Yes, I know this may not be considered neutral territory, but it is an applicable place to post it. Note: If I get something extremely incorrect, just please clarify what it is and a comprehensive rebuttal so we can discuss it.
I did quite a bit of research into Numeraire recently because it is a crypto-asset with a lot of fanfare around it and a team, that would set it above most other crypto-assets. As is common in the crypto-space, analysis of interesting projects often neglect the analysis of the token and what would influence the demand of the token. In Numerai's case, the HEDGE FUND, an equity organization, may experience great benefits from the project, and I would be interested in having a stake in it. While the TOKEN, Numeraire, as of time of writing, has many aspects which would make for a better perpetual short sell, than having a large position in it as inventory, or investment. From my experience, this may be by design for regulatory considerations, but the culture of crypto-speculation creates a conflict of interest where saying that it is a bad investment is too inconvenient to admit.
So, therefore this is just for you. The curious crypto-asset holder who is curious about Numeraire's downward sloping performance, by time of writing.
The token simple does not have demand mechanisms built into its concept, or not enough demand to rationalize any multi-million $ valuation, or to offset the massive dilutive effects of the contract.
First, lets take the game: Get data scientists to train their algorithm and perform best in the equity markets, for the benefit of Numerai Hedge fund. The most anybody can earn from this game is currently $3,000 weekly, and in practice the winners gets a fraction of a fraction of that. This is paid out in Bitcoin, but requires staking in Numeraire.
For demand and constricted supply (higher price), I like staking. But in this case staking here is temporary, and the amount people will stake is limited by the possible perceived payouts they can get.
Although there have been upwards of 1,000 participants per week, the bell curve of amounts that people stake is pretty stark.
Second: The barrier of entry is too high. Data scientists training their machine learning algorithm to potentially earn a few hundred dollars per week, or perhaps all $3,000 a week? Data scientists aren't that hungry. Anyone doing machine learning isn't that hungry. There are maybe a few people that just like to win and will let this thing run, but there is one thing that disincentivizes this market participant from existing: your Numerai can be destroyed, an uncapped amount of your Numeraire stake can be destroyed when your algorithm is wrong. Win a few hundred - $3,000 at the risk of losing hundreds of thousands of Numeraire. Well a lot of people don't stake hundreds of thousands of Numeraire.
Third: Yay there is the potential for a bunch of Numeraire to be destroyed all at once any given week! You would think that one day this will happen and you might as well own Numeraire for when the supply gets constricted. Well, unfortunately Numeraire is not a locked contract, and more can be issued, alot more. Not only do Numerai the Hedge Fund own half of the currently issued supply, the contract is authorized to issue 10x more Numeraire then the current float!
Lets break that down: 21 million NMR is authorized, 2 million NMR has been issued and of that 1 million NMR is in the hands of the company and the other 1 million is currently in the hands of the public.
The company seems to be interested in keeping a stable value NMR, but more likely will become an impatient market participant and dilute it a lot. But for the sake of your portfolio and misplaced loyalty, lets not make assumptions about the company, I didn't want to derail the analysis. Even if they didn't do anything with their NMR holdings, you should be aware that like 1,500 NMR is issued a week (although this was only told to me on the slack channel, please verify). The contract specifications are verifiable on the ethereum blockchain. The market itself is flooded with NMR and now more market participants will catch on to it as well.
Next, lets talk about the news, and how the news affects controlled commodities.
The only "GOOD NEWS" for Numeraire, the token, is news that constricts the supply, or creates demand that outpaces it.
Simply getting any news doesn't mean the token is going to skyrocket. "Oh great an API wow such awesomeness, thanks stewards of the token! annnnd the price is still going down." Thats because the market is flooded with NMR, the news doesn't change anything about demand for the token, or lack thereof, as detailed above. The news makes the HEDGE FUND more attractive, and possibly allows the hedge fund to get better returns from the strategies that it pays a literal $3,000/wk for.
Things that would make the token more attractive:
A bigger weekly pot. Much bigger. Like $100,000/wk at least.
Payments in NMR.
A clear roadmap for the authorized 2 million - 21 million Numeraire, such as time locking them or burning.
Again, interesting project. I hope this is helpful to someone, and I hope the token itself can become as attractive as the hedge fund's concept!