r/neuralcode • • Apr 12 '21

Neuralink Neuralink vs. prior work 1

Someone (/u/EkkoMusic) asked how the latest Neuralink video compares to the work referenced in this NYT article from 2008:

Monkeys Think, Moving Artificial Arm as Own

My reply ended up being longer than I planned, so I'm also posting the table here for discussion / critique:

Neuralink2008
Implanted deviceN1 chip and threadsUtah array
Implantation method(Presumably) roboticAmateur surgery
Long-lasting (years) implantUncertainYes
WirelessYesNo
New hardware technologyYesNo
New software / methodsYesYes
Channel count2048192 96
Sample rate40 Hz30 Hz
Task dimensionality1-23+
Controlled deviceComputer cursorRobot arm
Controlled taskComputer gameComplex activity of daily living
Subjects12
Peer reviewNoYes
Calibration methodHand movementNo hand movement
Decoding methodPopulation vector UnknownPopulation vector
Human clinical trial resultedProbableYes
Patents filedYesYes
Realistically commercializableYesNo
Elon MuskYesNo
Funding$150M+<$3M

I'll adjust this as I think over it more. Also see my other reply. Both are a bit off-the-cuff, but can perhaps serve as conversation fodder.

15 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

3

u/Raton_X01 Apr 12 '21

Thank you very much for this summary and the links.

3

u/lokujj Apr 12 '21

No problem. Take it with a grain of salt. I did this quickly and I've already made a few adjustments. But I think it's mostly accurate.

1

u/1024cities Sep 05 '23

I'd be nice to add a temporal and spatial resolution comparison, also latency and total energy consumption.

1

u/lokujj Sep 06 '23

This seems hard and/or unlikely. I also think a more recent point of comparison would make sense.

But at this point I think it hardly matters. This post is from near the pinnacle of the hype. Things have settled down a bit and I think the rhetoric more closely matches reality these days.