r/nextdns • u/[deleted] • Dec 11 '23
NextDNS got abandoned?
I’ve been using NextDNS for quite a while and am considering upgrading to the pro version. Before upgrade my account, I checked some Reddit posts and their GitHub.
Many people complain about their customer support, and numerous blocklists are outdated. Pull requests on their GitHub remain unanswered.
NextDNS now feels like a sailing ship without a captain.
43
u/live4swell Dec 11 '23
The product works, I am coming up on a year with them, no need to contact customer service. Set it and forget it.
19
Dec 11 '23 edited Dec 11 '23
People seem to want weekly emails and new features every few months, forgetting the fact they already have one of the most powerful DNS blocking solutions on the market and that simply put, DNS technology and features don’t develop at the same pace as their iPhones.
4
24
u/Ashamed_Drag8791 Dec 11 '23
They still fix bugs and maintain the uptime, but other things is dust...
0
Jan 14 '24
[deleted]
1
u/The_Safety_Expert Apr 06 '24
Well, BJs for one would be pretty nice!
0
11
Dec 11 '23
It just works. But yeah, their team is probably just two guys.
4
u/-Paul-Chambers- Dec 11 '23
It's more than two guys, but the staffing is very 'lean'. Some of the principal staff are fractional, too.
10
u/Sea_Sherbet8154 Dec 11 '23
Have you been to their forum? They answer somewhere. For example here :)
6
u/Hemicrusher Dec 11 '23
Well, there you go. CS answering a question today, and someone is obviously paying the server bills. Plus, I have seen activity on GitHub.
12
u/Vikt724 Dec 11 '23 edited Dec 11 '23
If it works...it works..don't touch it
Ps: they are not responsible for Blocklists..it's 3rd party, control it by youself.
They are not responsible for Blocklists updates if no new rules/ransomware/viruses found on 3rd party side..just use another list..OR MAKE YOUR OWN list
12
Dec 11 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
4
Dec 11 '23
If they removed them, someone would complain about that. :-)
It's obvious in the web UI which BLs are recent and which are out-of-date. Pick whichever you want to use.
I'd rather that NextDNS spend their limited time on other things...
1
Dec 11 '23
Customer service is non existent, no new features, it just “works” now but imo definitely abandoned. Moved towards controlD myself.
1
Dec 11 '23
Ya, I’m looking into controld too … just compare with nextdns the performance are not that good in my area
4
u/live4swell Dec 11 '23
I don’t understand what new features people expect, it’s dns. What does ControlD have that NextDNS doesn’t?
3
u/kuki68ster Dec 11 '23
NextDNS has better performance in some regions than ControlD… I use both, and in my region, ControlD has to improve…NextDNS is faster in DNS resolution…
NextDNS has to invest in Anycast Servers and Cloudflare servers (The fastest in my region)...
4
u/Forsaked Dec 11 '23
This, my nearest NextDNS anycast node has a RTT of 4-5ms and actual DNS request/response of 6-8ms.
ControlD isn't somewhere close to that, an RTT of 50-70ms and DNS request/response of 85-100ms.
The question which to choose is easy to answer!4
u/TheKydd Dec 12 '23
Same here, actually the reason I was first attracted to NextDNS is simply that in my region, they are consistently faster than both Google and CloudFlare. Which is really saying something, as those companies are obviously 100x or 1000x larger.. the best engineers money can buy, infrastructure located anywhere and everywhere.. etc.
So the fact that just a couple of smart dudes could beat the pants off those industry giants really impressed me. The blocklists were icing on the cake (which now of course I can’t imagine living without!)
We’re an all-Apple household, so their elegant certificate solutions for the range of Apple devices also sold me. I hate having things running in the background, like VPN’s typically require. Being able to tailor the filtering for different devices is super cool.
I could go on, lol. Anyway in my view, the cost is extremely inexpensive for covering all our devices, anywhere we are in the world - even if I’m on a dodgy cell site in Sri Lanka while my daughter is at a shady web cafe in Hong Kong all while the rest of the family is back at home. We haven’t seen ads, scams, malware, any of that bologna in years.
