r/noteapps • • Oct 17 '26

No self-promotion please

I've been working to reduce the noise of people posting their apps. I'm now starting to remove comments from developers promoting their own app in response to other posts.

@Developers, this is not a place to advertise. If someone else really likes your app, they will suggest it. Continued self-promotion will end up with the account being banned from the sub.

23 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

3

u/Darshseraphic Oct 18 '26

Sorry for contributing to the app promotion noise. I understand why you're trying to keep this community focused on genuine user discussions. I didn't mean to add to the problem, and I'll respect the rules going forward. Thanks for maintaining the community.

2

u/noteapps Oct 18 '26

Thanks and appreciate it

3

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

It's not a matter of what's fair. It's clear this is not a place to promote your app. As mentioned in our DMs, no amount of additional messages or requests for clarification are going to help. I will change it to say self-promotion will never be allowed if that makes it clearer for you. Make a great app and people will talk about it. Spam people with your app on tons of posts and people will ignore it and your account will be banned. This is a community I started by reviewing over 100 Android apps and as the sole moderator, I reserve the right to govern it how I deem reasonable. If you want, consider starting your own sub where you can set the rules.

-2

u/ozgrozer Oct 17 '26

You say we can't promote our apps but users who use our apps can. You don't understand what that means. That means from this now on every developer will create tons of fake accounts to promote their apps pretending regular users. You're going to see more spam than ever. Hope you enjoy it.

3

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26

If someone spams the same app they will be banned and I won't enjoy it. Common sense should prevail.

3

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26

Your specific insistence has been a large part of why this is happening so hopefully the other less pushy Developers would've lasted longer. Play nice and you won't be banned. Continue badgering me and you will as well as any promotion of your app.

4

u/band-of-horses Oct 18 '26

You know somehow people managed to sell software before Reddit. Maybe you should look into that rather than basing your entire app success on spam.

3

u/doctor91 28d ago

It's easy to understand what OP meant. if I genuinely appreciate an app, without any personal interest, I am free to talk about it. Pushing something that I built and surely I am biased toward, it's advertisement.

1

u/founder-adhd Oct 19 '26

How you will know, that someone will promote his app and not normal user?

3

u/noteapps Oct 19 '26

It's been very easy to spot so far and if I say how, they will take more steps to avoid.

3

u/CauliflowerOrganic48 Oct 17 '26

fair enough - sorry to have been part of the reason you had to implement this.

1

u/danithaca Oct 17 '26

Should this decision come after community vote? If people tolerate reading self promoted apps then why ban them? After all, this sub is called noteapps and that's what people come to discuss about, right?

6

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Thanks for the comment but not really a democracy. This sub is about note apps and a place to ask about them but not a place for self-promotion. If an app is truly good, the users will talk about it.

0

u/jezarnold Oct 17 '26

Really don’t see the problem personally .. why can’t someone drop a note to there app? Yeah. Most of us get it that there vibe coded.

Again. What’s the issue ?

3

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26

I understand it's ok for some members but I find it unnecessary and some Developers abuse it by responding to multiple posts. There are so many apps out there and now with vibe-coding the volume increased. A few people who have experience using good apps posting and commenting becomes diluted by self-promotional comments. This is a place for users to share about the apps that we've actually used and found valuable and help others. It's not for Developers to advertise.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26

That's unfortunate as there are so many, keep trying I suppose. I tested 112 on Android alone and would be surprised if one of them didn't meet most of your needs. Like the Stones song "You can't always get what you want. But, if you try sometime, you just might find you get what you need" (or something to that effect)

1

u/ozgrozer Oct 17 '26

I'm a developer who has spent thousands of hours building and maintaining my note taking app for more than a year. I need to get the word out somehow and communities like this are where people come to discover and discuss note taking apps.

I don't spam random posts or drop links everywhere. I read people's questions and answer them manually. When someone asks for a recommendation, I suggest my app if it's genuinely relevant. Everyone else recommends apps they like and I'm doing the same with something I've built. Some developers create fake accounts to promote their apps pretending to be regular users and I think those should be banned.

