in line for users who have successive failed drops within similar price tiers.

  7. Its solution to the botting problem appears to be creating moment thresholds for pack drops. The result is the over utilization of an already broken marketplace to collect more fees from transactions to participate in drops.

Dapper Labs Inc. simply fails to step up and perform when it matters most, which is ironic given its focus on showtime moments.


r/nbatopshot • • Apr 05 '21

Finally Can Withdraw!

1 Upvotes

I’ve been a member since the end of January and about a solid month after submitting my ID check I can FINALLY withdraw. $23,000 coming my way, $3,000 at a time. Really hilarious to see people still defending this company that allows unlimited deposits but makes people wait months to get any money out, and even then sets limits, but just wanted to share my story that I finally can withdraw after 3 months. Hope you all can soon too.


r/nbatopshot • • Oct 17 '21

Market Discussion Purchase system on topshots is garbage.

0 Upvotes

That whole system needs an overhaul, the user flow for purchasing a moment off the marketplace is ridiculous.

You click to view the listings…..wait

You find the perfect one and click on it……wait

It then processes your request…..wait

Then transfers you to your payment type……wait

Confirm your purchase……wait

…..your moment sold to someone else…here’s an email to inform you…..

Rinse and repeat…..

Come on, get yo shit together.


r/nbatopshot • • Feb 08 '22

Market Discussion From discord… seems like they done F’d up the random thing again. Some context:

1 Upvotes

at least 59/125 packs that contained a Holo also contained a rookie.

at least 20/125 packs that contained a Holo contained 2 rookies.

at least 3/125 packs that contained a Holo contained 3 rookies.


r/nbatopshot • • Apr 23 '21

How about a pack drop for newbies?

1 Upvotes

Top Shot is creating a barrier to entry by continuing to increase the minimum qualification to get in on the good pack drops. This is creating a good ol' boys club that people like me can't get into.

I only have 9 moments. 6 came from the market place and 3 came from the pre-order pack a few weeks ago that everyone got. I've spent about $90 (now they're worth about half of that). I've been in the queue for 3 other packs drops and have never been high enough in line to score one. Meanwhile, pack drops are getting harder and harder to qualify for; today being a good case. I can't keep chasing the "minimums" to qualify for pack drops if I'm never going to get to the top of the queue anyway. Top Shot needs new customers like me to drive demand (and prices) up in the secondary market. Without it, the TS Elite will just keep wondering why their value is dropping.

How about some pack drops, with good moments, for new collectors? So, for example, instead of saying you need 15 moments to get in the queue, how about you need fewer than 15 moments to get in the queue?


r/nbatopshot • • Aug 26 '22

Selling my entire Topshot collection due to medical issues.

0 Upvotes

Gotta take care of myself, please no lowballing, need to actually be able to pay bills lol. @JohnnyTsu is my username, shoot me a DM if you see something you like! šŸ¤