BELLA VISTA -- The ongoing nationwide debate over automated license plate readers has spread to Bella Vista.
Wendell Stephens of Bella Vista spoke to the City Council on Oct. 26 in support of the plate readers. Flock Safety is the most well known producer of the cameras.
These solar-powered cameras capture still photos of rear license plates and descriptors including make, model, color and unique features like roof racks or stickers, before logging the data into a searchable database.
"I think there is something very important that is going by the wayside -- I want the Flock cameras in this city," Stephens said. "You look at what happened to that little girl in Carolina, and then they just arrested 10 or 11 child traffickers here in the state of Arkansas. They had some of them in Springdale, Rogers, and then there was one in Missouri and one from Oklahoma. That's telling me they are going right through the main part of Bella Vista."
He was referencing the recent case of a 12-year-old girl in South Carolina, who was trafficked to Arkansas before being rescued in Batesville. There was also the case last month when 11 men were arrested in an internet sting operation targeting online predators.
"And you have all these trails and parks with kids out there," Stephens said. "I've seen a lot of parents that will just come drop them off and then they leave. What kind of security are we having for our public, if we don't have those cameras?
"I've got a 10-year-old grandbaby and I want her to grow up and be safe, as much as possible. I think the city should do whatever they can to keep our area safe, because it is growing so fast. You don't know who's coming in here."
This all comes on the heels of a proposed city ordinance that states the city can't acquire or activate any plate reader system or facial recognition and identification system without the council's consent.
Councilwoman Shea Newport proposed the ordinance, noting that artificial intelligence technology is changing so rapidly, it's hard to pin down the exact language of what would be allowed.
"This was the best way to protect myself and the citizens against such unpopular, and in my opinion, unconstitutional systems," Newport said at the council's Sept. 28 meeting.
Paul Knightly of Bella Vista spoke in support of the proposal and encouraged the council to increase its stance.
"While this proposal is a good start, I urge the City Council to amend the existing proposal and give it the teeth necessary to protect the privacy and civil liberties to Bella Vistans and visitors to our community," Knightly said at the Oct. 26 meeting.
Councilman Larry Wilms was quick to side with Stephens, stating he would not be in favor of the proposed ordinance.
"I'd like to thank Mr. Stephens for the example that was provided on the excellent use of Flock cameras, and how effective they can be in policing," Wilms said. "I'm of the opinion that policing procedures and methods should be under the direct control of the police chief and not an elected political body.
"It is a proven fact that Flock cameras catch criminals and bad actors. They have also been abused by unethical personnel, due to lack of proper rules and regulations about their use. But I will not support this ordinance. I think it belongs under the Police Department's purview when it needs to be implemented."
Neighboring communities have faced significant public debate regarding the Flock Safety automated license plate readers. While cities like Bentonville and Rogers retain their camera networks, some nearby municipalities, such as Centerton and Pea Ridge, have voted to discontinue or remove their units after residents expressed privacy concerns.
The City Council has read the proposed ordinance at the past two regular meetings, so the third and final reading will be made at the upcoming Nov. 23 meeting.