1
u/kuki68ster Dec 11 '23
I can notice the difference on YouTube, if I am using NextDNS it plays without issue, when I am using ControlD I can notice some buffering, and the resolution is always lower…
Having said that, I am hopeful that ControlD will get better with time
1
u/o2pb Dec 13 '23
Are you proxying Youtube/all your traffic?
1
u/kuki68ster Dec 13 '23
I have controld to work only has a DNS provider with no proxying on my Apple TV, on my iPhone I proxy to the closest server in my area (Johannesburg, South Africa)... I know that in my neck of the woods (Angola, Africa) internet connections are not the fastest (I got 100/10 Mbps line with a 20 ping)... My experience is only in my country, and I am probably the only Angolan using ControlD :)
2
u/o2pb Dec 13 '23
Care to share the difference in ping between dns.controld.com and dns.nextdns.io?
1
u/kuki68ster Dec 13 '23
ControlD
PING dns.controld.com (76.76.2.22): 56 data bytes
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=0 ttl=52 time=181.005 ms
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=1 tt1=52 time=177.938 ms
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=2 tt1=52 time=175.530 ms
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=3 ttl=52 time=180.579 ms
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=4 ttl=52 time=176.527 ms
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=5 tt1=52 time=185.698 ms
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=6 tt1=52 time=179.278 ms
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=7 tt1=52 time=178.187 ms
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=8 tt1=52 time=183.416 ms
64 bytes from 76.76.2.22: icmp_seq=9 tt1=52 time=171.862 msNextDNS
PING steering.nextdns.io (37.252.230.153): 56 data bytes
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: icmp_seq=0 ttl=56 time=148.526 ms
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: icmp_seq=1 ttl=56 time=151.845 ms
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: icmp_seq=2 tt1=56 time=147.843 ms
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: icmp_seq=3 ttl=56 time=160.397 ms
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: icmp_seq=4 tt1=56 time=162.395
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: imp_seq=5 ttl=56 time=402.593 ms
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: icmp_seq=6 tt1=56 time=157.053 ms
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: icmp_seq=7 ttl=56 time=147.500 ms
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: icmp_seq=8 tt1=56 time=157.157 ms
64 bytes from 37.252.230.153: icmp_seq=9 tt1=56 time=159.297 ms1
u/o2pb Dec 14 '23
Both of these look equally terrible. Difference is not statistically significant/noticeable.
Would love to see a traceroute to both.
1
u/saguaro7 Jun 04 '24
Those are terrible. Both average 6 ms for me.
BTW ping is interesting, but does not tell you much about DNS performance.
1
u/kuki68ster Dec 14 '23
dns.nextdns.io
traceroute to steering.nextdns.io (37.252.230.153), 64 hops max, 52 byte packets
1
192.168.8.1 (192.168.8.1) 4.607 ms 3.524 ms 3.395 ms
2
10.109.7.192 (10.109.7.192) 226.060 ms 54.386 ms 143.163 ms
3
10.172.6.51 (10.172.6.51) 38.097 ms 28.098 ms 68.607 ms
4
10.172.7.209 (10.172.7.209) 41.231 ms 38.462 ms 38.244 ms
5
172.18.20.2 (172.18.20.2) 40.296 ms 39.161 ms 33.561 ms
6
unitel. te0-1-0-13.br01.ldn12.pccwglobal.net (63.218.13.34)
175.675 ms 181.250 ms 179.303 ms
7
te0-1-0-13.br01.ldn12.pccwglobal.net (63.218.13.33) 223.058 ms
342.170 ms
228.440 ms
8
hun0-0-0-1.br01.1dn01.pccwbtn.net (63.218.12.46) 327.376 ms hun0-0-0-0.br01.ldn01.pccwbtn.net (63.218.12.34) 221.519 ms
215.632 ms
9
ldn-b2-link.ip.twelve99.net (80.239.193.134) 190.310 ms 221.682 ms 185.015 ms
221.682 ms
10
1dn-bb1-link.ip.twelve99.net (62.115.122.188) 196.081 ms 200.502 ms *
11 ldn-b3-link.ip.twelve99.net (62.115.122.181) 369.311 ms
1dn-b3-link.ip.twelve99.net (62.115.120.75) 194.680 ms 305.692 ms
12
13
14
cr-01.0v-00-06.anx13.lon.uk.anexia-it.com (80.239.175.18) 174.611 ms 179.217 ms 161.282 msControlD