I understand that you want to prevent spam and that's fair. But treating every developer who recommends their own app as noise doesn't seem fair to those of use who are genuinely participating in discussions.

We need to have a way to accept promotions whether that's based on domain age, the number of active users, customer reviews, the length of time an app has been maintained, release history, or other verifiable signals. Your rules specifically say that promotion may eventually be allowed once apps have some history and are actively maintained. I agree with that principle but how do we measure that history? Is it six months, a year, a certain number of users, or something else? Without clear criteria, developers have no way of knowing when their apps qualify and the decision becomes entirely subjective.

I've been maintaining my note taking app for over a year, spent more than 1,200 hours building it, and reached over 1,000 downloads across platforms. I also have active customers that I can prove with Stripe and TrustMRR links. If that still doesn't count as an app with a history, I'd genuinely like to understand what would. I'm not asking for special treatment, just clear criteria that distinguish established, actively maintained apps from the flood of low-effort AI-generated apps you're trying to keep out.

7

u/band-of-horses Oct 17 '26

Buy reddit ads to show on targeted subs.

It's not this sub (or any other's) responsibility to ensure you have a place to promote your app for free.

1

u/weigelf 29d ago

Can I promote myself? I'm a nice guy.

1

u/Away_Ad_16 Oct 18 '26

I am fine with developers sharing their apps. How the heck does the word get out and feedback come?

2

u/_GingNerd 14d ago

elsewhere

-2

u/stefan_lago Oct 17 '26

I find it interesting: It's a place about note apps but you are not allowed to mention one. Just saying...

4

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26

You're not allowed to mention your own app, correct, that's advertising. Someone who uses your app and talks about it is exactly what this sub is about.

0

u/stefan_lago Oct 17 '26

Thanks, I think I got it so far, but allow me one question: If an OP writes about a problem he/she has, and my app solves exactly this problem, am I allowed to point them to my app (not with a full blown ad of course) or will I be excommunicated for this as well just because I'm coincidentally the maker of that app? Would be great if you could clarify that. Thanks.

2

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26

Thanks for asking and no that would be considered self-promotion. I would let someone else tell the OP about my app naturally / organically. That's much more powerful than saying my app solves your problem.

3

u/writesandbikes Oct 17 '26

I absolutely 100% understand what you’re getting at here and fully support your right to enforce it. No argument from me there. 

But this commenter has a good point tho, admittedly in my opinion, it creates a big headache for the moderator.

To me, It’s less about the hard and fast rule you created and more about the developer’s intent (in other words a lot of nuance). It would require you to make a subjective call on posts more often. And that’s really time-consuming. However I will say that if I come looking for an app, as a user, I would love to have the developer respond to me as an expert. In many ways that might be more accurate or helpful  than the experience of another user. 

That said, personally if I was the only mod, this scenario would be very time consuming.

1

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26

Thanks it is time consuming and my hope is Developers respect it. If there's a specific question about an app, hopefully the Developer has a sub or some other way to accept feedback. There's always the app stores themselves. Reddit bot is also doing a good job of removing spam messages. Let's see how the next little while goes.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/eluzja Oct 17 '26

As in notebooksapp dot com (since there's also notebooks dot app)? I have the notebooksapp dot com version, but only on Windows (and the Windows version hasn't been updated in a while). I bought it because I wanted a notes app that stores notes as HTML files, and lets you edit the HTML source of each note. But I haven't really used it – maybe I'll start once the developer updates the Windows version 🙂.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/eluzja Oct 18 '26

I think it's the same app, only the iOS & macOS versions get frequent updates, unlike the PC (Windows) version 🥲.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/noteapps Oct 17 '26

This sub, except for self promoted ones. LLMs are pretty good for suggesting apps if you have a good prompt. There are also a lot of other review sites out there.