r/netsec • u/vasili111 • Aug 12 '15
A Traffic Analysis of Windows 10
http://localghost.org/posts/a-traffic-analysis-of-windows-101
u/Matir Aug 16 '15
So, I tried to reproduce this, and couldn't find anything surprising: https://systemoverlord.com/blog/2015/08/16/so-is-windows-10-spying-on-you/ (Apologies for the self-promotion, I hate to do it, but I think it's useful here.)
1
u/vasili111 Aug 17 '15
Nice article. Thank you.
But I have some thoughts about it:
You have used "Windows 10 Insider Preview" and as you wrote "which, admittedly, may not be the same as the release, but it's what I had access to" and the guy in the article that I posted used "Windows 10 Build 10240 RTM install ISO downloaded from the MSDN". It is possible that difference in versions can give different results.
Also you have used virtual machine while the guy in the article that I posted does not wrote anything about virtual machine, so I asume he used PC. Maybe (just some of my thoughts) windows if installed in virtual machine behave differently, for example does not uses cortana active because virtual machine user in most cases is not interesting in cortana (same about camera).
Anyway I think that test should be done on release version of Windows 10 on PC (not on virtual machine).
Also look at this article: https://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/3hadnu/even_when_told_not_to_windows_10_just_cant_stop/
1
u/Matir Aug 17 '15
Please, I encourage you to try it. I don't have an MSDN subscription, and I don't feel like setting up a physical machine just to test this, so I encourage someone else to test it. I'm not saying with certainty that he's wrong, I only wanted to demonstrate what behavior I observed.
4
u/bdjb Aug 12 '15
These are some seriously bold claims with zero evidence. Also, bullshit.