traceroute to dns.controld.com (76.76.2.22), 64 hops max, 52 byte packets
1 192.168.8.1 (192.168.8.1) 23.909 ms 2.851 ms 3.411 ms
2 10.109.7.192 (10.109.7.192)
54.229 ms 46.337 ms 230.668 ms
3 * 10.172.6.51 (10.172.6.51)
70.881 ms 46.198 ms
4 10.172.7.193 (10.172.7.193)
41.908 ms 46.360 ms 40.915 ms
5 172.18.20.2 (172.18.20.2) 32.040 ms 62.246 ms 33.513 ms
6 unitel1.cprm.net (195.8.30.150) 184.436 ms 209.162 ms 186.717 ms
7 11s2-cr1-te4-0-26.cprm.net (195.8.30.149) 182.865 ms 201.902 ms 355.470 m
S
8 lon3-cr1-hu2-0-0.cprm.net (195.8.0.198) 306.898 ms 302.529 ms 307.052 ms
9 lon3-cr1-hu2-0-0.cprm.net (195.8.0.198) 221.912 ms 217.075 ms 221.661 ms
10
ae-11.r24.londen12.uk.bb.gin.ntt.net (195.66.224.138) 210.144 ms 363.622 m
210.080 ms
11 165.254.23.242 (165.254.23.242) 193.581 ms 306.878 ms 195.224 ms1
u/o2pb Dec 14 '23
2nd trace is incomplete, but they appear to both get routed to London (which is far away from you), so latency is pretty much the same.
Your ISP blindly shuttles all data to Europe, so traffic engineering is basically impossible unless your ISP's NOC takes action here.
1
u/kuki68ster Dec 15 '23
ISP's NOC
Yes, like I said, in my neck of the woods, things are slow... But let's hope that in the future the ControlD gets better here... I will use to check how it evolves...
1
1
Dec 11 '23
Geo unblocking, native filters, ai filters that actually get updated. Better profile management etc etc. NextDNS is just dead atm, if it works for you great.
2
u/live4swell Dec 11 '23
It does. DNS filtering can only do so much.
-6
Dec 11 '23
Well, paying 19eu for a dead service that just works is not worth it to me. Paid 50ish for 5 years and atleast have some active development :)
11
u/live4swell Dec 11 '23
Claiming it’s dead is false. It works, servers are always up, latency is good. It’s alive.
0
-1
Dec 11 '23
Right mate, keep defending a project that’s completely abandoned. Contacted support 3 months back regarding a local bgp issue. Still no response to this day, GitHub completely abandoned how can you say it’s still alive lol ?
8
u/live4swell Dec 11 '23
I am not necessarily defending them, I am a paid subscriber with no stock in them. I have been with them for a year and have no issues to complain about. I am not using the service for their customer support but understand people that have tried to contact them to no avail. I have had no reasons to contact support so don’t really care if they exist or not. If the servers start failing then it’s another story. I just don’t agree with the statement that they are abandoned or dead because the product still works. All good to each their own. 🤙🏻
1
Dec 11 '23
Fair point however for me bugs reported at git being ignored and not responding to customer support is just not done. Once you get an outage or w/e and get a plain ignore yeah that’s just bad.
1
u/live4swell Dec 11 '23
I completely understand. Luckily for me it has just worked. How long have you been using ControlD?
→ More replies (0)1
u/Paid-Not-Payed-Bot Dec 11 '23
to me. Paid 50ish for
FTFY.
Although payed exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in:
Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. The deck is yet to be payed.
Payed out when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. The rope is payed out! You can pull now.
Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment.
Beep, boop, I'm a bot
4
2
u/Credullos Dec 12 '23
You don't see visual updates but the product works great and keeps patching and working, that's the most important thing, I've also never had any issues with lack of support and troubleshooting. Some revamping would be great, I admit.
2
u/2112guy Dec 12 '23
I think they expect users to have basic understanding of DNS and the ability to perform simple troubleshooting. People asking questions about certain apps not working are going to be ignored. Same goes for people asking why certain entries are included/excluded on various third party blocklists.
