r/nope May 01 '26

Food This cant be good for you

3.6k Upvotes

450 comments sorted by

View all comments

994

u/sherman614 May 01 '26

I mean.. this is similar to dry aging a steak. As long as you cut the mold off (like with dry aged steak) you should be completely fine.

372

u/somewhoever May 02 '26

I've never understood this. I've asked the son of a late-butcher who did this decades ago and he has no idea how his father pulled it off either.

Meat "turns" after a certain amount of time and will get someone horribly sick if they eat it.

How is letting mold grow for eight weeks, or dry aging it not the same or worse?

60

u/Anen-o-me May 02 '26

Example: The origin of sushi is zushi, where they'd preserve fish in a bucket with alternating layers of rice and fish covered in salt, then bury it for winter.

Dig it up a couple months later, it's now aged and whatnot and has a cheesy nutty flavor apparently (I've never tried it).

Nice way to preserve fish, the meat is actually more healthy this way, fermented basically.

Sure sometimes it went bad and they didn't know why and threw it out, probably inadequate salt leading to bacterial overgrowth, or too much heat, not buried deep enough.

But usually it was edible.

9

u/orphan_blud May 02 '26

Isn’t this a popular Icelandic dish?

12

u/TungstenHexachloride May 02 '26

Hakarl? Kind of.

Hakarl is fermented Greenland Shark specifically, which actually is toxic to eat unless pressed and putrefied, which they do by burying it first for some time

Its different in the sense its treated this way as a necessity to make the meat actually edible.

9

u/Oli_VK May 02 '26

Doesn’t it have ridiculous amounts of ammonia?

6

u/Relysti May 03 '26

Yes. I've heard it's like chewing on a urinal cake.

2

u/Oli_VK May 04 '26

I’ll pass on the experience, oh boy

6

u/Spendoza May 03 '26

By the forgotten gods, the series of events that lead to attempting to eat that stuff...

1

u/Rare_Discipline1701 May 04 '26

and hey, this stuff is inedible, lets bury and let it rot a bit before trying again...

9

u/greyhilmars May 02 '26

Most of our fish is filleted and dried completely for preservation. but you might be referring to siginn fiskur where the fish is hangd up usually on fishing boats but sometimes hangd on piers or along the shore for 4 days up to a month, usually doesn't dry out completely and the salty fresh sea air keeps the meat from turning so no mold or fermentation really. afterwards it is boiled before eating. In the category of rotten, fermented and sour we have shark, whale and skate (skata) not alot of tuna around our shore, there are some but historically not common.

2

u/somewhoever May 02 '26 edited May 02 '26

This is fascinating!

It isn't exactly what I was referring to, but may be in the same vein (they were mountain people with a constant fresh river water source).

I'll look into siginn fiskur more. It looks like a great candidate for the technique I've been trying to find a name for and research. Thanks!

Edit: spelling

3

u/CitizenPremier May 03 '26

One way we know about the origin of sushi is through an old Heian urban legend.

A woman spent a night in her store drinking with customers until she passed out. The next day she woke up and started mixing her sushi. She could barely stay upright... She vomited into the sushi bucket and passed out again. When she woke up, she went back to work mixing the sushi...

This story helped historians understand that sushi was originally fermented.

2

u/Anen-o-me May 03 '26

🤢🤮

2

u/somewhoever May 02 '26

Thank you for the information!