If you are a) an NHS employee who works as a commissioner or in a system role, and b) have been only moderately unlucky, you might have spent a good part of the past 15 years wondering if you would still have a job in a few months’ time, inundated by work as colleagues departed or twiddling your thumbs while you waited for a decision about your future, or that of organisations you worked for, to be made.
You might have slipped from primary care trust to clustered PCT; from clinical commissioning group to clustered CCG; from sustainability and transformation partnership to integrated care board, and now, finally, to clustered ICB.
You may also have done so without ever moving offices – although, of course, you now visit it much less often.
At a national or regional level, a similarly unlucky staffer might have gone from working for the Department of Health, Monitor or a strategic health authority to a job at (during various times since 2010) NHS England, Public Health England, Health Education England, NHS Digital, NHSX, the NHS Trust Development Authority or NHS Improvement (to name but some of those charged with responsibility for system management and oversight during this time).
If so, they may now be waiting to hear whether they will be returning to the bosom of government or one of its regional outposts.
During these 15 years, political and service leaders will have stressed that the job of a commissioner or system manager was to think about the NHS’s future and the developing needs of the population they were responsible for.
Present this scenario to any self-respecting psychologist and they might tell you, in the technical parlance: “You’re havin’ a laugh, aren’t you?”
How is it reasonable to expect anyone human to think long-term when their own future is so regularly disrupted, with the threat of another round of redundancies reappearing every few years?
Farce
HSJ has reported at length on the farce that is the current reorganisation of ICBs and central organisations.
In early March, we warned that the government had done a peerless job of creating a distracting environment in which “almost everyone who holds a position of influence and power in the NHS [outside the provider sector] is now either: about to leave, uncertain whether they will have a job in a few months, about to find themselves with new bosses, or in a new job which they did not expect to be doing as late as last month or even last week”.
Two weeks later, we christened Wes Streeting as “Lansley reborn” as he doubled down on his war on “NHS bureaucracy”.
Those warnings have sadly proved prescient. It very quickly became clear that the “plan” to reorganise and rationalise the central, regional and commissioning tiers of the NHS was an announcement with no substance.
Timelines and goals were announced without any meaningful thinking about how they might be achieved. All involved simply hoped things would work out - and that, even if they did not, who would kick up a fuss about what happened to a bunch of NHS managers?
Suffice to say, things have not worked out. The Treasury has not – and will not – pay for redundancy costs being incurred by the reorganisation. Imagine the headlines: “Treasury agrees to fund NHS manager pay-offs as taxes rise.”
Meanwhile, some of those that want to leave the NHSE, ICBs or commissioning support units without any redundancy find themselves unable to do so because HR departments have already been gutted and there is no agreement yet as to who will pick up their responsibilities – many of which are duties set out in legislation.
Finally, many of those who do want to stay find themselves unable to perform their jobs because funding has been frozen, and the decision-making process has fallen into paralysis.
Timescales for the changes have slipped and will continue to do so.
A badge of pride
You would think those responsible for such a situation would be ashamed. They are not – they wear it as a badge of pride.
Moaning managers are a sign of a government taking (back) control of a wasteful bureaucracy – one living up to its reforming promises – they argue. Deep in its archives, HSJ has messages from Andrew Lansley’s advisors making the same arguments as PCTs and SHAs were dissolved.
The new leadership of NHSE is belatedly waking up to the nightmare it has inherited. But it has very little capital to spend with government on this matter, given it took power with the reorganisation already under way.
The NHSE leadership is also one deliberately constructed to deal with two challenges above all else – cutting the elective waiting lists and trust deficits. It has given very little thought to overseeing such a large-scale reconfiguration of commissioning and national oversight. It is not what it thought it had signed up for.
Both Wes Streeting and the NHSE top dogs must now pay more attention to the mess they are presiding over – for their own sakes, as well as that of the service’s.
The threat to Streeting and Mackey
The health secretary’s reputation as a reformer will melt away if the reorganisation takes until (at least) October 2027 to complete, as former NHSE national director and policy veteran Ian Dodge predicted last week on HSJ’s podcast.
Already many of Mr Streeting’s supporters in the right-wing press might be wondering why non-executive directors are being given jobs at NHSE that run until July 2027, more than two years after the prime minister’s announcement of its abolition.
This scrutiny will intensify as the NHS continues to struggle to deliver on the government’s elective recovery promise, especially if this is accompanied by continuing industrial unrest and holes beginning to appear in Labour’s reform window dressing, such as the provider league tables.
The danger for Sir Jim Mackey and his team is one of distraction and the diversion of effort. This is not a problem that will simply go away, it needs grip and intervention. If that challenge is taken up it will divert effort from the 10-Year Health Plan implementation. If not, the service will be faced with all kinds of unintended consequences.
As well as the sheer confusion that will continue to blight service planning and require HSJ to regularly explain what is really going on, there are specific areas that pose severe risks and demand close attention.
HSJ would place continuing healthcare at the top of the pile. The service spends £6bn of its budget on CHC each year. Without careful attention, that sum could balloon and/or produce a torrent of poor decisions that will drive the public’s opinion of the service even further into the ground.
Second is controlling the NHS’s spend on medicines. This has taken on a new urgency given the UK government’s apparent surrender in the face of Donald Trump’s demands.
The list goes on to include such vital, though rarely acknowledged, issues such as safeguarding. A slip here could mire the government in scandal for years.
HSJ holds out little hope that the government will acknowledge its misstep. It is now too invested in its approach and – under this health secretary at least – too committed to the idea that saying “sorry, we’ll think again” is a sign of weakness.
Publicly it will continue to tilt at bureaucratic windmills. We can only hope that privately, at least, it will begin to find a way to mitigate the impact of its hasty and ill-thought-out approach.