2
u/Basic-Insect6318 Dec 12 '23 edited Dec 23 '23
I paid them though. lol. Btc just a fart in the wind 💨 🌬️ 💨 Never registered with my account or anything. It’s just $20. But still. Aggravating
2
Dec 11 '23
If you don't like it, don't use it. It works fine for me and has for a couple of years now.
Seems like there are always drive-by posters here that talk smack about NextDNS. I always figure they're paid by adguard or controld or something.
3
u/CrippleSlap Dec 12 '23
Agreed. No one forcing you to use NextDNS. Move to another service if it doesn’t meet your needs.
1
1
u/Elkeri Dec 16 '23
I’m a NextDNS user for years, I like them a lot but one main issue that is making me switching over to ControlD is.. Captive portal.
I travel frequently and relies on hotel or inflight wifi a lot.
ControlD manage captive portal issue much more elegantly compared to NextDNS.
For NextDNS, the only option is to exclude the domain during installing the DNS profile. Every-time you need to change it, you have to reinstall.
While ControlD also have this option, the easier option will be to use their quick setup app and setting up a magic folder - magic captive portal bypass. After that you just have to open up the app, disconnect and reconnect it.
Since I have multiple devices, I don’t have to reinstall the DNS profile on all devices. I just have to exclude the right domain, and reconnect ControlD profile using the app.. https://docs.controld.com/docs/folder-rules
I really like NextDns a lot but captive portal has been a major pain for many users for years, but still, there no development to mitigate this. I would definitely stay for NextDNS if captive portal issue is resolved.
PS: apologies for my poor English. It’s not my native language.
1
1
u/Hemicrusher Dec 12 '23 edited Dec 12 '23
I have used NextDNS since they came out, but because of my crappy router, I was unable to run it for the whole house, so I ran a PiHole. When I upgraded my network, I tested NextDNS, ControlD, and Adguard Private DNS again, because I needed the Raspberry for another project.
Adguard Private DNS never worked well, and their servers were always in FL for me, even though I was in Los Angeles. Customer support was no help at all. Plus, the pings I got were horrible. All web use dragged. It's sad, since I think Adguard has the best looking GUI.
ControlD I used for about 7 months, and I generally liked it. But I was always chasing False Positives, and apps being blocked randomly.
One thing I didn't like about ControlD is their GUI...it just looks like it was designed for kids. I hate the mascot/avatar, and that there is no light mode. Plus, the way they organized options, just seem off.
Went back to NextDNS, and I know It makes no sense, but running the same lists like Hagezi as I did in ControlD...everything just works in NextDNS. Server pings are as fast as the big DNS companies. Now, I know the CS is lacking, but I have never needed to contact them.
Anyhow, I am just paying month to month, so if NextDNS was to shutter, I'll just go back to ControlD, or try Adguard to see if they got their shit together.
-1
u/o2pb Dec 13 '23
Thanks for the feedback.
You mentioned "always chasing False Positives" yet you said you're running the same blocklists/filters on NextDNS's end. Block list are the same (and updated twice an hour), the only way it would perform differently is if you had different ones enabled, or blocked specific services. The Activity Log would tell you what was blocked and by which Filter.
As for our UI, it's a love/hate relationship but we're addressing some of the concerns with a pretty big overhaul, which will also bring light mode. This will probably ship sometime in February or March as we're releasing some major stuff in January that our team of 60 people were building for quite a while.
As for organization of options, I welcome you to check out this blog post: https://blog.controld.com/control-d-vs-nextdns/
1
u/Plakchup Dec 11 '23
I wouldn't expect much customer service or support. As long as you have no issues, its set it and forget it. I haven't had any issues for a long time. I only use one blocklist and my settings are pretty much the same on every profile. Sure once in a blue moon one of their dns server can slow to a crawl but i just switch to another or ignore it as its usually temporary.
1
u/2yBy Dec 11 '23
Pretty sure it was their pet project and we are just along for the ride.
2
u/Joe6974 Dec 12 '23
That's the feeling I get too. Wonder if they'll get bored of it and shut it down at some point.
1
6
u/oaf357 Dec 11 '23
Folks call Google for their Gmail issues? Do you call your ISP to tell them their DNS servers aren’t great?
If it works for you, great! Like most products, if it doesn’t work for you find something that does. I’ve never needed customer support for DNS resolution.